 .        
  


  , c  ,       ,   ,      ,             ,   "".  ,        ,  ,  ,        ,   .  ,    ,                 .      ,        ,   ,             .             ,       ,          .         ( )      (  ).

    ,      ,  ,  ,  .





.. 

         : - 








      : c ,           ,   ,        ,              ,   .  ,        ,  ,  ,        ,   .

               ,      Light from the East. Theology, Science and Eastern Orthodox Tradition. Minneapolis, Fortress Press, 2003 (        . ,    , : -  .  , 2006)  The Universe as Communion. Towards a neo-Patristic Synthesis of Theology and Science, London, T&T Clark, 2008.            ,   ,             .               .    ,        (  )   .           ,         ,   , ,       ,     .             ,             .                 , ,         .          , ,    .

             ,                ,      .              ,           .          ,               .                ,            ,      ,       ,             .

              : 1)  ,                ,     ; 2)   ,        ,      (         ,      ); 3)     ,               .

           The Sense of the Universe. Philosophical Explication of Theological Commitment in Cosmology (Fortress Press, 2015).      ,      ,   ,         ,       .            ,    ,    .

    , ,          .  ,      -  ,     ,    .

          ,   .             ,        ,              .        (    ,       )     .             ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  , .  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  , .  , .  ,   ,  .        .  (),                     . -  . .     ()             ,      2005-2016 .           ,        .   ,    ,   ,                       ,  #1573 (2001 .)  #11921 (2006 .),      ,      .          .







   ,   ,         ,        .

(Paul Davies, Are we alone?, p. 9091)

    - , ,    ,        ,       ,   .     ,       ,       .

(Dumitru Staniloae, Experience of God, p. 3)

     ,            ,    ,    .

(Christos Yannaras, The Meaning of Reality, p. 133.)




      


        ,     -    .      -,     ,         ,         .        ,    ,   ,              .             ,  ,    .                     .        , ,      (     )        . ,                      :        ,     ,   .   -  ,        ,      ,     - .     ,    ,  -         ,       - ,           . ,     ,       ,        ,     ,    ,          .

 ,  -                    ,    - ,            ,   .             ,               ,       ,    ,   ,   ,   .    ,                -    ,          .

  .       ?,       .          , . .  ,   ,  ,         , ,   ,    .      .  ,    ,     ,        ,      .

          ?,       .         ,       ,  ,     ,          .    ,   ,           ,          ,           .          ,          , ,  ,  ,                . ,         ,                         .

    ,   .            ,           .  ,           .    ,       ,        ,       ,     .      ,          -      ,       .              ,          ,  ,        .      ,    ,     ,            ,              . -  ,                .   ,   ,       ,     ,   .           ,      .

,      ,    , - ,    ,     .            ,      .        ,         ,   ,  ,        ,        ,   ,         ,         .   , ,           ,    ,      ,              ,   .      ,    ,            ,    ,     ,             . ,         .

           ,              (theological commitment),     ,             ,       ,      ,  -   [1 -   (Jean Ladri?re)  ,   ,            ,  , ,   ..,     ,  ,        ()  :           .   ,          ,      :            ,   ,      .    ,     ,      (   ),    (J. Ladri?re, Language and Belief (Dublin: Gill and Macmillan, 1972), p. 186).].         ,      ,       (    ,    [2 -            . . :             ,       : ?           (. . 10 ., . 7. .:  , 1957, . 187).]).

       ,        : 1)         ,     :             ,     ( ) ; 2)           ,        .          ,     (   ,          ,    ,      ,    ).   ,      ,       :       ,        -   , ,    (   )   .        ,           ,      ,       ,        ,    .            ,       ,      ,     ,                 [3 -    ,        1940-    Du Refus a lInvocation (   ),  ,      : ..        ,   ,      ,  ,     -    ,            ,       ,  ,    ,    ,         ,       .        ,      ,   ,          (G. Marcel, Du refus a linvocation (Paris, Gallimard, 1940), p. 32.  : .: . ,   . .: (, 2004, . 17.)  ).]. ,         ,      ,    ,       ,          .

                      .         ,       ,     ,           .         ,               .   ,          (  -    ,      ),  ,   :  ,  ?     ?, , ,     ?.            (philo-sophia)    (aletheia),      .         ,     ,  .                    :    ?              ,        .

  ,    ,        .           ,            (certitude ngative),  ,      ,    ,     (   : ,    ,  ,                ).  ,        ,  ,    ,   (multiverse      ),   ,       ,   ,   .      ,     ?  ?     .

    ,     (perennial)   (      ,   -?),      ,       .        ,   ,  ,      .        ;  ,         ,     ,       ,     .  ,    ,  , ,   ,  .                    ,        ( ),    ,         ,       ,      .

        ,    ,    ,    ,          ,      .   ,     ,   ,            ,           .          ,       ,      .      ,        (.     ,    ). ,                 . ,    ,   -,   -,    .                             .

 ,         ,     ,  ,  ,  ,  .    ,            .      ,       ,    . ,    (         ,        )            .          ,     ,         .     ,      ,           ,               - .  ,  ,       -,    -,        . ,  ,           ,        , ,     . ,     ,       ,           .        ,           ,             ,      ,            ,   .            - .        ,  ,        ,      ,     .      ,     .

     ,       .  ,   ,    ,            ,     .     -    ,      ,            .      ,          .   :     .

 ,     ,  ,  ,    ,               ,   ,      (signifies) ,    ,   .  ,             ,          ,     .       ,           ,        .          ,         .        ,    ,         ,        (ousia).           ,  ,    ,    ,   (        ).           :             -        ,  ,          .      ,  ,     ,      ,         ,      ,   ,      [4 -        ,     ,          .    ,      .    ,    ,      .    ,    ,   ,     .     ,          .   ,         ,    ,            .]. ,     ,   ,                    .   ,         ,     ,      ,      .     ,       ,  ,   -        .    ,     ,     . ,    ,       ,     ,                 .  ,    ,              ,  ,      . ,  ,       ,   -         :              .    ,      ,               .         ,     (  ) .

        :   ,                    ,        ,         ,       ?             ,      - ,            .             ,   ,            .  ,            ,   ( )    .      ,     ,        .      ,    ,         ,      ,       ,      ,     ,      ,      ,       ,            [5 -      58          . .].        ,     :    ?          ,     -  .         ,    ,   ,    .     ,          ,           ,    .  ,        ,      .      ,     [6 -          (Janicaud, D., Le tournant thologique de la phnomnologie fran?aise (Combas: ditions de lclat, 1990)),      Phnomnologie et Thologie, J.-F. Courtine (ed.) (Paris: Criterion, 1992),        .],    ,          ,        ,               [7 - Les phnom?nes saturs      ( )         - .      ,        ,     .              .       .    , ,    ,    , ,   ,   ,  .           ,  ,  .            : J.-L. Marion, Le phnom?ne satur en Phnom?nologie et Theologie (Paris: Criterion, 1992), pp. 79128 (  : .-. ,  // . . , . .  (.), () .        . .:  , 2014, . 6399); tant donn. Essai dune phnom?nologie de la donation (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1998); Du sucro?t. Etudes sur les phnomenes saturs (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 2001); Le phnom?ne rotique (Paris: Grasset, 2003).],           ,           .

    ,      ,   - ,   , ,  ,  ,            .  ,         ,          -   .     ,  ,         ,     - ,   ?        ,        ,    ,       (         ,  ,     )?        (     ) ,      (      ),         ,     ,      .  , ,   ,     ,       ,      ,   ,   ,   .               , ,   .  ,  -,   ,     ,   .

  ,          ,     .          .   ,                ,       ,    ,     .     ,  ,      ,     .            ,     . ,      ()   ,     ,       ,    ,       .    ,          ,        (, ,      )       ,   ,            ,          ,         .       ,        ,          ,     .            ,     ,         ,         ,               ,      [8 - . J. Lardriere, Language and Belief, p. 150,   J. Primack, N. E. Abrams, The View from the Centre of the Universe. Discovering our Extraordinary Place in the Cosmos (London: Fourth Estate, 2006), pp. 280290.].

    ,       ,    .   ,    ,    , ,   ,    ,       [9 -       :            ( ),        .               .].      ,            ,        ,      ..[10 - ., , L. M., Krauss, A Universe from Nothing (New York: Free Press, 2012),    7  8.]  ,     ,     ,        ,  -            ,          .       ,  ,     ,     (      - )          -    .           -    ,        -    (       [11 -     :        ,   ,        ,      ,   .                       ,   . (.    P. Nellas, Deification in Christ. Orthodox Perspectives on the Nature of the Human Person (Crestwood: St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1997)).]).     ,          ,     .            ,    ,    ,     ,      ,   ,      (Edmund Husserl)    .         (Karl Jaspers),     ,     ,   ,       ,     -      ,        ,        [12 - .,   . : , 2000, c. 77.].      ,              ,      (Martin Heidegger),   ( - ), ,   ,          -     .    ,    ,    .      ,               ,            .                 .        ,     (   )     (Sein), ,  ,       (Dasein),    [13 -  .],  ,   ,          ,      .   ,     , , - (non-attunement  . . )  -  ,         ,       [14 -    ,              .      96%       ,     ,   ,   ,   ,          .  . ,  ,         (   // . ,     .   . .: , 1998, . 236240).   ,        ,        ,       .].      ,       ,      (perennial) ,      . ,    ,              .          ,          .

 ,         ,    ,    ,           ,  ,   .        ,    .      ,         ,      .  ,            ,   ,         - ,         ,          (thanksgiving)        [15 -      Primack and Abrams, The View from the Centre of the Universe, p. 291,         ,        ,   ,            ,         .].               .       (selfhood)  ( -),         .    ,     ,      ,  . ,  , ,    ,        .   -   -  ,          .    ,    ,   ,         ,            ,             .        ,   .   ,   ,         ,  .       ,      ,  ,    ,     ,     . ,       .    ,     ,     [16 - . , , 264. : , 1999, . 93 (B. Pascal, Penses, 200(347). Tr. Louis Lafuma (Paris: ditions du Seul, 1962).].

    , ,  ,         .        ,        ,      ,     .                    ,    .       ,     ,      ,         [17 - .     - (A. Comte-Sponville, Lesprit de lathisme. Introduction ? une spiritualit sans Dieu (Paris: Albin Michel, 2006)).].      ,           .          ,             ,  ,          .   ,    .               :  ,    , , , ,   ,   ,   ,      [18 - . . ,     .  . .:  Ȼ, 1991, . 81.].                 ,    ,      (        )  - (        ),  ,      ,      [19 - Comte-Sponville, Lesprit de lathisme, pp. 6677, 217.].     ,    ,   , ,        (metanoia)  .   ,   ,           ,       .             ,             .      ,     ,   ,            ,    ,        .          , ,         ,      .         ,               .

          ,    .        :           .  ,        ,   ,  ,   ,           ,   .             (     ),                     .         .         .  ,   ,              ,             [20 -        .  ,  ,          ..        , ,   ,    [] ,    - []   ,     : ,     []   . ,     ,   [ ]  ; ,          (Ambigua 7 [PG 91: 1085B]).     : .  :     . . . . , . . , . . . : - , 2007, . 27, 269.     ,              .    .  ,          :    ,   ,    ,      ,        ,         ,     ,        (.  (),    . . . :  . . , 2007, . 58 (       : . . ,    10 ., . 4. .:  , 1957, . 158)).].      ,   ,            .           ,         .         [21 - .  ,    ():       -    ,     ,         (  . .: -  , 2002, . 171).].

           .   ,   ,    ,     .   ,       ,      ,         ,      .     ,                 :

		    :
		    , .
		 ,  , ?
		    , -
		 .  :  ,
		   ? ?
		   ,
		 ,   ,
		   
		    ;
		    ,
		   ,  , [22 - . ,  . .:  , 2009, . 26.].

          ,  -       ,       ,               ,     ,         ,    .    ,  ,   ,          ,     ,   .            .       ,        ( 3:11),          [23 -      .  :   ,           ,         - ,      (    , , . IV, -  , 1901, . 41);  .  :    ,       .      ,    ,          ,    ,   ( .     , .:  , 2002, . 16).].




           


,        ,   ,     ,       .         ,      ,   .          ,         . , ,              .  ,       ,    ,   ,         .          ,         .  ,              ,     .

    ,        . ,            . ,        ,  ,          .        ,    .       ,         ,         .           (        ),          ,   ,           ,       ,           .    ,        (  ,      ,   . . ).   ,    ,        ,    ,     .  ,       .        ,  ,          ,      .              (           [24 - . Marion, Certitudes ngatives (Paris: Grasset, 2010), . 87137.]),       ?    ,  , ,   ..    ,   .     ,    ,       (  [25 - .  ,       .         (         ?),    (. . ,     // . . . .   . . .: - , 2013, . 230236;  . . ,  .    //    . .: , 2012, . 170192).]).            .   ,          ,  ,     .. .        ,          -.    ,     , ,     ,  .      [26 - .    R. Dawkins, The God Delusion (London: Black Swan, 2007),  V. J. Stenger, God the Failed Hypothesis: How Science Shows that God Does not Exist (NY: Prometheus Books, 2008).],       -[27 - ., , Comte-Sponville, Lesprit de lathisme.],  ,   , ,    ,             ,     ,    [28 -         (C. Yannaras)    The Church in Post-Communist Europe, in The Meaning of Reality. Essays on Existence and Communion, Eros and History (Los Angeles: Sebastian Press & Indiktos, 2011), . 123143.]. ,    ,          ,           . ,    ,               ,                   - .       ,    ,           .         ,           ,  -,    ,  .  ,          ,     ,   ,         ,   .    ,        (,       ,    ,       ).               .          ,     ,        .     ,             .          ,   ,             ,         .

  ,      ,     ,   . ,         ,   -.   ,    ,   ,   ,   ,         .    ,   ,   ,           ,    ,  ,  ,      - .    ,        ,          ;       ,   ,   .         ,   ,          ;            .            ,     ,            .    ,       ,      - .

   ,    .       :         ,     .       ,   :        ,   .     ,   ,     ,  ,   , ,          ,    ,      .                  ,  . ,   ,      ,       ,    ,        [29 -  ,   ,             . : J. Leslie, The End of the World: The Science and Ethics of Human Extinction (New York: Routledge, 1996).       : M. Rees, Our Final Century, A Scientists Warning: How Terror, Error, and Environmental Disaster Threaten Humankinds Future in This Century  On Earth and Beyond (London: W. Heinemann, 2003).].            (   ,     ),           ,         [30 -    50       .   ,        ,          ,      ,      ,  ,       .             ,                ,      :             ,   ?               (CERN).        .      ,           ,  - ,      ,    - .            ,       .       ,  ,   (  ),        ,           - .].

      ,               ,          .      :              ,            [31 - ,     ,      ,        . , ,  ,              .].             , ,   ,     .       . ,         ,    -  (   )   .   ,     ,        ,        .   ,  ,              .    ,   (      ),               [32 -      ,          .       (thought convention),          ,   -    . .  (M. Harwit)      ,              ,    .                    ,      96%             .               .           . (.   M. Harwit, In Search of the True Universe. The Tools, Shaping, Cost of Cosmological Thought (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013), pp. 1624, 152153, 318322).].    ,            ,         ,       .  ,       ,   ,         .                (      4-    ,   ),            , ,         .

     ,      ,          -  ,        ,     - ,            . ,     ,                ,        ,           .

       .       ,     ,      .     :     ,         .         ,     ,                .     ,  - ,            ,  ,        .  , ,         ,         ,         .  ,       ,   .        ,    ,       .       ,           .      ,        .        ,           .         ,      ,  ,        .       ,    ,           [33 - ., : . ,    //   .   . .: - , 1993, . 47. .  . ,      . .: - , 2011, . 100146.]. ,      ,     ,        ,     - .

             ,   .          ,   ,    ,           ,         .           ,    ,              ,      .                  ,              .                  . ,    ,    ,       .           ,    -      .             ,     ,     .   ,     ,  ,     ,      ,    .

    ,           ,    ,         ,   ,          ,        .  ,               -   .  ,          ,   ,    2030        .   ,      ,       ,           .        ,       .        ,        .    , ,          .             .             .  ,    ,   .      .           :                    .      ,      ,              .         ,          .           ,        ,        .    ,     ,      ,       .      ,      ,   ,        (   ),      c    [34 -        ,  ,     ,   ,    ,     (, ).   ,         , ,   .   ,       ,     ,      .].         ,     . ,           ,    ,          ,      ,          [35 - ., ,         : W. B. Drees, A 3x3 Classification of Science-and-Religion. Studies in Science and Theology 4 (1996), pp. 1832; I. G. Barbour, Religion in an Age of Science (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1990); I. G. Barbour Ways of Relating Science and Theology, in Physics, Philosophy and Theology: A Common Quest for Understanding, R. J. Russell et al. (eds.) (Vatican City State: Vatican Observatory, 1988), pp. 2148.].

         .     c :     ,                    -  ,     -     .      -  ,        ,    ,   .           :    ?   ,         ,    ,        .                   ,     .            ,             ,          .          ,   . ,              ,   ,            ,    - .        ,     ,          ,        .

,          ,           .                  ,   .      ,        -     ,   ,        ,      .             ,       ,    ,       ,    .  ,    ,    .  ,                , ,    ,             .          ,     ,  ,       ,           .




     


         ,     .    ,   ,          ad extra,        .     ,     .           .          ,    ,  ,        ,     ,  ,   ,                .       ,                ,   ,  .

         (logos)   (aletheia),    ,      .   ,          ,  ,   ,   (.. )     .     (   )    ,        ,   .      .        ,             ,       .      ,           ,       ,  ,         , ,       ,  .            ,       (-),    ,      (-),    .

        .  ,   ,   (  ,   agape (.)  charitas (.) )   ,        ,  ,   :       [36 - St. Augustine, Contra Faustum, Book 32, 18, NPNF, Ser. 1, vol. 4, p. 581.].              ,         ,    ,              .      .    ,     (. 8.40),   ,        ,  ,   ,      .    -    ,     .   ,       ,       ,       ,   :      ,         ,     ![37 - .  , , . 10, XXIII, 34. .: RENAISSANCE, 1991, . 259.]     ,    ,    ,   ,    ,      .   ,    , ,         ,     ,   [38 - . .  ,  , . 12, XI, 16. .: , 2005, . 86.]. .   -  :     ,    ,   , ,    ,    ,  ,    (vrit)     (charit)[39 - . ,        // . . ,    . .: , 1994, . 449. (.  B. Pascal, De lart de persuader, en Lespirit gometrique et De lart de persuader (Paris: Bordas ditions, 2002) ( , )).]. ,    -      ,          ,       ,     :          [40 - B. Pascal, Penses (tr. Louis Lafuma), 377(280), p. 161.      .     ,   1916 ,      ,     . ,   , ,     ,        ,      ,      ,       .    ,   ,     ,    ,         :        :  ,     ,       :       . (. . . ,    (- ) //   . : , 2004, . 33).       ,           .  ,     ,     ,       ,            ,      (.   . .      . .: , 1996, . 139140.)           : .       ,      ;     -   ,   . (. , . ., . 38).].

,  ,    ,     .    (1 . 4:16)        ,    ,       ,   ,    ( 10:27).  ,     ,   ,   ,     (1 ., 4:20).          ,  ,    ,   ,    ,    ,          , ,          .   ,     ,     ,        .         ,        (. 13:1).          , ,        ,       :      (. 14:6).                      .

     .    ,  ,   ,   (1 . 13:7).  ,     ,    .           : ,    ,    ,     .          ,          :      ,        ,    ,   .          ,    ,   ,        .  ,       ,   .

     ,  ,  ,     ,  ,      .     :   ,   :     ( 10:27). ,  ,  ,        ,     :    ( 9:23),     .                  . ,   . :   ,     ,     ,    (1 . 8:2).    ,   ?          ,    :     ,    (1 . 8:3).     ,   , ,  () ,  ,      ,   .   ,             ,                  ,    .      ,  ,                  ,             .

          ,      ,      par excellence. ,   ,      ,    ,    .       ,                (. 3:19).            (communion).             .            ,     .  ,  ,      ,        .         ,             .        ,   ,              ,      ,      .         ,          (  )          .             .  ,          ,        .              ,             ,                 .




      


      (ecclesial)[41 -        ,        ,     ,    .      ,         ,     .], , ,        ,           ,       ,            .          ,              .                        .       ,      ,   ,   ,   ,      ,     [42 - ,         ,    ,    .    ,             (John Zizioulas)      . .   ,      .          .        , ,          ,    ,  .          .       (. ,   // . .   .      . .: - , 2005, . 532).        ,       ;      , ,    ,            (J. Zizioulas, La vision eucharistique du monde et lhomme contemporain, Contacts, 19 (1967), p. 91. (.           P. McPartlan, The Eucharist Makes the Church: Henri de Lubac and John Zizioulas in Dialogue (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1993), p. 59)).   , ,   ,    ,       .       ,     .               :       ,     ,      ,       .              ,       .       ,    ,       ,                      .           ,           ,           .        ,   ,     (   )     .                     ,         .]                     ,  -        .       ; ,        ,  ,               .

     ?  ,   ,      :      ,     .           :      ?       ,   ?  ,      ,      ,      . ,  ,           ,          , ,     ,  ,  .        ,    ,    .

          ,         .             ,     ,  ,   ,   ,    ,      ,     ,   ,     .     , -     ,   ,        ,   ,   ,     .           .       ,          ,      . ,   ,       ,       [43 - .           ,             ( , XII, 14.22).  ,     ,    ,          (1 . 12:8) ,     ( , XII, 15.25).         -    .     ,      .  ,    ,   ,      ,    , .  ,                (   ),            ,      ( 12:15).            ,         ,                .].            ,         (    ,      ,      ,     ).        .           ,      ,    ,     ,    ,   [44 -   ,          ,     (pleroma)       .  .  ,     ,       ,  ,               []      ,      [],    . (.  ,   ,  16, : I, 1995, . 5556.)].

 ,          , -  ,   ,      .               ,        , ,  ,        .          .      :   ,       ,    ,   .   ,   ,          ,    ,         [45 -  ,          .  ,       ( 2).           ( 7),       ,            : .       5.].       ,       ,            ,           .   ,             ,      ,     [46 - .        . 7 .   .       (pleroma) ,      ,        ,           (   22).  ,         ,     .].

    (   ),  ,     ,   ,             .   ,    ,  ,           ,  .       ,                  ,      .    ,      ,      [47 -           (  -  ),       .].                  ,  ,           .  ,   ,  ,        ,   ,           .          ,              (     ).             ,     ,      ,       - [48 - . Zizioulas, Being as Communion (Crestwood: St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1997), p. 120; . ,   . .: - , 2006, . XXXVII; A. Nesteruk, The Universe as Communion (London: T&T Clark, 2008), p. 217.].

           .    ,     ,       .    ,  ,        ,   .                  ,   .    ,    ,         [49 - ., , G. Marcel, tre et avoir (Paris: Editions Universitaire, 1991).],               ,    ,   .       ,     ,          , ,     .      : ,       ,   ,   [50 - Patriarch Ignatius IV of Antioch, Three Sermons, Sourozh: A Journal of Orthodox Life and Thought 38 (1989), p. 2. .  . ,  . .: - , 2005, . 8.].    ,   ,  ,   .  ,      ,    - ,          .             ,     ,        .




     


            .            ,  ,          ,        ,           .

     ,   ,          , ,  ,   .     ,      ,               .   ,           . ,  ,    ,            ,       ,  .               ,    [51 -       ,      ,           .      ,     ,        - ,      ,      .]. ,      ,     (    ) ,       .           ,               .

        .    ,         ?    ?  .        ,    ,    ?         ,   ,   .      ,         .      ,     .            . ,           .    .  ,   ,            [52 - ., , .  ,    -, 12,   4 . .: -  , 1994, . 1, . 206.]. ,      ,    ,      ,        [53 - ., ,  ,  1.6, 1.13, 1.20. .: -  , 2003, . 1.].     ,   ,          ,       ,          ,      [54 -   ,      ,    ( , Ia, 2,1)       (  , I, 3),        . (.     F. Coplestone, A History of Philosophy, Vol. II, Medieval Philosophy: Augustine to Scotus (London: Burns Oates & Washbourne Ltd., 1950), pp. 336337).].

                ,     ,    .       ,          [55 -     ,     ,  ,   ,       . .   E. Nicolaidis, Science and Eastern Orthodoxy. From the Greek Fathres to the Age of Globalisation (Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, 2011), pp. 93105.].               ,      , .           ,        ,        ,     .    ,      ,          .           ;          ,          .              ,  ,  ,   ,  ,        .   ,    ,    ,         .   ,     ,       ,  ,              ,      ,                .

     ,       ,         ,        :    ,          .        ,      ,         ,    ,  ,        .          ,     ,                  .  ,         (  ),           (  - res extensa),     ,            ,     .        ,            ,    ,        ,            ,     .

      ,                 ,        ,         . ,   ,  ,         . ,    ,   -,       -  ,  .  ,   ,     ,   ,       , ,   ,          ,  ,    .                 (veritas est adaequatio rei et intellectus). ,       ,            .                      ( ), , ,   ,             ().             ,         (   ),               [56 -             (   )       .      ,            ,  ,    ,              .  ,      , ,        ogito ergo sum (. , .,   // , . 2. :  , 2007, c. 11174).           ego         cogito.  ,    ,     ,      ,  ,  ,    .].

         ()          ,           [57 -                ,           .        ,    ,  ,              .].  ,     ,             ,    -        ,        .

                             ,            ,        .  ,      ,                           ,       [58 -       ,       ,  :   ,                (           ,             ),   ,              ? (A. Walker (ed.), Different Gospels (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1988), p. 4).].    ,      ,         ,          (,        ),               , ,        ,   ,              .              ,          : ,               , ,         .  ,                       ,           .          ,     . , ,   ,          .

       ,         ,     [59 - ., , R. Sokolowski, Introduction to Phenomenology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000), p. 198209.].       ,   (  )      .           ,         ,      ,   [60 -      20  .   (Dumitru Staniloae),          ,   ;             ,               (D. Staniloae, Theology and the Church (Crestwood: St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1980), p. 218, 215).          :             ,   ,    蔻.  (   ),   . :  I i, 2004, . 5354.].   ,      .      ,   ,         ,    .      ,        [61 - .  , . 29.].

  ,     -,            ,     ,      -    .    -,     - ,      .                    (  ,         ).  ,           .             ,   ,    [62 -       -  ,      ,    (Radical Orthodoxy).      ., ,  J. K. Smith, Radical Orthodoxy. Mapping a Postsecular Theology (Michigan: Baker Academic, 2004).            : A. Pabst, C. Schneider (eds.) Encounter Between Eastern Orthodoxy and Radical Orthodoxy. Transfiguring the World Through the Word (Farnham: Ashgate, 2009).].

 ,  ,     ,      c   (   ).           :       .  ,     ,      ,          ,     ,     ,          [63 -        . . :        ,              ,       (. ,     , . 81 (   . .))].      ,          ,      ,    ,         ,   ,   ,    ,         [64 -       -  (), ,             ,    ,       ,   ,    ,   ,   ,    ,    ,     ,   .  -  () ,    . .: , 2003, . 15. (.   . ,    // . , 1989,  3, . 2536).]. ,    ,           ,     .      ,             .   (: diairesis) .          ,          [65 - .                .        ,        .  ,    ,   , : L. Thunberg, Microcosm and Mediator: The Theological Anthropology of Maximus the Confessor (Chicago: Open Court, 1995); J.-C. Larchet, La Divinisation de lhomme selon Saint Maxime le Confesseur (Paris, Les Editions du Cerf, 1996).       ,      : . . ,  :       VII . .: , 2007; T. T. Tollefsen, The Christocentric Cosmology of St. Maximus the Confessor (Oxford University Press, 2008).].             ,   .        ,        ,            .      ,   ,     ,          ,  ,  ,       ,        [66 - ,            ,               .      :  ,        .           ,   ,          .    ,      ,   , ,  ,           (J. Chela-Flores, Fitness of the cosmos for the origin and evolution of life: from biochemical fine-tuning to the Anthropic Principle, in J. Barrow, J., Morris, S., Freeland, S., Harper, Ch. (eds.) Fitness of the Cosmos for Life. Biochemistry and Fine-Tuninng (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008). p. 155).].

            ,     ,           ,     ,      [67 -   ,        ,           ;  :                 (  )    (Walker, Different Gospels, p. 4).               ,      ,     (Ibid., p. 1).].              ,    ,   ? (. 9:25; . . 16:26).     ,                 ,       ?       -        [68 -   ,   ,     .        (T. Torrance):  -    ,      .       -  ,       (. Walker, Different Gospels, p. 52).              , ,   ..                     ,      ,     ,     . .    :          ,  - ,         ,           .  ,           ,    (Staniloae, Theology and the Church, p. 216217).].                 ,    ,          .  ,          ,              .           ,     (   )            .    ,          ,    ,  ,     , ,   ,         .          ,       .      ,   ,  :      ,      ,       ,    .     (,       ),     ,        ,    .            ,            ,           ,     .          ,   ,   .

            : ,    ,    -   [69 - . ,  ( XVI),    .     . .: - , 2007, . 40.].     ,    ,      ,          .          [70 -         .        ,      ,       .       ,   ,     ,     .        ,      (    ,   ,           ). .   ,          (theologia civilis  theologia fabulosa   ()    (, ) ),     theologia naturalis ( ),       ,     .     ,        theologia   ,    .     ,      .  ,       , ,   ,    ,    (. ,   , VIII, 1. .: - - , 1994,  II, c. 2).   ,  ,      ,           .   ,    -,     ,      . (. .-. ,   //: , , -16:2 (2012), . 213226).].         .

  ,    ,        ,  .               . ,     ,             (H. Albert)[71 - .  . ,    . .:  , 2010,              .],            ,     ,    .          .              ,   ,    ,            .          .       ,         , , .          ,      .       ,         .       ,      :            ,  ,     ,          ?   ,       ,    ,           ,    ?  ,          ?                       [72 - ., ,  .  (H. Kung)     . : H. K?ng, Does God Exist? An Answer for Today (London: SCM, 1978), pp. 32439, 439451.].                .

       ,   ,        (  )       .                  .       ,              ,         .  ,            ,     ,      ,      .             ,        .        ,            .             ,    ,       ,        .      ,      .               ,   ,    .             :                .




    


              ,    ,       ,    ,  ,      ,        .         ,         . ,      ,     , (,   ,        ),   ,         .  ,           .          ,          [73 -  ,   ,        ,       .  ,      ,        ,   (Erste Philosophie),   (Zur Ph?nomenologie der Intersubjektivit?t)           . (.    R. A. Mall, The God of Phenomenology in Comparative Contrast to that of Philosophy and Theology, Husserl Studies 8 (1991), pp. 115. .   E. Housset, Pesonne et sujet selon Husserl (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1997), pp. 265290,             . .   A. Bello, The Divine in Husserl and Other Explorations, Analecta Husserliana XCVIII (Dordrecht: Springer, 2009).        , .  :           ,    ,       ,          , ,   .      ,   .           .      (Mall, The God of Phenomenology, p. 13).].      ,          [74 - . ,       ,  1.     . .:   , 1999, . 128.].        ,      .  (D. Janicaud, 19372002)   [75 - D. Janicaud, Le tournant thologique de la phnomnologie fran?aise.].    ,    ,       .                    .  ,     :   ,    ,      ,           .  ,   ,     ,   . ,   ,   :      ,       ,    ?      ,      ,   ?         ,  ,  ,  . ,    ,      ,           (   ,      ,                  ,                  ). ,     :     ,                 ;          ,        [76 - . , ,   . .: - , 2010, . 119.]. ,  ,      ,    ,  ,     ,  ? ,  ,     ,        ?    ,   -  -, -?      ,   ,     , c      ,  ,   ,   ,         ?[77 - ., , J.-L. Marion, De Sucro?t; J. K. Smith, Speech and Theology. Language and the Logic of Incarnation (London: Routledge, 2002).]

,    ,                .           ,    ,       .      ,   ,      ,      ,               [78 - .:           .   ,       .    ,            . ,       , , ,      , , ,      ,     ( ,   , . 4445).].

,          ,     .            ,     .             ,  ,      .                   ,       .    ,       ,      .     ,       .  ,           ,       ,       .    ,     ,    ,    ,  ,     .




         


   , ,             ,   -   .        -       ,  ad extra (      ),               .  ,       ,           ,          .  ,    ,    ,      ,    ,   ,   ,      ,        .              ,       [79 -     -- (Jos Ortega y Gasset)   :        ,     .       , ,      ,     .   ,   ,   ,     (Jos Ortega y Gasset, Man and Crisis (London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd, 1959), p. 122).].    ,      ,         .          ,     ,           .          ,         .     ,             ,     ,        .

  ,       ,     ,      ,    ,        ,   , ,  ,         .        ,     ,   ,    .  ,              ,   - ,    ,    ,            .        [80 - ,  , . 15. .  ,   , . 6.],    ,         ,        .       ,    ,   ,         ,   ,         ,          .     ,            . ,   ,                 (,  ,         ),       ,                 ,      .      ,         .

  ,    ,     ,        .      (diairesis)   ,     .               - ,      ,  .    ,     ,           , -    . ,   ,     (          )   ,            ,        ,     ,     .      ,    ,   ,   ,      - ,    .

    ,    ,         ,       ,     ,      .       ,       ,         ?            .        [81 - ,    ,  , ,   Nellas, Deification in Christ, pp. 23104.].       ,    ,   ,         ,     ,           ,  ,       ,        .        ,     ,     .               ,       .  ,      ,         .   ,        ,          .      .    41-    (Ambigua)    (diairesis)   .              ,    ,      ,      ,   (telos)      .   ,          ,       .      ,       ,  ,     ,          ,     ,     .         ,     ,                  [82 -           (),        :         ,      ,      .      , ..  .      ,      (. . ,  ,  .  2 ., . 1. .: , 1993, . 182).    ,  ,        .   ,           ,       ( , . 188).].  .                ,   .       ,        ,     ,   .                 [83 - Ambigua 45, [PG 91, 1353C-1356A] [:   :         (). .:  ,    . , 2006, . 321322].].    ,         ,          .       ,      ,     ( 3:19),       ,    .      ,      ,   .        ,       ,        .       ,      [84 - ,  , . 21.].

      ,   ,     ,     .   -:  -       ,    ,           .    :    ,    ,    .      , ,       ,          ,      ,   .  ,         ,       ,     ,        .       ,     .   . :            ,         [85 - ,  , c. 23.].         :          ,     .             ,            ,      .          ,   ,     -,     ,        [86 - C      : .  (.),      .        .  I . .: , 2003; .  (.):     .   . .: , 2008.].         ,     ,    ,       ,         ,      ,    ,      [87 - ,  , c. 23.].    ,       ,         ,         ,       .  ,  ,       ,      ,    ,   ,   ,  .          :   - ,         .          ,          .

    ,           .  ,            ,          ,      ,           .        ,                 ,     ,       [88 - . .  , Homiliae in Genesin 29: 3 [PG 53: 264265].].                               ,           ,                .    ,          ,    ,                 .

  ,       ,    ,      ,       ,        ,    .          ,  ,       ,  ,          ,  ,     .     ,     ,                .      ,                 ,      ,         .                .                      , ,  ,   ,          ( ),          .     ,    . ,           ,         ,  [89 - ,  , . 211.].          -   , -[90 -  .];        ,    [91 -  , . 192.].     ,         ,     ,  .     -:     ,   ,    ,       .

  ,               (   ,   ),             ,          ,           .




     


              credo. -      ,        ,        .   ,                 ,   ,    ,   .   ,          ,           .               :         ,  ,  ,      ,               .    ,    ,       . ,         ,         .                        .           ,  ,  ,       ,        .        ,          :     ,            ,             (diastema




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=52001921)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


  (Jean Ladri?re)  ,   ,            ,  , ,   ..,     ,  ,        ()  :           .   ,          ,      :            ,   ,      .    ,     ,      (   ),    (J. Ladri?re, Language and Belief (Dublin: Gill and Macmillan, 1972), p. 186).




2


           . . :             ,       : ?           (. . 10 ., . 7. .:  , 1957, . 187).




3


   ,        1940-    Du Refus a lInvocation (   ),  ,      : ..        ,   ,      ,  ,     -    ,            ,       ,  ,    ,    ,         ,       .        ,      ,   ,          (G. Marcel, Du refus a linvocation (Paris, Gallimard, 1940), p. 32.  : .: . ,   . .: (, 2004, . 17.)  ).




4


       ,     ,          .    ,      .    ,    ,      .    ,    ,   ,     .     ,          .   ,         ,    ,            .




5


     58          . .




6


         (Janicaud, D., Le tournant thologique de la phnomnologie fran?aise (Combas: ditions de lclat, 1990)),      Phnomnologie et Thologie, J.-F. Courtine (ed.) (Paris: Criterion, 1992),        .




7


Les phnom?nes saturs      ( )         - .      ,        ,     .              .       .    , ,    ,    , ,   ,   ,  .           ,  ,  .            : J.-L. Marion, Le phnom?ne satur en Phnom?nologie et Theologie (Paris: Criterion, 1992), pp. 79128 (  : .-. ,  // . . , . .  (.), () .        . .:  , 2014, . 6399); tant donn. Essai dune phnom?nologie de la donation (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1998); Du sucro?t. Etudes sur les phnomenes saturs (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 2001); Le phnom?ne rotique (Paris: Grasset, 2003).




8


. J. Lardriere, Language and Belief, p. 150,   J. Primack, N. E. Abrams, The View from the Centre of the Universe. Discovering our Extraordinary Place in the Cosmos (London: Fourth Estate, 2006), pp. 280290.




9


      :            ( ),        .               .




10


., , L. M., Krauss, A Universe from Nothing (New York: Free Press, 2012),    7  8.




11


    :        ,   ,        ,      ,   .                       ,   . (.    P. Nellas, Deification in Christ. Orthodox Perspectives on the Nature of the Human Person (Crestwood: St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1997)).




12


.,   . : , 2000, c. 77.




13


 .




14


   ,              .      96%       ,     ,   ,   ,   ,          .  . ,  ,         (   // . ,     .   . .: , 1998, . 236240).   ,        ,        ,       .




15


     Primack and Abrams, The View from the Centre of the Universe, p. 291,         ,        ,   ,            ,         .




16


. , , 264. : , 1999, . 93 (B. Pascal, Penses, 200(347). Tr. Louis Lafuma (Paris: ditions du Seul, 1962).




17


.     - (A. Comte-Sponville, Lesprit de lathisme. Introduction ? une spiritualit sans Dieu (Paris: Albin Michel, 2006)).




18


. . ,     .  . .:  Ȼ, 1991, . 81.




19


Comte-Sponville, Lesprit de lathisme, pp. 6677, 217.




20


       .  ,  ,          ..        , ,   ,    [] ,    - []   ,     : ,     []   . ,     ,   [ ]  ; ,          (Ambigua 7 [PG 91: 1085B]).     : .  :     . . . . , . . , . . . : - , 2007, . 27, 269.     ,              .    .  ,          :    ,   ,    ,      ,        ,         ,     ,        (.  (),    . . . :  . . , 2007, . 58 (       : . . ,    10 ., . 4. .:  , 1957, . 158)).




21


.  ,    ():       -    ,     ,         (  . .: -  , 2002, . 171).




22


. ,  . .:  , 2009, . 26.




23


     .  :   ,           ,         - ,      (    , , . IV, -  , 1901, . 41);  .  :    ,       .      ,    ,          ,    ,   ( .     , .:  , 2002, . 16).




24


. Marion, Certitudes ngatives (Paris: Grasset, 2010), . 87137.




25


.  ,       .         (         ?),    (. . ,     // . . . .   . . .: - , 2013, . 230236;  . . ,  .    //    . .: , 2012, . 170192).




26


.    R. Dawkins, The God Delusion (London: Black Swan, 2007),  V. J. Stenger, God the Failed Hypothesis: How Science Shows that God Does not Exist (NY: Prometheus Books, 2008).




27


., , Comte-Sponville, Lesprit de lathisme.




28


        (C. Yannaras)    The Church in Post-Communist Europe, in The Meaning of Reality. Essays on Existence and Communion, Eros and History (Los Angeles: Sebastian Press & Indiktos, 2011), . 123143.




29


 ,   ,             . : J. Leslie, The End of the World: The Science and Ethics of Human Extinction (New York: Routledge, 1996).       : M. Rees, Our Final Century, A Scientists Warning: How Terror, Error, and Environmental Disaster Threaten Humankinds Future in This Century  On Earth and Beyond (London: W. Heinemann, 2003).




30


   50       .   ,        ,          ,      ,      ,  ,       .             ,                ,      :             ,   ?               (CERN).        .      ,           ,  - ,      ,    - .            ,       .       ,  ,   (  ),        ,           - .




31


,     ,      ,        . , ,  ,              .




32


     ,          .       (thought convention),          ,   -    . .  (M. Harwit)      ,              ,    .                    ,      96%             .               .           . (.   M. Harwit, In Search of the True Universe. The Tools, Shaping, Cost of Cosmological Thought (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013), pp. 1624, 152153, 318322).




33


., : . ,    //   .   . .: - , 1993, . 47. .  . ,      . .: - , 2011, . 100146.




34


       ,  ,     ,   ,    ,     (, ).   ,         , ,   .   ,       ,     ,      .




35


., ,         : W. B. Drees, A 3x3 Classification of Science-and-Religion. Studies in Science and Theology 4 (1996), pp. 1832; I. G. Barbour, Religion in an Age of Science (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1990); I. G. Barbour Ways of Relating Science and Theology, in Physics, Philosophy and Theology: A Common Quest for Understanding, R. J. Russell et al. (eds.) (Vatican City State: Vatican Observatory, 1988), pp. 2148.




36


St. Augustine, Contra Faustum, Book 32, 18, NPNF, Ser. 1, vol. 4, p. 581.




37


.  , , . 10, XXIII, 34. .: RENAISSANCE, 1991, . 259.




38


. .  ,  , . 12, XI, 16. .: , 2005, . 86.




39


. ,        // . . ,    . .: , 1994, . 449. (.  B. Pascal, De lart de persuader, en Lespirit gometrique et De lart de persuader (Paris: Bordas ditions, 2002) ( , )).




40


B. Pascal, Penses (tr. Louis Lafuma), 377(280), p. 161.      .     ,   1916 ,      ,     . ,   , ,     ,        ,      ,      ,       .    ,   ,     ,    ,         :        :  ,     ,       :       . (. . . ,    (- ) //   . : , 2004, . 33).       ,           .  ,     ,     ,       ,            ,      (.   . .      . .: , 1996, . 139140.)           : .       ,      ;     -   ,   . (. , . ., . 38).




41


       ,        ,     ,    .      ,         ,     .




42


,         ,    ,    .    ,             (John Zizioulas)      . .   ,      .          .        , ,          ,    ,  .          .       (. ,   // . .   .      . .: - , 2005, . 532).        ,       ;      , ,    ,            (J. Zizioulas, La vision eucharistique du monde et lhomme contemporain, Contacts, 19 (1967), p. 91. (.           P. McPartlan, The Eucharist Makes the Church: Henri de Lubac and John Zizioulas in Dialogue (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1993), p. 59)).   , ,   ,    ,       .       ,     .               :       ,     ,      ,       .              ,       .       ,    ,       ,                      .           ,           ,           .        ,   ,     (   )     .                     ,         .




43


.           ,             ( , XII, 14.22).  ,     ,    ,          (1 . 12:8) ,     ( , XII, 15.25).         -    .     ,      .  ,    ,   ,      ,    , .  ,                (   ),            ,      ( 12:15).            ,         ,                .




44


  ,          ,     (pleroma)       .  .  ,     ,       ,  ,               []      ,      [],    . (.  ,   ,  16, : I, 1995, . 5556.)




45


 ,          .  ,       ( 2).           ( 7),       ,            : .       5.




46


.        . 7 .   .       (pleroma) ,      ,        ,           (   22).  ,         ,     .




47


          (  -  ),       .




48


. Zizioulas, Being as Communion (Crestwood: St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1997), p. 120; . ,   . .: - , 2006, . XXXVII; A. Nesteruk, The Universe as Communion (London: T&T Clark, 2008), p. 217.




49


., , G. Marcel, tre et avoir (Paris: Editions Universitaire, 1991).




50


Patriarch Ignatius IV of Antioch, Three Sermons, Sourozh: A Journal of Orthodox Life and Thought 38 (1989), p. 2. .  . ,  . .: - , 2005, . 8.




51


      ,      ,           .      ,     ,        - ,      ,      .




52


., , .  ,    -, 12,   4 . .: -  , 1994, . 1, . 206.




53


., ,  ,  1.6, 1.13, 1.20. .: -  , 2003, . 1.




54


  ,      ,    ( , Ia, 2,1)       (  , I, 3),        . (.     F. Coplestone, A History of Philosophy, Vol. II, Medieval Philosophy: Augustine to Scotus (London: Burns Oates & Washbourne Ltd., 1950), pp. 336337).




55


    ,     ,  ,   ,       . .   E. Nicolaidis, Science and Eastern Orthodoxy. From the Greek Fathres to the Age of Globalisation (Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, 2011), pp. 93105.




56


            (   )       .      ,            ,  ,    ,              .  ,      , ,        ogito ergo sum (. , .,   // , . 2. :  , 2007, c. 11174).           ego         cogito.  ,    ,     ,      ,  ,  ,    .




57


               ,           .        ,    ,  ,              .




58


      ,       ,  :   ,                (           ,             ),   ,              ? (A. Walker (ed.), Different Gospels (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1988), p. 4).




59


., , R. Sokolowski, Introduction to Phenomenology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000), p. 198209.




60


     20  .   (Dumitru Staniloae),          ,   ;             ,               (D. Staniloae, Theology and the Church (Crestwood: St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1980), p. 218, 215).          :             ,   ,    蔻.  (   ),   . :  I i, 2004, . 5354.




61


.  , . 29.




62


      -  ,      ,    (Radical Orthodoxy).      ., ,  J. K. Smith, Radical Orthodoxy. Mapping a Postsecular Theology (Michigan: Baker Academic, 2004).            : A. Pabst, C. Schneider (eds.) Encounter Between Eastern Orthodoxy and Radical Orthodoxy. Transfiguring the World Through the Word (Farnham: Ashgate, 2009).




63


       . . :        ,              ,       (. ,     , . 81 (   . .))




64


      -  (), ,             ,    ,       ,   ,    ,   ,   ,    ,    ,     ,   .  -  () ,    . .: , 2003, . 15. (.   . ,    // . , 1989,  3, . 2536).




65


.                .        ,        .  ,    ,   , : L. Thunberg, Microcosm and Mediator: The Theological Anthropology of Maximus the Confessor (Chicago: Open Court, 1995); J.-C. Larchet, La Divinisation de lhomme selon Saint Maxime le Confesseur (Paris, Les Editions du Cerf, 1996).       ,      : . . ,  :       VII . .: , 2007; T. T. Tollefsen, The Christocentric Cosmology of St. Maximus the Confessor (Oxford University Press, 2008).




66


,            ,               .      :  ,        .           ,   ,          .    ,      ,   , ,  ,           (J. Chela-Flores, Fitness of the cosmos for the origin and evolution of life: from biochemical fine-tuning to the Anthropic Principle, in J. Barrow, J., Morris, S., Freeland, S., Harper, Ch. (eds.) Fitness of the Cosmos for Life. Biochemistry and Fine-Tuninng (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008). p. 155).




67


  ,        ,           ;  :                 (  )    (Walker, Different Gospels, p. 4).               ,      ,     (Ibid., p. 1).




68


  ,   ,     .        (T. Torrance):  -    ,      .       -  ,       (. Walker, Different Gospels, p. 52).              , ,   ..                     ,      ,     ,     . .    :          ,  - ,         ,           .  ,           ,    (Staniloae, Theology and the Church, p. 216217).




69


. ,  ( XVI),    .     . .: - , 2007, . 40.




70


        .        ,      ,       .       ,   ,     ,     .        ,      (    ,   ,           ). .   ,          (theologia civilis  theologia fabulosa   ()    (, ) ),     theologia naturalis ( ),       ,     .     ,        theologia   ,    .     ,      .  ,       , ,   ,    ,    (. ,   , VIII, 1. .: - - , 1994,  II, c. 2).   ,  ,      ,           .   ,    -,     ,      . (. .-. ,   //: , , -16:2 (2012), . 213226).




71


.  . ,    . .:  , 2010,              .




72


., ,  .  (H. Kung)     . : H. K?ng, Does God Exist? An Answer for Today (London: SCM, 1978), pp. 32439, 439451.




73


 ,   ,        ,       .  ,      ,        ,   (Erste Philosophie),   (Zur Ph?nomenologie der Intersubjektivit?t)           . (.    R. A. Mall, The God of Phenomenology in Comparative Contrast to that of Philosophy and Theology, Husserl Studies 8 (1991), pp. 115. .   E. Housset, Pesonne et sujet selon Husserl (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1997), pp. 265290,             . .   A. Bello, The Divine in Husserl and Other Explorations, Analecta Husserliana XCVIII (Dordrecht: Springer, 2009).        , .  :           ,    ,       ,          , ,   .      ,   .           .      (Mall, The God of Phenomenology, p. 13).




74


. ,       ,  1.     . .:   , 1999, . 128.




75


D. Janicaud, Le tournant thologique de la phnomnologie fran?aise.




76


. , ,   . .: - , 2010, . 119.




77


., , J.-L. Marion, De Sucro?t; J. K. Smith, Speech and Theology. Language and the Logic of Incarnation (London: Routledge, 2002).




78


.:           .   ,       .    ,            . ,       , , ,      , , ,      ,     ( ,   , . 4445).




79


    -- (Jos Ortega y Gasset)   :        ,     .       , ,      ,     .   ,   ,   ,     (Jos Ortega y Gasset, Man and Crisis (London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd, 1959), p. 122).




80


,  , . 15. .  ,   , . 6.




81


,    ,  , ,   Nellas, Deification in Christ, pp. 23104.




82


          (),        :         ,      ,      .      , ..  .      ,      (. . ,  ,  .  2 ., . 1. .: , 1993, . 182).    ,  ,        .   ,           ,       ( , . 188).




83


Ambigua 45, [PG 91, 1353C-1356A] [:   :         (). .:  ,    . , 2006, . 321322].




84


,  , . 21.




85


,  , c. 23.




86


C      : .  (.),      .        .  I . .: , 2003; .  (.):     .   . .: , 2008.




87


,  , c. 23.




88


. .  , Homiliae in Genesin 29: 3 [PG 53: 264265].




89


,  , . 211.




90


 .




91


 , . 192.


