 
  


   
           .   ,             ,   ,      .                     .          ,       20122016 ,          ,        .





 

  . . , .. 





  








 

..  (),

B.C. ,

.. ,

.. ,

.. ,

.. ,

..  (. ),

.. ,

.. ,

.. ,

.. ,

..  (. ),

..,

..  (. ),

.. ,

.. ,

..  (. ),

.. ,

..  (. ),

.. ,

.. ,

.. ,

.. 



JOURNAL SOCIAL SCIENCES AND CONTEMPORARY WORLD INSTITUTE OF ECONOMY RAS








Social Liberalism / ed. by A. Y. Rubinstein, N.M. Pliskevich. St. Petersburg: Aletheia Publishing House, 2016. 384 p.

The present edition is dedicated to one of the most important and systemic, so to say  backbone categories  that is to social liberalism. Using this concept, different authors and their critics separate their own ideological positions from the views of other researchers, engaged in the study of society and in the study of the behavior of individual people and groups. In the theoretical economics and in the economic policy, the specified category is used mainly in the context of the analysis of interactions between the market mechanisms of self-regulation and the public activity. In the given book, materials are contained, related to discussions on issues of social liberalism, organized by the journal "Social Sciences and Modernity" in the years 20122016, in which supporters of different schools of thought and ideologies participated, representing leading research centers of the scientific and educational organizations.



Keywords', society, state, patronized goods, liberalism, paternalism, social liberalism, economic policy, institutes.



JEL Classification-. C70, C72, D5, D6, D7, H41, Z28.




  


   ,   .   ,  . ,         ,    ,       .   ,       ,   ,  ,           [1 -  . .   /  . , , 1999, .412423 (   . .  / Peter Struve, Sozialliberalismus // Internationales Handworterbuch des Gewerkschaftswesens. Bd. 2. Berlin, 1932. S. 15311536).].   ,    .  :            .           ,     .        ,       ,         [2 -  . .  :     // , 3917,15.09.2015.].

 , , , ,       ,                    ,   ,      .        ,             [3 -        .  [, 20015]   . ,      .], ,    ,                     .

     , ,      ,         ,      .  ,  , :         ,   - ;      ,             ,           ,       [4 -          -            (2004, 6).        , ,   ,   .].

     ,     ,       ,       [5 -     ,  . . ,     . ,           ,         [ (1993, . 12)].].   ,    ,         ,          [6 -      ,   ,   [Sunstein, Thaler, 2003]   [Camerer et al., 2003] ,         . . : [, 2013


, 2013[6]].].

     ,      . . , . X. , . . , . . , . ,   ,  ,    ,     ,         ,         ,    .         ,        ,            .

  ,              ,     - .                ,          ,     ,    ,      ,   ,   .

   2012    :           - ,           ,   ,     ,          .  -,             ,         .               ,            .

 ,         ,    .           ,    XIV       (.-, 2015.)    :    .               .

    ,         ,        :   ,  -  ,   ,       ,    ,     . . ,    ,   ,    ,          ,   (-),   ,     .

            .   ,                .                   ,    .           ^             .

 ;    ;       .              . ;    2015.   ;   ;          .         .     .          .

   ;          ;   . ;              .




.. .  :   


     ,         .         ,    20 ,            .       ()         ,      [7 -        ,         ,          [, , 2000; 2008; Grinberg, Rubinstein, 2005; , 2010].],              -     ,    [, 2008; 2009


; 20 09


; 2011], ,                   [, 2010; 2011].

 ,  ,    2007.,    1929.,          [8 -   . ,     ,    ,      ,           [, 2007, . 332]. ,     ,      ,        [Arrow, Debreu, 1954],  ,   ,     ,   . ,   . ,     [Samuelson, 1954].],          . ,  . ,     ,         [Bortis, 2009].

     ,    ,         ,    .    ,      , , -,   , -,       ,      .

 ,     ,    ,     ,  ,            .               ,         ,     ,    ,     ,       .          ,      ,          .

        , ,             ,   .                       .       ,            .           .            (1776)  , ,                 .

    .  ,         (. , . , . , . , . , . ).   ,      .  [Sen, 1999; , 1996; 2004],              ,    ,  , ,       .

        . -,         ,  ,        ? -,     ,   ,    ? -,               ?

    ,          .    ,       ,  ,     .   XIX.           [9 -        ,      :    ,      ,        ..]. ,       - ,      ().   , ,       (),           .


 / ?

   .    [10 -     .    . ,        ,    ,       .    ,        ,            ,    .          .]    .  ,   . ,    , ,     1908. [, 2004, . 100],         XX.    ,   . ,     .       . .     ,    ,       [, 1914, . 798],     . .

  . ,          ,     1896.    ,     :   ( . . .),    (homo economicus)      [, 1997, . 18].    ,    :        ,               (. : [, 1997, . 19]).         ,       ,      ,        .

        .           ,       ,    .       :           ,          ,     , ,   , ,   ..              .      pro et contra.

   . . , ,     ,         [Schaffle, 1873, S. 113].     . :     ,     ,               ,     ,               ,   [Menger, 1923, S. 8].  ,    ,    . :       ,        [Samuelson, 1954, . 387]; . :        ,  ,       [Musgrave, 1959, . 87]; . :     ,  ,          [, 1992, . 109][11 -   ,        ,        [, 2004, . 100],      1950- .    .],   .            .

  ,     .              [12 -      ,    ,          [, 1994].        , ,   ,         .]          .    ,      -  ,   ,   ,  .                  .              :              ,     .  ,         ,          ,    .

      -,   1950- .     [, 2004; The Nature 1969; Modes 1973].        ,   ,     ,         ໠ ,     ,       ,        [Kincaid, 1998, . 295].

      :    ,             [Bhaskar, 1989, . 36].    :         ,      ,         ,      [, 2004, . 101].  , -,              [, 2008, . 45, . 3].

  XX.     ,    黠   .  [, 1899; , 2001]         ,     ,    .  [, 1980; 1994]         .              .

. ,  , ,          . ,        ,            ,               [, 2002, . 16].        . ,          [Agassi, 1960; 1973].           .

, . ,   ,        ,      ,         , ,  ,    [Giddens, 1984; 2001].               . , ,       ,     [, 1991].         . , ,     ,      ,       [Boudon, 1988; , 1999].         , ,         ,        ,      [Boudon, 1979].

        .   . ,        ,               [Touraine, 2005; , 1993, .3543][13 - .      .  [, 1995-].              , ,    -   ,              .  ,                    .

      ,   ,       -.              . .         ,       ,         [Taylor, 1989; , 2001].

 ,         , ,    ,     ()   [, , 2000, .4754; , 2008, .93114].         ,   ,  .       ,    . ,        [, 1994; 2009; , 2008],       .  ,           [, 2000; 2009].

       ,    [14 -   ,    :         ,    ,    [, 2001, . 10].],        ,            , ,   ,           ,    [, 2001, . 12],     .                       ,      [15 -              ,           .].

   ,  :     ,       [, 2001, . 11].                       ,     . ,        , , ,        ,    ,       .

        ,           ,     .          :  ,  ,    ,  ,         ,   .    ,        ,         [, 2004, . 103].

 , -,   .    ,      ,  ,  ,     ,     .            , ,      .   ,         ,       [Aoki, 2001].

     . :         ,      ,   .         ,       ,          .       , ,     ,       .        ,        (, 2008, . 51].

 ,    (,  . ),     .          -, -  ..        :          ,    ,         .  ,           -    .  , -,     ,     .

,         .       ,       . , .      , ,   ,      ,         [, 1998, . 192].       . , ,        .            [, 1996, . 44].      , .        , ,               .               [, 2010].   ,  ,    XXXXI.          ,       .

      ,            .          ,     ,      .  , ,   ,         ,    ,       .    ,    ,     ,     ,    ,            .          .

 ,      ,     .               ,     ,          .                    ,        ,    ,   [16 - ,    ,     ,      ,    .       .].  ,     ,   ,   ,        [Samuelson, 1954, . 388].

 ,   , ,   ,          .   ,     ,             ,      [, 2004, . 444].                          [, 2008].  ,    ,          X. ,      ,    [17 -         ,  ,      ,          , , ,   [Margolis, 1982, . 14].   , .  ,         ,        ,      [, 1997, .3031].].  

. ,        ,      ,       , , ,   .    ,   :    [, 2008, . 131],   .

-,        .  [Bergson, 1938]   - [Samuelson, 1978],                 [18 -       .  [Harsanyi, 1955]    .     . : ,           .       ,   ,     ,         ,        [, 2005, . 78].]. -,  ,     ,         (fair-share   FS-)     [Margolis, 1982, . 11].          ,      ,   ,     . ,    ,      ,     ,     .           -. ,                      ,      ( . [, 2010, .7981]).

,        ,   ,    , ,   .        ,      ;   ,    ,     ,     ;    ,       ,        .                .          .


     

             ,   , ,          ,       ,      [19 -    ,      ,   [, 2010, .111116].].  ,           .

  ,          ,        ,      ,    ,     -     . , .         ,          ,          .   ,                     . , .   :         ;          ,        .       .

    . , ,                        . ,    .  ,            ?     . ,    ,              . ,     ,     [20 -   ,       ,        ,           , ,   .     . ,                    ,      .].

 ,  ,   ,   ,         .        .        ,    , .      ,  .    ,    .    ,  ,   ,       ,       : , , , , ,  [, 2001, .78]. ,              ,   ,            .

         ,    :               ,         ,  ,  . ,      ,     . -,       [21 -              -   -     ,          [, 1997, . 18].           ,       .]   ,  ,              .            ,         . ,       ,      ,       .    ,             ,   ,         ,  ,  .

-,            [22 -            ,   ,        [Margolis, 1982, . 17]. ,             .],     ,      .     , ,    . ,         ,       ,          :               . ,                .      ,        ,  ,  .

-,     ,            ,   .            ,       ,       ,            .                    [23 -   .    . , . , . , . .   ,         ,  ,  ,  ..].            , , ,     .

     ,                  .     ,   ,                      .      ,     ,      . ,      :  ,    ,     -   ,   .

  ,    ,              .  ,          .       ,          [24 -     ,           (., : [, 2004]).].       . ,     [Arrow, 1951],     (  ), ,  ,   ,    .                .   ,       ()  , , ,     ,       ,   .

  ,          ,        [25 -               1909.  -       (Wertjreiheit),     .]   ,     , ,    : ,      ,     [, 2012, . 7].          .                  .       , ,    ,  ,      ,    .

             .                    (),     ,       .       ,      ,  ,          .  ,        ,        [26 -      .   軠  ,  ,   ,   ,  .       [Black, 1970, . 24].].

     ,          ,   ,    . ,  ,        ,      ,      [Boudon, 1979].  ,                ,      .  ,                 ,    .

    ,    .     .   ,                 ,        ,   ,        .  ,      ,      ,       ,   .   ,            , ,  ,   .          ,    [, , 2000, . 210],     . ,           [27 - ,         .    -,  ,     ,     .].

  , ,        ,        ,    XX.                      [Stigler, 1971].        .-. ,  "   ,    ,          [, 2007, .2223].

   ,        ,             ,    .  ,            .       ,             ,    .          ,    ,    .   ,          ,      -:     ()    ,      (),      [, 2010][28 -          (., , [Persson, Tabellini, 2005; , 2007, 2008]).].

     ,        .                .      .              ,             ,  .     ,        [, 2007, . 29][29 -        . ,      [Tirole, 1986].]. , ,      ,    ,   ,       .

        ,    ,                ,       ,   .        ,       ,     [Posnett, 1987; Rose-Ackermann, 1996; Salamon, Hems, Chinnock, 2000; , , 2005].                  .        ,       ,      ,      .

       ,              ,   ,         .                           ,      [30 -  ,              ,          [Samuelson, 1954].          ,    ,       ,      .].


  -

                ,       .          , ,    ,      [, 2009


, 2009


].     ,     ,          ,     ,     .

    .    ,             U


  U


.         ,       U


 = f (U


, U


, ,U


),  U


    i- .      U


,        .  , U


  U


          .        U


,       U


,   .






.1.    



    U


,         U


(),       A {


,  


 ,A


},     j-   R


   U


(


)    p


=p(A


)     x


= X(A


) = x





+ x





+ .+ x





.            Rj (. .1).

      U


,     ,    I.     U


         ()   ()       ,    ,           .   ,  U


     ,      X,    .    ,        U


(B),     B {B


,  B


 ,B


},     j-   Rj   U


(B


)   p


=p(B


),            x


= X(B


) (. .2).






.2.  



          U


.          ,    , -,   , -,    ,       X ,  ,        ,     ,                     ,     U


.

     U


,          x


,   :                .  ,      x


 =x





+ x





+ .+ x





  ,    ,      .    X       ,     ,        .  ,                 .  ,   X    ,          [31 -      ,            [Samuelson, 1954, . 108];   ,   . ,       ,         :     ,  ,       [, 1994, . 549].  ,              .].

        .   U


     U


     X                  X.          [32 -           S-,   ,  G-   ,   ,              FS- [Margolis, 1982, .3646].].        II ( ).     N   U


, U


, ,U


     X         U


 = f(U


, U


, ,U


)     U


     ,    X   :         N,           U


(X)  U


(X).

,          ,    X  .   ,       X -  [33 -    ,   ,     ,    .]        ,         .               ? , .   ,         X





.   ,      


 =x





+ x





+ .+ x





,          .

   ,       ,       ( II)     ,       ,  ,             .   ,                  .       ,       ,       


    U


(


)   ,     U


(B


)        .       ,      ,          .

        II.          -   ,       [Lindahl, 1958].               ,             ,       ,   .

    ,      -. -,              :     ,   ,       ;         ,       .

-,   -               ,               [Lindahl, 1958, . 85].            .          ,          ,      .

-,   -         ,    .     ,    ,      ,      [Lindahl, 1967, . 86, 91].    ,        ,    ,      .        ,   :   pj,    i-        x





;   p





,          x


 = x





+ x





+ .+ x





.



 ,         :              ,  -     ,        X,     -.  ,           ,     (. .3).






.3.  -   



       III ( ).     U


      X,       x





,     p





,              :             X


,     p





  p





.                       ,    ,    .   ,             [34 - ,     ,     ,     ,    .     ,    ,     .].      (p


)       X; ,   (p


),   ,       X       ,       U


.

   ,      II.       ,            U


, U


, ,U


      ,        U


,   ,            : MC


 = MU


 + MU


.

 ,                              ,   ,     .              ,        .   ,            . ,     ,     ,        ,        .          ,      U


.

            .        . ,            .       :     -             ,       ,       ,     ,     .           :            ,        ,  , ,   [, 2008, .113143].


* * *

          .            :      ,   .                            ,      ,   .

      ,             - ,  ,     ,  ,       .       ,            ,        .   ,      .   . . -,          . , . , .      XX .

    ,  , -,    .                .        ,   .              .  ,        .        ,                     .

-,       ,      ,         , ,    .       ,   a priori      : ,    ,    .         ,    ,    ,      .      .       ,    .

 , -,       ,               ,   .                 ,    ,       ,      .

                                           ,       .


 

 . .     . ., 1998.

 .   //  . 1995. 12; 1996. 12, 710; 1997. 7.

 . .,  . .     //  . 2005. 5.

 . .     . ., 2010.

 .   ,    . ., 2004.

 .    . ., 1994.

 .      . ., 2008.

 .   . ., 1999.

 .  // -.    . . 1. ., 1991.

 .    //    .  . ., 1997.

 . .  . ., 1994.

 .    . ., 1980.

 .       //  . 2002. . 2. 4.

 . - . ., 2009.

 .  . . I. ., 1994.

 . .    :       . ., 2001.

 . .,  . .   . ., 2008.

 . .,  . .  . ., 2000.

 .  .   , 1899.

- .    //  . 2004. 6.

 . .   ,   . . ., 2007.

 .     .    //  . 1993. 2.

 .    :    //  . 2012. 5.

 .-.   . ., 2007.

 . . -     . ., 2008.

 . .       :   . ., 2007.

 . .   (1859) //   . 1993. 11, 12.

 . .     .         . ., 1914.

     //  . 2004. 6.

 . ,     . ., 1997.

 . .    . ., 2010.

 .  : ,     //     . . 2. ., 1992.

 .  . , 1995.

 . .     .  I.         //    . 2009. 1.

 . .     .  2.      //    . 2009. 2.

 . .  :   //  . 2011. 3.

 . .  .    . ., 2010.

 . .   . ., 2008.

 .    . ., 1996.

 .   . ., 2004.

 . .    . ., 2000.

 . .   . ., 2009.

 . .    //    . 2008. 5.

 .  : -  //  . 2010. 11.

 .    //  . 2001. 4.

 .   //  . ., 2004.

 . .  //  . ., 2004.

 .   :    //  . 2008. 8.

 . .    //    . ., 1996.

 . .   :  ,  ,  .  . 12  1972.     .    . ., 2005.

Agassi J. Methodological Individualism // Modes of Individualism and Collectivism. London, 1973.

Agassi J. Methodological individualism // The British Journal of Sociology. 1960. Vol. 11. 3.

Aoki M. Toward a Comparative Institutional Analysis. Cambridge (MA), 2001.

Arrow K. Social Choice and Individual Values. New York, 1951.

Arrow K., Debreu G. The Existence of and Equilibrium for a Competitive Economy // Econometrica. 1954. Vol. XXII.

Bergson A. A Reformulation of Certain Aspects of Welfare Economics // Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1938. February.

Bhaskar R. The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of the Contemporary Human Sciences. Brighton, 1989.

Black M. Margins of Precision. Essays in Logic and Language. Ithaca, 1970.

Bortis H. From neo-liberal Capitalism to Social Liberalism on the basis of Classical-Keynesian Political Economy. Switzerland, 2009.

Boudon R. Individualisme ou holisme: un dbat metodologique fondamental // Mendras H., Verret M. Les Champs de la sociologie fran?aise. Paris, 1988.

Boudon R. La logique du sociale: introduction ? lanalyse sociologique. Paris, 1979.

Harsanyi J. Cardinal Welfare, Individualistic Ethics, and Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility // Journal of Political Economy. 1955. August.

Giddens A. Sociology. Cambridge, 2001.

Giddens A. The Constitution of Society. Outline of the Theory of Structuration. Cambridge, 1984.

Grinberg R., Rubinstein A. Economic Sociodynamics. Berlin, New York, 2010.

Kincaid H. Methodological Individualism/Atomism // The Handbook of Economic Methodology. London, 1998.

Lindahl E. Positive Losung, Die Gerechtigkeit der Besteuerung Eine Analyse der Steuerprinzipien auf Grundlage der Grenznutzentheorie, translated as: Just taxation  a positive solution, 1919 // Classics in the Theory of Public Finance. London, 1967.

Margolis H. Selfishness, Altruism and Rationality: A Theory of Social Choice. Chicago, London, 1982.

Menger C. Grundsatze der Volkswirtschaftslehre. Wien  Leipzig, 1923.

Musgrave R. A. The Theory of Public Finance. New York  London, 1959. The Nature and Scope of Social Science. A Critical Anthology. New York, 1969.

Modes of Individualism and Collectivism. London, 1973.

Persson T., Tabellini G. The Economic Effects of Constitutions. Cambridge (MA), 2005.

Posnett J. Trends in the Income of Charities, 1980 to 1985 // Charity Trends 1986/87. Tonbridge, 1987.

Rose-Ackermann S. Altruism, Nonprofits, and Economic Theory // Journal of Economic Literature. 1996. Vol. 34. 2.

Salamon L., Hems L., Chinnock K. The Nonprofit Sector: For What and for Whom? // Working Papers of the Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project. 37. Baltimore, 2000.

Samuelson P. A. The pure theory of public expenditure // Review of Economics and Statistics. 1954. Vol. 36. 4.

Samuelson P. Reaffirming the Existence of Reasonable Bergson-Samuelson Social Welfare Functions // Economics. 1978. 173.

Schaffle A. E. F. Das gesellschaftliche System der menschlichen Wirtschaft, 3. Aufl., 1. Band, 1873.

Sen A. Development as Freedom. Oxford, 1999. Le socialisme liberal. Une anthologie: Europe-Etats-Unis. Paris, 2003.

Stigler G. The Theory of Economic Regulation // Bell Journal of Economics. 1971. Vol. 2. 1.

Taylor Ch. Cross-Purposes: The Liberal-Communitarian Debate // Liberalism and Moral Life. Harvard, 1989.

Touraine A. Un nouveau paradigme. Pour comprendre le monde daujourdhui. Paris, 2005.

Wicksell K. Finanstheoretiche Untersuchungen, Jena, 1896.




.. .  ,     


   . .       ;     , ,   .



 컠       ,    ,     ( ,   , )    , ,   .                     . .     [, 2012]               ().         .

       .          .  ,         ,       ,  .


    

     ,  ,    :   (    )    (        ,     ).    ,  ,    ,         .  :    ,   ,      ( )  ( ).         ,      ex ante     .

            . -,                    ,     ,         .        (, ,   ),     ,   .          ,       ;       ,    [35 -         ,   , , ;       , , ,  [, , 2011].].

-,                  ,       ;          . ,      (    ,       .           .    )           ,        .         (, ,   )  .

    ,           :   ,      .             .     ,          ,          ,  ,                     .               . ,          ,                [36 -  ,             ,       ,   .            [Pomeranz, 2000].]. ,       ,                  ;             ,    (, ,  )     ?

,          ,          [37 -  ,          ,      ,  ,      ,      ( ,         ).]. ,          .                  (,   [38 -           ,          ,    .]),      .     ,  ,       ,       : ,          .             ,             ,  ,   .

,           ,  ,   ?                  (,           ). ,             ,    (      ),          . ,               ,       .                [39 -    ,                          [, , 2011];        ,                .].      ,         [, 2000].   ,   ,       ,       .

            ,    ,   .         ,     [Fligstein, 2002; Oleinik, 2010].    , ,        .

    ,                     ,   ,  .  ,          껠   :      (,  ,  .  [Buchanan, 1987]),   ,     , , ,    [Boltanski, Thevenot, 2006]      ,   . ,   ,   :                     , ,  ,            .


    

          ,      ,          .      ,           .         ,      ,    ,     .      ;       ,     (,   [40 -             (    ),     .])        [41 -       [Block, 2011]. ,       ,  ,      ..          .].

    , ,            ,       (:      ,    ,          ). ,    .  ,   ,       ;    ,            .    ,                     [Voigt, 2011],     .  ,         ,  .

 ,  ,          .  ,      ,      (  )          [42 -  ( )   ,  (  )          ,  ( , )      .].      ,         ,        ,     . ,          ,      ,  ,        . ,    ,          (,  ). ,       ,           [43 -  ,       (,  ,       )      ,   ,     ,  ,        ,    .         .   ,      ,                 .].

   ,            . -,          ,    -   ,          . -,    ,             , ,       ,  ,           (     ),     (    ). -,              ,     , ,    . -,          ,      ,   [44 -        ,        ExxonValdez,       : ,               ,         .]    .      ;           ,         ,                  . ,       ,             .

           ,           .  ,  , ,   ,    (,   ),    (  )      (  ,  )     .    , ,          ,     ,   , ,   ,    .   ,              ,       .  , ,              ,             ,   ,     ,        .

  ,   ,          .              .         ,  ,     (libertarian paternalism) [, 2009].          (        )  ,                    .


  

 , ,  ,              .          ,    . -,    (bounded willpower)             : ,      ,      .

 ,          ,     [45 -     ,         ,   .  ,      ,  ,       [ODonoghue, Rabin, 2001].]. -,   (bounded self-interest)   ,                      . -, ,    (bounded cognition)        , , ,     .      ,     (     !) .

     . ,       ,                   (wanting  liking dualism).     ,    (     )     (wanting system),    (    )  (liking system).           [Herrmann-Pillath, 2010][46 -      (experienced utility)    (decision utility)      ,      .]. ,    ,  ,          ,         .         (joy of destruction) [Abbink, Sadrieh, 2009];         ,        [Mildenberger, 2012][47 - ,           .              , , -,       [Piccione, Rubinstein, 2007],               ,   .]. , ,        .

         . ,             ; ,       [Bowles, Polania-Reyes, 2012].                      [McFadden, 2006].                  ,     [48 -  [Abel-Koch, 2011] ,    ,  ,            .         ,     (, )   [ODonoghue, Rabin, 2003].],        .  ,           ,                   .


 

      . -,               ,   ,     .   (      2000- .)    .   ,         ,         [49 -  ,  (complete)    ,           ,       .].  , ,             [Benartzi, Thaler, 2002]. ,       ,   . ,         ,       .

,  ,             (default option) [Sunstein, Thaler, 2003; Thaler, Sunstein, 2003, 2009][50 -  ,                    ,          .].         .              -,    .        :  ,       ,   ,           .       - (        ,     ),     (,   )  ..    ,   ,               .

     . -,   ,          ,      ( ,      ) .       ( ),     (,  ,    ). ,    ,     (   )         ,   ,     . -,    ,          . ,         ,       .            ,           ,       .

         . -,          .            ,     .  ,             ,     .     ,       ,     [Berggren, 2012],      [Stevenson, 2005]. -, ,  -          ,       .   ,         ,          [51 -     ,      2000- .                        ,  .       .]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/raznoe-65383/socialnyy-liberalizm/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


 . .   /  . , , 1999, .412423 (   . .  / Peter Struve, Sozialliberalismus // Internationales Handworterbuch des Gewerkschaftswesens. Bd. 2. Berlin, 1932. S. 15311536).




2


 . .  :     // , 3917,15.09.2015.




3


       .  [, 20015]   . ,      .




4


         -            (2004, 6).        , ,   ,   .




5


    ,  . . ,     . ,           ,         [ (1993, . 12)].




6


     ,   ,   [Sunstein, Thaler, 2003]   [Camerer et al., 2003] ,         . . : [, 2013


, 2013[6]].




7


       ,         ,          [, , 2000; 2008; Grinberg, Rubinstein, 2005; , 2010].




8


  . ,     ,    ,      ,           [, 2007, . 332]. ,     ,      ,        [Arrow, Debreu, 1954],  ,   ,     ,   . ,   . ,     [Samuelson, 1954].




9


       ,      :    ,      ,        ..




10


    .    . ,        ,    ,       .    ,        ,            ,    .          .




11


  ,        ,        [, 2004, . 100],      1950- .    .




12


     ,    ,          [, 1994].        , ,   ,         .




13


.      .  [, 1995-




14


  ,    :         ,    ,    [, 2001, . 10].




15


             ,           .




16


,    ,     ,      ,    .       .




17


        ,  ,      ,          , , ,   [Margolis, 1982, . 14].   , .  ,         ,        ,      [, 1997, .3031].




18


      .  [Harsanyi, 1955]    .     . : ,           .       ,   ,     ,         ,        [, 2005, . 78].




19


   ,      ,   [, 2010, .111116].




20


  ,       ,        ,           , ,   .     . ,                    ,      .




21


             -   -     ,          [, 1997, . 18].           ,       .




22


           ,   ,        [Margolis, 1982, . 17]. ,             .




23


  .    . , . , . , . .   ,         ,  ,  ,  ..




24


    ,           (., : [, 2004]).




25


              1909.  -       (Wertjreiheit),     .




26


     .   軠  ,  ,   ,   ,  .       [Black, 1970, . 24].




27


,         .    -,  ,     ,     .




28


         (., , [Persson, Tabellini, 2005; , 2007, 2008]).




29


       . ,      [Tirole, 1986].




30


 ,              ,          [Samuelson, 1954].          ,    ,       ,      .




31


     ,            [Samuelson, 1954, . 108];   ,   . ,       ,         :     ,  ,       [, 1994, . 549].  ,              .




32


          S-,   ,  G-   ,   ,              FS- [Margolis, 1982, .3646].




33


   ,   ,     ,    .




34


,     ,     ,     ,    .     ,    ,     .




35


        ,   , , ;       , , ,  [, , 2011].




36


 ,             ,       ,   .            [Pomeranz, 2000].




37


 ,          ,      ,  ,      ,      ( ,         ).




38


          ,          ,    .




39


   ,                          [, , 2011];        ,                .




40


            (    ),     .




41


      [Block, 2011]. ,       ,  ,      ..          .




42


 ( )   ,  (  )          ,  ( , )      .




43


 ,       (,  ,       )      ,   ,     ,  ,        ,    .         .   ,      ,                 .




44


       ,        ExxonValdez,       : ,               ,         .




45


    ,         ,   .  ,      ,  ,       [ODonoghue, Rabin, 2001].




46


     (experienced utility)    (decision utility)      ,      .




47


,           .              , , -,       [Piccione, Rubinstein, 2007],               ,   .




48


 [Abel-Koch, 2011] ,    ,  ,            .         ,     (, )   [ODonoghue, Rabin, 2003].




49


 ,  (complete)    ,           ,       .




50


 ,                    ,          .




51


    ,      2000- .                        ,  .       .


