    
  

  


             ,      .      ,     .  ,   ,      ,   ,     .     ,  ,  ,    ,   ,    ,        ,    .





 ,  

    





 . . , . . , 2018

   (.), 2018







     


             ,      .      ,     .  ,   ,      ,   ,     .        ?                :             .                 ,           ?  .             1)        ,           2)      , ,    , ,   .

           ,           . ,     ,  /  ,            .      ,        ,                .     ,              .

       ?  ,         ,      ,   .       .        ,   ,   ,  .  ,       ,       ,    (  ,  ,     ).

           , ,  ,      .     ,      ,   ,       .     ,     ,                 ,    ,    ,       , ,    ,    .   ,                    , ,   ,    ,         ,  ,     ,        .        ,         1)         2)  ,   ,      .

  ,           ,   .     ?        ?

        (      )  ,  ,   ,         ,        ,            .       ,     ,    -  - ,         ,   ,   ,   ,     ,     .

    ,  ,  ,    ,   ,    ,        ,    .

           ( ,       )     (, , ,    ⻠ ,      ,    )      (,           ),          .         ,           .   ,    ,     -         .

  .        ,     ,        ,        .



        ,     ,     ,        : 1)   2)  ,   ,    . ,           ,  , , , .    .           .              , ,     , , .        ,      .




 1. ,          


   ,   , ,    ,   :        ,   1)   [1 - Trump, fascism, and the construction of the people. An interview with Judith Butler by Christian Salmon, 29 December 2016, http://www. versobooks.com/blogs/3025-trump-fascism-and-the-construction-of-the-people-an-interview-with-judith-butler]  2)           ,          .[2 - Butler Judith. Foreword // Lorey Isabel. State of Insecurity: Government of the Precarious / Translated by Aileen Derieg. With a Foreword by Judith Butler. London, New York: Verso, 2015, p. ix.]      1)    ,        ,       2)   (   ) ,[3 - Trump, fascism, and the construction of the people. An interview with Judith Butler by Christian Salmon, 29 December 2016.]                  .[4 - Ibid.]

         ,   ,  ,   ,  軠   ,     .[5 - Butler Judith. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? London&New York: Verso, 2009, p. 33.]    ,  ,   ,       /,        ,    .      ,                   .[6 - Ibid., p. 3.]         , ,        .[7 - Ibid., p. 48.]

        ,            ,        ,  ,      ,     ,[8 - Trump, fascism, and the construction of the people. An interview with Judith Butler by Christian Salmon, 29 December 2016]      . ,      ,       ,             .

   (  )   (  ,   )              (    [9 - Butler Judith. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? p. 3.]).   ,    ,               ,  /   /,       ,   ,        .[10 - Butler Judith. Rethinking Vulnerability and Resistance // Vulnerability in Resistance, Judith Butler, Zeynep Gambetti, and Leticia Sabsay, eds. Durham and London: Duke University Press, 2016, p. 24.]   ,  ,     -,       ,  [11 - Ibid.]     ,   .          , ,   ,       ;[12 - Ibid., p. 14.]            ;[13 - Butler Judith and Athanasiou Athena. Dispossession: The Performative in the Political. Cambridge, Malden: Polity Press, 2013, p. xi.]        [14 - ., , Butler Judith. The Desire to Live Spinozas Ethics under Pressure // Butler Judith. Senses of the Subject. New York: Fordham University Press, 2015, p.7071.]  ..).



       ,           ,        ,   ,       .[15 - Antigones Claim. A Conversation With Judith Butler Pierpaolo Antonello and Roberto Farneti, September 2008, https://www.academia. edu/217727/Antigone_s_claim._A_conversation_with_Judith_Butler.]          ,   ,[16 - Butler Judith. Can the Other of Philosophy Speak? // Butler Judith. Undoing Gender. New York, London: Routledge, 2004, p. 235.] ,    ,     .

?

 ,   ,     ,    ,  (    ,    ,   ).         ,     .       ,     ,     ,  .     ,  ,    ,       .          ,   ,          .[17 - Ibid., p. 236.]     ,      ,  /       ,      ,         (   .., ..).[18 - Ibid.]  ,      /,    ,  . ,     ,   ,   ,       .[19 - Ibid.]     ,      ,     ,    .  ,      , ,   ,       .[20 - Ibid., p.236237.]



       ,  ,    ,     ,             .    ,    ,      -,        ,[21 - Ibid.]     .   ,                     .  ,           :          ,   ,       ?.[22 - Ibid.]

                  ,       .       ,    .[23 - Ibid., p. 239.]

       ,    ?

 ,          , :           ,                  .[24 - Ibid.]

      ,           ,  ,     ,    ,     ,        ,   ,       , , .

                .               ,         :      . (1987).[25 - Butler Judith. Subjects of Desire: Hegelian Reflections in Twentieth-Century France. New York, Columbia University Press, 1987.] ,      ,      ,  .             ,  ,   ,  ,  ,        .



             .      ,  - ,          ,       . ,  ,     ,               ,           ,   ,[26 - Butler Judith. Can the Other of Philosophy Speak? p. 236.]      (     ).       ,  :          conatus          .      . ,      ,     .[27 - Ibid., p. 235.]  :       ,          ,  ,            .         ,      ,      ,   ,   ,        ,    .[28 - Ibid.]     ,      ,      ,        :      ,       ,     ,   .[29 - Ibid., p.235236.]

                 ,       1)              2)         ,    .[30 -  .    / .   //  , - .    , 17, 2012, . 177.]  ,     ,      .  ,    ,     ,  ,     ,   . ,   ,   :              ,    .[31 -  , . 176.]

            .    ,       ,      .      ,    ,     .  , ,   ,    ,  , ,   ,  ,     , ,  ,        ,    .[32 - Butler Judith. Can the Other of Philosophy Speak? p. 240.]   :         .       ,   []      .[33 - Ibid.]    : ,    ,     ,  -       ,      .   ,      ,  ,         ,     ,     .[34 - Ibid., p.240241.]

                ,        ,    ,        .   ,  ,        ,  ,        . , ,  ,         ,  ,                 .[35 - Ibid., p. 250.]

            ,         ,  ?



            (1993).[36 - Butler Judith. Kierkegaards Speculative Despair // Butler Judith. Senses of the Subject, p.112148.]

,  ,           ,         , ,   ,      .   ,   ,    ,   ,      /.  , ,   ,    ,            ,      ,     ,   ,     :   .[37 - Ibid., p. 114.]

 ,  ,      ,      ,     ,   .  , ,    ,              .         ,          .

  ,     ,       ,    ,             ,    .    , ,     ,        ;  ,              .       ,    18481849         ,      .



 ,   ,    ,          .       ,  1)      2)    .      ,   .  .  ,         ,        ,   - .

    ,  ,   .         .          ,       ,      ,    ?[38 - Ibid.]   ,   ,   ,   ,  .   ,    Aufhebung,     ,             ,    ,    ? ,       ,     , ,    (  ,     )      .  - ,  ,          .

  , , ,  ,      ,   .         .    ,   , ,   ,  .    ,   ,  ,   ,      . ,  ,     ,         .      ,   ,     ,        ,    Aufhebung.  , ,  ,  ,          ,    .[39 - Ibid., p.115116.]

  ,   ,       .  ,  ,         .       .  ,       .           ,     ,  .[40 - Ibid.]

         Aufhebung,      ,     ,          ,    ,        ,              , ..  ,    .     ,  , ,     ,         ,        ?[41 - Ibid., p. 136137.]



       ,   ,    ,            .        ,   (1993),      , ,   ,   1)  ( ,   ;             )  2)  ().    ,       ,    ,     , ,  , ,         ( )   .         ,       ;     ;           .[42 - Butler Judith. Bodies that Matter // Butler Judith. Bodies that Matter: on the Discursive Limits of Sex. New York, London: Routledge, 1993, 288 p. 43.] ,  ,      ,   ,   ,  ,         .[43 - Ibid.]

   ,  ,                         ?,          11 ,        ,         .



        ,            ,          ,   .             ,    ,   . - (      [44 - . - .    / . . . . .: , 2006.]),             .   , -,   ,        ,       ,           ,       ?   .[45 - Butler Judith. Sexual Difference as a Question of Ethics: Alterities of the Flesh in Irigaray and Merleau-Ponty // Butler Judith. Senses of the Subject, p. 161.] ,     -,  ,        ?,    .[46 - Ibid.]  ,       ,  ,     ,     . ,      ,      ,     ( ,  ,   ,  )              .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/irina-zherebkina/voyna-i-mir-dzhudit-batler/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Trump, fascism, and the construction of the people. An interview with Judith Butler by Christian Salmon, 29 December 2016, http://www. versobooks.com/blogs/3025-trump-fascism-and-the-construction-of-the-people-an-interview-with-judith-butler




2


Butler Judith. Foreword // Lorey Isabel. State of Insecurity: Government of the Precarious / Translated by Aileen Derieg. With a Foreword by Judith Butler. London, New York: Verso, 2015, p. ix.




3


Trump, fascism, and the construction of the people. An interview with Judith Butler by Christian Salmon, 29 December 2016.




4


Ibid.




5


Butler Judith. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? London&New York: Verso, 2009, p. 33.




6


Ibid., p. 3.




7


Ibid., p. 48.




8


Trump, fascism, and the construction of the people. An interview with Judith Butler by Christian Salmon, 29 December 2016




9


Butler Judith. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? p. 3.




10


Butler Judith. Rethinking Vulnerability and Resistance // Vulnerability in Resistance, Judith Butler, Zeynep Gambetti, and Leticia Sabsay, eds. Durham and London: Duke University Press, 2016, p. 24.




11


Ibid.




12


Ibid., p. 14.




13


Butler Judith and Athanasiou Athena. Dispossession: The Performative in the Political. Cambridge, Malden: Polity Press, 2013, p. xi.




14


., , Butler Judith. The Desire to Live Spinozas Ethics under Pressure // Butler Judith. Senses of the Subject. New York: Fordham University Press, 2015, p.7071.




15


Antigones Claim. A Conversation With Judith Butler Pierpaolo Antonello and Roberto Farneti, September 2008, https://www.academia. edu/217727/Antigone_s_claim._A_conversation_with_Judith_Butler.




16


Butler Judith. Can the Other of Philosophy Speak? // Butler Judith. Undoing Gender. New York, London: Routledge, 2004, p. 235.




17


Ibid., p. 236.




18


Ibid.




19


Ibid.




20


Ibid., p.236237.




21


Ibid.




22


Ibid.




23


Ibid., p. 239.




24


Ibid.




25


Butler Judith. Subjects of Desire: Hegelian Reflections in Twentieth-Century France. New York, Columbia University Press, 1987.




26


Butler Judith. Can the Other of Philosophy Speak? p. 236.




27


Ibid., p. 235.




28


Ibid.




29


Ibid., p.235236.




30


 .    / .   //  , - .    , 17, 2012, . 177.




31


 , . 176.




32


Butler Judith. Can the Other of Philosophy Speak? p. 240.




33


Ibid.




34


Ibid., p.240241.




35


Ibid., p. 250.




36


Butler Judith. Kierkegaards Speculative Despair // Butler Judith. Senses of the Subject, p.112148.




37


Ibid., p. 114.




38


Ibid.




39


Ibid., p.115116.




40


Ibid.




41


Ibid., p. 136137.




42


Butler Judith. Bodies that Matter // Butler Judith. Bodies that Matter: on the Discursive Limits of Sex. New York, London: Routledge, 1993, 288 p. 43.




43


Ibid.




44


. - .    / . . . . .: , 2006.




45


Butler Judith. Sexual Difference as a Question of Ethics: Alterities of the Flesh in Irigaray and Merleau-Ponty // Butler Judith. Senses of the Subject, p. 161.




46


Ibid.


