   .  .   
 


  ,      ,  .   :                  :                    





   .  .   



 



  



 ,2018

 , ,2018



ISBN978-5-4490-6097-6

     Ridero




     .  

  

  





 . 

  

    



2012



Beyond aReasonable Doubt

Convincing Evidence ofthe Truths ofJudaism

Rabbi Shmuel Waldman

Feldheim Publishers

Jerusalem-NewYork

2005



 All rights for Russian translation and edition reserved

byGedalia Spinadel

Gedalia Spinadel

Am Asefer Publishing House

10\10Mexico, Jerusalem, 91270

Tel. 972-2-6416790; 052-890-8899

E-mail:gedaliasp@gmail.com (mailto:gedaliasp@gmail.com)




InBlessed Memory

Ofour dear father and grandfather

Rabbi Mendy Schachter zl

May his memory be ablessing forus all. He passed away on the 8th ofIyar, 5762

Avrohom and Sheavy Schachter, Shmuly, Esti, Shragi, Asher, Shaindy, and Yaakov Simcha







InBlessed Memoryofmy dear father

Rabbi Hershel Waldman zl

Beloved byone and all. He passed away on the 21st ofKislev, 5758

From his son, The author ofthis book

Shmuel Waldman and family







InBlessed Memory of

Reb Chaim Mosheben Reb Menachem MendelZL










 ,     ,          . , , ,         堖     .  ,    .

       ,    ,  , ,      ,         ,    ,   .

   ,  ,          .     .

.  .      ,          .

       ,      .

         .

Ƞ ,          ,   ,     ,    .



 

2003



  :



        .       .    ,    ,       [1 -   ࠖ .. spinadel.com].  .

           ,       Eastern UnionCommercial Real Estate Financing     .      ,  ,     .   ,     ,      ,      . ,  ,      . . Ƞ  ,    , ,    .   ,      ,    .            ,       .       , ,   .   ,    ,     .



 

2012







.

.

.

     ?

     ?



.   蠖    . ,  ,  ,     .

 : 1)    蠖     .

 젖 , ,       .

   ,      .

   .

        ,    .   ,   ,   ,   .  ,      ,       .

   -



 ,         [2 - . .       ,     ,     http://www.dovidgottlieb.com/publications.htm (http://www.dovidgottlieb.com/publications.htm) ( 堖 ..).    :   .     .    ,   ࠫ :    ,     .    ,     ,     ,   ,  .  ,    ,     (      ..)?   ,    ,  ,    ?  , ,     ,   , , ,   .        ,  ,    ,  .]! ,    , ,   .    ,    ?   ,   ?  ,  .  ,      , ,   . Ƞ-  ,    ,    ,   ,      . Ƞ 

 ,     ,       (, 23:28).      ,  ,  ,  . Ƞ ,    ,     ,              ,    -    ,    ,  .

      .     ,       .  .   , - , ࠖ   ,     ⠖    ,    ,   ,    .  ,    ,  .

         .     ,      , ,       .   .    ࠖ   .  ,   ,   ,    .  .     ,  . Ƞ .   ,    . ,  3300 ࠖ    .

 ,   ,     . ! !

 ,          .    ,       ,   ,    ,     ࠖ     ,      ,  -.



    :

* www.aish.com

* www.beingjewish.com (ABCS  )

* www.ohr.edu

* www.dovidgottlieb.com/publications.htm (.   Living Up tothe Truth,    .      ,    ,   ,  ࠖ ! . . . 12   堖 ..)

* http://www.torah.org/

 ,    :

* www.outreachjudaism.org

* www.jewsforjudaism.org

* www. Drazin.com .     The Hollow Inheritance ( ),        .    8  ,     .    ,   , ,      . (     ,  www.drazin.com/chap1.htm    8,   ,        , : www.drazin.com/chap2.htm).

           (464.),  . .      ()      .  ࠖ      (Gerald Segal),           www.jewsforjudaism.org.

  ,    : www.faithfreedom.org and www.alisina.org

      : www.evrey.com; www.toldot.ru, http://istok.ru/; www.limud.ru; www.machanaim.org; http://midrasha.net/; http://rmbm.brinkster.net/tanakh/toratmoshe.aspx;

Ƞ-   https://jewishbook.ca/




   


1ࠖ  .

2ࠖ      ( ).    ,          .

3ࠖ       ,      ࠖ  .

4ࠖ , ,   .       ,   .

5ࠖ ,            . Ƞ -       (   ),      [3 - . ,   Small Miracles and Small Miracles II byYitta Halberstam and Judith Levental, Adams Media Corp., 1997.].

6ࠖ ,          ,    .

7ࠖ   ,      ,     .

8ࠖ      ,   ,   ,  [4 - .   ,      .   ,  ,       ,     . What Darwin Didnt Know: ADoctor Dissects the Theory ofEvolution, byGeoffrey Simmons, M.D., 2004.].



   ,  ,   ,            ,        .  .    ,     ,   .

  .



   -   , ,  : shmuelwaldman5@gmail.com (mailto:shmuelwaldman5@gmail.com).

 ,   .




I

 


    ,  ,  ,   : -   !   !

  ,        .     ,   :    .    , ,    , .     ,  ,     ,   .       [5 -   ,    ,  ,   . ,     ,   , , : Signs ofIntelligence: Understanding ofIntelligent Design, byWilliam Dembski, James Kushner, Michigan, Brazos Press, 2001. Darwin s Black Box: The Biochemical Challenge toEvolution, byMichael Behe, Free Press, 1996; The Hidden Face ofGod, byGerald Schroeder, New York, Free Press, 2001.]!

  -     ,    .

 ,    .







     ,   .   ,   ,     (  ),   ,       ,   : !

  .  .  ?  : , , , .     .  ,    ,  .     ,      ,    ,   . Ƞ?   200 .

  ,    ?    ?  ?  ?   ,  ?     ,  ,  ,  , ,   ,   , ,   .        ,      ,  ,    !     .  ?   ,  ,  ,  !

   .

:  ,      , ,   蠖 .  ,        , ,    .

 ,   ,       ?

  ?

  ?

,   ,   ,     .

   ,    ?

   .

? Ƞ    ?

   ,      .

 :

 ?    ?

,   .

.  ,    ?

,  .

, -, .

       .      .

?

.  .       ,  

  ?   ?

  ,   .  .  .  ,     , .

?

.   .     ,    ,     :  .,    ,     ,  .    ,     ,   !

    ?

. .   .

  ?  .

?

,   ,  ,   ?

.

, .    ?

Ѡ?

.

   .

  ?

 ,  .    ,   ,       .     . Ƞ   ,  , ,   ,     ࠖ ,       ,     .       ,  ,      ,  .

,  ,   ,   ,    ?

.

     ,     ?

.

Ƞ ,     ?

  ?

 .  :    .  ,   . Ƞ ,  .       ,  ,    ,   ?

,   .    .  - .

    ?

.

  ,  ?

 ,   .

,  ,  - ,   ,   .







   ,    . . ,   - , ,    ,   . ,    . , .   - , 

 .

 .

Ѡ  .  :

Ƞ  ?

,   ,  .

  ,  .   ,   ,   .

.  .   .

, ,  .

 .     ,  ,   .

 ? ,  .  , ,   ,   ?

   .       ,  .

Ƞ ?

 .

 ?

  ,    . Ƞ .

  ,   .

,   .

,  .

,   ,     ,      .

  ,      ?

,   ,  , , .   ,  ,   .  ?

  ,   ,     .

,    ,    ,  ,  [6 -   ,    ,    , : Ӡ   ,    ,   ,   . Ƞ      .  , ,  ,    ,  ,   .         .    ,        (Report, June 1966, Confession ofProfessed Atheist, A.Huxley).]?

    ,  :       .         ,       . Ƞ       -   [7 - Michael Denton, Evolution: ATheory inCrisis, London: Burnet Books, 1985, pp. 326329.],   .

     , ,  ,       .  ,           .    .  ,   ,       .      ,        .       ,       .    . ,  :      , -   [8 - C.Darwin (1860)  Asa Gray, inF. Darwin, Life and letters ofCharles Darwin, vol.2, London: John Murray, 1883, p.273.].

 ,    ,   ,   ,  .   , ,      . ,      ,  .         .

   ,     .

 



    .

      .   ,                  .

   , , .     ,    ,    .

  .

Ӡ    ,  ,   ,  ,   ,    ,  .   ,    ,   .  ,      . Ƞ    , .     ,  ,   .  .    .      ,      ,    .      ,  .

 ,     , ,      ?   ,     ,   . ,   ?

   , ,  -   ,     ,  .      ,   ,        ,     , 蠫   .

   ,           ,   .  ?

 ,   ,          . ,      ,   .

      .      ,    .     ,          ,    .  ,     ,   ,    .   ,     ,     .    砫,    , ,      .

           .

 , ,   ,      ?







  .    . 蠖     ,   ,    .    ?     ,   ,       .    ,     .       ,     ,   .







         堖    .    , -    .    ?  -,       ࠖ    . ,   ,       ,          -,  .         .             ,     .    ,   ,     ,     ,    ,    .     ,   ,      .      ?  ,             ,      .




.  


    ,         ,  .

   .

 ,   ,   ?     .     ,    ,   ,  ,   .

 ?       .  .    ?     .      ?           ,     ,  ,  . Ƞ       ,   ,    ? ,  ,   .?

 :      .

        ,       ,    ?

    ,  堖     .  ,   ? 堖   .

,  ,    .     .

   ,    ,   .     ,      [9 - ABCs ofNature, pp. 166167.].        ?

   .    ,   .

             .      ?

,   .

  ,  ,     ,   . Ƞ    .

     .  ,    ,   .        .       .

      .      ,     ,   .

 ?







,      ?     , .   ,       . ,  ,     ,   ,   ,    ,   .

 ,       . ,      ,   .




 


  頖  ,    ,     .    ,  ,                ,         .

, .    ,      .          .  ,      ,  10 .    ,   100,000,000,000,000,000,000    ,     ,    .

    ,    ,      ,     .   :  ,      ,       (  ),    [10 - F. Hoyle and C. Wickramasinghe, Evolution from Space, Dent and Sons, 1981, p.24.].

        .

           , ,   ,   ,     .

,    137  !      ,    ,      .

            ,        .

 ࠖ    ,  , ,   fight-or-flight   .

,        . (  .)    ,           .            ,    ,     .        :     ,  ,   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  .      .    

,           . Ƞ ,     ,    ,   ,     ,      ,   .         ?

  [11 - Evolution: ATheory inCrisis :  , p.330.]:



     (   ),    .       ,      .      10.000.000.000.000.000.    , ,     (  )  .           ,         蠖    ! Ƞ     ,   . Ƞ      ,  -  ,     .



  ,   ,      ,   ,   (  , 3:14).




 


 - ,      ?    , , 110250 .

     ,       , , , ,    ,   ,  [12 - Physics Today 25, pp. 2328.]:   ,      ,    ,   ,  !

           :   ,   ,   ,     .

   ? [13 -    ,    . Π     ,    , ,   ,   (     ).].



   , -,    ,     (, 102:24).




2

 


 ,    ,    ,   ,    .    ,   ,    [14 -     ( every.com      ):     ,   -㠖 ,  ,     .  ࠖ   , ,    , ,   ,    ..]?   ,      -[15 -   ,     ,   : Permission toReceive: Four Rational Approaches tothe Torahs Divine Origin ( :      , byLawrence (Targum/Feldheim, 1996). Ƞ     ,       , Living Up tothe Truth ,  . ( : www.ohr.org.il./special/books/gott/truth.htm  )..]? , ,   ,            ?

    :



                 .

      ,     .

 :     .

 :   .

 :  ,        .

 .



           . ,   ,  ,   ,     .        .  ,         ,     .

   ,      ,         ? -,   . -, ,   .     ?    , ,      ,   ,  .  ,   (    )   .    ,     ,        ,     ?        .

,      ,        , ,        .

         ,     ?

 ,      ,  .        (     ,     ).         .  ,    ,           :      ,    ,      ( , III XV, 3).        ⠖     ,        ,   .    ,       (,  , I, 8).  , ,    ,      (  II,21).

 ,  ,     ,      ,     .     ?  ,     ,     .

    ,    ,  -㠖  -,   (, 4:35).

 堖   ,      -.    ,      :        .




 :  


   ?,  .     ? Ƞ   ,  , ? ,   ,         ,  .        .     [16 -         ,      , Their Hallow Inheritance: AComprehensive Refutation byM. Drazin www. Drazin.com..].




 


 [17 -       (460)      ,   ,   頖 ..  J.McDowell, Evidence that Demands aVerdict, ,   , ,            .  ,     ,          ,  .]:  ,   ,   -  -  [18 -    (,  )  ,   ,    , , ,    .      ,    ,   .   :   .]. , ,    .   (, 5:1718),        .    (, 26:17),     (26:26)  . Ƞ    ,  ,    .

  , ,  .   ,        .  ,   ,       ,   ,   ,  .

   ,   ,     .     ,    ,    (, 12:39).

     ,   ,  ,   ,    .     [19 - The Mythmaker: Paul and the Invention ofChristianity ( :   ) byH. Maccoby, Barnes&Noble, 1986,  .  ,    , 렖  .   ..].      (  ,     ).         (젖   ,  ).

 ,      ,        .   ,   ,      (   ),    .   ,     ,    (  I, 9:2022; , 2:610).

        ,   ,  .        - ,  .       ,  ,    .   ,      .

  ,   ,   .     ,  ,         .     .          ,  .   (  , 9:1922): ,   ,    ,   .      ,   ;     ,   ;   ࠖ   ,     -,  ,    ;     ,   .     셻.




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/shmuel-valdman/vne-sfery-razumnogo-somneniya-istina-iudaizma-fakty-i-svide/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


  ࠖ .. spinadel.com




2


. .       ,     ,     http://www.dovidgottlieb.com/publications.htm (http://www.dovidgottlieb.com/publications.htm) ( 堖 ..).    :   .     .    ,   ࠫ :    ,     .    ,     ,     ,   ,  .  ,    ,     (      ..)?   ,    ,  ,    ?  , ,     ,   , , ,   .        ,  ,    ,  .




3


. ,   Small Miracles and Small Miracles II byYitta Halberstam and Judith Levental, Adams Media Corp., 1997.




4


.   ,      .   ,  ,       ,     . What Darwin Didnt Know: ADoctor Dissects the Theory ofEvolution, byGeoffrey Simmons, M.D., 2004.




5


  ,    ,  ,   . ,     ,   , , : Signs ofIntelligence: Understanding ofIntelligent Design, byWilliam Dembski, James Kushner, Michigan, Brazos Press, 2001. Darwin s Black Box: The Biochemical Challenge toEvolution, byMichael Behe, Free Press, 1996; The Hidden Face ofGod, byGerald Schroeder, New York, Free Press, 2001.




6


  ,    ,    , : Ӡ   ,    ,   ,   . Ƞ      .  , ,  ,    ,  ,   .         .    ,        (Report, June 1966, Confession ofProfessed Atheist, A.Huxley).




7


Michael Denton, Evolution: ATheory inCrisis, London: Burnet Books, 1985, pp. 326329.




8


C.Darwin (1860)  Asa Gray, inF. Darwin, Life and letters ofCharles Darwin, vol.2, London: John Murray, 1883, p.273.




9


ABCs ofNature, pp. 166167.




10


F. Hoyle and C. Wickramasinghe, Evolution from Space, Dent and Sons, 1981, p.24.




11


Evolution: ATheory inCrisis :  , p.330.




12


Physics Today 25, pp. 2328.




13


   ,    . Π     ,    , ,   ,   (     ).




14


    ( every.com      ):     ,   -㠖 ,  ,     .  ࠖ   , ,    , ,   ,    ..




15


  ,     ,   : Permission toReceive: Four Rational Approaches tothe Torahs Divine Origin ( :      , byLawrence (Targum/Feldheim, 1996). Ƞ     ,       , Living Up tothe Truth ,  . ( : www.ohr.org.il./special/books/gott/truth.htm  )..




16


        ,      , Their Hallow Inheritance: AComprehensive Refutation byM. Drazin www. Drazin.com..




17


      (460)      ,   ,   頖 ..  J.McDowell, Evidence that Demands aVerdict, ,   , ,            .  ,     ,          ,  .




18


   (,  )  ,   ,    , , ,    .      ,    ,   .   :   .




19


The Mythmaker: Paul and the Invention ofChristianity ( :   ) byH. Maccoby, Barnes&Noble, 1986,  .  ,    , 렖  .   ..


