  
 


   ,             ,    .

     ?  2014  ,        BICEP2, ,   ,   .         -   ,        .         ,     ,    ?

 㠖         BICEP    ,     BICEP2,     .               ࠖ  -   ,    ,    ,      ,   .              .   ,   ,      ,   ,       ,          .

    ,          ?  ,     -    .





 

  :   ,     



  

   , - . . 

  

  . 

 . , . 

  . 

- . 

    Christopher Michel   SSPL/Getty Images



 Brian Keating, 2018

    , , .   -, 2019


* * *


  .           () .  ,  ,   ,  ,   ,          .  ,   ,     ,  ,          ,      ,   ,       .

,      ,  ,   ,        () ,        ,    .


  ,    ,  ,    


         (   .. ).








  ,      (www.traektoriafdn.ru (http://www.traektoriafdn.ru/))   2015 .           ,   ,       ,      ,    ,     .     -    ,          .

             - .






 



  10      ,    ,        .    ,    .    ,       .     ,         ,     .      ,      .

 䠖       ,   ,       .       ,  ,  ,   .  ,  ,   ,         PR-   .

        ,       .    ,   ,        ,           .    ,      .           ,        , ,      ,       .

-  : ,          ,   ,         ,        頖      ?   ,    ,    ,  . ,        . ,   ,           . ,           .      :     ࠖ  ?

               .             ,         ,           .   30       .   ,   ,       .       .   ,       ,          . ,          ,     ,       .

      ,         :      .      ࠖ   ,      ,    ,    ,    .      ࠖ  ,      ,         .


,  1864 

    .   ,        .      ,   : ,   .         .    Nobel & Sons         ,       젖    ,     . ,           ?  ,         ,       ,   .

      :    ,     . ,         ,      . ,        Nobel & Sons,        ,  .

   .          .  ,  ,    ,   .           .    XIX      ,      ;       .

    .     ,  ,    ,      ?   ,    ,      .          :     ,   ,           .         .     ? ,      ,      ,    ?   ,        !           ,   ,      ,         . ,      頖     ,    .


* * *

 ,   30   ,    .      .  ,          .      .


* * *

       .    .  ,         .                  :         ,   .

             .   ,          (, ,    ),   .   ,       ,       . (            15-                  ,     A&P.  ,     .)

 355                 .               (   ,        ,    ?).     ,   젖  ,    (      ,             ).         ,     .           (,   ).  ,     ,    .    ,      :  ,     !    ,       .  ,     ,         .

 1867 ,       ,       ,     (    ).       , ,    :             ,       ,  ,    Nobel & Sons   !          ,       .




 


         .    ,       ,        (     ).      ,   ,      ,   . ,  1888 ,   ,           Le marchand de la mort est mort   .   .     ,           . ,    ;       ,     .          , ,  ,      .     ,     ,          .

  ,     .            ,   :  ,       ,          .      ,     .   ,           .

   -      ,  1895 .      ,  ,   .        .              .       堖     :



             ,         .      ,         ,                 ,  :   ,          [1 - .     : https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/will/ (https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/will/).]



* * *




,      


13 2015 ,        2015 ,               -         . ,        ,     ,   ,        .     ,             [2 -   -        2016 ,       ,        ,      .        .   ,          ,  ,      ,   ,       .].



  

      ,     ,         

     2016 .

,  2015 

 ,




      .       .          :       ,    ,     .    ,         , ,   ,  ,    ?        ?    ,       .        .

       15   ,     . ,         30 ,       :  ,     .      ,    1959 :         :   ,  頖 [3 -   .       , , , 12  1959.      : https://www.jfklibrary.org/Research/Research-Aids/JFK-Speeches/Indianapolis-IN_19590412.aspx (https://www.jfklibrary.org/Research/Research-Aids/JFK-Speeches/Indianapolis-IN_19590412.aspx).].            ,  ,           .   ,    ࠖ       .

    .           .  ,        , ,         [4 -           . .: Magdalena Eriksson, A Great Prize Ages with Grace, Science and Technology Perspective 80, no. 4 (2002): 6264.  ,     ,        .].

    ,  ,        .  ,      ,    .   ,             .        ?      ,   ,    ,   ,      .

  ?      ,   2015 ,     ?        ? ,     ,   ,      ,            ?[5 -              ,       (   1948.)   .]         , ,   ,     ,     .   :   蠖 堖   - ,           ?


* * *

8 1895          .          ,  ,      .       ,  ,       .    ,  ,       ,     .        -          15 .        . , ,  -   ,  : ,    !  ,     ,          .

     堖       ,    ,  ,       .           [6 -  (. serendipity)  ()         .       ,      ,    . . .]  .          ,        ⠖ -,  ,     . ,         .

       ,    114 ,     ,         ,   .    ,    , ,  ,    ,               .        ,     ,     ,  .      .   :       -    ,    ?

       .       .   ;     .     ,      .      ,     ,     ,    ,    .

       .     5- , ,    ,                  ,         .

     .    ,      .  ,             ,    , ,  ,       .   ,         -.

     ,           .          ,  ,  , , ,    堖      ,       ,  ,  ,   ,    .

         :     ࠖ    1905   䠖        .  ,      (        ).  , ,    100         ,      .          1963 .

      .           1918   ,        [7 - Daniel Charles, Between Genius and Genocide: The Tragedy of Fritz Haber, Father of Chemical Warfare (London: Pimlico, 2006).].  1949                     ,            .    ,    ,   ;               .            ,    ?

  ,      ,      1973       ,   1994     ,           ,    .           ,     2012  ,     ,     ,    [8 - Associated Press, Desmond Tutu, 2 other Nobel Peace Prize laureates contest 2012 winner choice of EU, Fox News, November 30, 2012, http://www.foxnews.com/world/2012/11/30/desmond-tutu-2-other-nobelpeace-prize-laureates-contest-2012-winner-choice-eu.html (http://www.foxnews.com/world/2012/11/30/desmond-tutu-2-other-nobelpeace-prize-laureates-contest-2012-winner-choice-eu.html)].     ,   2016     ,   [9 - Valerie Richardson, Critics mock Nobel committee for handing literature prize to Bob Dylan, Washington Times, October 13, 2016, http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/oct/13/bob-dylans-nobel-prize-sets-off-literature-debate/ (http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/oct/13/bob-dylans-nobel-prize-sets-off-literature-debate/)].

   ,             ,     .   ,      ,         ,  ,   ,  .  ,      ,    .

,     (5-, 10-  13-頖       )              :  ,    .   ,    ,    ,     . ,  16-  (   )                    ,      ,     .                (  ,    ,      ,    ).

      .    ,      ,     . ,     ,     .    ,      .           ,        IPO  .      .   ,          ,      堖      ø-[10 -      : https://spie.org/Documents/resources/Free%20Posters/copyright%20posters/Mayer-poster-delivery.pdf (https://spie.org/Documents/resources/Free%20Posters/copyrigh%20tposters/Mayer-poster-delivery.pdf).].        .      :  ,  ,     .  ,           ,   , ,   ,   ,    [11 -  : Peter Doherty, The Beginners Guide to Winning the Nobel Prize: Advice for Young Scientists (New York: Columbia University Press, 2006); David Carter, How to Win the Nobel Prize in Literature (London: Hesperus Press, 2012); Tony Goldsmith, How to Win a Nobel Prize (independently published, 2017).].     , ,     ,    .   Christies     400 000  4,75 [12 - Rebecca Hersher, How Much Is a Nobel Prize Medal Worth? The Two-Way: Breaking News from NPR, October 16, 2016, http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/10/16/498146211/how-much-is-a-nobelprize-medal-worth (http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/10/16/498146211/how-much-is-a-nobelprize-medal-worth).].

      1901       . , ,             1 ,  18-         . , ,   ,    ,  :     .        ,    ?

  ,     ,    ,  .      ,         ,       .  ,            ,   .   ,   causa sui ( ),  : ,  ,    ,    ,  ,    .     .   .   .


* * *

       :     ,     .  ,   ,   ,    .   ,  -     ,          .




 1

 


,      ,       :  ?  ?  ?  ?

,   11, 450  ..

 ,          ,     .  ,       .      , ,     ,   .     -,        V.           ,     ,    ,    ,   ,   :       ?

   ,     ,     ,        ? ,     ,    ,      ,          ,           .            ,     -. ,        , ,       ,  , ,      .     ,      .

 ,           ,    :              ?     .      :       ,   , ,   , ,   (..       ), ,      ?

    ,    ,     頖       ,   .    1980-      ,     ,  , ,         .    ,   .       :  ,        (. inflatio ),         !  ,  ,           .          . ,  -     (  ,   ),        蠖      .

 30      .  ,    .     :          [13 -   . . . .],      (cosmic microwave background CMB),     .

    2014      .  ,        ,      :   .


17  2014 

      .        ,   .            ,            .           .    ,          .           .  ,       .

 ,   ?          ,     .     ,    ,     ,      ,   .      .       ,  , ,  .

  . 17  2014   ,     ,     -,  ,     BICEP2[14 - BICEP (.  . Background Imaging of Cosmic Extragalactic Polarization)      ,     .      ,      . . .]  ,   ,      .

BICEP2   ,   ,   .           ,      (  ).              .

 BICEP  .       ,   ,          ,     .     ,    컠        ,      .      ,     ࠖ  .

    BICEP2         , ,   ,      ,    -,         .     ? ,   .   BICEP2    ,        , ,     .

   .  :   .


* * *

-  -      .  10       . ,      The New York Times  The Economist      ,   .         .        .

  ,      .    -   ,    MIT  ,         ,   ,    .         ,  ,             .

-   ,     .  BICEP2    㠖 ,  , ,    in medias res[15 -  /   (.). . .].

   2014     ,         .     BICEP2,          POLARBEAR,         .      -   BICEP2        .    堖   ,        ,  .         .           (B-)    ,  POLARBEAR        .

        BICEP2,  ,         .         .       , ,               .   ,       BICEP2. ,   .    :   ,   ,    .

     .       .        ?   1974    ,     :      .       . ,   ,       ,       ,     (confirmation bias)    ,    ,   ,    .       .  ,   ,     .   ,      .     ,      .    BICEP2, ,    ,        .      - ?

    BICEP2   .       ,            .           ࠖ     ,            Planck    .   - BICEP2  Planck     -,     ,   .    .    .

  -            . -    ,    ,    :       ,     BICEP2    ,           -

 ,       .     ,         .       UCSD (   -)      PowerPoint,      ,     BICEP2.          . ,              (      -),      ,    .

    ?   ,           -      ,     .       -,     . ,  ,  ,    . 17  2014          BICEP2            .     .           2001    BICEP.        .   .

-   ,     ,        .              .       ,       ,         .

  .    , ,   ,   Simons Array   .  Simons Array     ,    BICEP2.             .  ,     BICEP,   ,     -.  ?    BICEP2    Simons Array?  , ?        .  ,    ?




 2

  



    ,

,  2005 

 ,           ,    ,   .         .   :             .

    .       !       ,     ,          ,   .      ?         .

,   !    ,    ,               .  BICEP        .  ,     .     ,    .

ࠖ       .         :        .   1912                :  !     !              ,     .

    ,  ,      , ,   ,  ,    :      .   ,    ,       ,    .        .

  .     ,      ,    .   13 000  ,    ,  ,       ,  . ,   ?      ,     .  ,         ,     .          .      .     .

   ,      ,     .        ,      .         ,         ,   .            ,   .    .

  ,         ,   , ,  ,           ,  .         ,    .              ,     .     ,   ,  ,           .      ,        ,     !  -    . -     .


-,  -, 4  ,  1984 

,      !      ,   .   .     .    .    .         .   ,      !     ,    ,    .    ,    ?   13 ,       .

            ,        ,       .   .  Google    14 .  ,     ,    The New York Times    .       !

    ,     . ,    ,         ,   ,  ,   ,   . ,        ,   !            ,  ?       ?!

    .     ,   79 ⠖      ,    ,     .               -,     3,35     .   ,    ,    .        ,    ,         .

 ,         ,       ,        .           -.       .        蠖   ,       -.           .          . ,            ,     .

      ,         .           . - .   .         ? ,   :         ?   ?

    -  ,     .      ,     - ,   .  ,        ,       ,   .          ,     .  ,   .

         ,  ? ,          頖        ,        ,     ,   .     ,  ,         .       , ,        .

  ,           The New York Times.      ,      ,       .  ,    ,    ,        . ,    ,         (Peterson Field Guide to the Stars and Planets),     .  13- -,     ,            .              -,         ,     .   ,     .

          ,      .  ,      ,    젖  ,         .         ,    : ,  ,      . ,       ,       :    ,    ,    . ,     ,    ,  ,   ,     (        ).

    .   ,          .       ,      ,          .              .   .

      ,     .           .      .    ,     .          .

   ,        ,    ,            ,        .    ,       ,  ,          -     .             .

   .   ,       .     ,        .  12 ,        -,     .        ,  ,             .  ,  ,    ,   ,    ,        .

         .  ,         ,     .  ,         .

          .    ,      .    ,     .   ,                 ,         ,     (  ,  ,       ).        -   ?

  1984 ,      ,        ,        .    .         ,  ,     .     :       ,    ,    ,   ,       ,  ,       ,   -  [16 -  ,    ,   , 1615.; .: Discoveries and Opinions of Galileo, translated and edited by Stillman Drake (New York: Doubleday Anchor, 1957).].     ,    .      -.       ;  ,       .

           .   ,     .      ,   .  ,   17          ,     1993 ,    ,        .

 , ,    ,         .       ,      .  ,    ,         頖  ,    .    .   (  )      , , ,     :    ?      :           ?

   .        ,        1993 .        .  23- ,            .      𻠖   ,   24 000    ,  .      .    ,          ,     ,     ,      .          !        .




  


       : ,       ?     ,  ?  ,     ,      ?       .  ,    :   ,  ,     

        ,       .    ,       ,    ,      .     ,      ,   ,   . ,     ,      .       ,     .        ,   273  (460 F).       绠      .

 ,  ,   , [17 -    ,    ,   . . . .] , ..        .       ,   ,   : ,     ?        ,    ,     , ,  ,      ,    ?  ,  , ,    ࠖ .          ,    ,        . ,    ,      ,     ,    ,  ,   , ,   ,   ,  13,82  ,     .          .     ,    .  ?    .     ,      ,    ,   ,  .

          ,       .    ,   :        .    ,   ,     .       ,      .   ,   ,     ,    . ,       ,   , . ,    ,  .   ,        .  ,    , :              !

   .         ,     ,      .   1994     .  ,   ,  ,       -  -.  ,    ,     . ,   -    ,  ,      .

          .            ,  ,    ,     :  ,  ,  ![18 - J.Ax, Group- Theoretic Treatment of the Axioms of Quantum Mechanics, Foundations of Physics 6, no. 4 (1976): 37199; J. Ax, The Elementary Foundations of Spacetime, Foundations of Physics 8, no. 78 (1978): 507, https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00717578 (https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00717578).] ,           ,   -     .

 ,    .      ,         ,  ,      .    ,   ,     .

         ,    .      (    )   .          ,     , ,   . ,       ,       .  15      ,   .   ,       .

   .   ,   - , ,  ,   ,        -   .              ,           .        :      ,   .      . ,  ,  ,           ,    .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/brayan-kiting/gonka-za-nobelem/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.     : https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/will/ (https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/will/).




2


  -        2016 ,       ,        ,      .        .   ,          ,  ,      ,   ,       .




3


  .       , , , 12  1959.      : https://www.jfklibrary.org/Research/Research-Aids/JFK-Speeches/Indianapolis-IN_19590412.aspx (https://www.jfklibrary.org/Research/Research-Aids/JFK-Speeches/Indianapolis-IN_19590412.aspx).




4


          . .: Magdalena Eriksson, A Great Prize Ages with Grace, Science and Technology Perspective 80, no. 4 (2002): 6264.  ,     ,        .




5


             ,       (   1948.)   .




6


 (. serendipity)  ()         .       ,      ,    . . .




7


Daniel Charles, Between Genius and Genocide: The Tragedy of Fritz Haber, Father of Chemical Warfare (London: Pimlico, 2006).




8


Associated Press, Desmond Tutu, 2 other Nobel Peace Prize laureates contest 2012 winner choice of EU, Fox News, November 30, 2012, http://www.foxnews.com/world/2012/11/30/desmond-tutu-2-other-nobelpeace-prize-laureates-contest-2012-winner-choice-eu.html (http://www.foxnews.com/world/2012/11/30/desmond-tutu-2-other-nobelpeace-prize-laureates-contest-2012-winner-choice-eu.html)




9


Valerie Richardson, Critics mock Nobel committee for handing literature prize to Bob Dylan, Washington Times, October 13, 2016, http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/oct/13/bob-dylans-nobel-prize-sets-off-literature-debate/ (http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/oct/13/bob-dylans-nobel-prize-sets-off-literature-debate/)




10


     : https://spie.org/Documents/resources/Free%20Posters/copyright%20posters/Mayer-poster-delivery.pdf (https://spie.org/Documents/resources/Free%20Posters/copyrigh%20tposters/Mayer-poster-delivery.pdf).




11


 : Peter Doherty, The Beginners Guide to Winning the Nobel Prize: Advice for Young Scientists (New York: Columbia University Press, 2006); David Carter, How to Win the Nobel Prize in Literature (London: Hesperus Press, 2012); Tony Goldsmith, How to Win a Nobel Prize (independently published, 2017).




12


Rebecca Hersher, How Much Is a Nobel Prize Medal Worth? The Two-Way: Breaking News from NPR, October 16, 2016, http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/10/16/498146211/how-much-is-a-nobelprize-medal-worth (http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/10/16/498146211/how-much-is-a-nobelprize-medal-worth).




13


  . . . .




14


BICEP (.  . Background Imaging of Cosmic Extragalactic Polarization)      ,     .      ,      . . .




15


 /   (.). . .




16


 ,    ,   , 1615.; .: Discoveries and Opinions of Galileo, translated and edited by Stillman Drake (New York: Doubleday Anchor, 1957).




17


   ,    ,   . . . .




18


J.Ax, Group- Theoretic Treatment of the Axioms of Quantum Mechanics, Foundations of Physics 6, no. 4 (1976): 37199; J. Ax, The Elementary Foundations of Spacetime, Foundations of Physics 8, no. 78 (1978): 507, https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00717578 (https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00717578).


