 .     
 

 

 


 
                   :     .     .      ,     .     ,      ,       Begriffsgeschichte     .    ,              :     XVIII,       ,        ,         ,         XVIIIXX,           .





 :     





 ,  

 :   [1 -         :  .,  . Context is king:      // . 2015. 134. .2144.]



                   :    ,  ,    . ,     ,                 .  Begriffsgeschichte             .                 (,    ,       ,    ,   . . )[2 -   ,    , ,   ,  ,     : [Phillipson, Skinner 1993; Tuck 1993; Dunn 1996: 1922; Palonen 2003: 1128;  2004; Chignola, Duso 2008; Guilhaumou 2010: 5963; Mulsow, Mahler 2010].].

         . , . , . .         Res Publica   ..      - (          , . .)[3 -            ., , : [ 2016].].  ,         ( )     . Ѡ2015           ,                   ,     .         ;         opus magnum      [ 2018][4 -  ,               .     (  ) ,  ,   ,    :      (  . .., ..)  ,         :      ,      (foundation)   (. .) [ 2018, 2: 534].        origins,  , ,    . The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution (1967),    . .      (2010).],     . , , ,             . .      .       ,  , ,     .

                    .                       ( ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ),       -  .          ,        .




   


  ,      .      ,     ,    ,        .         . ʠ                  ,       .       (   19401950? )                        . (  ,   ,    . ,      .)    ,         . ,         Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought 蠫Ideas in Context [Clark 2006: 215216;  2010: 114].  ,        Philosophy, Politics and Language,      1956, ,  ,        ,        (    ),  .

      1949,    (   !)          XVII  .     ,      : ,     .         ,      (intention  effect,    [Pocock 2006: 37]).  , ,           .    ,     1688,     ,     ,    :    ,    .  ,         .            contextualism (  . : [Skinner 1988a: 275277[5 - .      .]; Bevir 1992; King 1995; Hume 2006;  2010; Floyd, Stears 2011]),           .       ,        . .[6 -         .: [King 1983; Bevir 2004; Grafton 2006].],         Begriffsgeschichte  .

     ,      ;         .  ,      ,            ,           (., : [Pocock 2013];        ).   ,         ,                          .                ( )           ,   .

        ,       .  ,       ,     ,            [ 2004].  ,       ,        ,  ,         ,     .       ,         ,              [White 1969; LaCapra 1983; Toews 1987; Pagden 1988; Jacoby 1992; LaCapra 1992].  ,     ,   ,             .

 2013   ,   5Questions,   ,  intellectual history[7 - ,       :   1985 , ,  History Today.]    ,       (   , ,  ,   .)     .          :        .      ,  , ,  ,  ,     ,        [Jeppesen, Stjernfelt, Thorup 2013: IV].   ,  , ,         ,    .         ,           ,       [8 -       ,   intellectual history, . : [Brett 2002].].             -           [9 -             . ,  .1  .19.]   ,                    .    ,   ,                ,    : Context is king [Pocock 2006: 37].

      ,        ,   .         ,     ,       [Palonen 2003].      ,  ,           Meaning in Context [Tully 1988], The Political Imagination in History [DeLuna, Anderson, Burgess 2006] 蠫Rethinking the Foundations of Modern Political Thought [Brett, Tully, Hamilton-Bleakley 2006].   2009     -   ,              ,       Journal of the History of Ideas (2012. Vol.73. 1).

   , ,             ,       ( )   .      ,         ,  : Three British Revolutions: 1641, 1688, 1776 [Pocock 1980], Philosophy in History: Essays on the Historiography of Philosophy [Rorty, Schneewind, Skinner 1984], The Languages of Political Theory in Early-Modern Europe [Pagden 1985], The Return of Grand Theory in the Human Sciences [Skinner 1985], Machiavelli and Republicanism [Bock, Skinner, Viroli 1990], Political Discourse in Early Modern Britain [Phillipson, Skinner 1993], The Varieties of British Political Thought, 15001800 [Pocock, Schochet, Schwoerer 1993], Milton and Republicanism [Armitage, Himy, Skinner 1995],  Republicanism: A Shared European Heritage [Van Gelderen, Skinner 2002], States and Citizens: History, Theory, Prospects [Skinner, Str?th 2003], British Political Thought in History, Literature and Theory, 15001800 [Armitage 2006], Sovereignty in Fragments: The Past, Present and Future of a Contested Concept [Kalmo, Skinner 2010], Families and States in Western Europe [Skinner 2011].  ,          , , , The Cambridge History of Renaissance Philosophy [Schmitt et al. 1988].

                                , ,  .      .                 .  ,    ,          .          -,   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ( ,    )  .           (., .), ,    ,    ,      XIX .




   


     1940    .        (. 1924),               .          ,              .             ,            .                  .                    . ,    ( ,   )       ,          ,    (  .: [Palonen 2003: 173180]).  ,        , ,   ,     :   ,        .

            25 ,  29            [Skinner 1969][10 - .      .].   - - ,             -,  1965-  2008      ,     (19791996)     (1996).               1981            ,      .  2008?       ,               .  ,  (   )      , , , , , ,     .

      ,             .         ,   ,    1969      ,           ()          [11 -    ( 2003) . : [Palonen 2003: 181190].].    1970?       ,       Visions of Politics [Skinner 2002,1].               1978,            [Skinner 1978].        ,               XVI           . ,                        .

  .,   1978-  1982     35     [Palonen 2003: 91].   :



           ,       ,      ,         . ,   ,  -    ,    ⠫ [Palonen 2003: 93].


                 -  ,    ,   ,     .  :



      蠫 ,   ⠫,            . <>         ,        ,  ,      --   [Palonen 2003: 94].


        ,      XVII   ,    ..                 . , 1981   ,      [Skinner 1981], 1996?         [Skinner 1996], 1998?      [Skinner 1998][12 -   ,      (    .      [ 2006]), .  ..     (www.inliberty.ru/article/liberty-zorin ( : 14.08.2018)).], 2008?       [Skinner 2008], 2014?     [Skinner 2014],           .                  ,  1985 [Skinner 1985].         XX  , , , , ,  (  .), , -    ,       . , 2003              ?  [Skinner 2002].       ,        (     . [13 - .       : [ 2017].]),        XVII ,    . ,  2018        :      [Skinner 2018].

             ,         ,              .    ,   -             .        ( ,  ,    )   - ,           . -               ,               .

        ( )     ,     .         ,         ,          .            ,   ,      .              ,   ,        .                              .           ,    .     -    (       [14 -     ., : [Skinner 2012].])      .  ,    ,              .

     1924.     ,      ,     ,     ,            .                    ,      ,  .                   , [15 -   ,              ,    .      ( ),        ,     ,         (  ).  ,        .              . ,       .          ,        ,     ,           ,    ,         .   ,             .          ,     idiom     ( )   ,   :   ,      , ,    ,       .]  .      :     ,   ,  , ,  , ,    .       ,               XVXVIII.

      :        ,      ,  .   ,          ,     .     1952    ,           ,            .  1966?   ,      -,  1975     [16 -       .: [Hampsher-Monk 1984; 1998].].

             :       British studies,                  .  ,      ,  Renaissance studies      XVXVI.        : The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law: A Study of English Historical Thought in the Seventeenth Century [Pocock 1957],              ; Virtue, Commerce and History: Essays on Political Thought and History, Chiefly in the Eighteenth Century [Pocock 1985][17 - .         .],             .

   The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition [Pocock 1975]      ,     [Hankins 2000].            ,       XVII,          XVIII.  ,             (1977, 1992),            ,   (1987),          .  1965        The Maori and New Zealand Politics [Pocock 1965],          .

 ,      ,       - ,      . , 1971          Politics, Language and Time: Essays in Political Thought and History [Pocock 1971],          .         19602000?      Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method [Pocock 2009]. ,   1990?         , ,  .         Barbarism and Religion [Pocock 19992015]     ,              .

       ,    ,      ,            .          ,  ,      .         ,   ,      ,           ,   ,       .

    -                   .  -       ,       ,  ,  , ,     .  ,        , ,  , , , ,  ,               .      -                  .

The Machiavellian Moment              .                          .    ,        ,       ,          .     .     ,    ,       .    ,        , ,  ,                          - .        ,       :       ,      ,      , ,         .




         XX


            ,  1960? .                ⻠   .         . ,   intellectual history  1970?                  , ,          ,         . ,     ,    ,           [18 - ,    Art of Theory           (. : www.academia.edu/1073948/Quentin_Skinner_on_Meaning_and_Method ( : 23.05.2018)).],       .     .  ,         :  [Skinner 1969],  [Pocock 1962],  [Dunn 1968]   ,            .          .      ,    ,      ,       ,       .                    ,      ,    ,           ,    .

 ,   ,    :  ,       ,                  ,   , ,     . ,   ,       ,        ,        , what he was doing by writing a text,    .

      ,                 , ,       (beliefs)               .         ,            ,             [19 -    ,         :  ,      ,              .  ,  ,             ,           . ,   ,       ,     . , ,     ,       ,             ,  ,   .].   , -,      , ,     ,     ,  ,    [20 - .    : [Bourdieu 2001].]. ,      ,            (),      ,    [Pocock 1985; Skinner 1988b; 1988c].

               .                . ,                        (intention),    (meaning and context),  (move). ,     :   ,    ? (What was doing the author by writing his text?).           .         , ,  (sub-language),    (second-order language), , langue  parole,  , ,  (texture),  .       .            ,       ,  ,    ,     ,      .

    ,   -        .        ?          XX.         19501960? , ..     ,       .       (words are deeds)     򻠖   ,        .           Ѹ.        ꠫  ,   ,   ,      ,             .     ,           ,        [21 -  .       ? : [Skinner 2002, 1].].

         , ,  ,     :    -   ()         ,                , ..       ,  .      ,      ,         ,   ,   ,      ,       .               XX.

-               ,  1960? .                ,         [Pocock 1971/2009: 27;  2004][22 -         [Pocock 1971/ 2009: 27].].            ,          (1962)   ,     -   .  ,         蠫  .             Art and Illusion ( ,            ⠫,      ,      ,      [Gombrich 1960: 5273])         ,     ,       .        ,     [Gombrich 1960: 7273].  ,                       ,    ,        [Thompson 1993].

                        Begriffsgeschichte  ,       ,    [23 - .   Begriffsgeschichte,    : [Richter 1995; Van Gelderen 1998 (.       ); Palonen 1999; Skinner 1999; Palonen 2003: 171; Chignola, Duso 2008: 5182, 256282;  2010; Muscolino 2012: 9298; , ,  2012: 2331]  .].                           [Pocock 1996].   ,             ,     ,      ,    ,                    [24 -    ,  ,       (words are deeds),    , , ,          ,    ,   . <>     ,     ,       [ 2006: 38].].                ,                 .

   ,             (         [ 2002])[25 - .      ,      : [Ball, Farr, Hanson 1989].].  ,  1978        ,  ⠫          .   -              .        ,      ,       .    ,               ,                  .               ,   second-order languages, ..         ,  -   .          ,     ,      .                ,   ,      , ,  ,         .

        : a)   , b)    c)     ,     .                       [Tully 2002].   ,       ( 蠫),   ,     .     ,                       ,       .           ,       .            ,       ,    ,   ,         .    , ,      ,     ,                  [Skinner 2008].    ,    (    )          .

    ,  ,            ,        [Pettit 1997].  ,          ,       .               .          ,       [26 -  .    :       .].




   :     


            ,   .   ,            ,   , ,      ,     [27 - .     The State of the Art,    .].   ,                .           ()   ,         .                  , ,   ,             ,      .

         ,               .   ,   ,      ,       ()     ,  ,    ,       .            (       )   ,           [Pocock 1971].  ,     - ,      ,           ,     .      ,             ,  ,        .            ,      .                .  ,         ,    -                 .

       :        ,              .  ,   ,  ,      .         ,          ,       [28 -      .  .     :     [Tully 1988: 725],      .].         :                      .           ,      ,   ?    ,       ,          ,           .       ,  ,  ,  ,      .       [29 -           .        , ,        ,   .],       ,   ,    .

     (parole),          (langue),       [Pocock 1987/2009].          ,   ,        ,           ,       .      ,  ,      ,      .              ,         .          ,         ,      ,      .                 ().

   ,       ,    ,                       [30 -               ,        ,        ,      (.,  : [Hollis, Skinner 1978]).      .: [Simmons 2012].].             , , ,    ,           ,           .   ,                    ,      - .   ,   ,                         .    , ,          .    ,     ,   ,     .  ,        ,            .




  


                  ,   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,    .          ,     ,    ..      Res Publica   - [ 2002; 2004; 2006; 2009; 2011; 2013; 2015]. ,   , 2018            [ 2018].      Gefter.ru        .                      ,       .          .

            ,   ,       . ,     ,    ,    λ,           .  ,    ,           ,       .     ,   ,         [ 2014: 18].    ,        ,     ,           . ,      ,   ,         ,       (),          (, )   ,       ().                - .

         .         ,    , -  .     .., ,    ,          [Skinner 1975: 217].    ,        ,    (,        )      ,      ? ,    .   -          ,       long-term-  ,    .     :      c  mentalit,      ,  ,   limaginaire social  ,      ,                  [Vincent 2003][31 -         .: [Guilhaumou 2010].].     (   [Chignola, Duso 2008])    ,   ,             [32 -         .   : [Castiglione, Hampsher-Monk 2001].].     ,  ,    (, ,   )       ,     ,  , .     ,         :       ,    (        ) ,         .

                 .              XVII ( ) XVIII  (),           .          :        XVIXVII      XVIII ,        [33 - .,  ,        .].      ,                       .         1969   ,      ,     , ..      ,    .         ,            . ,     ,        ,            .      -        ,       .

              ,    ,   ,   ,    ,         ;              , ,       .       ,          ,       .                 ,     .

  蠫   ,            .           ,     .          ,        .     ,  ,    :

 )    )  ;

    ;

    ,    .

   ,          ,               (,         ),   ,  ,    .  ,    ,      ,           .

,             ,            .    ,    ,     ,   .               ,     .                                 . ,                   ,  )    ,  ,       ,  )      ..  ,  , ,       .

                .     ,  ,     蠫              [34 -    134-  λ ..               ,        [ 2015].               .                   ?             ?          , ,     ,           ,          .                 ,                 .].   ,        :        .  ,        [Habermas 1962],       (,  , , , , ,    ),         ,      [35 -           XVIII (   ) .: [Goodman 1992; Van Horn Melton 2001].        ,   ,   ., : [Struever 1974;  2012].].           ,       .            (  ,       ,      ),            ,     .  (    )          ,              ,    .      , ..  ,        ,         - .

              ,    ,    ,                         .           ,         ,         .                      ,    , ,    , ,         .

,    ,     .   ,       [Pocock 1996/2009; 1998/2009; 2005/2009],        .                 ,  , ,      .                    ,            .   ,            ,             .               ,     ,        .

        ,       ,         ,       (.,  : [Pocock 1985]).      , -    -      ,                   . ,          蠫 ,  蠫 .                 , ,               .

               ,            .       :   ,    II,         .           ,    , ,             ,          .             ,       .        ,  ,          1990?     ,  ,  .   ,     ,         ,                    .

    ,     ,   .                     .         ,  ,  ,    ,   ..      .     ,  蠫,              ,     .                . ,     ,         (             ),           -  .        ,     -              .

 ,      ,                   ().     ..                      - .







[ 2010]   .       [2000]/ . . .//  ,  ,  /  . ... ., 2010. .112152.

[ 2014]  .. :   ,    . ., 2014.

[ 2004]  ..   : (      )// . 2004. 66. .616.

[ 2010]   .     :  .   : //  ,  ,  /  . ... ., 2010. .298319.

[ 2006]   .     / . . ..//       XVIXX/  . .., .. ... ., 2006. .3353.

[, ,  2012]  .., ..,  .  :     //  :     :  2./  . .., .. .. .1. ., 2012. .546.

[ 2002]   . The State [1989]/ . . .//     /  . .. ., 2002. .1274.

[ 2004]   .      : , , / . . .// . 2004. 66. .5566.

[ 2006]   .   / . . .. ., 2006.

[ 2009]   . :   / . . ., 2009.

[ 2011]   .   :    / . . ..//  . 2011. 3. .131151.

[ 2013]   . ,    ?  :       30 2012./ . . .  . .// Ab Imperio. 2013. 1. .2154.

[ 2015]   .   / . .//    /  . .. ., 2015. .2542.

[ 2017]   .       / . . .// . 2017. 146. .3960.

[ 2018]   .    :  2./ . . .. ., 2018.

[ 2016]  ..     : (      )// . 2016. 3. .181191.

[ 2012]  ..      //       / . . .. ... ., 2012. .723.

[ 2015]    /  . .;   .// . 2015. 134. .119132.

[ 2004]   .     :  ?/ . . .// . 2004. 66. .4447.

[Armitage 2006]  British Political Thought in History, Literature and Theory, 15001800/ Ed. by D.Armitage. Cambridge, 2006.

[Armitage, Himy, Skinner 1995]  Milton and Republicanism/ Ed. by D.Armitage, A.Himy, and Q.Skinner. Cambridge, 1995.

[Ball, Farr, Hanson 1989]  Political Innovation and Conceptual Change/ Ed. by T.Ball, J.Farr, and R.L.Hanson. Cambridge, 1989.

[Bevir 1992]  Bevir M. The Errors of Linguistic Contextualism// History and Theory. 1992. Vol.31. 3. P.276298.

[Bevir 2004]  Bevir M. The Logic of the History of Ideas. Cambridge, 2004.

[Bock, Skinner, Viroli 1990]  Machiavelli and Republicanism/ Ed. by G.Bock, Q.Skinner, and M.Viroli. Cambridge, 1990.

[Bourdieu 2001]  Bourdieu P.Langage et pouvoir symbolique. Paris, 2001.

[Brett 2002]  Brett A. What Is Intellectual History Now?// What Is History Now?/ Ed. by D.Cannadine. London, 2002. P.113131.

[Brett, Tully, Hamilton-Bleakley 2006]  Rethinking the Foundations of Modern Political Thought/ Ed. by A.Brett and J.Tully with H.Hamilton-Bleakley. Cambridge, 2006.

[Castiglione, Hampsher-Monk 2001]  The History of Political Thought in National Context/ Ed. by D.Castiglione and I.Hampsher-Monk. Cambridge, 2001.

[Chignola, Duso 2008]  Chignola S., Duso G. Storia dei concetti e filosofia politica. Milano, 2008.

[Clark 2006]  ClarkJ.D.C. Barbarism, Religion and the History of Political Thought// The Political Imagination in History: Essays Concerning J.G.A.Pocock/ Ed. by D.N.DeLuna with the assistance of P.Anderson and G.Burgess. Baltimore, 2006. P.211230.

[DeLuna, Anderson, Burgess 2006]  The Political Imagination in History: Essays Concerning J.G.A.Pocock/ Ed. by D.N.DeLuna with the assistance of P.Anderson and G.Burgess. Baltimore, 2006.

[Dunn 1968]  Dunn J. The Identity of the History of Ideas// Philosophy. 1968. Vol.43. 164. P.85104.

[Dunn 1996]  Dunn J. The History of Political Theory// DunnJ. The History of Political Theory and Other Essays. Cambridge, 1996. P.1138.

[Floyd, Stears 2011]  Political Philosophy versus History? Contextualism and Real Politics in Contemporary Political Thought/ Ed. by J.Floyd and M.Stears. Cambridge, 2011.

[Gombrich 1960]  GombrichE.H. Art and Illusion: A Study in the Psychology of Pictorial Representation. London, 1960.

[Goodman 1992]  Goodman D. Public Sphere and Private Life: Toward aSynthesis of Current Historiographical Approaches to the Old Regime// History and Theory. 1992. Vol.31. 1. P.120.

[Grafton 2006]  Grafton A. The History of Ideas: Precept and Practice, 19502000 and Beyond// Journal of the History of Ideas. 2006. Vol.67. 1. P.132.

[Guilhaumou 2010]  Guilhaumou J. Discorso ed evento: Per una storia linguistica delle idee [2006]/ Trad. eintrod. di R.Raus. Roma, 2010.

[Habermas 1962]  Habermas J. Strukturwandel der ?ffentlichkeit: Untersuchungen zu einer Kategorie der b?rgerlichen Gesellschaft. Frankfurt am Main, 1962.

[Hampsher-Monk 1984]  Hampsher-Monk I. Political Languages in Time  The Work of J.G.A.Pocock// British Journal of Political Science. 1984. Vol.14. 1. P.89116.

[Hampsher-Monk 1998]  Hampsher-Monk I. Speech Acts, Languages or Conceptual History?// History of Concepts: Comparative Perspective/ Ed. by I.Hampsher-Monk, K.Tilmans, and F.Van Vree. Amsterdam, 1998. P.3750.

[Hankins 2000]  Hankins J. Introduction// Renaissance Civic Humanism: Reappraisals and Reflections/ Ed. by J.Hankins. Cambridge, 2000. P.113.

[Hollis, Skinner 1978]  Hollis M., Skinner Q. Action and Context// Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 1978. Supplementary vol. 52. P.4369.

[Hume 2006]  HumeR.D. Pococks Contextual Historicism// The Political Imagination in History: Essays Concerning J.G.A.Pocock/ Ed. by D.N.DeLuna with the assistance of P.Anderson and G.Burgess. Baltimore, 2006. P.2755.

[Jacoby 1992]  Jacoby R. A New Intellectual History?// The American Historical Review. 1992. Vol.97. 2. P.405424.

[Jeppesen, Stjernfelt, Thorup 2013]  JeppesenM.H., Stjernfelt F., ThorupM. Preface// Intellectual History: 5Questions/ Ed. by M.H.Jeppesen, F.Stjernfelt, and M.Thorup. Copenhagen, 2013. P.IIIV.

[Kalmo, Skinner 2010]  Sovereignty in Fragments: The Past, Present and Future of a Contested Concept/ Ed. by H.Kalmo and Q.Skinner. 2010.

[King 1983]  The History of Ideas: An Introduction to Method/ Ed. by P.King. London; Canberra, 1983.

[King 1995]  King P.Historical Contextualism: The New Historicism?// History of European Ideas. 1995. Vol.21. 2. P.209233.

[LaCapra 1983]  LaCapra D. Rethinking Intellectual History: Texts, Contexts, Language. Ithaca, N.Y., 1983.

[LaCapra 1992]  LaCapra D. Intellectual History and Its Ways// The American Historical Review. 1992. Vol.97. 2. P.425439.

[Mulsow, Mahler 2010]  Mulsow M., Mahler A. Einleitung// Die Cambridge School des politischen Ideengeschichte/ Hg. von M.Mulsow und A.Mahler. Berlin, 2010. S.717.

[Muscolino 2012]  Muscolino S.Linguaggio, storia e politica: Ludwig Wittgenstein e Quentin Skinner. Palermo, 2012.

[Pagden 1985]  The Languages of Political Theory in Early-Modern Europe/ Ed. by A.Pagden. Cambridge, 1985.

[Pagden 1988]  Pagden A. Review: Rethinking the Linguistic Turn: Current Anxieties in Intellectual History// Journal of the History of Ideas. 1988. Vol.49. 3. P.519529.

[Palonen 1999]  Palonen K. Rhetorical and Temporal Perspectives on Conceptual Change// The Finnish Yearbook of Political Thought. 1999. Vol.III. P.4159.

[Palonen 2003]  Palonen K. Quentin Skinner: History, Politics, Rhetoric. Cambridge, 2003.

[Pettit 1997]  Pettit Ph. Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government. Oxford, 1997.

[Phillipson, Skinner 1993]  Political Discourse in Early Modern Britain/ Ed. by N.Phillipson and Q.Skinner. Cambridge, 1993.

[Pocock 1957]  PocockJ.G.A. The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law: A Study of English Historical Thought in the Seventeenth Century. Cambridge, 1957.

[Pocock 1962]  PocockJ.G.A. The History of Political Thought: AMethodological Inquiry// Philosophy, Politics and Society. 2nd series/ Ed. by P.Laslett and W.G.Runciman. Oxford, 1962. P.183202.

[Pocock 1965]  The Maori and New Zealand Politics: Talks from aN.Z.B.C.Series with Additional Essays/ Ed. by J.G.A.Pocock. Auckland, 1965.

[Pocock 1971]  PocockJ.G.A. Politics, Language, and Time: Essays on Political Thought and History. Chicago, 1971.

[Pocock 1971/2009]  PocockJ.G.A. Working on Ideas in Time [1971]// PocockJ.G.A. Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method. Cambridge, 2009. P.2032.

[Pocock 1975]  PocockJ.G.A. The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition. Princeton, 1975.

[Pocock 1980]  Three British Revolutions: 1641, 1688, 1776/ Ed. by J.G.A.Pocock. Princeton, 1980.

[Pocock 1985]  Pocock J.G.A. Virtue, Commerce and History: Essays on Political Thought and History, Chiefly in the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge, 1985.

[Pocock 1987/ 2009]  Pocock J.G.A. The Concept of a Language and the mtier dhistorien: Some Considerations on Practice [1987]// PocockJ.G.A. Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method. Cambridge, 2009. P.87105.

[Pocock 1996]  PocockJ.G.A. Concepts and Discourses: A Difference in Culture? Comment on a Paper by Melvin Richter// The Meaning of Historical Terms and Concepts: New Studies on Begriffsgeschichte/ Ed. by H.Lehmann and M.Richter. Washington, 1996. P.4758.

[Pocock 1996/ 2009]  PocockJ.G.A. The Historian as Political Actor in Polity, Society and Academy [1996]// PocockJ.G.A. Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method. Cambridge, 2009. P.217238.

[Pocock 1998/ 2009]  PocockJ.G.A. The Politics of History: The Subaltern and the Subversive [1998]// PocockJ.G.A. Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method. Cambridge, 2009. P.239256.

[Pocock 19992015]  Pocock J.G.A. Barbarism and Religion: In 6 vols. Cambridge, 19992015.

[Pocock 2005/ 2009]  PocockJ.G.A. The Politics of Historiography [2005]// PocockJ.G.A. Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method. Cambridge, 2009. P.257271.

[Pocock 2006]  PocockJ.G.A. Foundations and Moments// Rethinking the Foundations of Modern Political Thought/ Ed. by A.Brett and J.Tully with H.Hamilton-Bleakley. Cambridge, 2006. P.3749.

[Pocock 2009]  PocockJ.G.A. Political Thought and History: Essays on Theory and Method. Cambridge, 2009.

[Pocock 2013]  PocockJ.G.A. Intellectual History// Intellectual History: 5Questions/ Ed. by M.H.Jeppesen, F.Stjernfelt, and M.Thorup. Copenhagen, 2013. P.143145.

[Pocock, Schochet, Schwoerer 1993]  The Varieties of British Political Thought, 15001800/ Ed. by J.G.A.Pocock with the assistance of G.J.Schochet and L.Schwoerer. Cambridge, 1993.

[Richter 1995]  Richter M. Pocock, Skinner and Begriffsgeschichte// The History of Political and Social Concepts: A Critical Introduction/ Ed. by M.Richter. New York; Oxford, 1995. P.124142.

[Rorty, Schneewind, Skinner 1984]  Philosophy in History: Essays on the Historiography of Philosophy/ Ed. by R.Rorty, J.B.Schneewind, and Q.Skinner. Cambridge, 1984.

[Simmons 2012]  Simmons D. The Weight of the Moment: J.G.A.Pococks Politics of History// History of European Ideas. 2012. Vol.38. 2. P.288306.

[Schmitt et al. 1988]  The Cambridge History of Renaissance Philosophy/ Ed. by C.B.Schmitt, Q.Skinner, E.Kessler and J.Kraye. Cambridge, 1988.

[Skinner 1969]  Skinner Q. Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas// History and Theory. 1969. Vol.8. 1. P.353.

[Skinner 1975]  Skinner Q. Hermeneutics and the Role of History// New Literary History. 1975. Vol.7. 1. P.209232.

[Skinner 1978]  Skinner Q. The Foundations of Modern Political Thought: In 2 vols. Vol.1: The Renaissance; Vol.2: The Age of Reformation. Cambridge, 1978.

[Skinner 1981]  Skinner Q. Machiavelli. Oxford, 1981.

[Skinner 1985]  The Return of Grand Theory in the Human Sciences/ Ed. by Q.Skinner. Cambridge, 1985.

[Skinner 1988a]  Skinner Q. A Reply to My Critics// Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics/ Ed. by J.Tully. Princeton, 1988. P.231288.

[Skinner 1988b]  Skinner Q. Language and Social Change// Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics/ Ed. by J.Tully. Princeton, 1988. P.119132.

[Skinner 1988c]  Skinner Q. Social Meaning and the Explanation of Social Action// Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics/ Ed. by J.Tully. Princeton, 1988. P.7996.

[Skinner 1996]  Skinner Q. Reason and Rhetoric in the Philosophy of Hobbes. Cambridge, 1996.

[Skinner 1998]  Skinner Q. Liberty before Liberalism. Cambridge, 1998.

[Skinner 1999]  Skinner Q. Rhetoric and Conceptual Change// The Finnish Yearbook of Political Thought. 1999. Vol.III. P.6073.

[Skinner 2002]  Skinner Q. Visions of Politics: In 3 vols. Vol.1: Regarding Method; Vol.2: Renaissance Virtues; Vol.3: Hobbes and Civil Science. Cambridge, 2002.

[Skinner 2008]  Skinner Q. Hobbes and Republican Liberty. Cambridge, 2008.

[Skinner 2011]  Families and States in Western Europe/ Ed. by Q.Skinner. Cambridge, 2011.

[Skinner 2012]  On Politics and History: A Discussion with Quentin Skinner by Georgios Giannakopoulos and Francisco Quijano// Journal of Intellectual History and Political Thought. 2012. 1. P.731.

[Skinner 2014]  Skinner Q. Forensic Shakespeare. Oxford, 2014.

[Skinner 2018]  Skinner Q. From Humanism to Hobbes: Studies in Rhetoric and Politics. Cambridge, 2018.

[Skinner, Str?th 2003]  States and Citizens: History, Theory, Prospects/ Ed. by Q.Skinner and B.Str?th. Cambridge, 2003.

[Struever 1974]  Struever N. The Study of Language and the Study of History// The Journal of Interdisciplinary History. 1974. Vol.4. 3. P.401415.

[Thompson 1993]  ThompsonM.P.Reception Theory and the Interpretation of Historical Meaning// History and Theory. 1993. Vol.32. 3. P.248272.

[Toews 1987]  ToewsJ.E. Review: Intellectual History after the Linguistic Turn: The Autonomy of Meaning and the Irreducibility of Experience// The American Historical Review. 1987. Vol.92. 4. P.879907.

[Tuck 1993]  Tuck R. The Contribution of History// A Companion to Contemporary Political Philosophy/ Ed. by R.E.Goodin and Ph. Pettit. Oxford, 1993. P.7289.

[Tully 1988]  Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics/ Ed. by J.Tully. Princeton, 1988.

[Tully 2002]  Tully J. Political Philosophy as a Critical Activity// Political Theory. 2002. Vol.30. 4. P.533555.

[Van Gelderen 1998]  Van Gelderen M. Between Cambridge and Heidelberg: Concepts, Languages and Images in Intellectual History// History of Concepts: Comparative Perspective/ Ed. by I.Hampsher-Monk, K.Tilmans, and F.Van Vree. Amsterdam, 1998. P.227238.

[Van Gelderen, Skinner 2002]  Republicanism: A Shared European Heritage: In 2 vols./ Ed. by M. van Gelderen and Q.Skinner. Cambridge, 2002.

[Van Horn Melton 2001]  Van Horn Melton J. Introduction: What Is the Public Sphere?// Van Horn MeltonJ. The Rise of the Public in Enlightenment Europe. Cambridge, 2001. P.115.

[Vincent 2003]  Vincent J. Concepts et contextes de lhistoire intellectuelle britannique: Lcole de Cambridge ?lpreuve// Revue dhistoire moderne et contemporaine. 2003. T.50. 2. P.187207.

[White 1969]  White H. The Task of Intellectual History// The Monist. 1969. Vol.53. 4. P.606630.




 





 

     [36 -   : Skinner Q. Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas// History and Theory. 1969. Vol.8. 1. P.353.    : Skinner Q. Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas// Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics/ Ed. by J.Tully. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1988. P.2967.      Princeton University Press.]



    ,   , ,     [37 - .           : [Mandelbaum 1965: 33, fn.].      ,    ,            .],       ,   .        : , ,     ,    , ,   -  .         :        ? ,    (    )    ,    , -,  .   (,      ) ,    ,        ,            .     (,      )    ,          ,            [38 -             蠫.        (   )       .           .  ,      ,    ,     .  ,         ,     . .    ,    : [Bateson 1953: 16].         廠  : [Leavis 1953: 173].].

            ,            :                      .  ,   ,       ,       .                        .

         .      , ,          ;    ,     ,       ,    ,     ,    .  ,           ,  ,       .




I


     ,   ,         ,       -   ,          .   ,      ,     ,          .    ( )   ,   ,   ,     ( )   [Merkl 1967: 3][39 - Π  蠫    . : [Morgenthau 1958: 1; Sibley 1958: 133] (       ).],      [Bluhm 1965: 13],     [Catlin 1950: x],     [Hacker 1954: 783].

,  ,   ,     ,        [40 -      ,   ,  ,    ,     .].             ,  ⠫ ,     [41 - .  ,          : [McCloskey 1957: 129]. Π         ;         : [Hacker 1954].],    ,      ,     [42 -        .: [Jaspers 1962: Preface],  : [Nelson 1962: 3233].      . : [Murphy 1951: v]   ,   ; [Ryan 1965: 219]   ,   ; [Strauss 1948: 7]     ,    .]      蠫 [43 -    ., : [McCoy 1963: 7]. Π  ., ,   : [Strauss, Cropsey 1963].]. ,  ,   ⠫                  [Bluhm 1965: v].  ,          ,          ,  ,      .

    ,                  ,   ,     ,        ,    .       ,   .        [MacIntyre 1966a: 2][44 -  ,    ,    .],     ,      -  .   ,             [Wolin 1961: 27][45 -         ;  .: [Wolin 1961: 1117].]  .          ,     -            ,      -   ,               .                  , ,        -   .    , -,     ? ,  ?  ,         .          -  ,    ,    ,         -    -    ,    .

          ,          ,         ,        (       ),        ,     .       ,  [Allport 1955][46 - .   ,    (set)       [Allport 1955: 240]    ,      .]  ,    .        .      ,     ,       [Allport 1955: 239].              ,      ,      ,              ,     ,     .  ,   ,   ,   ,  ,    ,   [47 -     ,       (  ?)    ,     : [Dunn 1968: 9798].].  ,         ,     -         ,               ,    .

         [48 - . : [Gombrich 1960],     .        :  ,   ,    [Gombrich 1960: 75].]    ,    ,    ,   ,      ,      .                  [Kuhn 1962][49 - .  V,       . ,     ,  . . ,           : [Collingwood 1940: ch.7].].          .      ,  ,       , ,         ,           . ,    ,  ,    ,       .    , -, ,   ,       ,     ,       ,  -,   ,             ,    .

   ,    ,     (,      )   -        .         ( )          .   ( )   ,     .

    .  ,    -               . ,   ,      ,             ,        (  ),          ,      -    .

        .     -    ,     ,      . ,                       [Marsilius of Padua 19511956, II: 6167].  ,   , ,  ,            ,  ,            .     [50 -    : [Pocock 1965]. . : [Bailyn 1967].]    (        ),         ,      ,        . ,        ,    ,     . (                   .)                 ,   ,       ,   ,         [Marsilius of Padua 19511956, I: 232].   ,  ,      ,    [51 - . : [Marsilius of Padua 19511956, I: 234, fn.]. ,    , ., , : [DEntr?ves 1939: 58].],       ,       ,           .           ,           ,         .  (   )         ,    .      -  XVII       . (  ,       ,    I,       ,  ,    ,   [Pocock 1957: ch.11].)       ,       ,          [Gwyn 1965: 50, fn.],  ,        蠫       [Plucknett 1926: 68][52 - ,       ,       ,     : [Convin 1929: 368]. .    : [Convin 1948: 42].].  , , ,      ,    ,  ,      - [53 -       . : [Thorne 1938].],           .

       ,     ,      ,    (,   )        ,       ,     . , ,     ,          (I, x, 4).     ,    (,   )          ,   ,   ,            .   ,                  ,                 [Morris 1953: 181,197].                (149, 155). ,                 .     , ,  ,        ,                    [Gough 1950: ch.3 (    ), 145 ( )].               . ,    (  , ,  )           ,      , ,   ( )        .    ,        ,      , ,   ,       [Gwyn 1965: 52].    ,  ,          ,           : ,  ,         ,      ,             ?       :  -   (     )   .

            ,       ,           ,   (   ,   )   ,    -     ,    [Lovejoy 1960: 15].                   , , ,  ,   ,    - .      ,        .  ,  ,    ,  ,     ,           -    ,           [Bury 1932: 7],         [Weston 1965: 45],        (,   )     [Raab 1964: 2].  ,              .  ,      ,    ,        . ,   ,      ,  XVI        [Bury 1932: 7] 蠫      [Sampson 1956: 39].       :           ,       ,            XVIII,       [Vile 1967: 30].

  ,   ,     ,           ,            .           ,    ,                  ,     .  ,   ,       [Raab 1964: 2];   ,     [Jones 1947: 50];         [Armstrong 1965: 382];     ,         [Popkin 1953: 300];       ,      [Cassirer 1955: 151][54 -    ,  ,        .].         ,           ,    ,   .          :     ,   [Morris 1966: 8990].        :    .     :       [Raab 1964: 1, 11][55 - ,   ,        ,         .  ,       : [Anglo 1966].].  ( ,  )   ꠫ ,  ;         ,       [Bloom, Jaffa 1964: 12, 4, 36].   .

  ,   ,         ,     ,  ,   ,          蠫        .        .         ? ,        ,       [Gwyn 1965:9]. , ,        1648? ,          [Vile 1967: 46].        .  ,     ? ,      (,      ,      ). , ,       ? ,       ,        [Gough 1957: 59].

 ,                            ,      .   ,     ,     .    -,            ,       .

           (    )   . ,                   [Strauss 1957: 12].   ,    ,    , ,  ,    ?    ,        ,      [Bloom, Jaffa 1964: 12][56 - .                : [Kaufman 1954].      (,  )  : [Cropsey 1962]         ,         .]. ,         [57 - Π .: [Strauss 1953];  .: [Strauss 1958].].            ,      [58 - .           : [Coltman 1962].].    ,     ,   ,          [Strauss 1958: 1112].     ,                 [Strauss 1958: 14].  ,          ,     .          .    ,      ,     ,       ,      .

          ,    ,      ,         .      ,     ,  -    ,    .          , , ,      [Cranston 1964: 3435]. ,  ,   ,  ,   ,    [Marsilius of Padua 19511956, I: 312].        ,    ,             [Shirley 1949: 256].      ,        ,    :                 .         ,     .         ,    - ,    -   ,       ,         . ,          ,                      , ...            ,       . ,      <>    .     ,    .   ,         .   ,    ,        ,   ,                .    ,       ,  ,   ,     .       ,     ,       ,  .     ,           -    [Weldon 1946: 26, 63, 64].  ,            . ,  , ,      ,       ,       , ,        ,    ,         .      - ;             ,         [Sabine 1951: 67];      ,             蠫            [Aaron 1955: 284285];     ,                 [Friedrich 1964: 178].          ,  ,      ,        .     ,        ,     [59 - Π   .: [Plamenatz 1963, I: 43].], [60 -   ⠫     ,           [Russell 1946: 578].  ,      ,         .] [61 -         [Hacker 1961: 192],    [Hacker 1961: 285].],        -  [Lerner 1950: xxx][62 -      -   ,       [Lerner 1950: xxx].]        .

             ,            ,       -               ,      .   , ,    ,   (     )   ,      , ,         ,          [Davies 1946: 80].   ,   ⠫      ,    ,      ,             [Dahl 1963: 113].     ,                ,     , , ,     ,         [Cox 1960: xv, 189].   ,      ⠫       , ,  ,  򻠖  ,       , ,  ,       ,         [Stark 1960: 144, 153].     ,      ,    ,    ,       :   -              ,      ?

      , , ,  ,       .  (    ),  -             -    .                       ,           ,    . , ,    ,          ,        ,           .           , ,  ,  ,         ,     ,           ,       .            ,       ,     ,     .          [63 -              ...: [Pocock 1962].                ,     [Laslett 1967: 371].].        ⠫   ,    ,    ,   , ,  [McGrade 1963: 163].      ,        ,       ,    ,           ,       [Warrender 1957: vii].        ,   ,         ,                    [Stewart 1963: v  vi].        ,           ,   ,  ,  ,        -  [Barnard 1965: xix] (. : [Barnard 1965: 139]).           ,          ;    ,   ꠫ ,       [Watkins 1965: 10].

                ,  , ,         . , ,   , ,  ,       ,      ,             [Cassirer 1954: 46, 62][64 -         ,   ,    ,   ,       ,  -  ,        .].  ,    ,            ,      ,              ,        [Hood 1964: 28].    ,             ,         ,         ,            [Parkin 1956: 2, 4].       ,         ,   ,   (  )   ,   ,      .     ,     ,           [Avineri 1968: 3]. ,  ,     -   ,                 .         :       . ,   ,          -  . ,    ,    .      ,           .              ,       ,      [Sabine 1951: 642].     ,  -     ,   ,      .    ,              , , ,       , , ,             [Hearnshaw 1928: 243].     ,   ,   ,           ,   ,   ,     , ,   ,  , -,        [Adler 1967: xi][65 - . : [Bird 1967: 22].       ,       (sic)            .      , ,  [Adler 1967: ix  xi].].        ,    ,       .   ,         ,       ,    ,       .

  ,      ,         ,           . -,  ,    ,         -      ,      ,    ,       .          .   ,   ,                  [66 -    .  ꠫      : [Locke 1967].].  -    ,   ,       ,       ,     ,          ,        [Seliger 1968][67 -       [Seliger 1968: 209210]   ,     .]. ,       :  ,      .    ,        ,       . ,        ,      ,  , -, ,    ,              ,  -,             :  ,           [Hobbes 1946: 466467][68 -   , ,   , , ,     .    .  : [Skinner 1964].].    ,      ,              .  ,  ,   , -,         ,       ,      .     ,            .   ,           ,  ,    ,  ,     [Hood 1964: 64, 116117, 136137].

  ,   ,    ,        ,    ,   ,       ,        ,      ,       .   ,           ,     ,    ,      (  )? [Harrison 1955]. ,     (      ), ,    .     ,        ,   ,         [Macpherson 1962: viii],  ,   ,    .  ,     -      ,    ,          XIX [Strauss 1952: 3031].   ,                ,    .   , ,        -  ,               .       ,      ,      ,              [69 -       .: [Cochrane 1961].       () . .         ,     蠫: [Baron 1961].].             .   ,           -     ,    ,       ⠫. ,      ⠫      ,          [Avineri 1968: 2];            ,            ,      ? ,          ,      ,   ,       [Tucker 1961: 7, 11, 21, ch.XI][70 -  ,        ,  ,    ,      (   ),             [Tucker 1961: 233].       ,     ,      [Tucker 1961: 243].].

      ,     ,         . ,     ,    ,          .         ,   ,  . ( ,  , , .)           ,    ,      ,           ,          , ,   , [71 -    : [Strauss 1952: 2425, 30, 32].].           ,       , ,   ,    ,    . -,      ,     .   ,     .  -,  ,     ,        ,      [Strauss 1952: 25].    (      ) ,           , ࠫ      .     -    ,  ,            ,   , ,        ,         .        ?         ,      [Strauss 1952: 30].     ,       ?   ,  ,    , ,    ,       .    ,   ,  ,  ,             [Strauss 1952: 24, 32].     ,  ,             -,   , , ,   ,             -     ,       .




II


      ,   ,    ,   -     ,    ,  ,   .   , ,         ,               ,     ,           .  ,            ,          -  .    ,       -   ,       , , , -    ,       .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/sbornik/kembridzhskaya-shkola-teoriya-i-praktika-intellektualnoy-istorii/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


        :  .,  . Context is king:      // . 2015. 134. .2144.




2


  ,    , ,   ,  ,     : [Phillipson, Skinner 1993; Tuck 1993; Dunn 1996: 1922; Palonen 2003: 1128;  2004; Chignola, Duso 2008; Guilhaumou 2010: 5963; Mulsow, Mahler 2010].




3


           ., , : [ 2016].




4


 ,               .     (  ) ,  ,   ,    :      (  . .., ..)  ,         :      ,      (foundation)   (. .) [ 2018, 2: 534].        origins,  , ,    . The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution (1967),    . .      (2010).




5


.      .




6


        .: [King 1983; Bevir 2004; Grafton 2006].




7


,       :   1985 , ,  History Today.




8


      ,   intellectual history, . : [Brett 2002].




9


            . ,  .1  .19.




10


.      .




11


   ( 2003) . : [Palonen 2003: 181190].




12


  ,      (    .      [ 2006]), .  ..     (www.inliberty.ru/article/liberty-zorin ( : 14.08.2018)).




13


.       : [ 2017].




14


    ., : [Skinner 2012].




15


  ,              ,    .      ( ),        ,     ,         (  ).  ,        .              . ,       .          ,        ,     ,           ,    ,         .   ,             .          ,     idiom     ( )   ,   :   ,      , ,    ,       .




16


      .: [Hampsher-Monk 1984; 1998].




17


.         .




18


,    Art of Theory           (. : www.academia.edu/1073948/Quentin_Skinner_on_Meaning_and_Method ( : 23.05.2018)).




19


   ,         :  ,      ,              .  ,  ,             ,           . ,   ,       ,     . , ,     ,       ,             ,  ,   .




20


.    : [Bourdieu 2001].




21


 .       ? : [Skinner 2002, 1].




22


        [Pocock 1971/ 2009: 27].




23


.   Begriffsgeschichte,    : [Richter 1995; Van Gelderen 1998 (.       ); Palonen 1999; Skinner 1999; Palonen 2003: 171; Chignola, Duso 2008: 5182, 256282;  2010; Muscolino 2012: 9298; , ,  2012: 2331]  .




24


   ,  ,       (words are deeds),    , , ,          ,    ,   . <>     ,     ,       [ 2006: 38].




25


.      ,      : [Ball, Farr, Hanson 1989].




26


 .    :       .




27


.     The State of the Art,    .




28


     .  .     :     [Tully 1988: 725],      .




29


          .        , ,        ,   .




30


              ,        ,        ,      (.,  : [Hollis, Skinner 1978]).      .: [Simmons 2012].




31


        .: [Guilhaumou 2010].




32


        .   : [Castiglione, Hampsher-Monk 2001].




33


.,  ,        .




34


   134-  λ ..               ,        [ 2015].               .                   ?             ?          , ,     ,           ,          .                 ,                 .




35


          XVIII (   ) .: [Goodman 1992; Van Horn Melton 2001].        ,   ,   ., : [Struever 1974;  2012].




36


  : Skinner Q. Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas// History and Theory. 1969. Vol.8. 1. P.353.    : Skinner Q. Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas// Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics/ Ed. by J.Tully. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1988. P.2967.      Princeton University Press.




37


.           : [Mandelbaum 1965: 33, fn.].      ,    ,            .




38


            蠫.        (   )       .           .  ,      ,    ,     .  ,         ,     . .    ,    : [Bateson 1953: 16].         廠  : [Leavis 1953: 173].




39


Π  蠫    . : [Morgenthau 1958: 1; Sibley 1958: 133] (       ).




40


     ,   ,  ,    ,     .




41


.  ,          : [McCloskey 1957: 129]. Π         ;         : [Hacker 1954].




42


       .: [Jaspers 1962: Preface],  : [Nelson 1962: 3233].      . : [Murphy 1951: v]   ,   ; [Ryan 1965: 219]   ,   ; [Strauss 1948: 7]     ,    .




43


   ., : [McCoy 1963: 7]. Π  ., ,   : [Strauss, Cropsey 1963].




44


 ,    ,    .




45


        ;  .: [Wolin 1961: 1117].




46


.   ,    (set)       [Allport 1955: 240]    ,      .




47


    ,       (  ?)    ,     : [Dunn 1968: 9798].




48


. : [Gombrich 1960],     .        :  ,   ,    [Gombrich 1960: 75].




49


.  V,       . ,     ,  . . ,           : [Collingwood 1940: ch.7].




50


   : [Pocock 1965]. . : [Bailyn 1967].




51


. : [Marsilius of Padua 19511956, I: 234, fn.]. ,    , ., , : [DEntr?ves 1939: 58].




52


,       ,       ,     : [Convin 1929: 368]. .    : [Convin 1948: 42].




53


      . : [Thorne 1938].




54


   ,  ,        .




55


,   ,        ,         .  ,       : [Anglo 1966].




56


.                : [Kaufman 1954].      (,  )  : [Cropsey 1962]         ,         .




57


Π .: [Strauss 1953];  .: [Strauss 1958].




58


.           : [Coltman 1962].




59


Π   .: [Plamenatz 1963, I: 43].




60


  ⠫     ,           [Russell 1946: 578].  ,      ,         .




61


        [Hacker 1961: 192],    [Hacker 1961: 285].




62


     -   ,       [Lerner 1950: xxx].




63


             ...: [Pocock 1962].                ,     [Laslett 1967: 371].




64


        ,   ,    ,   ,       ,  -  ,        .




65


. : [Bird 1967: 22].       ,       (sic)            .      , ,  [Adler 1967: ix  xi].




66


   .  ꠫      : [Locke 1967].




67


      [Seliger 1968: 209210]   ,     .




68


  , ,   , , ,     .    .  : [Skinner 1964].




69


      .: [Cochrane 1961].       () . .         ,     蠫: [Baron 1961].




70


 ,        ,  ,    ,      (   ),             [Tucker 1961: 233].       ,     ,      [Tucker 1961: 243].




71


   : [Strauss 1952: 2425, 30, 32].


