 .    
. . 

. . 

. . 

. . 


              ,        ,            20162017,   ,           .            ,   20162017 .                         .    ,    .





.. , . . , . . , . . 

 :    



       

        

   20162017

  



2- , 



:

  ,      ,           

  , ...,         (  )



R.D. Farkhutdinov, L.I. Khamidullina, A.R. SuleymanovA, R.R. Shigabetdinov

TAX DISPUTES: FROM THEORY TO PRACTICE



Theoretical aspects of interbranch relations of civil and tax law

Index to the text of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation

Developments of tax legislation 20162017

Samples of procedural documents



2nd edition, revised



MOSCOW

YUSTITSINFORM

2018



Reviewers:

Egorova M.V., Chairman of administrative and other public law cases section of the Arbitration Court for the Volga Region

Levushkin A.N., Professor of Civil Law Department of the All-Russian State University of Justice (RPA of the Ministry of Justice of Russia), Doctor of Law, Professor



Tax disputes: from theory to practice / R. D. Farkhutdinov, L. 1. Khamidullina, A. R. Suleymanova, R. R. Shigabetdinov. 2nt ed., revised. M.: Yustitsinform, 2018. 92 p.



This revised edition contains the materials of theoretical studies of civil and tax law interbranch relations, as well as judicial practice of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan for the period 20162017, concerning tax legal relations, structured in accordance with the sections and chapters of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation.

Judicial practice is presented in the form of brief conclusions on the most relevant judicial acts rendered in 20162017. The proposed format allows the reader to freely navigate the large volume of judicial decisions and promotes the formation of structured knowledge about the approaches of courts to the problematic issues of tax legal relations.

For a wide range of readers interested in the issues of tax legislation



Keywords: transaction reality, tax disputes, developments of tax legislation, sample documents, judicial practice.



 LLC Yustitsinform, 2018







         ,                   .

,  ?

     ,   ,               ,    .

 ,    ,      (   50 %     ),           ,         -.

    :              - ,           ,        ,     .

          ,           ,    ,  .

         ,  ,  . 198.199  ,     , , .

               2016  2017 .,     .




 1

       





-  (   ) - 


                 - .        ,    -         .

       ,  ,          .

             ,       .

       ,                 .

            ,         .

  ,     ,            . . .[1 -  . .     :   / 2009.]

  ,    ,   . . [2 -  . .       (, , ):  / 2014. -224 .], . . [3 -  . .        //   .    3(29). -2015.], . . [4 -  . .      / , -. 2013. 188 .].

    ,                 , . .      - ,    ,   ,       .                [5 -  . .       (, , ): . /2014. 224 .].

         , ,      ,     ,                 .

    , -,       , -,  ,       , , -         ,   ,      .

          , , ,    - ,   , , .     ,        , ,    ,         ,    .             ,           [6 -  . .,  . .      /   // Email: istfil@mail.osu.ru].

      ,          ,           ,    .

   ,     [7 -     (. 1)  31.07.1998  146- (.  03.07.2016) ( . ., .   01.09.2016)]       ,  ,  ,  , ,    ,           ,       .

      , -        ,         () ,  . . [8 -  . . -   : .  . . : .: 2001.].

, , . .   :  () , . .  ,    ,      ,                - .

 ,    -     ,       -  ,         ,       [9 -  . .       (, , ): . . .  / , -.-2014. -224 .].

 ,          ,                 .   ,           ,               ,    ,   -,       -      .

  ,        (. 166  [10 -     (. 1)  30.11.1994  51- (.  03.07.2016) ( . ., .   02.10.2016).]),           (. 170  [11 -  .]).             .

,       ,         ,    ,     ,   .

       . . 3, 4     53[12 -      12.10.2006  53         .]:      ,  ,  ,                 ,        (  ).       ,             .

        03  2015 .    07-4879/2013[13 -      03.02.2015  309-14-2191.] ,                          - ,            .

    ,         ,                                 .

 ,                     ,           .




     


  -  - ,       ,  ,    .

                  ,  ,           (. . [14 -  . .               /   .  .  1 (34). 2013.], . . [15 -  . .        ,    // 19.11.2015 http://xn 7sbbaj7auwnffhk.xn-p1 ai/article/13994], . . [16 -  . . -   ,           /  . . : 12.00.03 //   . .: 2010. 176 .]).

    ,  ,   . 1064    20152016 .   .

,  . 57          [17 -    (   12.12.1993) (  ,          30.12.2008  6-,  30.12.2008  7-,  05.02.2014  2-,  21.07.2014  11  ).].

         ,    .        ,    .

                     .           :




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/a-r-suleymanova/nalogovye-spory-ot-teorii-k-praktike/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


 . .     :   / 2009.




2


 . .       (, , ):  / 2014. -224 .




3


 . .        //   .    3(29). -2015.




4


 . .      / , -. 2013. 188 .




5


 . .       (, , ): . /2014. 224 .




6


 . .,  . .      /   // Email: istfil@mail.osu.ru




7


    (. 1)  31.07.1998  146- (.  03.07.2016) ( . ., .   01.09.2016)




8


 . . -   : .  . . : .: 2001.




9


 . .       (, , ): . . .  / , -.-2014. -224 .




10


    (. 1)  30.11.1994  51- (.  03.07.2016) ( . ., .   02.10.2016).




11


 .




12


     12.10.2006  53         .




13


     03.02.2015  309-14-2191.




14


 . .               /   .  .  1 (34). 2013.




15


 . .        ,    // 19.11.2015 http://xn 7sbbaj7auwnffhk.xn-p1 ai/article/13994




16


 . . -   ,           /  . . : 12.00.03 //   . .: 2010. 176 .




17


   (   12.12.1993) (  ,          30.12.2008  6-,  30.12.2008  7-,  05.02.2014  2-,  21.07.2014  11  ).


