 
  


    ,       ,                 .           ,    ,                       .          , ,   .   ,               .    ,           .





 

 





 



,            ,  ,   ,    ,   ,     .        ,  ,  -,   ,        .     -[1 - ., :      :  2 . . 1:      / . . .. , .. . .: , 2010. . 1729.], [2 - ., :  .. : . .: . - .. , 1910. . 106123.], [3 - ., :  .    :      , , ,     / . . . . .. . .: - . . . -, 2000.], [4 - ., :  .. :      : . . .: , 2011. . 2539.],  , ,  .      .   ,    ,     ,  ,  , .

   ,    ,      ,                 .

   ,    ,     ,       .        ,  -, , , , , ,    .      ,     (,      ),  ,      (, , -   ..),       ..          ,  .




 


   ,        ,    ,   -      ,              .      ,      ,                    .

         ()         .      ,      ,    ..    ( )   ,  ,   .

   ,    .            .   ()         (),    .

 ,       .           ,     .     -   .

         ,    ,     ,      .

        , ,  ,      ,       .      ,        .            ,           ,      , ,  ,   ..  ,  ,       .

    (VIIIIII .  ..),            ,      .

  ,         ,      ,      ,   ,                    .   ,        ,   - ,  ,            .  ,  ,    ,     ,    ,     ,   -     ,   .           ,     ,        ,   ,  ,  , ,     .  ,    ,      ,     ().

   ,            .     ,  ,  ,   ,            ,      .

            ,  ,         ,   ,    ,           .       ,      .   VIV .  ..     (),      .    .     ,   .

           (, , ,   ..),          ,       ,   ,     ,    .       ,       .         ,         ,        ,   , ,        ..

           ,        -  (  ),        .            .

               ,      .  ,      ,  (), ,          ,           .    ,        .

        .       ,    ,   .     ,  ,      -.        ,        ,   .     .               .     ,        .  ,     :  ,  ,   !       [5 - .:  .. :       . 2- ., . .: ; , 2001. . 75.].          .

   , , ,  ,    .    ,    .             ,              (  )  .              ,        ,    .        .

  -      , ,     ..      .         .   .           -   ,             .

          ,              ,         [6 -  . . . . 19.].           ,      - ,   .     ,  ,    .       ,                  .

  ,           ,  ,       .




 


             .        ,   .       .   ,    ,           ,   .

 ,        ,     .          ,  , ,  ,      ,         .

   ,             .                 ,   .

       .   ,    ,   ,   .                    .                   .

      ,     .      .     ,         ,  ,     . ,        ,         .

    IVIII .  ..   .      . ,  ,          .            ,      .                   .

     ,  ,         - .      .     (      )      ,       ,             .

         ,       ()     . ,           ,       ,    [7 -  . . . . 93.].   ,  ,         ,     .

       ,   11 .  ,        .  ,    .      ,                 .                .         ,    ,        . ,               .

  ,     ,   :  (  III .  ..),  (  III .  ..), - (XXXI .  ..),    (  I .  ..).

   IV .  ..          .   III .  ..     .         ,     ,      .    ,        .        , ,     .

 III .  ..  -        .      .   ,   .   XXIVXIII .  ..           .

      .       XXXII .  ..         ()        .     ,       . ,    ,   ,          .     .               18501800 .  ..       .    ,     .

     ,        . ,     ,    [8 -  .   //    :    / ., .  . . .. . .: , 1991. . 87.].  ,              (  )          ,        .         ,        ,    .

          ,   ,       ,        (, ).       , , ,      ,    .            ,       .        ,           [9 -  .. : . . .: , 2001. . 84.].

     ,      ,    ,        .           ,         [10 -  .. : . . .: , 2001. . 88.].

            II . ..,        206 .  ..                 .         .     ,          .

        -   , ,   .          .       .       ,    .         .

 ,    ,         .    ,     ,     .           ,  , , ,    .               , ,  ()   .







   ,   III . ..     .       -,       .  -         ,     ,        .             [11 -   :  /  . .. . .: , 2007. . 6364.].     :    ,  , ,    ,            .

          .              .      ,      ,   .  ,   ,   ,    ,   ,      ..[12 -      . . 1:     . . 34.]                -      .

          . ,      ,   .   ,    .           ,    ,    ,   ,   ,  , -,     ,     [13 - ... . . 40.].       ,    .

,    ,    ()   (XXIV .  ..)[14 - Foster B.R. Social Reform in Mesopotamia // Social Justice in the Ancient World / K. Irani and M. Silver (eds.). Westport, Conn.: Greenwood, 1995. P. 169.],    ,    ,   .         ,    ,  ,       , , ,  .       ,         [15 - .:     .   / . . .. . .: ,, 1985. . 86.].

     -  -.          ,    .      ,      ,     .         񻠖  ,    .                  [16 - .:  ..   . . 1.   :  -. .: , 2013. . 2128.].               .

  III .  ..       - ,   III  ,   2112 g 2003 .  ..     - (-) (. 21042095 .  ..).       .      .        ,      ,            ,    -.

  -,    ,      ,     .           18991900 .     .          1954 .          1965  1981 .  ,  2011 .,           ,    .     -      ..   2013 .[17 - .:  ..   . . 1. . 7384.]       [18 -  ..  -:     // . 2013. 1. . 230.]:

    ,      ,       . 13; 3036;

      . 1826;

- ,     ,     ,    (. 51)  . 412, 2729, 37, 38, 46, 47, 5154, 8082;

 , ,           1317, 37, 38, 78, 79;

      (.3945),   (.4850),        (.5558, 6064, 70, 71, 77),     (.6569),     (.7275),     (.8387).

      .

  III .  ..            .        XVIII .  ..    , ,    ,  (-)[19 - .:  .  / . . . .. . .: , 2007. . 31.].

            -[20 - .:   .         . . 1: /  . .. . .: ,1983.] (XX .  ..)  43 ,   [21 - BryceT. The Routledge Handbook of the Peoples and Places of Ancient Western Asia. Routledge, 2009. P. 235237.] (XIX .  ..)  61     [22 - .:  ..   //    /  . ..   . [.] 1:  . .: ,1982. . 103108.] (XVIII .  ..)  282 ,  .                    ,            .

  -,    ,    -,  , 43  (,    


/


 )  .   -,   -,    .      .   (. 2537)  , -, ,       - .          ,   .      :        ,   .  -        ,       . ,        [23 - .:  ..     : . 4- . . 1. .: , 2005. . 85.].

        .       ,     .             :    .             (),    ,   ()  .    ,       ,      .        ,      ,   .   ,      ,     -  ,    [24 - .:   .         . . 1: .].

                   .

   - ,   (   )    : ,   .  ,     , , .          .           ,   - .            ,       .   ,            ,         ,     .        [25 - .:      . . 1:     . . 125.].

   ,  .       :  (  )  .            (),      .  ,   (),    . ,      .         .          ,    .           .  ,     -   ,    ,            .

         ,          ,          .

-,             . ,     ,      (    ).

-,          (),     ,   ,     ,  ,      .      . , -,       . ,      ,   ,   ,     .

          .     ,   ,       ,   [26 - Driver G.R., Miles J.C. The Babylonian Laws. Oxford, 1956. P. 4145; Lemche N.P. Justice in Western Asia in Antiquity, or: Why no Laws Were Needed // Chicago Kent Law Review. 1995. Vol. 70. P. 1706; Steele F.R. The Code of Lipit-Ishtar // American Journal of Archaeology. 1948. Vol. 50. P. 430; Westbrook R. Biblical and Cuneiform Law Codes // Revue-Biblique. 1985. Vol. 92/2. . 247264.].

            , ,  ,      ,         ,   [27 - Bottero J. Mesopotamia Writing, Reasoning, and the Gods. Chicago, 1992. P. 50, 160, 184; Sassoon J. Ancient Laws and Modern Problems: The Balance between Justice and a Legal System. London, 2001.].

,    ,      ,     ,    ,   ,   .          [28 - Roth M.T. Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor. 2nd ed. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1997. P. 2; Rubio G. From Sumer to Babylon: Topics in the History of Southern Mesopotamian // Current Issues in the Study of the Ancient Near East / d. by M. Chavalas. Claremont, CA. 2009. . 34; Westbrook R. Cuneiform Law Codes and the Origins of Legislation // ZA. 1989. Vol. 79/2. P. 201222.].           ,    [29 - Culbertson L.E. Dispute Resolution inthe Provincial Courts of the Third Dynasty of Ur: PhD Dissertation. University of Michigan, 2009. . 155156.].  ,   ,     ,         [30 - Yoffee N. Context and Authority in Early Mesopotamian Law // State Formation and Political Legitimacy. New Brunswick, 1988; Roth M. Op. cit. P. 4.].       .          ,   ,  ,  ,  .        .     ,         ,           .

   ,                 .                          (     , -  ,  ,    )[31 -  ..  -:     // . 2013. 1. . 229.].

    ,        XXIIXVIII .  ..        , ..    .     ,    [32 -  .: Fortner J.D. Adjudicating Entities and Levels of Legal Authority in Lawsuit Records of the Old Babylonian Era: Dissertation. Cincinnati, 1996.].  ,     .

      - ,  , , , ,   [33 - Kramer S.N. Schooldays: A Sumerian Composition Relating to the Education of a Scribe. Philadelphia, 1949;  .. -  IIIII   ..: . ... ., 1995.].      ()             ,        [34 -  ..     : . . .:  , 1973. . 43.]. ,                [35 - .:  ..   . . 1. . 51.].   ,     .

 ,        .     ,         [36 - .:  ..       //   . 1981. 4. . 9.].

-,        ,               ,     .         ,    .        .        ,      [37 -  .. : . .: , 2002. . 125.].

,       ,  ,     . ,       [38 - .:  ..   . . 1. . 44.].    ,  ,   .

,   ,    ,         ,        .

       .   .         (, ,  ,        .)     ,  ,    ,           .               ,  :    ,        - (  ),      (   ;         ),      ,       .  ,    ,    ,       [39 - .:  .. . . . 7.].

   ,           ,        .  -     .   ,  ,      ,  ,  ,   ,   , ,      ,       [40 - .:  .. . . . 8.].   -          .

        ,           ,      ,  .   (, ,    )      .    ().       .    ,         .




 


 ,   ,          ,  ,   .                         .         .              ,               ().  ,     ,     ,   .   ,   ,      , ,  ,    .

      .      .    ,      ,     ,       ,         .              ,          ,    ,   .        .                  .         ,        .       ,       ,     ,      .

      . ,                      (,     )   .   ,   ,  :  , ,      ,        .    :  ,     ,    ,         ,    .    ,  ,         .       ,      :   ,  ,   ,   ,  .  ,      ,   .    ,    .       ,  ,    ,    ,    ;   ,  [41 - .  // .:  3 . . 2. .: , 1970. . 216217.]. , -        .

        .       ( XXX   XXVIII .  ..)    ( XXVIII   XXII .  ..).       .      ( XXI   XVIII .  ..).      ,               .      (XVIIX .  ..),      ,     (VIIIIII .  ..).         (, , , ,     ).      ( )  27    XXXIII  VI .  ..

              (   ).           ,    ,       ,       .         .         ,  ,    ,    ,     ,      ,    .  ,       ,   -.         [42 - .:  .. . . . 122.].           ,  ?

,    .         ,     .       .        ,   [43 - .  . . 127.].

,    ,      ,           ,           ,         ,  . ,           ,      -[44 -  .:  .. . . . 621.].

  ,               , ,     .     ,        .        ,      .         ,    XI .  ..:

    .     .       .    .        .   .      .      .        .     .     .   .    .     .      .     .     .    .   .           .     .      -.     .     .       .         .       .        .      .        .      .       .        [45 -     . .: . ., 1973. . 71 (.   . . 1).].

 34 ,    , 21      -, 9  ,  ,        , 4     [46 - .:  .. . . . 146.].

,            .

            .          ,           ,         .          .  ,   ,    ,         ,  .

,   ,    :   ,       .              ( ),         .         .

                ,               .        .             ,   ,      ..          ()       [47 - .:      . . 1:     . . 111112.].

    ,          .                   .             ,  ,   [48 - .  . . 121.].

        .       .         (XXVIIIXXIII .  ..),    .       V .          ,      .   :    ,  ,  ,     [49 - Erman A. Die Literaturder ?gypter. Leipzig, 1923. S. 98.].           [50 - Zaba Z. Les maximes de Ptahhotep. Prague, 1956. P. 169170.],       .

    [51 - .:      //   . 1950. 2. . 126127.]     (XXIIXXI .  .)      ,         (  ).          ,       .                  , ,       ,      .                      [52 - .:     .  . . 78.].

        () (   ())   XVIXI .  ..   ,               ,      (XXIIXXI .  ..)[53 - Fecht G. Der Vorwurf an Gott in den Mahnworten des Ipu-wer (Pap. Leiden I 344 recto 11,1113,8; 15,1317,3): Zur geistigen Krise der ersten Zwischenzeit und ihrer Bew?ltigung. Heidelberg, 1972.]. ,             [54 - .:  .    344.         ( 1750 .  ..) / . . .. . .; ., 1935. . 339.].       ,   .      .                 .

        .       ,             ,     .         ,        ,         . , ,          ,   .        ( III .  ..),    .           III (XIX .  ..)   II  (XIII .  ..).        720715 .  ..     40 .           ,   [55 - .:      . . 1:     . . 113.].          (33230 .  ..)[56 - .:  . . . . 32.],      .

                  ()       .       ,  ,     .            .




 


      . ,     ,              .

       :  - (XVIIIXII .  ..),   (XIIVIII .  ..),  -,     (; VIIIII .  ..),    (III .  .. III . ..).

      ,  ,   .        -   .              ,            [57 - .:   :  /  . .. . . 243.].

    ,      ,  .    ,   ().          ,      ,     .  -              .       .           [58 - .:  .. . . . 88.].

   ,              : ,     ,     ,    .    VIV .  ..          .            . ,                 .         .         [59 - .:      . . 1:     . . 163.].

            (VIII .  ..).      (-; 551479 .  ..), - (VIV .  ..)    ( ; 390338 .  ..).

 VIIII .  ..     .       .    ,  .       .

        .         ,     .              .        ,    .

        ,   ,    .        .        ,        .                 .     : ,   .      - ,          [60 - .:  .. . , , . .: , 1993. . 510.].          VIIV .  ..

 VIIII .  ..      .      ,   , ,  .    ,     .   ,   ,   ,       .           .       [61 - .  . . 184185.].

            ,    , ,  .         ,     .      ,     , ..   .           ,   .            ,                .          ,  ,   ,        [62 - .:      . . 1:     . . 162.].

        ()    .           .              ,            .      .           ,    .             (  ),     .

 ,  ,       .    ,       .       ,      .       ,   .        ,          .

       .         .    ,      .       ,     .      .       . ,      ,      ,     .

     ,     ,        .      ,  ,     .    ,    , - [63 -  .. . . . 65.].           .       ,  , .

                  .                   .         ,      .

     -    .        ,    ,         .          ,     .       :  ,     ? , ,  :  .         ,   ,  ,   .

          ⻠ . ,   ,      , ,  ,       .   ,    ,       ,             .

         (5040- . III .  ..)  ,     .        ,        .           .         (   )      [64 -  .. . . . 263.].

                .          ,     ,          .         ,     ,         ,      ,        .       ,    ,    .

       ,      ,     ,    .  ,     ,      -     .       ,   ,       ,   .

  - ,      ,  ,        ,    ,   ,  ,    ,          .           ,  ,      ,  ,                 [65 -  ..  . . 3.   (VIII .  ..). ., 2006.  6, .      (www.oldevrasia.ru).].

                :   .       ,     .   ,      ,     .       ,   ,       [66 -  .. . . . 269.].

     .    -,   ,   .   ,       .   ,     ,      .    ,      ,    ,     -,   .       ,        .

   ,      ,        ,      ,     .         ,  ,    ,    ,    .         ,    , , , ,     .

              .      ,      .  ,  ,    ,   ,    ,   ,     .      ,    ,  .                 , , ,   [67 - .:     .  . . 185.].

   (    )     - (369286 .  ..),                 ,    .         [68 -     .  . . 186.].

              .  ,   221 .  ..     ,         .       .

     ,    .        ,                      .      .             .    10 .      2  . -        .           .      ,        .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pavel-krasheninnikov-6000318/zarozhdenie-prava/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


., :      :  2 . . 1:      / . . .. , .. . .: , 2010. . 1729.




2


., :  .. : . .: . - .. , 1910. . 106123.




3


., :  .    :      , , ,     / . . . . .. . .: - . . . -, 2000.




4


., :  .. :      : . . .: , 2011. . 2539.




5


.:  .. :       . 2- ., . .: ; , 2001. . 75.




6


 . . . . 19.




7


 . . . . 93.




8


 .   //    :    / ., .  . . .. . .: , 1991. . 87.




9


 .. : . . .: , 2001. . 84.




10


 .. : . . .: , 2001. . 88.




11


  :  /  . .. . .: , 2007. . 6364.




12


     . . 1:     . . 34.




13


... . . 40.




14


Foster B.R. Social Reform in Mesopotamia // Social Justice in the Ancient World / K. Irani and M. Silver (eds.). Westport, Conn.: Greenwood, 1995. P. 169.




15


.:     .   / . . .. . .: ,, 1985. . 86.




16


.:  ..   . . 1.   :  -. .: , 2013. . 2128.




17


.:  ..   . . 1. . 7384.




18


 ..  -:     // . 2013. 1. . 230.




19


.:  .  / . . . .. . .: , 2007. . 31.




20


.:   .         . . 1: /  . .. . .: ,1983.




21


BryceT. The Routledge Handbook of the Peoples and Places of Ancient Western Asia. Routledge, 2009. P. 235237.




22


.:  ..   //    /  . ..   . [.] 1:  . .: ,1982. . 103108.




23


.:  ..     : . 4- . . 1. .: , 2005. . 85.




24


.:   .         . . 1: .




25


.:      . . 1:     . . 125.




26


Driver G.R., Miles J.C. The Babylonian Laws. Oxford, 1956. P. 4145; Lemche N.P. Justice in Western Asia in Antiquity, or: Why no Laws Were Needed // Chicago Kent Law Review. 1995. Vol. 70. P. 1706; Steele F.R. The Code of Lipit-Ishtar // American Journal of Archaeology. 1948. Vol. 50. P. 430; Westbrook R. Biblical and Cuneiform Law Codes // Revue-Biblique. 1985. Vol. 92/2. . 247264.




27


Bottero J. Mesopotamia Writing, Reasoning, and the Gods. Chicago, 1992. P. 50, 160, 184; Sassoon J. Ancient Laws and Modern Problems: The Balance between Justice and a Legal System. London, 2001.




28


Roth M.T. Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor. 2nd ed. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1997. P. 2; Rubio G. From Sumer to Babylon: Topics in the History of Southern Mesopotamian // Current Issues in the Study of the Ancient Near East / d. by M. Chavalas. Claremont, CA. 2009. . 34; Westbrook R. Cuneiform Law Codes and the Origins of Legislation // ZA. 1989. Vol. 79/2. P. 201222.




29


Culbertson L.E. Dispute Resolution inthe Provincial Courts of the Third Dynasty of Ur: PhD Dissertation. University of Michigan, 2009. . 155156.




30


Yoffee N. Context and Authority in Early Mesopotamian Law // State Formation and Political Legitimacy. New Brunswick, 1988; Roth M. Op. cit. P. 4.




31


 ..  -:     // . 2013. 1. . 229.




32


 .: Fortner J.D. Adjudicating Entities and Levels of Legal Authority in Lawsuit Records of the Old Babylonian Era: Dissertation. Cincinnati, 1996.




33


Kramer S.N. Schooldays: A Sumerian Composition Relating to the Education of a Scribe. Philadelphia, 1949;  .. -  IIIII   ..: . ... ., 1995.




34


 ..     : . . .:  , 1973. . 43.




35


.:  ..   . . 1. . 51.




36


.:  ..       //   . 1981. 4. . 9.




37


 .. : . .: , 2002. . 125.




38


.:  ..   . . 1. . 44.




39


.:  .. . . . 7.




40


.:  .. . . . 8.




41


.  // .:  3 . . 2. .: , 1970. . 216217.




42


.:  .. . . . 122.




43


.  . . 127.




44


 .:  .. . . . 621.




45


    . .: . ., 1973. . 71 (.   . . 1).




46


.:  .. . . . 146.




47


.:      . . 1:     . . 111112.




48


.  . . 121.




49


Erman A. Die Literaturder ?gypter. Leipzig, 1923. S. 98.




50


Zaba Z. Les maximes de Ptahhotep. Prague, 1956. P. 169170.




51


.:      //   . 1950. 2. . 126127.




52


.:     .  . . 78.




53


Fecht G. Der Vorwurf an Gott in den Mahnworten des Ipu-wer (Pap. Leiden I 344 recto 11,1113,8; 15,1317,3): Zur geistigen Krise der ersten Zwischenzeit und ihrer Bew?ltigung. Heidelberg, 1972.




54


.:  .    344.         ( 1750 .  ..) / . . .. . .; ., 1935. . 339.




55


.:      . . 1:     . . 113.




56


.:  . . . . 32.




57


.:   :  /  . .. . . 243.




58


.:  .. . . . 88.




59


.:      . . 1:     . . 163.




60


.:  .. . , , . .: , 1993. . 510.




61


.  . . 184185.




62


.:      . . 1:     . . 162.




63


 .. . . . 65.




64


 .. . . . 263.




65


 ..  . . 3.   (VIII .  ..). ., 2006.  6, .      (www.oldevrasia.ru).




66


 .. . . . 269.




67


.:     .  . . 185.




68


    .  . . 186.


