  :  
  


        ,           .         ,   , ,  , , .  -           ,    .     ,         .       ,          ,  ,  ,    ,  ,   ,   .





  

  :  








           ,  ,   ,   . ,   ,      ,      ?    ,    ? , , ,             ?     ,       ,        ?

         .          , ,   ,      ,                       .          ,         :       ,     .   ,     ,      .  ,                  ,         .  ,   ,    , , ,  .        .    ,   ,   ,          ,          cogito,      .    ,     ,  ,  ,        .         .             ,     ,    ,     ,    , .  ,   ,   .          .

       ?    , ,           ,        90- [1 - .  . .    ? /, 1996, 6, 1997, 1, 2.].      ,      ,   ,    .          ,        ,     . ,   ,     [2 - .  . .     . .: , 1998;  . .    . .:       , 2004.].   ,    ,      (-)     ,    ,   ,          ,         ,      .  ,                    ,  ,         - .

      ,           .



1.      ,        ,     ,   ,    .      ,           ,  ,        , ,      , ,    .. ,              .      -  ,      ,    ,       ,    .           ,       !      . ,   ,  ,  ?      , , ,   .. ,   ,       (, , ,    ..)  ?     ,          ,    ,            [3 -  ,    ,    ,      ,      .   "  (    . . .) ,           .  .  . .: , 1990, . 631.].



2.     - ,   ?   ,   ,        ,  ,       .                              .    ,      ,     [4 - . Jouvenel B. de. The Pure Theory of Politics. Indianapolis (IN): Liberty Fund, 2000, pp. 268  269.].        ,     (   )  .             ,  ( ),  ( ,  ..),    (    ,  ,   ..).        (, ,   ..)                .        . .     ( ),    ,       ,      ,     ,      ,  ,        ,    .      ,      ,   . .      ,  ,     .         ,   ,   ,  [5 - .  . . .: , 2001, . 97  .].               .



3.     ,    ,     ,   ,      par excellence. ,         .         .   ,                      , ,   ,         .        ,       .    ,    廠       ,            ,     ,      , ,   ,   ,  ,    ,    ,        ,       ,  ,          .       ,     ,   -,   ,  .          ,       ,    ,        .    ,         ,  ,                 .

            (   )      .              .     ,   ,         [6 -   . .   . . 3. .: , 1977, . 339.].              . . 廠   ,       ,  ,       . .     [7 - .  ,              . .  .  .  .  .   . . 1. .: , 1991, . 285  .],          .    ,   ,    ,   ,   .  ,         -         ໠  .       .     ,                         .



4.          ,      ,     .                         ,    .          (        )    .   ,                     ( )   [8 - ,  ,       , , .          (      !), ,    ,    . .  .    /  . . .  . . 7. .: , 1994, . 49, 54.].       .    ,    (  )        ,     ,              .  , ,                 .           ,        [9 -              .    .       (   ).        .           ,    .    ,      ,         ,    . (. Habermas, J. Remarks on Discourse Ethics, in Habermas,J. Justification and Application, tr. C. Cronin. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press, 1993, p. 36 ff.  . . .).       (  )          .               ,          . (. Habermas, J., Between Facts and Norms, tr. W. Rehg. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press, 1996).].  ,     ,      .  ,   ,                 ,      ,     (    )  .            ,               .

  ,         ,  .               ,   ,     (  ) ,            -     .       .           ,           .    ,       .   ,         ,              [10 -   ,  ,    ,         .. ,       ,      ,     .    . (Foucault, M., Nietzsche, Genealogy, History, in Foucault, M., Language, Counter-Memory, Practice. Selected Essays and Interviews. Ed. D. F. Bouchard and S. Simon. Ithaca (NY): Cornell University Press, 1977, p. 142).       ,      .].                  .         ,    .

   ,          ,       ,          ,   ,  ,     .          ,   .           ,       ,      ,                  . ,       ,     .      ,         ,       ,   .    , ,   ,                   ,     ,           ,   .                 ,        .            .          .         [11 - . Shapiro, I., The Evolution of Rights in Liberal Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986, p. 198 ff.],   , ,     .        [12 -  . .    ,       . .   // . . . . 42, . 278.]                .   ,       ,      ,   [13 -      . . .  Capitalism and Democracy: Schumpeter Revisited, ed. R. D. Coe and C. K. Wilber. Notre Dame (in): University of Notre Dame Press, 1985, p. 154.],     ,          .



5.               .         .  ,               ,    ()            ,   .               , ..             .   ,       ,    ,     [14 -     . Horkheimer, M., Traditional and Critical Theory, in Critical Sociology. Selected Readings, ed. P. Connerton. Harmondsworth (UK): Penguin, 1976, pp. 212 ff.].          ,         .         -,         ,                . (      ,              ).



6.     ,    ,   ,      ,                  .   ,                   .         ,      ,   ,    ,   :    ,  ,   ,         ?..  ,     ,        ,               ,       [15 -  .   . . . . .: , 1994, .485486.].   ,  ,            .       ,        ,   .               (               )        ()        .

           ,         . .       ,     ,     ,          [16 -                () . , ,    ,         ,         . . Habermas, J., Civil Society, Public Opinion, and Communicative Power., in Between Facts and Norms, pp. 359387.]. ,          ,     .                   ,   ,  ,   .             [17 -  ,    ,       ,    . Castoriadis, CIntellectuals and History., in Castoriadis, C., Philosophy, Politics, Autonomy. Essays in Political Philosophy, ed. D. A. Curtis. ny: Oxford University Press, 1991, p. 12.].  .       ,        .  ,      ,      modus operandi      .        -      ,             ,       .      .    ,        ,   ,  -   .     (        . . .),    ,          [18 - Merleau-Ponty, M., Humanism and Terror, tr. J. ONeill. Boston: Beacon Press, 2001, p.XXIii (   . .).].



7.               ,    ?          ,     (   ) ,  , , ?            ,         :  ,   ,     .    ,         -  ,      [19 -  .    .  .  .  . .:  , 2006, . 6970.].           .    ,                   ( ,    ).  ,   ,           ,     (  )      [20 -   ,  ,    ,          (  ) .   ,   ,    ,   ,          (  )   . .  .    .  . ., . 8.].  ,       (  )            .   ,                ?,  (-)    ?,  ,   ,   (,   ) ?.           (  )?,     (   )?,  (  ,     )?         .

   ,         ,          ?   - :    , , ,      .   ,   ,       [21 -  .   (. . ).  .   . . . . . . . .: -      , 2004, . 75.].      ,    . , ,          .                  ,    .           ,   .        ⻠   ,     (sic!)[22 - . .   k . . . VIII. .-.: , 1935, . 50.].     . ,   (  )  ,       ,    .

   ,            (  )  ,       .            :        .          ,    [23 -  , . 32.].          ,   ,         ,         .                  ,      ,     .    , ,      ,   ,   .      .      ,     ,   .               ,    .         ,         ,   .          []  [24 -  , . 26.].   ,      .          .



,   ,     .     ()  ,                     ,  :  ,  ,   .         ,           ,      .          ,  ,   . ,    ,          .            ,        .

    ,     ,  -.           80-  90-   .                       .      -       ?          .    ,     .    ,       Realpolitik    -     .       ,  ,      ?       ?                軠    ?     "     .            -       , ,      ,          --.       ,               ,   ,        ,     ? ,    ,           ". ,     廠     .    ,      ,       ,       .        ,  ,   ,             (  )  .                    .

    .         ,  (   )        .             ,        ,   , ,  ,    ..,           .          ,     , ..         . :  []    [25 - .  .   .  .  .   . .: Ad Marginem, 2005, . 73.]. ,    -   , ,   ,         ,           .            .,          19891991 ,                         .

           , , ,      . ,      ,               , ..          ,        (      ).                      -  ,     ,        .               ,       ,    .             ,      ,         case study         ,           [26 - . , 2008, 5.].

   ,     2009 .            ,               ,    .      .           ,   ,    ,     .  ,     [27 - .  .  .       XX . .: -, 1999, . 29.].  , ,        ,        -.     컠         ,    ,         ,       -.        ,             [28 -              ,  ,  ,  ,     (. . .).                         ,   ,   ,      ..]         (  )    -   .

       ,         .                  ,       .                                ,          .   ,    ,   ,          . , ,      ,    ,  ,   .        ,               .   .     .  ,     ,             .



 2009 . 




 1







   ?





1.     


      ,       ,   .                ,   ,   , ,      .                ,     .        .         ,     ,   200  (!!).        ,      :    , , ,        (World Wildlife Fund),    ,     100  200  .       ,   ,   , USAID,  ,  (         ,      )  ..[29 - . Keane, J., Global Civil Society? in Global Civil Society 2001, ed. H. Anheier, et al. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001, pp. 26, 35.                  Civil Society and Global Finance, ed. J. Aart Scholte (L. NY: Routledge, 2002),     .]

      .   ,          ,           .  ,        ,       [30 -     , 5              ,            . . Putnam, R., Bowling Alone: the Collapse and Revival of American Community. ny: Simon & Schuster, 2000; Democracies in Flux: the Evolution of Social Capital in Contemporary Society, ed. R. Putnam. ny: Oxford University Press, 2002.         ,       !].      , ,            .  ,         [31 - Comaroff, John L. and Jean, Preface, in Civil Society and the Political Imagination in Africa: Critical Perspectives, ed. J. L. and J. Comaroff. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1999, p. VII.].   ?

,          ,      (: )  ,   (:      ) [32 -        ,   . (. Keane, J., Democracy and Civil Society. L-ny: Verso, 1988, pp. 3, 14).      ,      .].             ?

   , ,    (  ) - ,           . , ,    . ,     1995.   (Dan Coats),     ,      ( 19 ),         (         ).  ,   ,     [33 -              . Daniel R. Coats, Gertrude Himmelfarb, Don Eberly, David Boaz, Can Congress Revive Civil Society?. in Policy Review, January  February 1996, no. 75, p. 24 ff.]. ,      . ,    ,   :  ,  ,           ,  (  )  ,      .

   ,    ,          . ,        ,       , ,  ,      [34 -     .  .     . . . . . . .:  , 1998, . 13.].             ,  ,  ,     ,               ,        ?      -  ?       ,       , , ,    ,          ,        ?          ?[35 -           . . Wiarda, H.J., Civil Society: The American Model and Third World Development. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2003.      (  )  ,    ,      ,           ,      (. . ., . 15).]

  ,           ,  , ,  ..,           ,  , ,    ..   [36 - . Cohen, J. L. and Arato, A., Civil Society and Political Theory. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1994, p. IX.].        ,        ,   ?          ,   , ,  , ,      ,    ,    .    ,    ,  ,         ,        ,     - ,                 ,          [37 -    . Ahrne, G., Civil Society and Uncivil Organizations, in Real Civil Societies: Dilemmas of Institutionalization, ed. J. C. Alexander. L.: Sage Publications, 1998, pp. 8993.].

       .                  , ..       ,         [38 -   ,   ,    ,   ,          []          .  ,            ,      -   . . Habermas, J., The New Obscurity: The Crisis of the Welfare State and the Exhaustion of Utopian Energies, in The New Conservatism. Cultural Criticism and the Historians Debate, tr. S. W. Nickolsen. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1989, p. 67.        ,    :            ( )  . . Habermas, J., Between Facts and Norms, tr. W. Rehg. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1996, p. 275 ff.                ,      .].         ,             (      ).

      .        ,      - , ,  ,          (..            ,    , ,        )?        ?

,    -            (           ),  ,  ,        [39 -       . ., , Lukes, S., Of Gods and Demons: Habermas and Practical Reason, in Moral Conflict and Politics. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991, pp. 219220 ff; Walzer, M., Philosophy and Democracy, in What Should Political Theory Be Now? Ed.J. Nelson. Albany, NY: The State University of New York Press, 1983, p. 88.].       -       :          ,   , ,  ,          [40 - ., , Habermas, J., Between Facts and Norms, pp. 307308.]. ,      ,              .

                  .      ? ,   ,                 ,        ,     ,    (       )  .. . [41 - .  , .378379.].      ,                    .    :     ,               .        ,       [] [42 -  , . 358.],     ,      :          (    -,  , ,     ),     ,    - ,     ,  ..   ,     ,   .

,   , ..    , ,   , ..    , .          .        ,         .    ,          ,                 .  ,        .          XIX            ( 181   )             .          ,       ,         (         ),      .        ,      ,       .         ,     ,          80-              [43 -  ,      ,   80-  XX ,                ,        . .,  , Taylor, C. Modes of Civil Society., in Public Culture, 1990, vol. 3, no. 1, p. 9596; Seligman, A., The Fragile Ethical Vision of Civil Society., in Citizenship and Social Theory, ed. B. S. Turner. L.: Sage Publications, 1993, p. 139; Kumar, K. Civil Society: An Inquiry into the Usefulness of an Historical Term., in British Journal of Sociology, 1993, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 375376 ].                    ,        ?      ,  ,            , ,   ?                           .




2.    


              ?      ?   ,      ,   .             ,   (    )    ,       ?          ,    ?          ,      -   ,            .

,   ,          .   ,       ?       ,     .      ,        ,      .       ,       -        .       ,       .        , ..      ,      , ,   ,  .      ,      ,     ?

            ,            -.       ,     (        )       ,           .  -          ,       .               ,         ,  ,   ,   ,          , ..        (     ). ,             ,        ,         ,     -         (           ).

  -    [44 -     ,            ()  (.., 1275 b 34).]     ,                                      .    ,  ,  ,   (   ,    )     , .. . ,        (     ,     ),      ,    ,      ,           [45 - , .   , http: korel2.rsl.ru / nettext / russian / marks / evreickii. html].

       ?    (    ,    ),     ,    ,        , ..      ,       .          ,    ()     :  ,     ,  ,   ,        [46 - . Habermas, J., The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, tr. T. Burger. Oxford: Polity Press, 1989, pp. 2527.].       .

       ,               [47 -    . Calhoun, C., Civil Society and the Public Sphere, in Public Culture, 1993, No. 5, pp. 267280.].    .

:            ( civitas  ..)                 ,    ,   ,  ,    -.          廠      ,        .

:              ,   ,       ,   .        - ,         - ,     :     ,       ,       ,    -     .  ,          ,          (  , , ,      ).       ,     .     ,      .     ,    . ,       ,         .

:    ,   ,      ,      ,      ,   ,    ,      ,    ,     .        ,      .        ( )                    ,         .

:  ,        ,   -      ,     .   ()  ,   ,        ,                 ?,         [48 -                . . , . .     . .: , 1998, .1136.].   ,   ,   ,   - ,      .                       ,     (-) [49 -     ,  ,    "         ,     .           ,          -. . Gramsci, A., From Selections from the Prison Notebooks, in The Civil Society Reader, ed. v. A. Hodgkinson and M. W. Foley. Hanover  L.: University Press of New England, 2003, p. 190.].           ,          .     .  ,            ,   ,  ,     [50 - ,         ,        (           ).         ,                  ,     Machtergreifung. . Berman, S., Civil Society and the Collapse of the Weimar Republic, in World Politics, 1997, vol. 49, no. 3, p.401402 ff.].

     ,           컠 , , ,    ..        ,               ,      -   . ,             , , ,   ..,            ,         .




3.   


  -    (    )       -.        (), ,           , ,      컠 , ,      , ,                ,          [51 - . Habermas,J., The Theory of Communicative Action, vol. 2, tr. T. McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press, 1987, p. 328; Cohen, J. L. and Arato, A., Op. cit., pp. 451  452.].

     ?   ,                         ?         ,      ?  ,         (  )       ,   ,      - [52 - . Hall,J. A., In Search of Civil Society, in Civil Society: Theory, History, Comparison, ed. J. A. Hall. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1995, pp. 23, 6.].          ,       ,    ( ,   ..).        ,     ,    ,       ,   , ..  ,   , ,    ,     [53 -             :   "      ,   . . Bermeo, N., Ordinary People in Extraordinary Times: The Citizenry and the Breakdown of Democracy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003, p. 7 (  1    ).].

 ,       ,        ,           . ,            (     ).            (  )   ,   -[54 -         :                        . [  ]   , ,   ,   ,     . Anderson, P., Arguments Within English Marxism. L.: NLB, 1980, p. 175, note 34.].         ,                  .                , , .            (    ),        .

            ,                [55 - . Shklar, J., The Political Theory of Utopia: From Melancholy to Nostalgia, in Political Thought and Political Thinkers, ed. S. Hoffmann. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1998.      . . 163164, 168  169.].        :        ,     ,   (  )       ,       , ,   ( ) . ,  ,    , .    ,   - , [].     ,     [56 - Arendt, H., The Human Condition. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1958, p. 303.].

 ,  ,      ,       ,       . ,              (    )   ,   .            ,           -, ..  ,       .  ,             -:  ,    ,       ,       [57 -        . . Mannheim, K., Ideology and Utopia. NY: Harcourt, Brace and Co, 1940, p. 173, 177.    ,        .       ,     .              (,    )        ,        ()      ,      (   ,      ,      ..).].

  .

     .              ໠     .  ,   ,              .    ,               ,         .      ,     .        -  - ,      (        ,     ),      .        ,    ,    ,        .     -    .

           .      .      ,     ( )     ?             ,    ()         ,    raison detre[58 -   ,     :        ,    ,     ,             ,       "  . Gellner, E., Conditions of Liberty: Civil Society and Its Enemies. L.: Hamish Hamilton, 1994, p. 5 ( . . .).]? ,       ,    ,   ,   ,  , ,     - ? , ,             ,         ?

   :                   ,    ,              ,      ,  -  ,         .        .




   





 


      ,       .       .



1.        ,    .  ,          ,  ,       .   ,              ,    (, .).                .  ,   ,   ,             .

2.      ,     .       :          ,    ,          .     :    ()     ,       (, , .),     컻.  ,       ,          [59 - .  . . .  . .: , 1997, . 106.]   ,     ( ,  )     .

3.            (     , , ,   -   ).                 (    ,       [60 -                (.-: -, 1997).]).     ,  ,         ,            ,           .       ( )             ,        .

4.      ,     ,     .  (   )       ,             .       ,        .   ,     ,    .         ,     ,              (, -,  ,    ).       ,         .   ,  ,      ,  , ..       ,      . ,   廠    ,  ,     .      :       .

5. ,  , ,     ,        .               ,  , ,     , ,    .        ,     ,            ,           .  ,    post factum       ,    ,              .



         .   ,         .     .  , ,     .          (  )          , ,   ,      ,         ,    ,     -.

             , , ,           .        ,     .          ,      ,     .

    . .       .       ()          ,  .         ,           [61 -  , ,    , . .       /  , 1995, 5, . 9; , . .   11     /   : , , .  . . . . .:   , 2003, . 73; , . .   /  , 1992, 3, . 72.].

      .      ,  , -, , -,    .          ,           (  ).      ,   .       ,     .         ,     . ,    .

       ?  ,             ,   ?     ,       񻠖  ,         (  )  .      .

     ?         . ,       ,        .        ,    ?  : .  ,   ,     ,      ,     ,    ,    [62 - , .     (. XVI) / , .    . . 3. .: , 1988, . 369.].        ? ,  ,        ,    ,  ,        ?          ,   : 廠  ,         ,        (. ., . 271). ,  ,        ,    .       .            ,  ,   (      -  ),        . ,   , .

,   ,    ,    ,               . ,             (       ,       ).     ,          .

               ,            ,      .     ,         (,     ),        .

        .              (  ) ,        [63 - Civil Disobedience and Violence. Ed.J. G. Murphy. Belmont (CA): Wadsworth Publishing Co, 1971, p. 94.].        ,         (,   ..).      -       .   ,    ,  (,  )    .        ,  .  ,       ,         [64 -              ,      .]. (          ,     ,  ,    ).

  ,  ,                   ?         ,     (   )    [65 - , . .  . .: , 1969, . 468.]".    ,             ,       ,  .                     . ,           .                 ,     .           .

   . .   . .     .    ,          ,   ,  , , [66 - , . ., , . . : - . .: , 2000, .2324.].   ,       ( . . .)   ,                 ..                ,      ,       (. . ., .2426).

,        , .   ,       .       ,      ,         ,    ,          ,        ?  , ,    , ..,    ,   .           (     ,      ).  ,      ,          .

         ,         ,      , ..    ,  .     :            ,     ,     , .  :         "  [67 - , . . .: , 2001, . 97.].

    ,     ,  ,  ,        ,    ,    .                . (,      ,   .         (. 25),     ,       ,  , ,  .   ,        !        (. 26),     ,     ,    .        .)

    .        ,      ,           (. . ., . 13). ,  軠    ,   ,            ,       . , ,       . 󻠖      黠     ,     .  ?    廠  .  ,   ,     (  , ).

         .   ,       ,  ,   , ,   ..                     (. . ., . 17, 28).     ,   ,      . ,       :    (  ),    (   ). ,  ,        ,      ,   .   ,          , ,            ,     ,  ,   ,       ( ., . 18, . . 17)?

,   ,          , -   (  - ),        .       .




-    


 -            .   ,      ,          ,   , , , , , ,   ..       ,         .  ( )               [68 - ., , Rule, J. B. Theories of Civil Violence. Berkeley (CA): University of California Press, 1988.].     ,         ,        ,  , , ,   ..,            ,   ?

  ,                ,        ,        [69 - . Arendt, H. On Revolution. N. Y.: Viking, 1963, p. 9.        ,  ,          XX    . . Arendt, H. On Violence. San Diego: A Harvest Book, 1970.   ,   ,   .],        ![70 - . Riches, D. The Phenomenon of Violence / The Anthropology of Violence. Ed. D. Riches. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1986, p. 2.],      [71 - Jean Baudrillard: The Disappearance of Art and Politics. Ed. W. Stearns, et al. N. Y.: St. Martins Press, 1992, p. 292.],     [72 - . ONeill, O. Which Are the Offers You Cant Refuse? /Violence, Terrorism, and Justice. Ed. R. G. Frey, et al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991, p. 179.],     ,       [73 - . Muro-Ruiz, D. The Logic of Violence / Politics, 2002, vol. 22, no. 2, p. 116.],          ,               [74 - . Bolsinger, E. The Autonomy of the Political. Westport (CT): Greenwood Press, 2001, p. XII.].     , ,  .

   ?        ,         ,    (      /   ),    ,     ,           [75 - . Weber, M. The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. Tr. A. M. Henderson and T. Parsons. N. Y.: Oxford University Press, 1947, p. 155.]?        ,                          -  - ?  ,   - ,    [76 - Gadamer, H.-G. Historical Transformations of Reason / Rationality To-Day. Ed. T. Geraets. Ottawa: The University of Ottawa Press, 1979, p. 4.], .. ,    ,     .       ?              .      ,      .

  ,          (    ,       ), ,  ,                      .



1.                .        .         ()  /     ,       ,   , , .     .

  ,  ,          ,     ,     ,   ,        [77 - Keane, J. Reflections on Violence. L. N. Y.: Verso, 1996, p. 67.].

     ,        .       ?     :    ,     ?       ,       ?

,    .      ,       ,     ,                .          ,       .    ,            ,   -     .

,     [78 -      ,  ,     ,      ,        .       , ,     ,              .].             ,          .     ?            ,      ,           ,  ,       ,     ?   : , ,       ,    ,                 ,     ,      .

   ,  ,            ,  :        ,       ,     .  ,      .

  :     .          "    .          .      . ,    ,          .        .         ( )  .       ,            .

     .           ,    .   : Nemo ad praecise factum cogi potest (      ).      ,          ?        .      ,        .   ,               ,    ,      ,    .

  ,     :          ,    ,   ,   .       ,    ,    .      ,         . ,       (        )     .

     ,          .    ,    .           ,        ,          ,       .             ,     ,  (  )    .        ,     .

:            ,       ,    ,        . :              ,       (   ,     ,    ,    ,      ,     ).  ,    ,       . :  ,          ,     ,         ?           ,      ?

              .           ,         , ..        .                , ..  ,      ,     : ,   , ,     .

  ,        ,         .    ,        ,  ,             ?      ?                 ,      ,            .     ,     ,      .

   .          ,  .   .  ,            ,   ,      ,               .    .   .     ,  ໠   ,        ,          [79 - . , . . .   . . 3.].

  ,       .         , ,   .   , ,   ,      (      -   ),   .     ,       .      ,          ,   (        ).      ,   ,   .

    .  ,      .              ,              .       -  ,                .    (  , ,  )    ,       -     .            ,     ,           , ..       -  , ,   ,   (  ) .

,        ,    ,      .      ,          .      .         ?      ,      ?   - , ..     .          ,        , ,   .



2.       ,       ,    . ,       ,                 [80 - Sibley, M. Q. The Problem of Coercion / The Ethical Dimension of Political Life: Essays in Honor ofJohn H. Hallowell. Ed. F. Canovan. Durham (N. C.): Duke University Press, 1983, p. 173 ( . . .).      ,                  .].      : .   ,       腻[81 - George, S. Preface / Salmi, J. Violence and Democratic Society. L.: Zed Books, 1993, p. x.].

      ,        (  ),     .      .

        ,   ,      .   ,        ,       ,       .        -   -     .   ,                   ?

,            ,          .             .       ,        (  ,   ),   ,  , ,         .

        ,               .            .    (     ),          ,             .          ,       ,     ,    ,         (     , ,    ).

             ,                (    ,        ).                 .  ,    ,      ,              ,      




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/boris-kapustin/kritika-politicheskoy-filosofii-izbrannye-esse/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.  . .    ? /, 1996, 6, 1997, 1, 2.




2


.  . .     . .: , 1998;  . .    . .:       , 2004.




3


 ,    ,    ,      ,      .   "  (    . . .) ,           .  .  . .: , 1990, . 631.




4


. Jouvenel B. de. The Pure Theory of Politics. Indianapolis (IN): Liberty Fund, 2000, pp. 268  269.




5


.  . . .: , 2001, . 97  .




6


  . .   . . 3. .: , 1977, . 339.




7


.  ,              . .  .  .  .  .   . . 1. .: , 1991, . 285  .




8


,  ,       , , .          (      !), ,    ,    . .  .    /  . . .  . . 7. .: , 1994, . 49, 54.




9


             .    .       (   ).        .           ,    .    ,      ,         ,    . (. Habermas, J. Remarks on Discourse Ethics, in Habermas,J. Justification and Application, tr. C. Cronin. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press, 1993, p. 36 ff.  . . .).       (  )          .               ,          . (. Habermas, J., Between Facts and Norms, tr. W. Rehg. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press, 1996).




10


  ,  ,    ,         .. ,       ,      ,     .    . (Foucault, M., Nietzsche, Genealogy, History, in Foucault, M., Language, Counter-Memory, Practice. Selected Essays and Interviews. Ed. D. F. Bouchard and S. Simon. Ithaca (NY): Cornell University Press, 1977, p. 142).       ,      .




11


. Shapiro, I., The Evolution of Rights in Liberal Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986, p. 198 ff.




12


 . .    ,       . .   // . . . . 42, . 278.




13


     . . .  Capitalism and Democracy: Schumpeter Revisited, ed. R. D. Coe and C. K. Wilber. Notre Dame (in): University of Notre Dame Press, 1985, p. 154.




14


    . Horkheimer, M., Traditional and Critical Theory, in Critical Sociology. Selected Readings, ed. P. Connerton. Harmondsworth (UK): Penguin, 1976, pp. 212 ff.




15


 .   . . . . .: , 1994, .485486.




16


               () . , ,    ,         ,         . . Habermas, J., Civil Society, Public Opinion, and Communicative Power., in Between Facts and Norms, pp. 359387.




17


 ,    ,       ,    . Castoriadis, CIntellectuals and History., in Castoriadis, C., Philosophy, Politics, Autonomy. Essays in Political Philosophy, ed. D. A. Curtis. ny: Oxford University Press, 1991, p. 12.




18


Merleau-Ponty, M., Humanism and Terror, tr. J. ONeill. Boston: Beacon Press, 2001, p.XXIii (   . .).




19


 .    .  .  .  . .:  , 2006, . 6970.




20


  ,  ,    ,          (  ) .   ,   ,    ,   ,          (  )   . .  .    .  . ., . 8.




21


 .   (. . ).  .   . . . . . . . .: -      , 2004, . 75.




22


. .   k . . . VIII. .-.: , 1935, . 50.




23


 , . 32.




24


 , . 26.




25


.  .   .  .  .   . .: Ad Marginem, 2005, . 73.




26


. , 2008, 5.




27


.  .  .       XX . .: -, 1999, . 29.




28


             ,  ,  ,  ,     (. . .).                         ,   ,   ,      ..




29


. Keane, J., Global Civil Society? in Global Civil Society 2001, ed. H. Anheier, et al. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001, pp. 26, 35.                  Civil Society and Global Finance, ed. J. Aart Scholte (L. NY: Routledge, 2002),     .




30


    , 5              ,            . . Putnam, R., Bowling Alone: the Collapse and Revival of American Community. ny: Simon & Schuster, 2000; Democracies in Flux: the Evolution of Social Capital in Contemporary Society, ed. R. Putnam. ny: Oxford University Press, 2002.         ,       !




31


Comaroff, John L. and Jean, Preface, in Civil Society and the Political Imagination in Africa: Critical Perspectives, ed. J. L. and J. Comaroff. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1999, p. VII.




32


       ,   . (. Keane, J., Democracy and Civil Society. L-ny: Verso, 1988, pp. 3, 14).      ,      .




33


             . Daniel R. Coats, Gertrude Himmelfarb, Don Eberly, David Boaz, Can Congress Revive Civil Society?. in Policy Review, January  February 1996, no. 75, p. 24 ff.




34


    .  .     . . . . . . .:  , 1998, . 13.




35


          . . Wiarda, H.J., Civil Society: The American Model and Third World Development. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2003.      (  )  ,    ,      ,           ,      (. . ., . 15).




36


. Cohen, J. L. and Arato, A., Civil Society and Political Theory. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1994, p. IX.




37


   . Ahrne, G., Civil Society and Uncivil Organizations, in Real Civil Societies: Dilemmas of Institutionalization, ed. J. C. Alexander. L.: Sage Publications, 1998, pp. 8993.




38


  ,   ,    ,   ,          []          .  ,            ,      -   . . Habermas, J., The New Obscurity: The Crisis of the Welfare State and the Exhaustion of Utopian Energies, in The New Conservatism. Cultural Criticism and the Historians Debate, tr. S. W. Nickolsen. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1989, p. 67.        ,    :            ( )  . . Habermas, J., Between Facts and Norms, tr. W. Rehg. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1996, p. 275 ff.                ,      .




39


      . ., , Lukes, S., Of Gods and Demons: Habermas and Practical Reason, in Moral Conflict and Politics. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991, pp. 219220 ff; Walzer, M., Philosophy and Democracy, in What Should Political Theory Be Now? Ed.J. Nelson. Albany, NY: The State University of New York Press, 1983, p. 88.




40


., , Habermas, J., Between Facts and Norms, pp. 307308.




41


.  , .378379.




42


 , . 358.




43


 ,      ,   80-  XX ,                ,        . .,  , Taylor, C. Modes of Civil Society., in Public Culture, 1990, vol. 3, no. 1, p. 9596; Seligman, A., The Fragile Ethical Vision of Civil Society., in Citizenship and Social Theory, ed. B. S. Turner. L.: Sage Publications, 1993, p. 139; Kumar, K. Civil Society: An Inquiry into the Usefulness of an Historical Term., in British Journal of Sociology, 1993, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 375376 




44


    ,            ()  (.., 1275 b 34).




45


, .   , http: korel2.rsl.ru / nettext / russian / marks / evreickii. html




46


. Habermas, J., The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, tr. T. Burger. Oxford: Polity Press, 1989, pp. 2527.




47


   . Calhoun, C., Civil Society and the Public Sphere, in Public Culture, 1993, No. 5, pp. 267280.




48


               . . , . .     . .: , 1998, .1136.




49


    ,  ,    "         ,     .           ,          -. . Gramsci, A., From Selections from the Prison Notebooks, in The Civil Society Reader, ed. v. A. Hodgkinson and M. W. Foley. Hanover  L.: University Press of New England, 2003, p. 190.




50


,         ,        (           ).         ,                  ,     Machtergreifung. . Berman, S., Civil Society and the Collapse of the Weimar Republic, in World Politics, 1997, vol. 49, no. 3, p.401402 ff.




51


. Habermas,J., The Theory of Communicative Action, vol. 2, tr. T. McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press, 1987, p. 328; Cohen, J. L. and Arato, A., Op. cit., pp. 451  452.




52


. Hall,J. A., In Search of Civil Society, in Civil Society: Theory, History, Comparison, ed. J. A. Hall. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1995, pp. 23, 6.




53


            :   "      ,   . . Bermeo, N., Ordinary People in Extraordinary Times: The Citizenry and the Breakdown of Democracy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003, p. 7 (  1    ).




54


        :                        . [  ]   , ,   ,   ,     . Anderson, P., Arguments Within English Marxism. L.: NLB, 1980, p. 175, note 34.




55


. Shklar, J., The Political Theory of Utopia: From Melancholy to Nostalgia, in Political Thought and Political Thinkers, ed. S. Hoffmann. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1998.      . . 163164, 168  169.




56


Arendt, H., The Human Condition. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1958, p. 303.




57


       . . Mannheim, K., Ideology and Utopia. NY: Harcourt, Brace and Co, 1940, p. 173, 177.    ,        .       ,     .              (,    )        ,        ()      ,      (   ,      ,      ..).




58


  ,     :        ,    ,     ,             ,       "  . Gellner, E., Conditions of Liberty: Civil Society and Its Enemies. L.: Hamish Hamilton, 1994, p. 5 ( . . .).




59


.  . . .  . .: , 1997, . 106.




60


               (.-: -, 1997).




61


 , ,    , . .       /  , 1995, 5, . 9; , . .   11     /   : , , .  . . . . .:   , 2003, . 73; , . .   /  , 1992, 3, . 72.




62


, .     (. XVI) / , .    . . 3. .: , 1988, . 369.




63


Civil Disobedience and Violence. Ed.J. G. Murphy. Belmont (CA): Wadsworth Publishing Co, 1971, p. 94.




64


             ,      .




65


, . .  . .: , 1969, . 468.




66


, . ., , . . : - . .: , 2000, .2324.




67


, . . .: , 2001, . 97.




68


., , Rule, J. B. Theories of Civil Violence. Berkeley (CA): University of California Press, 1988.




69


. Arendt, H. On Revolution. N. Y.: Viking, 1963, p. 9.        ,  ,          XX    . . Arendt, H. On Violence. San Diego: A Harvest Book, 1970.   ,   ,   .




70


. Riches, D. The Phenomenon of Violence / The Anthropology of Violence. Ed. D. Riches. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1986, p. 2.




71


Jean Baudrillard: The Disappearance of Art and Politics. Ed. W. Stearns, et al. N. Y.: St. Martins Press, 1992, p. 292.




72


. ONeill, O. Which Are the Offers You Cant Refuse? /Violence, Terrorism, and Justice. Ed. R. G. Frey, et al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991, p. 179.




73


. Muro-Ruiz, D. The Logic of Violence / Politics, 2002, vol. 22, no. 2, p. 116.




74


. Bolsinger, E. The Autonomy of the Political. Westport (CT): Greenwood Press, 2001, p. XII.




75


. Weber, M. The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. Tr. A. M. Henderson and T. Parsons. N. Y.: Oxford University Press, 1947, p. 155.




76


Gadamer, H.-G. Historical Transformations of Reason / Rationality To-Day. Ed. T. Geraets. Ottawa: The University of Ottawa Press, 1979, p. 4.




77


Keane, J. Reflections on Violence. L. N. Y.: Verso, 1996, p. 67.




78


     ,  ,     ,      ,        .       , ,     ,              .




79


. , . . .   . . 3.




80


Sibley, M. Q. The Problem of Coercion / The Ethical Dimension of Political Life: Essays in Honor ofJohn H. Hallowell. Ed. F. Canovan. Durham (N. C.): Duke University Press, 1983, p. 173 ( . . .).      ,                  .




81


George, S. Preface / Salmi, J. Violence and Democratic Society. L.: Zed Books, 1993, p. x.


