    
  


  ,   ,     ,               2001.     -      .           XIXXX.        - .              -    .              .   , ,        , ,    -   .





    

   A. . , B. . 



         -               2017.                          ,      ,   ,    



 :

..  ( ),

..  ( ), .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. 



      <http://id.hse.ru (http://id.hse.ru/)>



In this monograph, the authors, who have many years of law-making, expert and academic experience, analyse the main issues of the practice of applying and amending the norms of the Administrative Offences Code of the Russian Federation (adopted in 2001) and the new version of it, for the purposes of implementing the third codification of administrative and tort law.

The most important areas of the reform of the system of the legislation concerning administrative offences of the Russian Federation and its constituent entities are substantiated. A theoretical justification is put forward of concepts of administrative liability and administrative and tort law. Contentious aspects of the relationship between administrative liability and criminal liability are considered, as are the existing models of the legislative regulation of public liability in foreign countries, while the genesis of the institution of minor crimes in the Russian law and legislation of the 19th and 20th centuries is also examined. The nature of existing models for the legal regulation of administrative liability in foreign countries is set out.

The monograph is intended for practising lawyers, parliamentarians, officials in federal and local government agencies, undergraduate and graduate students as well as professors of state law in law schools.







      ,      ,    ,   ,                (. 1 2   ),           .        - ,   ,        . ,       ,    ,       ,     ,     ,                      ,      . ,  ,              ,   ,   .  ,  ,   ,    ,          ,      .

      ,  ,      - .   ,   ,      (),  ,    ,        ,            .         ,  , . ,  ,      ,   ,       ,           ,     ,         ,       ,         ,        ,    .

          ,    ,      ,             ,      .  , ,   ,    ,     ,            ,    -     ,            .  ,  ()      ,                  ,        (  )         .                  ,        ,    , ,  ,  .

   .              ,           ,      ,  ,    ,    ()       . -         -          ,     ,              .

       ,    -          - ,       (    ) ,   ,    ,     ,           ,    - . , ,  ,              ,           -  ().

  -    ,    ,               ,   -    .  ,        ()        .   ,                 ,   .

    , ,      ()     ()  ,       ,  - ,           ,            .           -          , ,  .            ,                   (.  . 2.1),     .

    ,                 ,            (),     ()        . ,      ()   ,           ,  -    ,              ,        ,      .

                           ,   ,      - ,        ( ,              ,     ,  ).         ,     ,                  ,          - ,     ,          ,          .

           ,   ,     ,     .          ,          . ,          (. 3.13      )    .   ,        20  200,              ( . 2. 49           60  480),       .         ,          (    500. .;      1 .)        ,    . 2. 46        5.  5 .

   ,      ,                 .    ,  ,                    15   ,             4 .       . 3.9 ,                      , , ,          .

                    ,     (. 7.29, 11.33, 12.3, 13.19.2, 14.1.2  .).        () ,  . 1 . 3.3 (   5. .;     50. .).        (),  ,          ,  . 1 (. 1), 19 (. 1)  55 (. 3),   ,    ,           ,            ,   ,    ,         .

               .        ,        (,     ).   -   ,              ,       ,     ,  ,     -   ,   ,          . 15 (. 2)   ,      ,   ,  ,         .

              .            , ,         (. 48, 50, 120  .),  , ,                        . , ,                       - ,          .   ,            ,      . 1. 2        - ,     ,  ,    ,    (),       ,       .              ,     ,           ,     ,   ,        .

                (  )    ,      .       -      ,               ,  -  ,    ,    ,   ,      ,  ,       ,     ..           -          -           ()   .

 ,  ,           - ,       -   ,        ,       .         , ,     ,            ,   -                 , ,          .       ,                    .

              ,     . 2. 118       , ,           ,   ( ),                   ,      -, ..   -, .

    ,      ,             () ,             ,  ,         .             . ,  ,       ,  .                -           ,      ,      ,              ,      .



    ,

  , 

.. 




 I

    





1.     


                     II   , ,        18601870. : , , ,   ..

 ,      1861.      1864.    ,        .  ,          (,     ),               .

       - ,         ( )                 .

     ,       XIX.        -        ,   ,   .       ,              ,                      , , , , , , , , , , -, [1 -            ( )      .:  ..    . ., 1897;  .. - :    . ., 2015. .1751.].

     polis ().      -    [2 -     . .: , 2000. . 901.]           (politeia   ).   -         ,   , .. .                     -,   , .. [3 -  XIX   , ,     : . .       (.:  ..     : 4. . .  ..   ..      . .: -, 2003. . 3. . 216);  .    . . 11.].

                  ,        .

             , ,      ,      ,               .     ,     ,      ,              -     .

                       . ,  IVII.  ..       ()       ,    .           -,      ,              .       (  , , ,   .)     ,      ,       .                    ,                .

,            ,             (oicos[4 - .: http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/naTHHCKO-pyccKnfi (http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/naTHHCKO-pyccKnfi) .]).             ,        ,  ,   ,   .        ,                   (pater familias[5 -  .]).     ,              (, , , ),        [6 -  .   : 4. . III: . ., 2018. .4748.].

     ,                  -    .    (..      )      ()                .

,                            1860-      :     II  19  (3 ) 1861.          ,           22  1862.    .

                     (         ),             .               ,    .   100             1964., , ,        .

       XVIII   XIX.       .     (   )        - .   ,           ,   (, ).                .

               (    )       .               ()             ,  ,          -    .        ,      -    .          ,    ,    ,            ,          .

           ,      ,     ,     .     ,   ,    , ..     ,         .        ,       ,          -[7 -  .:  .    . .1112;  .. - :    . .2223.].

                  XVIXVII.   -            -  - .

   XVII.  XVIII.              ,                   ,    -         ,           ,          .

                   ,      ()         .             XVII   XVIII          .        (    ),      I:        1724. -  , -          .. .                 , ,     ,      .              ,            .

             .     XVII   XIX.  (.   , ..  , .. , .  , .  , . , .  , .  , .          )       , ..      ( ) ,      (),      ( ,   ..).   ( . , . , .   )     ,   .       ,             ,             .    camera   kameralien       . ,  ,     ,        , ,             .             .

, , ,             ,               ,     (    )        [8 -       ,    .:  .    . .1044;     :  /  . .. . ., 1988. .234258;  .. - :    . .2033.].

                  ,        ,   ,  ,   .   ,      ,      XIX.    (Polizeistaat)[9 -     ,        ,     . :  ..    :      XVIII . ., 1858;  .              . ., 1874;  .    ;  .   / . . ., 1982;     . .237258;  . . . . III. .44223  .].

             1718.  I.             .       ,  ,                    ,    ,      ,    ,  , ,  ,         (..        ).

,   1721.          ,       ,  ,   [10 -        ., .:  ..    ;    : . .    -   / . B.M. , .. , .. . ., 1981;  ..,  ..,  ..     (17181917.). ., 1992;  ..     // . 1992. 2. .8896;  ..   -     (18641879). . , 1999;  ..,  ..  : ,  . ., 2009. .110112;  .. - :    . .2024  .].  ,    1721  1775.                ,  ,  ,     ,         ,   [11 - .:  .    . .2122;  .. - :    . .2324.].

               .

,          -  (    )      XVII.      1649.,     XIX.    ,                .

 -    . IVII, IXX  XXIXXV .        - : . XXI      . XXII              ,    ( 26 ).         ,   . ,  . I      ,  . IV    ,  . V    (),  . XII   ,  . XXII  XXIV  ,   .             : . II  III       (    ,  ); . XXI     (   )  ..

   1649.         ,   ()                    ,    .         ,       .. ,     ,      [12 -  ..   1649.    // -  . 2010. 22. .2426.].

 180 ,              ,       1832. 15.,      1  1835. -    , XV ,    ,             - .        廠   11 ,    ,     ,    ,   10    .       .

 1  2             .                    ,       ,       ( ,   ,     ).  ,   1835.         -     .

  10               -          1845.    12 ,  1711        ,     .          1845. ,          1832.            ,         .   ,       , . 3    ,            .

 ,    1830-1840- ,       -   ,   -           ,            [13 -      -        .:  ..   - : ,    // - . . . 2013. 2 (7). .126135;  .          (     ) //.   . 2013. 7. .5357;  ..,  ..          // . . . . 2017. . 14. 4. .2026.].

              -      ,   , 1864.,     .    13 :    ,          150  ,            :

1)    ;

2)   ;

3)     ;

4)   ;

5)     ;

6)      ;

7)  ;

8)    ;

9)  ;

10)   ;

11)   ;

12)  .

             ,                            (    ) 1984.,          (    , ) 2001.

, , ,   1864.          .            25        1889.,  -       :

    ;

        ;

     ;

    ;

         ;

   ;

      ,  

  .

       -          ,      , 1899.    (         )                .         ,         1857.  ,              ,   ,       ,            (  ).            :

     1.;

     2 ;

   .

     

       - , ,         1845.   ,    1864.      ,           1810.[14 -  ..          criminal matter ( ) // . . 2013. 1. . 47.]

       ,     XIX                  ()     -         ,  ,  ,   (   )        [15 -           .:  .    ;  ..  . ., 1911;  ..     . , 1911;  .. - :    . .4151;  .       // -  . 2011. 12. .1214.].




2.   


  -              -     100 .                       [16 - .:  .           // .   . 2011. 2. .2729;  ..,  ..           // . . . 2012. 10. .99106;  ..       // .   . 2007. 1. .29;  ..      // , . 2007. 6. .97100;  ..       .4252;  ..    :  // . 2012. 2. .4953;  ..      ,         // - . . . 2013. 1 (6). .3745;  ..   - ;  .      ;  ..,  ..         :  . . . . ., 2017;  .. ,              // -  . 2000. 3. .6574;  ..        ? // .  .    :  V .  .  / . . .. . ., 2010. .721727;  .       XIX   XX . ., 2003  .].

                   ( ,    )       XIX      -      .

           1903.               -            XX.           .

      ,        ,   1903.              .       ,              :        ,     (   )   .

           .       ,  -       XIX.     II      .       XX.     -       黠 , , , ,    ..

        .    1903.                       .            (,      -   ). , ,    , -                  .                         1996.     (   ).

  ,                  -       () .  ,   ,         ,         ,  , ,  (       ),    -[17 -  ..  : 2. . . 1  1874, . 2  1876;  ..        II         . ., 1915;  .. , .;  .      . ., 1875;  .    . ., 1878;  .    . . 14. . . 1  1891, . 2  1893, .   1895, . 4  1896;  .      .].

,                 (..    )         XIX.                          -, -, -  .

   -      XIX       :

    ,      ;

     ,          ;

    ,  ,  , , , ;

      () ,    ;

        ()    ;

      .

    -      ,     ,     (-), ,    .. ..

   ,           XIX           ,         ,  ,    ,    ()    .  100               (.. )      ,  ,     ,      -  ,      [18 - ., .:  .    ;  .      .].

 ,               ,   - ,  (        )             -  .

          ,               (   ) 1922.       19221923.        (     )  1940-       ,       - .

 -                  ,           (   ).   - ,         ,             ,          .

,   XIX   XX.    -          ,    ,    ,  , ,    ..  ,                 .

                 ѻ           . ,              , ,     ;      , -, , ,    ..;     , , ,    ..      ,    , , ,        .

                 1903. (   )        -   .       ,    ,     (    )             1903.  ,    ,    20              ,              ,   [19 - ., .:  .. . . .4142.].   ,     ,      .

  ,    ,    ,      .         ,      ,              .               -     -    .

 ,                .      ,                 ,      .              ,           - ,    . .. [20 -  . .3745.].

   ,           .  ,          ,      . ..   , ,      1810.,             .  ,                      .    ,    ,         .    ,  ,          (    ).        - [21 - . :  ..       . 45.].

     ,  ,    ,   ,    - ,           XIX.          .        150-   ,                ,              (    ),        (      ).

                           ,       ,        .                    ,   . 19   .                ,           ,         .

 ,              ,     -  ,  .                   .   ,                            [22 -        . . V  .].

               , ,         ,         XIXXX.        [23 -             .:  ..   - ;  .       .5357;  ..,  ..          .2425.].

 ,                        (    ),            .

,       41  31  2017.[24 -    .]                     -          [25 -        .].

        ,           .            ,           .           ,    ,     ,   ,              ,  ,      .

   ,            ,            ,       ,        ,            - ,           .               - ,    , . .. [26 - .:  ..    :     //. 2018. 1. .132133.].

,      ,           :

  ()  ;

    ;

    ,    ;

    ;

        .

  ,      ,            ,   !

 ,            ,        80  ,         ,        2016.   40. .      ( 80    900      , ..  10%)          100   - .  ,           . 14  15    ,       80           .      -  (  )  ,                2002.    5. , -      .

,          ,   ,          ,       ,     80  ,        ,    :

    ;

  ()   ;

  ()   .

          80        .

                 ,                    1903.,              .  , ,   ,           ,     - ,   [27 - .:          [ ] //  : . 2017. 31 . URL: https://ria.ru/society/20171031/1507931968.html (https://ria.ru/society/20171031/1507931968.html).].      (  )  ,      ,                         - [28 - .:    :      [ ] // . Ru: . 2017. 31 . URL: https://pravo.ru/review/view/145516/ (https://pravo.ru/review/view/145516/).].

     ,  ,               [29 - .:  .      // . . 2017. 2. .5053.].    (   )      .        , ,     ,            ,  , ,    .        ,          19   ,     29  - ,   (   )  [30 - .:  .     //. . 2017. 4. . 23.].

  . .. ,             ,   ,         ,           ,     ,    ?[31 - .:  ..    :      . 132.].                20172025.[32 - .:  :   (20172025.): . . ., 2017. . 38.]

       ,        ,         (petty offense)    (fixed sum),                        .           ,         .

  ,                               .      100                XIX.,     -      ,      ,                   - .

                    ( ,  )     ,                 -        [33 - .    .. , ..   .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , ..   .].

    ,                 , ,   ,    - ,         .

 ,            ,   1993.   -      -    .    . 71  72    (    ),       -      ,    -        .

,      ,          ,           -   .  . 1. 72. ,   1994.,    ,     -           ,            .     ,       ,    ..,       71  72[34 - .:   .  /  . .. , .. , .. . ., 1994. . 364.].

             ,              .              (    )    (             )      ,        - ,      ,    ,            .

 ,          1920-         - ?        . ..  (             ),       , ,      .              ,           ,      .       (      )    [35 -  .. . . . 4445.].

         .         -         ,        .       ,           ,   -    ,   .

  ,    ,          (, ,           )           ,      . 71  72                    ,              ,                  ,   .

 ,                  ,      -     ,       (           ),    (  ), , -,        ,  -,           , ,  .      150-                    - [36 - .: Recommendation No. R (91) 1 of the Committee of Ministers to Member States on Administrative Sanctions / adopted by the Comm, of Ministers on 13 Febr. 1991 at the 452nd Meet, of the Ministers Deputies (=     13  1991.  452-   ) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://rm.coe.int/09000016804fc94c (https://rm.coe.int/09000016804fc94c); Directive 2010/73/EU, amending Directive 2003/71/EC on the prospectus to be published when securities are offered to the public or admitted to trading and 2004/109/EC on the harmonization of transparency requirements in relation to information about issues whose securities are admitted to trading on a regulated market [Electronic resource]. URL: http:/eur-lex.europe.eu/LexUriServ/ LexUriServ.do?uri=C)J:2010:327:0001:0012:EN: PDF; Moor-van VugtA., de. Administrative Sanctions in EU Law // Rev. of European Administrative Law. 2012. Vol. 5. No. 1. P.548.]!

 (   )                     -          ,             150 .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/kollektiv-avtorov/reforma-administrativnoy-otvetstvennosti-v-rossii/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


           ( )      .:  ..    . ., 1897;  .. - :    . ., 2015. .1751.




2


    . .: , 2000. . 901.




3


 XIX   , ,     : . .       (.:  ..     : 4. . .  ..   ..      . .: -, 2003. . 3. . 216);  .    . . 11.




4


.: http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/naTHHCKO-pyccKnfi (http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/naTHHCKO-pyccKnfi) .




5


 .




6


 .   : 4. . III: . ., 2018. .4748.




7


 .:  .    . .1112;  .. - :    . .2223.




8


      ,    .:  .    . .1044;     :  /  . .. . ., 1988. .234258;  .. - :    . .2033.




9


    ,        ,     . :  ..    :      XVIII . ., 1858;  .              . ., 1874;  .    ;  .   / . . ., 1982;     . .237258;  . . . . III. .44223  .




10


       ., .:  ..    ;    : . .    -   / . B.M. , .. , .. . ., 1981;  ..,  ..,  ..     (17181917.). ., 1992;  ..     // . 1992. 2. .8896;  ..   -     (18641879). . , 1999;  ..,  ..  : ,  . ., 2009. .110112;  .. - :    . .2024  .




11


.:  .    . .2122;  .. - :    . .2324.




12


 ..   1649.    // -  . 2010. 22. .2426.




13


     -        .:  ..   - : ,    // - . . . 2013. 2 (7). .126135;  .          (     ) //.   . 2013. 7. .5357;  ..,  ..          // . . . . 2017. . 14. 4. .2026.




14


 ..          criminal matter ( ) // . . 2013. 1. . 47.




15


          .:  .    ;  ..  . ., 1911;  ..     . , 1911;  .. - :    . .4151;  .       // -  . 2011. 12. .1214.




16


.:  .           // .   . 2011. 2. .2729;  ..,  ..           // . . . 2012. 10. .99106;  ..       // .   . 2007. 1. .29;  ..      // , . 2007. 6. .97100;  ..       .4252;  ..    :  // . 2012. 2. .4953;  ..      ,         // - . . . 2013. 1 (6). .3745;  ..   - ;  .      ;  ..,  ..         :  . . . . ., 2017;  .. ,              // -  . 2000. 3. .6574;  ..        ? // .  .    :  V .  .  / . . .. . ., 2010. .721727;  .       XIX   XX . ., 2003  .




17


 ..  : 2. . . 1  1874, . 2  1876;  ..        II         . ., 1915;  .. , .;  .      . ., 1875;  .    . ., 1878;  .    . . 14. . . 1  1891, . 2  1893, .   1895, . 4  1896;  .      .




18


., .:  .    ;  .      .




19


., .:  .. . . .4142.




20


 . .3745.




21


. :  ..       . 45.




22


       . . V  .




23


            .:  ..   - ;  .       .5357;  ..,  ..          .2425.




24


   .




25


       .




26


.:  ..    :     //. 2018. 1. .132133.




27


.:          [ ] //  : . 2017. 31 . URL: https://ria.ru/society/20171031/1507931968.html (https://ria.ru/society/20171031/1507931968.html).




28


.:    :      [ ] // . Ru: . 2017. 31 . URL: https://pravo.ru/review/view/145516/ (https://pravo.ru/review/view/145516/).




29


.:  .      // . . 2017. 2. .5053.




30


.:  .     //. . 2017. 4. . 23.




31


.:  ..    :      . 132.




32


.:  :   (20172025.): . . ., 2017. . 38.




33


.    .. , ..   .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , ..   .




34


.:   .  /  . .. , .. , .. . ., 1994. . 364.




35


 .. . . . 4445.




36


.: Recommendation No. R (91) 1 of the Committee of Ministers to Member States on Administrative Sanctions / adopted by the Comm, of Ministers on 13 Febr. 1991 at the 452nd Meet, of the Ministers Deputies (=     13  1991.  452-   ) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://rm.coe.int/09000016804fc94c (https://rm.coe.int/09000016804fc94c); Directive 2010/73/EU, amending Directive 2003/71/EC on the prospectus to be published when securities are offered to the public or admitted to trading and 2004/109/EC on the harmonization of transparency requirements in relation to information about issues whose securities are admitted to trading on a regulated market [Electronic resource]. URL: http:/eur-lex.europe.eu/LexUriServ/ LexUriServ.do?uri=C)J:2010:327:0001:0012:EN: PDF; Moor-van VugtA., de. Administrative Sanctions in EU Law // Rev. of European Administrative Law. 2012. Vol. 5. No. 1. P.548.


