 .         
  


   ,       :  , ,   .      ,    ,  , .   :     ,       .      .

  ?         ,     ,       .        ?     ,         ?

           .

  ,     ,     .





 

 .         



  . 

 . 

  . 

 . 

  . 

  . 



 Dr. Ichak Adizes, 2004

 The Adizes Institute, 6404 Via Real, Carpinteria, California 93103, Tel: (805) 565-2901, fax: (805) 565-0741, www.adizes.com (http://www.adizes.com/)

The Adizes Institute Publications

    , , .   , 2014



  .                        ,         ,           .



       (www.litres.ru (http://www.litres.ru/))


* * *


    ,     :



  

( ,  , );



  

( ,  );



  

( ,  );



 ,    ,     ,  ,     ( ),           .







     ,     ,         .        .

    ,    ,   ,     .

       .

  .




 


                     ,       ,  .    35                . ,    ,                                 .       .     Inc. Magazine, Fortune, The New York Times, The London Financial Times, Investor Relations Daily, Nations Business  World Digest.

       .   ,       40 .                -           ,         - .     ,     22 .   Corporate Lifecycles: How Organizations Grow and Die and What to Do about It (  :          ),    1988 ,         Library Journal        .          1999    Managing Corporate Lifecycles (   ).        .

ichak@adizes.com (http://mailto:%20ichak@adizes.com/)




  


,     ,          .        .      ,   ,    ,      .

   ,  ,  1937 .      ,     ,      XV     .   1943  ,   ,    ,      .   12 ,       (,        ).      ,           ,             -  .            .      .                .    ,         .  ,  ,     ,   ,    ,    .      ,        .  1963     ,         1967  1982       -.  1982     (Adizes Institute),     ,       .     :      ,        .      .

        .   ,   ,      (Corporate Lifecycles),   1988 .    ,  ,         .      (  )     ,   .         ,     [1 -           ,   1972     .            ,             .].    1990-            .

       , ,   ,   ,          ,       .             .        , ,   .         .   ,     ,   .

        .  ,   ,          ,  ,   ,       ,   . ,     ,         ,        ,             -.      : (P)roducing results   ,          , (A)dministering  ,  , (E)ntrepreneuring  ,   ,  (I)ntegrating  ,            .        ,      ,     .  ,               ,        .      ,           .  ,                       (complimentary team),          .  ,   ,  ,       ,    .

      ,       .   ,        .     ,  ,         ,     .  ,  ,   .           .  ,            .

      ,           .            ,     ,     .  ,                   .        ,                .

           , ,   ,         ,    .      , ,      ,                     .       .

          .  ,               :            .        ,            .  ,  ,      ,          -. ,           -        .

             ,    ,      ,     .        .

 , ,        ,  ,   ,    . , ,        -, ,         .    : -      ,          ,   ,   ,   (,  )  .             ,   .  ,  , ,             -.    ,   -  ,   .

          ?  : ,        .    -    ,  -       , -          . , ,          ,       .

          .



. . 
. .-. ., .,     -  
,  2006.




 





    ?


   .        .    ,     .     .

  ,       ,     .

   ?               .       .   ,    :   ,  .     ,      .        ,   ,     ,   ,     ,  - .

,       ,  .   ,        ,   ,  ,  ,    .       , ,             .     .

   ?

      How to Solve the Mismanagement Crisis[2 -  .    .     . .:     -, 2006. . .] (    Dow Jones Irwin  1979 ,       )              .  ,     ,            .           , , ,    .           ,         .

     48          .            .          Corporate Lifecycles: How Organizations Grow and Die and What to Do about It (Paramus, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 1989) (   :          ). ,          2004      : Corporate Lifecycles: Volume 1: HOW Organizations Grow, Age and Die; Volume 2: WHY Organizations Grow, Age and Die; Volume 3: HOW to Manage Balanced Growth and Rejuvenate Organizations (   :  1:     ;  2:     ;  3:        ).

  ,    ,   The Pursuit of Prime (  ), Santa Monica: Knowledge Exchange, 1996,  Adizes Institute,    ,   ,      Mastering Change ( ), Santa Barbara: Adizes Institute, 1992.

 ,       ,          . ,      (The Ideal Executive: Why You Cannot Be One and What to Do About It / A New Paradigm for Management   :          /    ),   .      ,                ,      .

     (      ,        ,    ,   )    [3 - Ichak Adizes. Management and Mismanagement Styles: How to Identify a Style and What to Do About It. The Adizes Institute Publications, 2004. . .]  Management and Mismanagement Styles (    ).  [4 - Ichak Adizes. Leading the Leaders: How to Enrich Your Style of Management and Handle People Whose Style Is Different from Yours. The Adizes Institute Publications, 2004. . .]              ,   ,    ,   , ,    ..

  ,    ,            ,  .      ,      ,       :       B,       A.  ,  30     ,    ,     ,   ,   . ,           .         ,      ,   ,   .




 


             .

 ,           : (P)roducing results   ,          , (A)dministering  ,  , (E)ntrepreneuring  ,      ,  (I)ntegrating  ,            .

     -  .      ,      ,    .        ,      .      ,  ,      ,    ..

 ,      ,       ,      .         I (),   . (  ,   .)

    ,        ,    ,      ,     ,     .

 ,  ,        ,    .       -.   ,     .               ,           .

      ,   ,            ,           ,      .   ,     (   ),      ,  ,      ,    .    ,       ,   ,       .   ,   .                   .

  ,     ,  .     ,             ,   ,       ,      .       ,    -   ,   .     , .    ,   .           ,   .        .

     ,  ,         .         .     ,           ,     .

     .       ,   .      ,        ,     .   .    .  ,     ,  ,        ,    ,            .       ,    .        30-    .       48           ,      ,   ,     100  .




 


  14 .          ,      .         ,     .

       ,   ,             .   ,   ,      .      ,   ,          .            .

  1         .          ,  ,  .

  2    ,    ,         .         .   3 ,               .   4             .

    ,   ,       ?   5        .     [5 -   .      (.:     -, 2006)    complimentary teams    .   ,   .     ,        ,     - ,    .     ,        ,        ,     .   ,           . . . .],      .  6         -  , ,    .   7             (mutual trust and respect, MT&R),             ,      .

   ?   8   ,    ,       ,    ,   [1 - Frost, Robert: The Mending Wall, from the poetry collection North of Boston (New York: Henry Holt, 1915)*.*      (18741963)  ,    . . . .].  9    ,             .

            ,    ,         .   10  11        ,    10     ,   11    .        ,      ;         .

  12     ,      ,     ..     ,     ,       .

 ,  13  14      ,    (   ,     ),     ,       .   13         .   ,    , ,             ,         .   14   ,   ,      :     ;     ;            ?




 


 ,      ,          .    ,            .          -.         -  ,           .

         ,     ,       ,   ,   , ,             .   ,       ,            .

          ,  ,  ,    ,      .




   


     ,      30-      ().          ,  ,     ,   (organizational symbergist)     ,                   .

      48   ,        15       120  ,          .          ,  , ,  ,    ,    .       .  ,             .  , ,      ,    ,    , , , , ,    ,          .          ,         .




  


            ,   ,      .            (),    (  )   ().        .  ,     ,        ,      ,       .  ,     ,   ,    ,    .             .




  


   ,      .   -            ,  ,    ,         ,    .   : Adizes Institute, 2815 East Valley Road, Santa Barbara, CA 93108,      : Ichak@adizes.com (mailto:%20Ichak@adizes.com).

.



  
-, , 2003 




 1

  



:       ,   ,       ,      -   ,   .




    ( )


            , , ,   .  ,   .     ,        .        .

      ,      .   ,     ,   .         , ,                      .

       ,   ,   ,   .    ,      .                  ,  .     ,   ,       .

  ,  -   ;    .       :  ,         .             .  ,  ,          .           .    ,    ,         .    ,         .

    .     ,    ,       .    ,     .     ,   ,       .

    ,      .           .      .

  :    -?

,    (,    )    .



 ? ,      .  ? ,    .  ? ,   .   ? .

 

  ,       ,      ,        ,   .       ,        .

    ,  ,   ,    .      ,     ,   . ,      -,   MBA.     ,        ,       .




  ?


  New York Times   ,      [2 - Fowler, Elizabeth M.: The Team Approved at the Top, The New York Times (Business section, Sept. 16, 1977).]:                .

   ?

      ,   .

?

     ,    .    , , ,  , ?

,              .    , ?    .   ,  .  ,  .  ,       .

       ,   ,      !       (     ,    ).       ,   .      ,           ,   .

          ?



1.  .   ,        ,  . ,     ,  .     ;   ,  ,        ,    ,   ,   [6 -      ,    executives,          (        ,     ).   ,        ,    ,     .      executives   .      ,     ,  ,   . . . .].

2.   .   ,    Funk & Wagnalls, Oxford Illustrated, Random House  Websters Third New International,      : ,  ,    , , , , , , ,   , , ,  , ,  ,  , ,  , , , ,   ,    , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,   , , , , , , ,   , ,  , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,   ,   ,   , , , .

       ? .      .    ,  .      : ,   ,  ,   ;    ,      .



        ,   .

  

     New Yorker   ,    . ,   ,    .   : !    . , ,    .   ,      .

    ,       ,   .    ,    (   ) ,   ,   ,  .    ?    ,       ,    .

3.   .      .       ,   ,       .

       .            .       ,     ,     .        ,     .       ,    .  ,   ,           .

 ,  ,      ,        ,    .      ,    - .

4.   .    .                  ,    .       : -,    ; -,           .

          ,   ,        .       .

,       ,     .          ,      .  ,       ,  :      .

 :          ?     .  :          ?  :   .

   ?

 , ?

   ?

    !

 , :           ?

 !

  ?

      .    -       ?  ! ?     ,      .

 :     ,      ,       ,        ?

  ,   ?           ,     ,     :       ,  ,    ,   .

   ?

   ,        ,     ,           .

,     ,    ,    .    !!!  .      .     !

 ,           . ,  -       ,    , ,  ,     ,      .

       .       ,  ,        ,   .     ,       .

     :  -         .   ,         .          :        .    ,    ,     ,      ,    ,     . (      .)

 ,   ,       ,          .      ,     .  ,   ,   ,        .     ,     .

,       ,      ,  ,      ,     .



5.     .      ,    ,  , , ,    .   ,          .   ,           ,   ,  ,        ,    .   , -      .    ,    .        - ,   1970-          - -  .  ,    [3 - Adizes, Ichak: Essays on the Management of Performing Arts; Santa Barbara, CA: Adizes Institute Publications.  ;      .].

        .        . ,        ,       [4 - Adizes, Ichak and Zukin, J.: Health Planning for Developing Nations, HCM Review /Winter 1977, pp. 1928.].   ,     ,    ,            .   ,  ,          . ,    ,   ,     .

           ?   ,           .    ,   .       .      .      ,           .      ,     ,            .



6.   - .   ,     ,   .  ,       ,       ,   . ,        ,  ( !)    ,     ,    -   .     ,   -         .      ,   ,     ..   .

       ,       ,         .      ,           :     ,      ,   ,    [5 - Adizes, Ichak, and Elizabeth Mann Borgese: Self-Management: New Dimensions to Democracy (Santa Barbara, CA: Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions and ABCCLIO, 1975), pp. 3031.].

   ,      . ,       , ,  ,       - ,  ,    ,    ,      ,        ,    [6 -  ,  6.].



7.   .    (to manage)      ,    , ,   .     , , .        ,   manage,    .

   manage   manejar,        .      ,   manage,      .

  ,      ,          ,           .

     ,      ,   .   ,  , ,   .                       , , , ,   ,            . (     :       , ,          ,  ,         .)

 ,  ,         .     ,     . (       ?)     ,           ,  ,    ,    ,      .      ,        ,      .    ,            .    ,    ( !) ,        .  ,     ,     ,  ,            .       ,       .




 


       ,    .    ,    ,     ,      .

    ?       ,    ,         ,       ,     , ,   .    ,       .

        ,      ,        .          , ,   ,    .

       .                  ,            (MBA).   ,   ,  Administrative Science Quarterly (   ).       ,            .

       .          . ,        ,         ,       .

     (executive)[7 -      ,    executives,          (        ,     ).   ,        ,    ,     .      executives   .      ,     ,  ,   . . . .].   :   ,   ,   .     ,     .      (2004 ).

   ,   ,     ,     ,       [7 - ., , Kotter, John P., Force for Change: How Leadership Differs from Management (New York: Free Press, 1990).],  ,       -  .   ,     -       ,                  ,        .

    ,     .  ,   ,   .     ,       - ,   , , , ,   .     [8 - Fowler, Elizabeth M.: The Team Approved at the Top, The New York Times (Business section, Sept. 16, 1977).].

 -          .  ,     ,    ,    ,          ,     .

   ?

    ,       ,    ,        ?  ,       ,     ?

   , -,      ,  -,    .      ,    , ,                   .  ,   ,          .

        -,  , ,   - ,  ,        ,   .      ,      ,                .  ,   ,    -,          - .      ,      (         ,    MBA)   .      .         .    ,      - .

,           -   .          ,      .

    ,     :          .       ,    ,    .

 ,         .   (Adizes Institute)    , ,   ,            ,       ,   .




 2

 



:   ,        ?




 


       :    ?          -   .    ,           , , ,              .         .

   :                     .           ,         ,    , ,    .

       .      ,    .            .   -           .




 


          ?

 40    ,                .    ,        .   , ,        ,      .

   ,         [9 - Adizes, Ichak, and Elisabeth Mann Borgese: Self-Management: New Dimensions to Democracy; Alternatives for a New Society (Santa Barbara, Calif.: Clio Books, 1975).].

       .    .        ;    .     .

    .    ,     . ,          .       , -        .        ,           .      -,  ,           .      ,     ,   ,   -    .

       ,     ;        .      ,          .          .           ,  .

    :           .  ,   -    .       ,  ,   ,         [10 - Djilas, Milovan: The New Class: An Analysis of the Communist System (New York: Frederick A. Praeger, 1957).].     ,   .     .      ,        ,   ,       [11 - Adizes, Ichak: Industrial Democracy Yugoslav Style: The Effect of Decentralization on Organizational Behavior (New York: Free Press, 1971; reprinted by Adizes Institute, 1977).].

     ,    ,    ,   ,   1747     ,       C,        ,     .  , ,  -    , , ,    ,   .  30           .         ,  ,          .           ,           .




 (PAEI)


         ?     (P)roducing,   (A)dministrating,   (E)ntrepreneuring    (I)ntegrating,  PAEI.        .

 ,       ,  (P),   ,      .      ?     ?    ?   (P)   .    ,   ,  ,       .

 , (A),  , ,       :           .   (A)     .

   .   ,    .            ,       .    (E),           .        ,   /       .

 ,     (I),        ,            ,         .

          .

         .








(P):   ?

(A):    ?

(E): /   ?

(I):    ?



           ,   .

        , (P)  (A)       ,        . (  ,   .)       , (E)  (I)            .         ,      .      , ,  ,         ,        .

     ,     ,  , ,      .       (E)  (P),       .    (A)  (I),          .

     ,    ?  ,       ?  (P)  (E)  ,     ,    (A)   ,     (I).

 ,   ,   ,     ,       .        ,    ,           ,   ,       .




    


         .        ,         .    ,  .

     - ,    ,    .          ,             .

   ,      .  ,      (P)       .       (Paei)  P   ,    ,   a, e, i ,     .

       (pAei),  (paEi)   ,   (paeI)   .    ,            (P),    (A),    (E),    (I).

    (PAEI)            1  100      ,     ,    . (PA-) , (paEI)    .. (.    : Management and Mismanagement Styles      ).

   ,        ,      (I),        .    ,     (PaeI)  .        .

     (PAEI)   (    ),      : (P-) ,    -, (-A-) , (-E-) , (-I)  .       4-  .          Management and Mismanagement Styles (    ).

 (PAEI)         .  (PAEI)            .             ,        ,   .   ,     ,     .

,          ,  ,            ,       .  ,          ,  ,      .                [12 -     .: Adizes, Ichak: Managing Corporate Lifecycles (Paramus, N.J.: Prentice Hall Press, 1999).].

 ,   ,      .   ,        , ,    ,   ,       .    ,   ,   ,     ,      [].       :  ,      ,       45   ,   ,    , ,       . (    ,     -:     ?   ,   ,   , :   ,     !).  ,      (PAEI)     ,   ,       ,      ,      Corporate Lifecycles: Volume 1: How Organizations Grow, Age and Die; Volume 2: Why Organizations Grow, Age and Die; Volume 3: How to Manage Balanced Growth and Rejuvenate Organizations (   ,  1:     ;  2:     ;  3:        , Adizes Institute, 2004.  ,     Corporate Lifecycles (   ), ,     Prentice Hall  1999 .

    ,     .       ,          ,     .  ,     ,            (P) .   ,    ,       .

  30      ,   ,     ,   (PAEI)    ,     .            .                    .   ,   ,    12     ,     150   4      [13 -     (Adizes Institute) .   www.adizes.com (http://www.adizes.com/).].

            .




  


    ,       ,  (P),   ,        .

  ?       ,     .   ,     .     , -  .      ,  .

        ?  .

      .              .    .

        ,    .    ,     .      , , ,   .

    .     ,     .        .    .      .         ,    :   ,  ,     .              ,          .

   ,   ,      .      ,            .   ,    , ,    ,     .       ,      ,      ,      .

     ?         .      ,      ,             .        ,       .    ,        ,     ,  ,    ,      .

  ,   ,   ,     ,         (        ),    ( )         ().       ,        telos ( ,  ), ,     .

          .    .      .       ?    ?     ? ,     ,  :     ?      ?

  ,     ,       ,      .          ,   .

      ?   ?     ?

,  ,  ,     ,  : !!!

,  ,   .

     , ,   ,     ,  -.  ,    ,    ,   ,   ,   :      .   , ,    :   ?         .

     .  ,         ,     .      ,   ,  .  ,  ,       ( ),         ,   .

  ?       :    ?   ,    ?   ?  ?     ,      ,     ,    ,           ,        ,    ,    .     ,    ,  ,          .  ,       ,    .      ,        .

      ,      .

 .         ,   ,           .

           (P) ,    .       ,  ,    ,   ,    ,  .      ,         ,   ,  .

 ,       (P)  (A) ,   ,     ,   . (,   ,        , ,     .)

      ?    ?

:     .   (P)   .  (A)     .

 ,       .    ;   .      ,      ,   .         .         ,  .      ,      .

  ?    !    ?      ,     ?

    ,  ,   ,  ,         .       ,   ,    .   ,   ,  ,   ,       ,   ,     .

        .     ?              ,     .                    ,        .

    ,     ,   .     ,    ,             .




 :  (Paei)


 ,     ,    (P) ,   ,     ,     ,     ,   .  ,   (Paei),   ,   (P) .

   (P) ,    . -,   ,           .      ? -,   ,      ,   ,   ,     .








 :     ,   ;        .   ,  ,        :   .      ?  ,    ,  .      .

   -           !       .        ,      ,        .         ,   .      ,      ?   .  ,       .       .        .   ,    ,     ,   .

    .  ,   ,   .     ,    ,        ,          .   ,   !         ,      ,     . (P)   ,      ,       .

  ,   (P)      .




  


   ? .  ,     ,   ?

  ,   ,    ,       .

    ,          .   ,  ,    .       (P),     ,   (P) .     ,         ,  (A).

     .     ,   , (P),      ,   ,    ,       .  ,    ,   ,    .       ,        .      ,      .

   ,    .      ,    .    (P)  (A),         .         ,      ,         .








    (P),    (A)   .       ,  ,    .       .

       .  ,    ,      .    .        .      ,     .      .   ,  .    ,     .

       .    ?  ,   ,      .      A   B. ,   ,    ,   ,       A   B      .       .  (P)   ,      (P) .

        ,    ,    .   ,     .

    ,     - ,           .               .   ,  ,       .     ,     (A) .




 :  (pAei)


      ,    .    ,        .     .

    ,   ,         ,    ,     ,     .     .   ,      .     ,    .    -,      .     !  ,   ,      ,               .

 ,   (A) ,  ,   .      :     ,         .   ,  (A)         ,     (P)   ,   .

          ,   ,    ,  ,    .      ,         ,   ,  .

   ,  ,      .     .    ,    ,        .    (  ,          ),      ,     .

    ,     .      .  ,      ,     .

 ()     .           ,          (  ),   -   ,    .

 ()    .  ,             .

    ,    .

  .   ,   ,     .    -   -.   ,    ,   ,  ,     ,      .     (),     (P) ;     ,        (A) [14 -    (P)  (A) .  , (A)   ,    ,   (P).   ,               .  (P)     (A) . ,       (A) : ,    .].

- (pAei)    ,   ,    .         .   .    ,      ,   ,     (paEi) ,   ,     ,      .

         .    :         (paEi) ,         (pAei) .      (E),      -  .  (A)    ,  ,   ,  .

    (E) ,  .




  


     ? .     .    ?      ? .      ,    ,  ,       .   ,  (E) .

 (E)    ,    .     (A)      ,   ,  (E)    ,     ,      .    ,    ,    .

  ,    (E)       .    ,        ,   ,  ,    .    ,  ,     : !  ,  .

  ,   ,  ,    .    ,     .           : ,  ,   !            ,              .

     ,  ,   (E) ,        ;          ;        .  ,  (E)  ,        .

    .    (E)   ,     ,     ,      ,       ,        .      .

    , (E)      .       .     ,   (E) ,            .




   (paEi)


  How to Solve the Mismanagement Crisis[8 -  .    .     . .:     -, 2006. . .][15 - Adizes, Ichak: How to Solve the Mismanagement Crisis (Santa Monica, Calif.: Adizes Institute, Inc., 1979).],       (PAEI),   ,   (E)     (paEi),  .      30  .   ,    ,    .

 (paEi)     .   ,       ,     (P) .    (E) .

,       (E)  ,      (P) ,     .        ,   .     ,     .   ,   ,    .       .      ,     .

    .        ,    .           . ,     (P),    ,   :       .

    (P),         ,     .     .




  (paEi)


  ,      .  ,     ,       ,          .      ,              [16 -   (E) .  Schumpeter, Joseph: Business Cycles (New York: McGraw Hill, 1939), pp. 102109; Drucker, Peter F.: Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), Chapter 10.].

      .    ,    .

      -. ?       .          ,       .  ,         ,     .   ,      , ,   ,      ,  ,   ,  ,  ,    (E).     ,     .

 ,   ,  .     ,          ,  ,       .       ,      ,  ,   ,  .

 ,     ,   .      ,    ,         -,    .   ,    ,     ,        ,     ,     .

 ,  ,      .         .    , ,          .     ,     .   ,   .     ,  ,     ,   .

(E)     .   ,      ,    ?  ,  (E)       .









 


   ,    ,           .       ,   ,     ,           .

          ,     ,   , (E) .         ,         , (A) .     ,   ,      ,   ,        ,   ,  (P) .

     ?      ,       ?

  ,         .       ? -.        ,  , .          ,  , ,   .

 ,     ,    (P), (A)  (E)?   , ,    ,       ,    ,      ,    .  ,     .

 ,    ,        ,        .

   ,    ?

    .

?    (P), (A)  (E) ,  ,          .

   ,      . ,  ,  .             . ?      ,    ,     .

  ,   ,  (I) .

 ,    ,            [17 -    (I) .  Lawrence, P.R. and J. W. Lorsch, New Managerial Job: The (I)ntegrator, Harvard Business Review, 45 (November 1967), pp. 142151.].  (I)   ,     ,         ,        .

  ,     ,    ,     .    ,      ,     .

  ?   ,       ,   ,   .   .     ,     ? ,    ,  .

                  ,       ,    .         . ,    ,   ,   .

        . ,    .  .    (P)   :    .     .     ,     ,     .

     .    ,    .  .  ,    ,           .     .    ,    , ,    .

,        ,  -.  .         ?    .         ?     ,          .

 ,      .      .          .

   ,    ,    . ?            .  : ,    ;     .     .      .

,        ,    ,  ,        .    ?    .

    ,  .

         !!!   ,  .    .    ,      .  ?

      ,       .       ,       .            ,   .  ,  ,     ,  ,   ,         - .

   .    ,             ,          ,     .     ?  ,   ,      . ?          ;         :    ,   ,  .               .

     .     ,    ,    ,   ,     ,       .       . ,      , ,       ,   ,      .  ,   (PAE-),    ,  (I)     ,  ,    ,       ,    .

    ,   ,      ,     ,     ,   .      .    .

  (I)   ,         .      ,    .     .     ,         ,  [9 -   ,            ,        .  ,   . . .]    .    ,      .       ,        ,      .       :  ,  .

     ,   ,       .        .        ,  :       ,    ?    ?       ,    ,     .   ,    .

,  ,      (P),     ,         .   ,  ?     .

:      .    .    ,   .            ,    .        .   ,         .

      ,    -    .       ,  ,      .

,   , ,       .    ,        .        ,         .        , (I) . ,     ,  ,       ,  .




 :  (paeI)


             ,    .      .     ,    .     ,      .

 ,  ,  ,    ,    , ,   ..           .  ,  ,  ,   ,  .

         ,       .            [18 - (I) ,   ,      , ,   ,   ,       . ,     (I)      ,         ,         .          .   ,                 . . Argyris, The Fusion of an Individual with the Organization, American Sociological Review, 19 (1954), pp. 145167; and Personality vs. Organization, Organizational Dynamics, 3 (1974) no. 2, pp. 217.         (I)      .      . . Blau, Patterns of Interaction among a Group of Officials in a Government Agency, Human Relations, 7 (1954), pp. 337348.].

   ,      .

  ,           ,              .    ,  ,       ,               .

   ,           ,   ,  ,            .

  ,                ,   .

      ,    .       .               . , ,  :            , ,    .  ,  ,  , ,   , , ,        .

    ,          ,     ,    .       ,      ,     ,     .

      ,        ,  .   ,       ,  :      .   .




(I)   


  ,        ,  ,  ,        .          ,     .   ,    ,     .








      (I).            (PAei), (paEi), (pAEi), (PAEi) ,     ,    .    ,      (I) . (       11.)




 :  


   ,     .

   ,            .  ,     ,   , ,      .

   ,     :       , ,      (PAEI).  ,       (P),        (E),          (A).  ,     (I)      .

,       ,       .           ,               ,     .

, ,   ,   ,  ,  ,     ?

 - .       ,         .




 3

   ?



:       ,     ?




   


 ,      .    ,        .     (P),      ,      ,    (A),         .    (E)     (I),         .                         .      ,         ,   ,    ,    - .

 ,  .

  .

  - .

       (E  P),      (A  P),      (I  E  P)  ..      ,           (PAEI) .   . ?      .

    :    .     .  -   ,  .

    .        .

      ?    .

   ,  ,       .      .

 - ,  ,     .     .      .

       , ,   ,  ,      .

?   .

       !




 


 ,  (PAEI) ,   ,  ,        ,   ,    ,    .   ,     .     .      ,    .              ;            .        ,    ,       .  ,     .         ,    .

  ,    ,    ,    .  ,  , ,    [10 -   (Andy Warhol) (19281987)   ,  ,  -,     . . .],           .   ,    ,   ,     [19 -     .  Adizes, Ichak: Corporate Lifecycles, Volumes 1, 2, 3, ,    ,  Adizes Institute  2004;   Paramus, N.J.: Prentice Hall Press, 1988.].  ,            ,     ,       :        ,        .



    ,        .

 . 

     .

    ,      ,   ,  ,  [20 - Drucker, Peter F.: Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), p. 616.].      ,   .

   , ,   (A)      (I).           (P),     (E).           (E),    (A).  ,    , , ,       (I).   ,      (P).    ,     ,        (  ) (EI).

  ,    ,  ,       .       (A),   (P),   (I)     (E).  ,      (PAEI).

      ,  ,           ,         ,     . ,         (E) .   (I)        ,      ,         (A)    ,         (I),         .

  (P)       ,     , [11 -     : (P)-eons,   ,   () ,  peon -  . . . .].          (E)  ,      ,    ,      .

                .              . ,  ,    (P),    (A),  , ,    (E)      (I).         ?   , ,      ,   [21 -  , p. 616.].




   


  ?       ,     ,   ,   ,    .

   ,         ,          .       .

     .

   ,       ,       .    ;  ,      ,       .

   :     ,      ,      .  ,      (PAEI) ,  ,     .



  ,     - .

 

,  ,   . (P)  (E) ,  (P)   ,   (E)      .

   :    ,      .  ,  ,    ,     ,         .          , , -      .  , (P)  (E)         ,     ,   ,         .    .        ,  ,   .

    (E),        ,     (P).       ,        .

    (E)  (P).   ,       (P) . ,   ,     :      ,       !  ,     ,    .




 (P)  (A)


     ,      (P)  (E).   : (P)  (A).

              ,    ,   ,   ,   ?  , .  ,     ,       ,     ?  .       .           ,     .   ,      ,    .

  ,        ,     ,          . ,   .

 (P)   (A)   .

     ,       .    ,          ,   .      ,        .

  :   ,       .  ,    (A),   (P).      ,    ,     .

   ,     ,    .  ,      ,       ,   .    ?            ,       .

     : ,     ,    ,       ,           ,   ,   ,     .         ,     .     , , ,    ,      .

       ,   .    .       .       .  ,          ,  ,   .       ,      .      ,      .

       ,    ,   ,         .

    ,      ,           .         , ,          ,   ,       ,  ,      .   ,       ,    ,    ,    .      (A);    (P),       ,     .

 , (P)/(A)       ,       .  ,   ,       .    ,   .    ,    ,  .    ,    ,      ?        ,    !     . ,   ,       ,      ,  ,      .

,  ,        :  ,    ,     .       ,  .

       ,   ,     .   .




   


 (A), (I)    .  ,     ,         .

(I)   ,   (A)   .    ,    ,  (A)   . (A)  ,       ,      .        ,  ,    .

(I)   ,  (I)    .    (I)     ,  (A). ?    ,  ,    .         ,     ,      .     .

 .    :      ?

 ,  .

?  .     .

,  ,      .

 (I). ?        . ,  ,  ,     ,    .   ,    (A),   :     ,       .         .

     ,    ,  ,  ,   (AI).    ,         , ,     .       . ,        ,        .       .

    ,  (A)  (I) ?

 .

(A)   (I),         ,      .            .  (A)     (I)?     ,    .   ,   .     ,   .  ,  (A)    (I) .  , (A)      ,  ,   ,    (I),   .      (A),    (I).     (A)        .




  .


   .

   ,     (http://www.litres.ru/ichak-adizes/idealnyy-rukovoditel-pochemu-im-nelzya-stat-i-chto-iz-etogo-sleduet-3/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes









1


          ,   1972     .            ,             .




2


 .    .     . .:     -, 2006. . .




3


Ichak Adizes. Management and Mismanagement Styles: How to Identify a Style and What to Do About It. The Adizes Institute Publications, 2004. . .




4


Ichak Adizes. Leading the Leaders: How to Enrich Your Style of Management and Handle People Whose Style Is Different from Yours. The Adizes Institute Publications, 2004. . .




5


  .      (.:     -, 2006)    complimentary teams    .   ,   .     ,        ,     - ,    .     ,        ,        ,     .   ,           . . . .




6


     ,    executives,          (        ,     ).   ,        ,    ,     .      executives   .      ,     ,  ,   . . . .




7


     ,    executives,          (        ,     ).   ,        ,    ,     .      executives   .      ,     ,  ,   . . . .




8


 .    .     . .:     -, 2006. . .




9


  ,            ,        .  ,   . . .




10


  (Andy Warhol) (19281987)   ,  ,  -,     . . .




11


    : (P)-eons,   ,   () ,  peon -  . . . .










1


Frost, Robert: The Mending Wall, from the poetry collection North of Boston (New York: Henry Holt, 1915)*.

*      (18741963)  ,    . . . .




2


Fowler, Elizabeth M.: The Team Approved at the Top, The New York Times (Business section, Sept. 16, 1977).




3


Adizes, Ichak: Essays on the Management of Performing Arts; Santa Barbara, CA: Adizes Institute Publications.  ;      .




4


Adizes, Ichak and Zukin, J.: Health Planning for Developing Nations, HCM Review /Winter 1977, pp. 1928.




5


Adizes, Ichak, and Elizabeth Mann Borgese: Self-Management: New Dimensions to Democracy (Santa Barbara, CA: Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions and ABCCLIO, 1975), pp. 3031.




6


 ,  6.




7


., , Kotter, John P., Force for Change: How Leadership Differs from Management (New York: Free Press, 1990).




8


Fowler, Elizabeth M.: The Team Approved at the Top, The New York Times (Business section, Sept. 16, 1977).




9


Adizes, Ichak, and Elisabeth Mann Borgese: Self-Management: New Dimensions to Democracy; Alternatives for a New Society (Santa Barbara, Calif.: Clio Books, 1975).




10


Djilas, Milovan: The New Class: An Analysis of the Communist System (New York: Frederick A. Praeger, 1957).




11


Adizes, Ichak: Industrial Democracy Yugoslav Style: The Effect of Decentralization on Organizational Behavior (New York: Free Press, 1971; reprinted by Adizes Institute, 1977).




12


    .: Adizes, Ichak: Managing Corporate Lifecycles (Paramus, N.J.: Prentice Hall Press, 1999).




13


    (Adizes Institute) .   www.adizes.com (http://www.adizes.com/).




14


   (P)  (A) .  , (A)   ,    ,   (P).   ,               .  (P)     (A) . ,       (A) : ,    .




15


Adizes, Ichak: How to Solve the Mismanagement Crisis (Santa Monica, Calif.: Adizes Institute, Inc., 1979).




16


  (E) .  Schumpeter, Joseph: Business Cycles (New York: McGraw Hill, 1939), pp. 102109; Drucker, Peter F.: Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), Chapter 10.




17


   (I) .  Lawrence, P.R. and J. W. Lorsch, New Managerial Job: The (I)ntegrator, Harvard Business Review, 45 (November 1967), pp. 142151.




18


(I) ,   ,      , ,   ,   ,       . ,     (I)      ,         ,         .          .   ,                 . . Argyris, The Fusion of an Individual with the Organization, American Sociological Review, 19 (1954), pp. 145167; and Personality vs. Organization, Organizational Dynamics, 3 (1974) no. 2, pp. 217.         (I)      .      . . Blau, Patterns of Interaction among a Group of Officials in a Government Agency, Human Relations, 7 (1954), pp. 337348.




19


    .  Adizes, Ichak: Corporate Lifecycles, Volumes 1, 2, 3, ,    ,  Adizes Institute  2004;   Paramus, N.J.: Prentice Hall Press, 1988.




20


Drucker, Peter F.: Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), p. 616.




21


 , p. 616.


