   
  


  (-)
            ,         ,      .   ,     ,   ,  ,  ,   , - ,   -,            .





   



 -, 2000


* * *







         ,     ,         .

            .          .          .     ,     .              ,       .  ,           ,    ,       ,   .                  .  ,     ,           .

        ,        ,    ,          (     ,    ),      (,  ),         .

,      ,      ;  -   -      .        ,      ,       .

  XIX       ,           ,    -.                  .       :      ,  ,      ,          ,            .

                (    ). ,  ,    ,    .   .,   ,             .      (,   ..)     .   ,    ,                  .            ,             .

  , ,  . , . . , . ,  .             ,       .         ,      .       ,      ,         .  , ,          ,     .      ,  -,     ,      (-,    ) .

       . ,      .  1926           ,   .      ,    ,        .  ,        .    .            ,      ,          .  :       ,    ,   ,     .       ,     , ,     .     :   ,   ,        .     :      ,        ,            ,            .   :       .      :    ,      ,        .        ,   [1 - Freud S. Die Frage der Laienanalyse // G. W. XIV. S. 285.].

             , ,         ,      []  , ,   ,   셻

 ,                .   ,     ,        .

   :    ?, -,     :      ,       ?

, ,      20- .  ,   :      [] ,     ,    ,      ,  .    (    , 1926)     , ,   ,       : ,     ,       ,         ,     :    ,      ,     ,             .   ,      ,    ,        :  , ,    .      ,             ,      ,    [2 -  .].



                ,       -         (, , )  . ,  , , ,                  .       , ,    .              , ,      .      (  ,    ,    ),  , ,    ,           .      .       ,    .

,      ,              ,       .

                     .  , ,         .           .          ,      ,           ,   .  ,       ,    .               ,       (      ),         .        (,    ).           ,     .    , ,  -10,          .        ,    .  ,                . ,   -        .            ,                  .     ,     .. ,              . ,          ,    .

   ,   ,      ,            ,          .    ,         ,  ,    .        (          )       (        )  .. ,   ,       .          ,     .

        ,   ,          .           : -           ?         .   ,          ; ,               .

 ,    , ,   ,     ,        . ,        .

     ,   .   , , ,              , ,   ,     .             , ,  .    ,         ,       ,   [3 -  . .   //  . 1998. 1. . 27.].

 ,  ,               ,      , ,    .      ,           .        ,    ,         .        .    컠 , ,  .       ,   ,     ,     .                     .           .         ,         .      .              ,           ,   .             ,     .           ,     ,            ,             . ,               ,        .

        ,     ,       .      ,   .      ,   /   .       .       .         .     -    ;          ,         ,     .              .  ,         .

        :      , ,         ;        .

       ,             ,   .     ,  ,  ,     ,             .      ,        .     .

. . , . . , . . 




 

  





. . , . 

    





 :       ?


       ,         .     ?             (.    ).         ,            .     ,   ,   . ,    ,         ,       .

                     (. Kazdin, 1994);  ,        ,         (., , DSM-IIIR, 1987).       ,    ,          ,      ,      . ,          ,        .      ,           ,   , ,   ,         ,              .

        : -,      ,    ,   ,  ,   ; -,     ,              . ,    ;          ,       [4 - , ,  .].        ,                  .   . (Stiles, Shapiro, Elliott, 1986)         ,   ,   ,       .   ,      ,      .

       .             ;                      ;  ,               .             ,      . , ,     ,            ,  ,      (SASB)   (Benjamin, 1974)  ,        .  ,   ,   ,   ;      ,  ,     .




     


            (       ),             .               - ?     ?       ?

            (. K?chele, 1992; K?chele, Strauss, 1998).      , ,        ,      -     -   .         ,      ,             .

  ,    ,   ,   ,      .  XIX       ,       .                 ;            . .  (Spence, 1993)       ,      , -:        ,   ;         ,    ,  , ,       ;         ,        -     ,  ..              ,           (single case study).            ,         ,         .   ,    ?           ,    ,  :

1)                  , ,   ..;

2)         ,             ;

3)         ,   ;

4)       ,        ;

5)        ,        ,       .

  ,          ,    1930-         , ,    19501970- .         (Fenichel, 1930),          ;         (Jones, 1936)   (  : Alexander, 1937) .                ,    ..  1952      .  (Eysenck, 1952),          ,         ,        .                 ,  67% (   ) ,   ,         ,         (, ),        .                 ,     ,      .

      ;            ,  ,       ,    ,     ,     ,   ,       ,       ,       ,   .        .  (Bergin, 1971).

      .  (Rogers, 1957), ,  ,           .           .      ,        ;        Q-,      , ,         .

             .              .

         1950-   ,              ;         .  (Wallerstein, 1986)[5 -           ,   ;          ,    (.  , 1997).].        ,      :    ,  ,              ,       ,      .   ,    ,     ,        (Wallerstein et al., 1956).

         ,      ,    ,         (    ),                 ,      . 22    , 20    ,  22       -   ,      (        ).         ,            ,         (  )  .

       (Kernberg et al., 1972)   (Wallerstein, 1986);  ,              ,    ;           ,         :     .           :   ,           ,   ,           .

          ,          : ,  ,   ,      ,            .

           ,          ,         ,    .     , .   1968          ,         (Luborsky et al., 1988).           .   73 ,    -  (  8  264 ),       .

      :   :

)   (  HSRS),

) ,

),

)    .

       ,                  .        :

1)  ,      , ;

2)      ,                  ,   ,    ,      ;

3)       ,    (.  1).



 1

        






       ,     , ,  ,   ,        , , ,     .

, ,       ;   ,             ,     .            (Luborsky, Schimek, 1964):

1)   ;

2)    ;

3)  ;

4)   ;

5)      ;

6)         ;

7)   ;

8)   ,    .

               [6 - CCRT  Central Core Conflictual Theme;       .:  . .           //  . 1994. 2.].  ,              ,        .          .                     .

     70-   ,   ,           ;                (Luborsky, Schimek, 1964),   (Horowitz, 1979),   (Dahl, 1988)  .        ,           (Weiss, Sampson, 1986),      (Gill, Hoffman, 1982).  ,       ; , ,  .  (Krause, 1988; Krause, Luetolf, 1988)                 -.       -    (Flader et al., 1982),          ,               .




  



  

        ,      ,        ,    .    ,       .  ,                 , ,   ,   ,    ,   ,     (Bergin, Garfield, 1994).            ,          .  , ,     ,      .                .         ,           ,   ,          .


    

   ,  ,  ,    ,  ,       (   ).    ,     (Eysenck, 1952)   1952            .       ,          .  ,       , ,   ,         ,     ,  ,     .       ,     .      ,      ,   ,    ,   ,          ,   .    , , ,       40%   (Bergin, Lambert, 1978).   ,    . (Howard et al., 1986)     ,         2431 ,      ,    ,      ,  ,    .

     ,   ,  ,    ,      ,    ,  ,  ,    .     , , ,     . ,     ,           . ,    (Nicholson, Berman, 1983)           ,        ,       ;         .






.1.         ( ),    (         ;         ).



 ,   ,    ,      .                       ,     -  ,     .          :  ,    ,      ,       , , -   .        ,       (    ,  ,        ,  ,   ).      ,       ,        .      ,             (Bergin, Lambert, 1978; Beutler, 1979; Goldstein, Stein, 1976; Kellner, 1975; Rachman, Wilson, 1980; Luborsky, Singer, Luborsky, 1975; Shapiro, Shapiro, 1982; Nicholson, Berman, 1983).

,      (Shapiro, Firth, 1987) -  (    ),       ,      ,    (  ),   .     ,      .      ,            (   )    ,          .         ,      ,        .        ,   ,     ,   30    7      .

          ,          .   - ,      ,  , , ,            ,      ,     .    :        - ,   ,       .

                      ;        :

1.       .

2.      , , ,     .

3.          ,    ,              .

            ,   ; ,      ,    ,    .      :   ,   ,  ,   ,      .              ,        (Rogers, 1957): ,  ,     .     ,                     .    (Lambert, Bergin, 1994)     ,      , , ,     :








       ,             , ,    .  (Strupp, 1980a, 1980b, 1980c, 1980d)     ,               ,       ,        .                    .         (),   , ,  .  ,    ,     ,          .     (    ) ,   ,               ,                 .

              ,        ,  .     ,    , , ,       .  ,                  .       (Luborsky et al., 1979),    (Cross, Sheehan, 1982),    (Morris, Suckerman, 1974a, 1974b, 1975)    .

              ,                 .    ,   ,      ;  ,     ; ,       -        ,  ,              ..

         ,       ,      :

1.           ,        ,    .    ,            .

2. ,  ,   ;   , , ,  ,      ;   ,    ,     .    ,          ,      .

3.          ,     : -               ,       .            ,          .

4.  ,             ,        . ,   ,                    .   ,           ,        .

5.,    ,      , -,       .        ,      , ,  ,  ,                   , ,  .         ,     ,           .

6., ,    ,               ;         ,    .  ,               .   ,             ,      ,      .




   


                    :  / ;  ;  ;   ,  ,   (. Lambert, Hill, 1994).               (,   ).        . ,     , ,  ,              .

    : , ,  ;       ,     , , ,     .    ,        ,       .       ,       ,    ,        .

 (Elliott, 1991)      :  (  );  (     ,   ..,     ); / (  , , ,   ..);  (     ).

         -,   .      ,          . ,       Q-,        ,    .  ,     ,        -   ;          :            ,         (Strupp, Schacht, Henry, 1988, p. 7).

                  (Greenberg, Pinsof, 1986),  (Kiesler, 1973),  (Russell, 1987).         ,        .     .         (SASB  Structural Analysis of Social Behavior, 1974),               .

        ,  .        .  (Kiesler, 1983).   ,        ,         (-)    (-). .                :         ( ),         ( ),       ( ).

 ,    ,   . .  (Sullivan, 1953).    ,       ,             .             .             ,             .            .

          ,          (    )    :  (),  ()   .      ,      ()   () ,        ,        : , ,          ,                  .     (),   ,         ,         ,   ..

     ,  ,          ,     -  .           .               ;         ,           ,   : ,              ?

     ,          .          ,         ,      .                         .     ,  ,            .  ,             ,  ,     .

          . ,   ,    (Henry, Schacht, Strupp, 1986)  ,      ,         ,        . ,       ,     .                       ?  ; ,   ,                 . ,           ,        ,      ( ,  ),    .

      ( ,   ,        )             .                   , ,   .   ,  ,           ,  ;         (. Henry et al., 1990).

      ,   ,    .  (Henry, 1996):         ,              .        ,                         .

 ,           ,             ,  , .       -          ,     .       ,    ,          .







Alexander F. (1937) Five year report of the Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis, 19321937. Chicago, Institute of Psychoanalysis.

Benjamin L. S. (1974) Structural analysis of social behavior // Psychological Review. 81, 392425.

Bergin A. (1971) The evaluation of therapeutic outcomes // Garfield S. L., Bergin A. E. (Eds.). Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change. N. Y.: Wiley, 217270.

Bergin A. E., Lambert M. I. (1978) The evaluation of therapeutic outcomes // Garfield S. L., Bergin A. E. (Eds.). Handbook of psychotherapy and behaviour change: An Empirical Analysis. 2nd ed. N. Y.: Wiley.

Bergin A. E., Garfield S. L. (Eds.) (1994) Handbook of psychotherapy and behaviour change. 4th ed. N. Y.: Wiley.

Beutler L. E. (1979) Toward specific psychological therapies for specific conditions // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 47, 882892.

Cross D. G., Sheehan P. W. (1982) Secondary therapist variables operationg in short-term insight-oriented and behavior therapy // British J. of Medical Psychology. 55, 275284.

Dahl H. (1988) Frames of mind // Dahl H., K?chele H., Thom? H. (Eds.) Psychoanalytic process research strategies. N. Y., 5166.

Dahl H., K?chele H., Thom? H. (Eds.) (1988) Psychoanalytic process research strategies. N. Y.

Elliott R. (1991) Five dimensions of therapy process // Psychotherapy Research. 1, 92103.

Eysenk H. (1952) The effects of psychotherapy: an evaluation // J. Consult. Psychology. 16, 319324.

Fenichel O. (1930) Statistischer Bericht ?ber die therapeutische T?tigkeit 19201930 // Rado S., Fenichel O., M?ller-Braunschweig C. (Hg.) Zehn Jahre Berliner Psychoanalytisches Institut, Poliklinik und Lehranstalt. Wien: Int. Psa. Verl., 1319.

Flader D., Grodzicki W. D., Schr?ter K. (1982) Psychoanalyse als Gespr?ch: Interaktionsanalytische Untersuchungen ?ber Therapie und Supervision. Frankfurt/M, Suhrkamp.

Gill M. M., Hoffman I. S. (1982) Analysis of transference. Vol. II. Studies of nine audio-recorded psychoanalytic sessions. N. Y.: Intern. Univ. Press.

Goldstein A. P., Stein N. (1976) Prescriptive psychotherapies. N. Y.: Pergamon.

Greenberg L., Pinsof W. (Eds.) (1986) The psychotherapeutic process: A research handbook. N. Y.: Guilford.

Henry W. P. (1996) Structural Analysis of Social Behaviour as a Common Metric for Programmatic Psychopathology and Psychotherapy Research // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 64, 6, 12631275.

Henry W. P., Schacht T. E., Strupp H. H. (1990) Patient and therapist introject, interpersonal process and differential psychotherapy outcome // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 58, 768774.

Henry W. P., Schacht T. E., Strupp H. H. (1986) Structural Analysis of Social Behavior: Application to a study of interpersonal process in differential psychotherapeutic outcome // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 54, 2731.

Horowitz M. Z. (1979) States of mind: Analysis of change in psychotherapy. New York/London.

Howard H. I., Kopte S. M., Krause M. S., Orlinsky D. E. (1986) The dose-effect relationship in psychotherapy // American Psychologist. 41, 159164.

Jones E. (1936) Report of the Clinic Work. London Clinic of Psychoanalysis.

K?chele H. (1992) Psychoanalytische Psychotherapieforschung // Psyche. 46, 3, 259285.

K?chele H., Strauss B. M. (1998) Approaches and Methods in Psychotherapy Research or Do we need Empirically Validated / Supported Treatments. Motevideo.

Kazdin A. (1994) Methodology, design, and evaluation in psychotherapy research // Bergin A., Garfield S. (Eds.) Handbook of psychotherapy and behaviour change, 4th ed. N. Y.: Wiley, 1971.

Kellner R. (1975) Psychotherapy in psychosomatic disorders: A survey of controlled outcome studies // Archives of General Psychiatry. 35, 10211028.

Kernberg O. F., Bursteine E. D., Coyne L., Appelbaum A., Horwitz L., Voth H. (1972) Psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. Final report of the Menninger Foundation // Bull. Menninger Clin. 36, 3275.

Kiesler D. (1973) The process of psychotherapy. Chicago: Aldine.

Kiesler D. (1983) The interpersonal circle: A taxonomy for complementarity in human transactions // Psychol. Rev. 90, 3, 185214.

Krause R. (1988) Eine Taxonomie der Affekte und ihre Anwendung auf das Verst?ndnis der fr?hen St?rungen // Psychotherapy and Medical Psychology. 38, 7786.

Krause R., Luetolf P. (1988) Facial Indicators of transference processes within psychoanalytic treatment // Dahl H., K?chele H., Thom? H. (Eds.) Psychoanalytic process research strategies. N. Y., 241256.

Lambert M., Bergin A. (1994) The effectiveness of psychotherapy // Bergin A., Garfield S. (Eds.) Handbook of psychotherapy and behaviour change. 4th ed. N. Y.: Wiley, 143189.

Lambert M., Hill C. (1994) Assessing psychotherapy outcomes and processes // Bergin A., Garfield S. (Eds.) Handbook of psychotherapy and behaviour change. 4th ed. N. Y.: Wiley, 72113.

Luborsky L., Bachrach H., Graff H., Pulver S., Christoph P. (1979) Preconditions and consequences of transference interpretations: A clinical-quantitative investigation // J. of Nervous and Mental Disease. 167, 391401.

Luborsky L., Schimek J. (1964) Psychoanalytic theories of therapeutic and developmental change: implications for assessment // Worche P., Byrne T. (Eds.) Personality change. N. Y.: Wiley.

Luborsky L., Singer B., Luborsky L., (1975) Comparative studies of psychotherapy // Archives of General Psychiatry. 32, 9951008.

Luborsky L., Crits-Christoph P., Mintz J., Auerbach A. (1988) Who Will Benefit From Psychotherapy. N. Y.: Basic Books.

Morris R. J., Suckerman K. R. (1975) Morris and Suckerman reply // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 43, 585586.

Morris R. J., Suckerman K. R. (1974) The importance of therapeutic relationships in systematic desensitization // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 42, 148.

Morris R. J., Suckerman K. R. (1974) Therapist warmth as a factor in automated systematic desensitization // J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 42, 244250.

Nicholson R. A., Berman J. S. (1983) Is follow-up necessary in evaluating psychotherapy? // Psychological Bulletin. 93, 261278.

Rachman S., Wilson G. T. (1980) The effect of psychological therapy: Second enlarged edition. N. Y.: Pergamon.




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/raznoe/osnovnye-napravleniya-sovremennoy-psihoterapii/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Freud S. Die Frage der Laienanalyse // G. W. XIV. S. 285.




2


 .




3


 . .   //  . 1998. 1. . 27.




4


, ,  .




5


          ,   ;          ,    (.  , 1997).




6


CCRT  Central Core Conflictual Theme;       .:  . .           //  . 1994. 2.


