   .        
 


Historia Rossica
      .                   .         ,       ,          .     ,          ,   .   ,     XIX         .    ,  , ,     ,  ,        ,   II.  ,  ,                ,  .   ,  ,    ,        .      ,     ,    , ,    .





 

           








           ,   - ,    ,     ,    ,            .      ,  , -  ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,    .

         ,       . ߠ      ,      , ,       .    ,    .              ,    .     ,  ,   ,    렖    ,    .           ,    .       ,    ,         .         .

ߠ   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,  , .  ,  ,  ,  .

        .


    ,          ,    ,   .   []  ,    ,       ,    . Ƞ     ,  , ,        .   ,  ,  .

 2: 213 ( .-. )

, ,            , , ,  , ,     ,  , ...           . .

   , 1809









        .      ,      .            .         蠫 .     ,  ,         :       .    , , ,  .  XV.          . ʠ .      20 ,      (15%  ).     -       .      ,       .

           .    (  17621796)        ,   .   ,            .          -,   ,   ,  ,     .          .           젖      , , ,  .         ,   ,  .      ,  ,        . ,           .

       . , ,     , ,   ,         ,       ,       .    . II (  18941917)       ,   ,    -  ,    .

  ,        ,       .       ,       , ,  .          .       , ,  ,      .        ( -), ,        .       ,   ,              .   ,     頖      ,        ,     .

             ,            .        .   ,      ,     ,    .     ,         ,   -    [1 - Zemon DavisN. Society and Culture In Early Modern France. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1975. P.152187. Π .: PolitkovskayaA. A Small Corner of Hell: Dispatches from Chechnya/ Transl. Alexander Burry and Tatiana Tulchinsky. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003. P.9194 ( : ..  . .:, 2003.. .).].            . ,   젖 ,    . Ѡ   ,  ,      1990?.               .      ,      ,   .

          .           . ʠ XVI.       .        ,         , ,        蠖       .   XVIIXVIII.         .  XIX.,    ,         .  18201860?.      .           ,              (. 1). ʠ  .     ,     .        .      XVII    .  ,           .

              .   ,         ,     [2 - ., : BaberowskiJ. Der Feind ist ?berall: Stalinismus im Kaukasus. Munich: Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt, 2003.].           ,        .  ,    ,   ,     .         ,  ,   ,  ,    .     -   ,      ,       .

            ,  ,  ,     ,  ,        .  ,            .  1980?.              ,    -    .      ,         [3 - Π  , ,      .: McChesneyR.D. Central Asia: Foundations of Change. Princeton, NJ: Darwin Press, 1996. P.3.       ,               . ., : BennigsenA., HenzeP.B., TanhamG.K., WimbushS.E. Soviet Strategy and Islam. Houndsmills, UK: Macmillan, 1989,   : BullietR. The Case for Islamo-Christian Civilization. New York: Columbia University Press, 2004.].

           1991.,         .       -         .    ,          , , ,  .  , ,          .  ,         .       ,    -  ,         ,         頖             [4 - .: Abu ZahabM., Roy O. Rseaux Islamiques: La connexion afghano-pakistanaise. Paris: Autrement, 2002; Rashid A. Jihad: The Rise of Militant Islam in Central Asia. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2002;    :  / . ., . . .:  , 2001; Uzbekistan: The Andijon Uprising// International Crisis Group Asia Briefing. 2005. No.38. May 25.].

       ,   . Ѡ ,     ,         . Ѡ ,         ,     .             ,    .

               .    -   ,  ,               XVIII    . ߠ ,                  堖 .       1917.    ,      ,               ,    ,  ,    .      .    ,       [5 - .: WortmanR.S. Scenarios of Power: Myth and Ceremony In Russian Monarchy. 2vols. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995, 2000 (. . .: .  .    .  2./ . .. .:, 2004.. .).].        ,           [6 - .: KappelerA. Russland als Vielv?lkerreich: Entstehung, Geschichte, Zerfall. 2nd ed. Munich: C.H.Beck, 1993; LievenD. Empire: The Russian Empire and Its Rivals. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2001; LeDonneJ.P. The Russian Empire and the World, 17001917: The Geopolitics of Expansion and Containment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.].   ,                ,    ,     .

 ,             .         (16131917)    .   XVIII.       , , , ,     .           ,            .       ⠖ ,   頖  ,   .          頖  蠖  ,      ,    .             . ,      ,            .  ,   ,          [7 - ., : SunyR.G. The Empire Strikes Out: Imperial Russia, National Identity, and Theories of Empire// A State of Nations: Empire and Nation-Making in the Age of Lenin and Stalin/ Eds R.G.Suny, T.Martin. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001. P.2366; . : SlocumJ.W. Who, and When, Were the Inorodtsy? The Evolution of the Category of Aliens in Imperial Russia// Russian Review. 1998. 57. No.2 (April). P.173190.].      ,            ,  ,            1917.;   ,    ,  modus operandi   ,  . Ѡ    ,        蠖 .       -   ,   ,      .   ,     .       .   .      .    ,   -       .     XVII. ,   ,           ,      .

  ,    ,    ,          ,    砖    ,  ,      ,   ,     .   ,     .        ,        .             ,             . ʠ    ,       ,        ?        .   ,    ,     ,    .

 , ,   .           .  ,      . Ѡ XVIII.            .      , , , ,       .      ,        ,   -  ,   ,      .   XVIIIXIX.   -.         ,        .           ,       .  蠖 ,       .      ,           , , ,     ,    .      ,      .

     ,        , ,         .   ,     ,          .       ,            ,   ,     ?      .        ,     ,    ,     .        ,  , ,   .      ,     .

Ƞ  ,      :      ,  .   ,       ,      .       ,   ,          .  ,  ,      . Ӡ       ,      ,  ,    ,        ,         .     :            ,         ,      [8 - BullietR. Islam: The View from the Edge. New York: Columbia University Press, 1994. P.194.].          ,          ࠖ    .

         .         ,      ; ,  ,     [9 -          2004.].           . ʠ .     , ,      .    -     .           (   VII.  );            .    ,    ,   ,   [10 - .: DeWeeseD. Islamization and Native Religion In the Golden Horde: Baba T?kles and Conversion to Islam In Historical and Epic Tradition. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1994; FrankA.J. Varieties of Islamization In Inner Asia: The Case of the Baraba Tatars, 17401917// Cahiers du monde russe. 2000. 41. No.23 (AprilSeptember). P.245262.]. XV.       ,      .

堖      .    -          . ʠ            .              . ʠ 1820?.  I (  18011825) I (18251855)      ,      .           ,         .  1834 1859.              ,              . ʠ XIX.          .   ,     , ,   ;      ,    .

     ,  ,    .     ,           ,   ,       .        .         ,  .    ,       ,               ,   .                   .          -,      ,      .

ʠ XIX.        (  ).            : ,  , , , ,    ().  ࠖ        -   .  1897.            ,     ,    ,       .           .      ,   ,    ,    .

  ,       ,       .   1897.,       ,  .       - .         (   ) 蠫  (  );         [11 -   :  , , / . ... .: , 2001. .324327.].  ,            ,      ,,         .               .       ,  ,   蠖   .          ,         .

  ,               .  XVI.           ,    .  XVIII.        .          ,    ,         .      ,   ( )  ,         . ,    ,   ,      .         I    ,     .              (18531856)     [12 - ., : BrooksW. Russias Conquest and Pacification of the Caucasus: Relocation Becomes a Pogrom in the Post-Crimean War Period// Nationalities Papers. 1995. 23. No.4. P.675686; ReynoldsM.A. Muslim Mobilization in Imperial Russias Caucasus// Islam and the European Empires/ Ed. D.Motadel. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014. P.187212.].

, ,                  .     ,   .           .         ,   ,          .            .

       .     ,     ,   ,       .     :        , ,     ,       19441945..      ,  .     ,      ⠫  ( -),            ⠫   .       ,    , -,  -    ,    .                .            ,     . ʠ1860?.             21.               .   XIX  .           [13 - MazowerM. Violence and the State in the Twentieth Century// American Historical Review. 2002. 107. No.4. October. P.11581178, .  .1163.       .: KemperM. Khalidiyya Networks in Daghestan and the Question of Jihad// Die Welt des Islams. 2002. 42. No.1. P.4171; Habi?ogluB. Kafkasyadan Anadoluya G??ler ve Iskanlari. Istanbul: Nart Yayincilik, 1993; MeyerJ. Turks Across Empires: Marketing Muslim Identity in the RussianOttoman Borderlands. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.   ,      1891 1904.  312 000: SwietochowskiT. Russia and Azerbaijan: ABorderland in Transition. New York: Columbia University Press, 1991. P.1022. Π       ., : . .400. .1. .2329, 3692, 4009; . .187. .485. .684; SiegelJ. Endgame: Britain, Russia and the Final Struggle for Central Asia. London: Tauris, 2002; ..       . .: , 2009.].

      ,    , ,    ,   .       , ,  ,          . ,           ,    ,    ,      . ,  ,  堖   ,   .  XIX.     ,     ,      .  ,         .

          .       ,      ,    .          ,     ,      .          .  𠖠     1820?  1850?.,  ?          .               ,          ,     .      ,   . ,    ,             ,   . Ѡ                 ;        ,     ,         ,      [14 -      -    ⠫    ,       ,      ,       . .: KhalidA. The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform: Jadidism in Central Asia. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998;        .: KemperM. Herrschaft, Recht und Islam in Daghestan: Von den Khanaten und Gemeindeb?nden zum gihad-Staat. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag, 2005. . : .., .., .. .    :  . .:, 2017.].

              .      ,      ,   ,  .        ,      .            ,      .       ,     ,     ,     ,  . ,   ,   .       .          XVIII    .     ,       .          .           .       ,          .        ,   ,      ,     , ,   ,     [15 - Kennan Jr. E. L. Muscovy and Kazan: Some Introductory Remarks on the Patterns of Steppe Diplomacy// Slavic Review. 1967. 26. No.4 (December). P.548558; WhiteR. The Middle Ground: Indians, Empires, and Republics in the Great Lakes Region, 16501815. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991. P.52.].

    .         ,   .  ,      ,             .             .              .   .                     .      .  1898. II     ,   ,   .             ,    [16 - .: Napoleon in Egypt: Al Jabartis Chronicle of the First Seven Months of the French Occupation, 1798/ Ed. R.Tignor, transl. Sh. Moreh. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener, 1993; Molla und Diplomat: Der Bericht des Eb? Sehil Num?n Efendi ?ber die ?sterreichisch-osmanische Grenzziehung nach dem Belgrader Frieden 1740/1741/ Transl. and ed. E.Prokosch. Graz: Verlag Styria, 1972. S.9192. Π      - .: Motadel. Islam and the European Empires; Sel?uk Esenbel. Japans Global Claim to Asia and the World of Islam. American Historical Review. 2004. 109. No.4 (October). P.11401170; Naimur Rahman Farooqi. Pan-Islamism in the Nineteenth Century. Islamic Culture. 1983. 57. No.4 (October). P.283296; FischerF. Germanys Aims in the First World War. New York: W.W.Norton, 1967, .  .121. Π    (puissance musulmane) .: RobinsonD. Paths of Accommodation: Muslim Societies and French Colonial Authorities in Senegal and Mauritania, 18801920. Athens: Ohio University Press, 2000;   .: DoniaR.J. Islam under the Double Eagle: The Muslims of Bosnia and Hercegovina, 18781914. New York: Columbia University Press, 1981.].

 ,   ,       ,         . Ƞ ,      ,         ,  .   ,         ;                    .

  ,    ,           .          ,  ,   ,  [17 -        , , ,   ,  : CrewsR. Empire and the Confessional State: Islam and Religious Politics in Nineteenth-Century Russia. American Historical Review. 2003. 108. No.1 (February). P.5083. . : WerthP. The Tsars Foreign Faiths: Toleration and the Fate of Religious Freedom in Imperial Russia. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.].           ,      ,  .    ,       ,         ,      .        ,   ,  ,      .  XIX.,  ,      .

 ,       ,    ,     ,     .   ,          ,        .           ,      ,  ,          .           .  ,        ,     .         ,       ,         ,   -      .     ࠖ,   XIX.,   .    ,                 .

  ,        ,     ,      .              .        ꠖ  , ,  ,       [18 -         , ,        ,    ,    . .: Nathans. Beyond the Pale: The Jewish Encounter with Late Imperial Russia. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2002. . : Slezkine Yu. The Jewish Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2004.]. , ,  ,      ,                     .       ,   ,    ,          , ,         , ,   ,   .  ,  ,   . ,   ,          .    , ,   ,     ,   ,     ,        .   ,  ,      ,     .

                ,             .               ,   ,   .  -    .  ,       ,       ;  ,      ,       ,      ,       [19 - .: h ?. ??-?  ?  ?  ( h?  ??   ???)/ . ..??. : . . ?., 1989,   1900.; Rida'addin Fakhraddin oghli. Athar. : , 19041909.].

,     ,        ,      蠖  , ,       ,  .        ,        ,   .        .     ,     ,   ,        . Ƞ   ,  XVIII., ,          ,   ,   ,  .      ,   ,     XVII.,       ,      (')  . ,        ,       .

 , ,  ,      ,   .      ,   .      ,         .          .      ,      ,    ,      ,          ,       ,     .  ,          ,    . ..    .  1877.   -          ,        ,      ,      . Ѡ        , ,   ,       [20 - ..  . .:   III. . ..., 1848. .9192, 144; ..  / . ... .: , 1999. .517;   .: TaruskinR. Entoiling the Falconet: Russian Musical Orientalism in Context// Cambridge Opera Journal. 1992. 4. No.3 (November). P.253280.].  ,      .       ,        ,     .      ,                .             ,         . Ѡ        ()  .

     .     ⠫       ,              [21 - ..  . .:   , 1961. .9294; ..   :      XIX. :   , 2002;   / . ..;     ( XVIII XX.):  . .:: 2006;           XVIII XX./ . . . ... :   . .  , 2011;       (XIX  .): / . ... .:  , 2013;    :  / . . ... .: , 2016.].    1810.       , 1817.     , 1832.    ,     ,  .          ,    ,        1788.,      蠖       .        .               ,   1860? 1880? ,        . 1872.     ,        ,   .     堖  렖   .  ,   ,    ,               , , , ,  . ,    ,        ,     ,   ,        [22 - O               .: NaganawaN. The Hajj Making Geopolitics, Empire, and Local Politics: AView from the Volga-Ural Region at the Turn of the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries// Central Asian Pilgrims: Hajj Routes and Pious Visits between Central Asia and the Hijaz/ Eds A.Papas, Th. Welsford, Th. Zarcone. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 2012. P.168198; CrewsR.D. An Empire for the Faithful, A Colony for the Dispossessed// Cahiers dAsie Centrale. No.17/18; Turkestan russe: une colonie comme les autres?/ Eds S.Gorshenina, S.Abashin. Tashkent; Paris: Collection de lIFEAC, 2009. P.79106;  : Muslim Networks, Imperial Power, and the Local Politics of Qajar Iran// Asiatic Russia: Imperial Power in Regional and International Contexts/ Ed. Uyama Tomohiko. London: Routledge, 2012. P.174188;  : The Russian Worlds of Islam// Islam and the European Empires. P.3552; KaneE. Russian Hajj: Empire and the Pilgrimage to Mecca. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2015.].  ,            ,        ,      ,    .     .         ,           ,  -    ,  .

          .       ,        .        ,    ,   .         .   XIX.      ,           .        頖      [23 - ., : Lieven. Empire;          .,  : ?i?ek K. Tanzimat ve Seriat: Namaz Kilmayanlar ve I?ki I?enlerin Takip ve Cezalandarilmasi Hakkinda Kibris Muhassili Mehmet Talat Efendinin Iki Buyruldusu// Toplumsal Tarih. 1995. March. .2227.].

             ,    . ,        .  ,      ,          ,   [24 - PetersR. State, Law and Society in Nineteenth-Century Egypt: Introduction// Die Welt des Islams. 1999. 39. No.3. P.267272,  .].      ,      ,         ,        .        ,      ,        .     ,                      ,      [25 - DeringilS. The Well-Protected Domains: Ideology and the Legitimation of Power in the Ottoman Empire, 18761909. London: Tauris, 1999; ZamanM.Q. The Ulama in Contemporary Islam: Guardians of Change. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002.].          ,      ,       .        ,      ,     .           .

        .      ,       ,   ,         ,     .          ,          -  .               . ,  ,   ,        ,    [26 - ChanockM. Law, Custom, and Social Order: The Colonial Experience in Malawi and Zambia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985; RobertsR., MannK. Law in Colonial Africa// Law in Colonial Africa/ Eds K.Mann, R.Roberts. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1991. P.358.      .: AsadT. The Idea of an Anthropology of Islam// Center for Contemporary Arab Studies, Georgetown University, Occasional Paper Series. 1986 (March). 15 (. .: .   // Islamology. 2017. 7(1). P.4160.. .); Genealogies of Religion: Discipline and Reasons of Power in Christianity and Islam. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993. P.2754.].

     ,         .            ,    ,               XIX.,     .       ,      .       .            .,        ,  , , . -           ,   [27 - ., : KarpatK.H. The Politicization of Islam: Reconstructing Identity, State, Faith, and Community in the Late Ottoman State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001; KaraA. T?rkistan Atesi: Mustafa ?okayin Hayati ve M?cadelesi. Istanbul: Da Yayincilik, 2002; MarasI. T?rk D?nyasinda Din? Yenilesme (18501917). Istanbul: ?t?ken, 2002.].    .   ,          ,      . ,         ,   .            ,       .  ,         .

          .     ,     ,  .      ,            .    XIX  .         .        ,         .           ,    ,         .   ,   ,      ,      [28 - ZamanM.Q. The Ulama in Contemporary Islam.].  ,     ꠫,              ,  .   蠖   .    ,       .

      .         ,             ,    . Ѡ   ,            ,         .          [29 - BrubakerR. Ethnicity without Groups. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2004,  .727;      ,       . Π     .: Kemper. Khalidiyya Networks.].             ,    ,               .        ,     ,        ,  , ,         ,   .

              ,             .       -,      .     XVIII.     (.2). 1           . ,   ,      ,          .  2 ,              -    XIX.,         .  3     ,   .              . ʠ XIX.  ,     ,  ,        .  4 ,           .  5  ;           ,   -  .  6            ,    -      ,    ,     ,      ,   .

      ,              ,     .             .,     ,    ,     .        ,   (   ),     ,              [30 - ., : BowenJ. Does French Islam Have Borders? Dilemmas of Domestication in a Global Religious Field// American Anthropologist. 2004. 106. No.1 (March). P.4355. . : KastoryanoR. Negotiating Identities: States and Immigrants in France and Germany// Transl. B. Harshav. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002.].             .       ,     .                   .  ,  ,      ,      ( )      .       [31 - Π        ., : ChandrasekaranR. How Cleric Trumped U.S. Plan for Iraq: Ayatollahs Call for Vote Forced Occupation Leader to Rewrite Transition Strategy// Washington Post. 2003. November 26; TylerP.E. After the War: Baghdad// New York Times. 2003. June 5.].  ,          ,   .    .                 ,           .  ,  ,       ,    ,       ,      .




 1

  



 1802.         - -.        .             .  -     ,   XVI XVII.       , . ,       , ,     .  ,                , .       .  ,     ,  XIV.,     .   -          [32 - FriedmanY. Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi: An Outline of His Thought and a Study of His Image in the Eyes of Posterity. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 1971; AlgarH. A Brief History of the Naqshbandi Order in: Naqshbandis: Cheminements et situation actuelle dun ordre mystique musulman// Historical Developments and Present Situation of a Muslim Mystical Order/ Eds M.Gaborieau, A.Popovic, Th.Zarcone. Istanbul: Isis Press, 1990. P.344.].

          ,    -     .   XVIII.         ,      XVI.      ,               .                .       .  -             .            [33 -    ,    , .: Rida'addin Fakhraddin oghli. Athar. .6. :  .-.., 1904. .276, 317; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte in Tatarien und Baschkirien, 17891889// Der islamische Diskurs unter russischer Herrschaft. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1998. S.82212; ?. ??-?  ?  ?  ( h?  ??   ???)/ . ?..?. : . . ?., 1989. .270; AlgarH. Shaykh Zaynullah Rasulev: The Last Great Naqshbandi Shaykh of the Volga-Urals Region// Muslims in Central Asia: Expressions of Identity and Change/ Ed. J.-A. Gross. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1992. P.113114.].

   -       .        .          . ʠ XIX       ,     .          .             .  ,       젖 ,  ,    ,      ,            ().

          蠖     .           ,    .      ,       ,    ,           -.       ,       ,         .         ,           ,    .

     ,     :   ,            ?     ,      .    ,  ,   ,    ,         ,  -.    ,  ,  ,        .  ,    ,   ,       .

          ,  - ,          ,     .     .             .  ,        ,           .       蠖  .         .




  


             . Ѡ XVII.               ,       .   ,       [34 - ., : MerleA. Le miroir ottoman: Une image politique des hommes dans la littrature gographique espagnole et fran?aise (XVI


XVII


si?cles). Paris: Presses de lUniversit de Paris-Sorbonne, 2003.].        -   .

Ѡ   ,     , ࠫ .        [35 -  . P.197].         ,     .  ,       ,     . ʠ ,       ,        .     ,   ,       ,       ࠖ  (. 1).

 1692.           .                ,    ⠖ .          ,       .    ,      蠫   .  ,           .  ,  , ,    ()[36 - .  . .:, 1990. .157.].

          , ,   ,    .        .            :

1)  ;

2)  ;

3)  ;

4)  ;

5)  ;

6)  ,   ;

7) ;

8) ;

9)  ;

10)    .

,      ,  .       .           蠫    [37 -  . .326, 333.].  ,       ,    ,       .

    ,     ,   ,     ,,  .         .         XVII.   蠖,   .       . ,   ,     .        ..,     1674.    [38 - SumnerB.H. Peter the Great and the Ottoman Empire. Hamden, Conn.: Archon Books, 1965; .. ..   / ...  . .362.].

  (  16891725)  ,   ,       .      ,       . ,      XVII.,  1716.    ,   .     ,    ,    ,      ,        .  1711.  ,    ,  .      ,  Π  ,  1722.              ,  ,    .       -      , .  ,    ,    蠫       [39 - ..  . . 1: 4758; LeDonneJ.P. The Grand Strategy of the Russian Empire, 16501831. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004. P.74;  / . .. .: , 1716;   . .:  ., 1784.].

           .   ,        . Ӡ ,    ,    ,         .         ,    .           ,       .   .  1743.  , ,  418 536   [40 - KhodarkovskyM. Russias Steppe Frontier: The Making of a Colonial Empire, 15001800. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2002. P.189201 (. . .:  .   . .:  , 2019); NolteH.-H. Religi?se Toleranz in Russland 16001725. G?ttingen: Musterschmidt Verlag, 1969. S.5489; KappelerA. Russlands erste Nationalit?ten: Das Zarenreich und die V?lker der Mittleren Wolga vom 16. bis 19. Jahrhundert. Cologne: B?hlau Verlag, 1982. Π  : . .12. 8978. 22 1744. .157158.].

     ,        .              ,     .   (  17301740)         ,              .   (  17411761)   ,     ,   , , ,     .

       .          ,     , .        ,       . Ƞ   ,      ,             .

          .           . ,        ,  ,        ,          .        [41 - . .9. 6890. 11 1736. .743; .12. 8978. 22 1744. .158159.].

       ,         .  ,              蠖.   -              .         ,             1755.,   .       .    -               ,    .      젖  (?) ( 1722.)   ( ,  ),      ( 1745.).        [42 - GilyazovI. Die Islampolitik von Staat und Kirche im Wolga-Ural Gebiet und der Bat?r?ah-Aufstand von 1755// Muslim Culture in Russia and Central Asia from the 18th to the Early 20th Centuries. Vol.1/ Eds M.Kemper, A. von K?gelgen, D.Yermakov. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1996. P.6989; ..    XVIII :   . : - , 2001;    .: FrankA.J. Muslim Religious Institutions in Imperial Russia: The Islamic World of Novouzensk District and the Kazakh Inner Horde, 17801910. Leiden: Brill, 2001. P.165173.].

  1762.,        .    ,       ,  ,       [43 - WortmanR.S. Scenarios of Power: Myth and Ceremony in Russian Monarchy. Vol.1. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995. P.110146 (. . .:  .  . .1. .:, 2002); FisherA.W. Enlightened Despotism and Islam under Catherine II// Slavic Review. 1968. 27. No.4. P.542553.].   ,      .  1764.     ,       -  .  1767.   ,           ,   .    ,       ,  ,         .    ,        , ,        ,      .     ,         ,       ,    ,       .        ,  -    .             ,   ,     .

      ,      .           .      ,    ,  .       .  :    ,     ,     ,           [44 - Russia under Catherine the Great/ Ed. and transl. P.Dukes. Vol.2. Newtownville, Mass.: Oriental Research Partners, 1977. P.104105; MadariagaI.de. Russia in the Age of Catherine the Great. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1981. P.151163, 503518 (. . .: . .    . .:  , 2002).].

  ,           ,        .      ,        ,        ,      .  ,        ,   .      ,     ,      .         ,  ,          ,  ,      ꠫  .    ,             .  ,           ,        [45 - SchwarzK. Vom Nutzen einer Christlichen Toleranz f?r den Staat: Bemerkungen zum Stellenwert der Religion bei den Sp?tkameralisten Justi und Sonnenfels// Im Zeichen der Toleranz: Aufs?tze zur Toleranzgesetzgebung des 18. Jahrhunderts im Reiche Josephe II, ihren Voraussetzungen und ihren Folgen/ Ed. Peter F.Barton. Vienna: Institut f?r protestantische Kirchengeschichte, 1981. S.8689;    .: RaeffM. The Well-Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 16001800. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1983. P.5669; ...    ,         . . 3. .:    , 1777. .3042.].

      ,              .    ,      ,      .     ,  ,     ,    ,          ,          .       ,    .  ,   ,       蠫 ,     .           ,    ,      ,    [46 - Π .: SchreinerK. Toleranz// Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe: Historiches Lexikon zur politisch-sozialen Sprache in Deutschland. B. 6/ Eds O.Brunner, W.Conze, R.Koselleck. Stuttgart: Klett-Cotta, 1990. S.505.].

     ,           .         ;           ,    .       .                [47 - .: FreezeG.L. The Rechristianization of Russia: The Church and Popular Religion, 17501850// Studia Slavica Finlandensia 7. 1990. P.101136;   .: BartlettR.P. Human Capital: The Settlement of Foreigners in Russia 17621804. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979.].         , ,  ,      .

      ,         ,    .       adhoc       -.        ;   ,           .

,     ,      .        - .   ,   ,     ,     ,      .         ,       .     ,     ,    ,    ,            [48 - .: MadariagaI.de. Russia P.510515.          Religionspolizei.    ,  ,       . .: Schwarz. Vom Nutzen S.8990.].

              ,       .   (  ) ,          .       ,      .        .   1768.  ,     ,     .      ,     .    ,          .   ,    ,   [49 - .: LeDonneJ. The Russian Empire and the World, 17001917: The Geopolitics of Expansion and Containment. New York: Oxford University Press, 1997; MadariagaI.de. Russia P.187204.].

          ,   .  ,        ,       ,      .      1771.  ,     ,         ࠖ . ,     ,           ( ).              ,  ,    .                [50 - Voltaire and Catherine the Great: Selected Correspondence/ Transl. and ed. A.Lentin. Cambridge: Oriental Research Partners, 1974. P.124, 128; .          XVIII  XIX. .:  , 2001. C. 34, 102.].

           .     ,     ,      ,  ,       .      ,    .       ,   ,      ,       () .    ,      .    ,   ,      .      ,  ,     .        ,  .       - ,       .      ,       , .       ,    , ,   ,       ⠫  [51 - ..  :     (  XIX). .:  , 2000. .12;     II/ . .., ... .:  , 1995. .101133.].

                  . ,   -  (17681774)       .   1773.   ,    ,   ,           .   ,    ,           .      ,             .  ,  ,         ,  ,       ,  ,         [52 -   Π      ,           ,     . . .19. 13996. 17 1773. .775776.].

    .     17671768.    ,     1773.   .    (),         . ,         ,  1774. - .       ,      -      .         , ,  ,           .         ,           .  蠖,   ⠖,       ,   ,    .   ,      ,        [53 - ..   //         . 1859. 3. .61.].

          ,         ,        .       ,  ,        :       ,   .          .    ,   ,       .  ,  , , ,     ,    ;    ,    .        :    ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  ,    ,    .

      .      ,     ⠫  蠫  .     ,  , .   ⠫   ,  ,    ,    , ࠫ. ,  . -    ;      [54 -  -  , ,        ,      . .: .  , 1790. C. xiiixv.].

 ⠖,         (1784)       .       ,       ,  .    ,   ,    .       ,    .

        .   :     , , ,  ,      .       ,        .          ,    .   :    ,   [55 -   . .25.].

          ,      ,   .      ,   .         ()     (),  XVIII.       [56 -   :         XVIII. .:   , 1985. .4041.].

          ,   1769.   .      1758.   ,      .       (  ,   )          .  ,   ,          .                .       , --,  ,    , ,   ,.        ;      .          ,       ,  - []  .      蠖    ,    ,  ,   蠫   -[57 - ..       . -:     , 1769. .26, 3637. . : Mouradgea DOhsson. Tableau gnral de lempire othoman. Vol.4. Pt. 1. Paris: Firmin Didot, 1791. P.495530; .               1768 1769. .1. .:   , 1795. .179; ..  . .9.].

, , -,    ,    , ,   .  ,    ,  ,       .       ,            .   ,      ,   ,      ,    .        ,        XIX.  ,     ,  ,            ,  .     , ,  ,     . , -,    .         ,   ,      .    ,     ,            ;     ,  ,       ,    ,     ,       ,      .

Ƞ,      ,      ,        [58 - .  ,   1800. .1. .: , 1802. .224227.].              ,  .  ,  頖  .    , ,      ,          .




 Ƞ


 ,       ,     .          .   ,     ,       .               ,          .  ,     ,        .     ,      ,        ,      .  ,           ,      .      ,   .

      ,        ,            .    ,       ,       蠖.         .     ,       ,  -.  ,       .             .         ,       ,  ,,   [59 - .: FreezeG.L. The Russian Levites: Parish Clergy in the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1977; FreezeG.L. The Parish Clergy in Nineteenth-Century Russia: Crisis, Reform, Counter-Reform. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983.].

 1787.,          ,   - .            .  1785.    ,        ,         ,    .       蠫,     III[60 -  .. . . 1: 6869; .., ..      . .1. .:, 1998. .462463.].    -          . ,      ,    .         ,        .  ,       1760  ,             .   ,       ,    ,                   .       ,         ,    ,  .

           ,            蠖, , ,   .         1730?.;              (  ).  1754.         ,    .        ,           ,      .    , ,     ,  ,   ,     ,    ,  : Π (?)!      [61 - FrankA.J. Islamic Historiography and Bulghar Identity among the Tatars and Bashkirs of Russia. Leiden: Brill, 1998. P.2139;     / . ... :    , 1993. .26 (    ), 71 (. .).].

       .  1785.   -           (17561824)       150    ;     .  ,  -,     ,   ,      ,               .        -  , -      .   , , ,    (-)          .   ,           .  , 1787.                ;         3600     [62 - ..    . . 1: 8485; .. , . . 1: 101102; . 5: 683; -  .: Mubadele: An Ottoman-Russian Exchange of Ambassadors/ Eds and transl. N.Itzkowitz, M.Mote. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1970;   .: FrankA.J. Muslim Religious Institutions. P.161217;    .: ..  . . 1: 50.].

Ѡ       .    ,    , ,     ,    ,              ,        .      1788.        .      32-  ,       .    ,   1500 ⠖      , ,      .                ,   ,   ,          [63 - .: FisherA.W. Enlightened Despotism; Akdes Nimet Kurat. Rus h?kimiyeti altinda Idil-Ural ?lkesi// Ankara ?niversitesi Dil ve Tarih Cografya Fak?ltesi Dergisi. 1965. 23. Nos 34. .124125.        ecclesiastical,  spiritual,       .        ,   ,      1721. .: CracraftJ. The Church Reform of Peter the Great. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1971;      .: . .22. 16710, 16711. 22 1788. .11071108.].

 1789.    ,         .  ,        ,    .                                    .                ,       .       ,       ,     .               [64 - FisherA.W. Enlightened Despotism. . 5: 563564.       ,          .         .].

 , ,    ,     ,            ,  :  , ,   .       -:   ,    ,       ,            .          ,    .  , -               ,      ,    [65 - . 5: 564566, 565.].

              .       (  )       .   ,          ,     ;        ,       [][66 -  . 565.].     ,        ,      ,   .

      ,       ,  .           ,      . Ѡ         ,     .       ,    .         ,  ,        ,     .      ,        ,   .       , ,     ,    .        .        ,      ,  [67 -  . 566.].

 ,       ,      (),        . ,     ,   ,    ,    -,      . Ѡ1770?.          - .         .                     [68 - ..    . , 1: 84.        - (  ),    ( ),   ; . 5: 683.].     ,        ,     .

    ,         .  1792.     , ,          ,    .            .        ,  ,     ,              [69 - . 5: 559560.].

                  . ʠ1800.   頖             1900[70 - AzamatovD.D. The Muftis of the Orenburg Spiritual Assembly in the 18th and 19th Centuries: The Struggle for Power in Russias Muslim Institution// Muslim Culture in Russian and Central Asia from the 18th to the Early 20th Centuries. Vol.2/ Eds A. von K?gelgen, M.Kemper, A.J.Frank. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1998. P.355384; . 5: 683684.].  1791. ,     527,     , 339 (),     ;     ,     ,     .     XIX.    ,    頖. Ӡ    ,        ; ,       . Ѡ                 .

    ,        .       .    ,  4 1789.,   ,        ,         .          ,      蠫  ,     [71 - . .6. .3. .2411. .7980.].

 ,          .        ,    ,        ,    .  ,       ,          .  ,      ;  ,              .     ,            -,   .  ,          ,  ,    .  :      ,        [72 -  . .85., 82., 7576.].

       .         ,  .    , -,    .     ,         ;     ,    ,   --     ,  [73 -         ,  ,     . .: Akg?nd?zM. XIX. asir Baslarina Kadar Osmanli Devletinde Seyh?lisl?mlik. Istanbul: Beyan, 2002.]. Ѡ  ,     .   ,       ,         ,             .       ,   .

    .        ;            .

      ,              .  ,      ,     ,   [74 - .: Masud Kh. M. Adab al-mufti: The Muslim Understanding of Values, Characteristics, and Role of a Mufti// Moral Conduct and Authority: The Place of Adab in South Asian Islam/ Ed. B.D.Metcalf. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984. P.124151.].       .          ,     .     ,    ,   ,   .

 1805.           .       ,       .  ,     ࠖ,      .     ,      .  ,  ,   ,    ,      ,   []       [75 - . .6. .3. .2411. .121123., 126126.].

   .   ,        .   ,    ,     .       ,  ,     :            ,     .

  ,    .        ,         .         ,      ,      .      ,        50.         ,          ,        .     .     , ,  20          .  1805.  14       ,          [76 -  . .127128.].

       . ,       .  1811.      ,        .         :    -    . ,    ,      蠖  -.        ,    ,  ;    1815 1818.  ,       ,        [77 - . .31. 24819. 18 1811. .872; . .6. .4. .8085. .4949., 69.].

         ,     .   ⠫         .  ?              堖     .  ,         ,         .  1832.,    ,  ,                [78 - . 2-. .7. 5500. 14 1832. .498505.].            蠫 ,  -   .




  


   ,        ,      .     -              .   1815.     ,   .     ,           .          .   :        ,               .

 ,     ⠫            .  ,     ,    ,       蠫    .                         ,   .      [79 - . .6. .3. .4744. .1.2; ..         XIX.//  : , , / . ... .:, 2003. .195223.].

            ,     .            ,                ,  ,  .         ,               .         .            ;              .        .

  1801.         ,           .   ,       ()   ,      ,  .     ,       :                ,              ,    [80 - . .6. .2. .724. .135.].

  ,   ,         .  ,    ?      ,         ,  .         ,   .    ?        .      ,    , ,  ,   [81 -  . .135135. -      -   - (17671843); ? . ??-?. .232, 260; Fakhraddin oghli Rida'addin. Athar. .9. :  .-.., 1905. .7; Kappeler A. Russlands erste Nationalit?ten. S.460.].              .

     1787.,    ,   ,    .   , ,             .     ,        .          , : ߠ       ,      ,    [82 - ? . ??-?. .260261.].   ,       . ,         ,  ,     .

 1799.         -   -,      [83 - Fakhraddin oghli R. Athar. .9: 7.].   ,     (, ,   ), 1800.         .   ,              ,       ().      .   蠖蠖      .           (  , )[84 - ? . ??-?. .261; Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.59.]. ,     1801.,       .

      .  , ,  .  ,   ,  ,       ,     [85 -     ?      ,     (    )   ,   .].       ,              ,      .

    ,         .  ,  ,    .         ( 1819.     ),       .       () , ,    ,     -,     ()    [86 - ? . ??-?. .261262; Fakhraddin oghli R. Athar. .9: 7.].

       .     -; , ,      . ,          ,      ,  , .      ,   [87 - KemperM. Entre Boukhara et la Moyenne-Volga: Abd an-Nasir al-Qursawi (17761812) en conflit avec les oulmas traditionalistes/ Transl. S.Dudoignon// Cahiers du Monde russe. 1996. Nos 12. Jan.June. P.42; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.59.].

, -,   ,   ,      ,    .      ,       .            . ,          ,      ,  ,       ,      .  ,      .      ,           .             ,     . ,             젖 ,        (     )[88 - SchachtJ. Abu l-Layth al-Samarkandi// Encyclopaedia of Islam. 1: 137.        : ?.. XVIII?砖 ?    ???. : ? ?, 1998. .121123.].

 ,           .         ,     .                  .               ,  1746.    ,    .

   ,                   ,    () .  ,   ,       -       .         ,            ,     .       ,       [89 - . .6. .2. .724. .135.136; .6. .2. .1026. .55.; Algar. Shaykh Zaynullah. P.113114; Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.5859.].         ,   ,           .

          .       ,       ,   ,   ,       .       -    ⠫.  ,       ,       .    ,     ,         .     ,   ,        ,  [90 - . .6. .2. .1026, .4.    : ,  , ,      ,  ;  . .99., 2121.].     ,          .




  


      ,   ,          .        ,     .     XIX.              .

         ,             .          ,          .  ,      ,    ,       .         .       .  ,           ,         .

   1824. -    -       .   ,     ( 1825  1840.)  1831. ,         .         ,       ,        ,      . ,            ,     ,       [91 -       ?  ?    ??? ?-?? ?-. .: KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.7073.].

,  ,         ,          .    ,    .       1820? 1830?.        .              ,        1827.     -  .  1829.                 .      (     ),            ,       .   ,     ,    ,     ?   .        ,      [92 - . 2-. 1827. .2. 893 (). .168169. Π (  ? ?-) .: ? . ??-?. .273; ., .  :      ( XVIII  ). : , 1995. .118; AzamatovD.D. The Muftis. P.364365;      ( )  . . 2-. 1830. .5. 3659 (13). .396.].

    -   , ,      蠖  ,    ,     .     XVIII.    :     ,      ,     [93 - . .I-295. .3. .303. .3.4.     7 1734., 22 1763. 18 1797.,   17 1773.,  494 496  ,  62    124   ;  . .5.].   1829.     .      ,   ,       .       ,  ,       , ..     ,  .  :       ,              ,    .      ,        ,      .   ,  ,         ;         [94 - . .I-295. .3. .303. .1., 77.      ,         ,     .  . .8.].

         .     ?          .      ,   ,  , ,        .       ,  ,        .   ,          .        ,  ,        ,      .  ,        .    ,     ,          .

,    , ,    . ,  ,       .  , ,    II (  18551881),   ,        ,             .  ,     ,  ,          ,    .   ,     ,  ,                     [95 - . 2-. .5. 3659. 13 1830. .396, 397.].

     I,      ,       ,     1827.,     . ,       ,  :    ,      [96 -  ; StanislawskiM.S. Tsar Nicholas I and the Jews: The Transformation of Jewish Society in Russia, 18251855. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1983.].                  ,          .

       ,       , ,       .      ,   .                .     ,       ,  ,   ,       .    ,    ,        .                  蠖      [97 - .     . :   , 1844. .7273; SmithJ.I., HaddadY.Y. The Islamic Understanding of Death and Resurrection. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1981. P.3161.].

 ,    ,       ,        . ,     ,     .  1831.      I,    ;      . ʠ  ,  蠫      ,        .   1833.  ..           ,     ,       ,      .            1834.,        ,     ,      ().   ..              ,   . ,        3500            [98 - .: . .I-295. .3. .303. .1313., 2023, 23.        :  . .1516, 24., 34, 3737.].

      ,  ,  ,     , ,    -     ,   .         ,   ,     . Ѡ 1796. ,    ,      .                  .  1803. I          .

     .  1804 1813.         .

 ,        .    XIX.      .  1813.         .       ,         .  II  ,      .              ( )      .           .  -  18261828.      :      蠫       .       ,       .  1830?.            .  1843.  ,      ,   [99 - Osmanli devleti ile Azerbaycan T?rk hanliklari arasindaki m?n?sebetlere d?ir arsiv belgeleri. Vol.1. Ankara: T.C.Basbakanlik Devlet Arsivleri Genel M?durl?gu, 1992. P.191200; JersildA. Orientalism and Empire: North Caucasus Mountain Peoples and the Georgian Frontier, 18451917. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 2002. P.15.].

               .      ,     ,         .   1830?.  ,    ,          ,  ,  ,      ,     ,   ,  ,  ,     ,     ,        .     () ,     ,       .

 ..        ,      .         ,     ,         ,     ,         ,           . Ѡ    ,   ,       .    ,           [100 - . 2-. .11. 8881. 1836. .133134.].

         .  1843.        ..   .            .  ,    -   ,          .      ,         .  1830. -   ..       .     ,  ,             ,    .  ,         ,         .    1843.    ,    .           ;          [101 - ..  :    / . ... 2003. 155. 7. .105107;     軠// . 2002. 5. .1819.].

   ,  ,     . ʠ1844.          .     ,      . -       ,        .      I,             ,   ,   ,     [102 -  . Π  .: KaneE. Russian Hajj: Empire and the Pilgrimage to Mecca. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2015.]. ,                  .  ,  ,           .


* * *

                .           ,      . Ƞ         .         (1718)   ,     ,           .  ,     ,    ,      .   :      ,               ,   ,    [103 - . :  . . .; .:   , 1961. .7778, 84.].          ⠫:  ,       ,     .

      ,     .         .  1829. I             [104 - .., ..   .377378, 464465.].    - -       .   ꠫  1831.    ,     -,    ,   ,    .        ,        ,   .  : Π!   ,    ,   .      .       ,    ,  .    .     .     ,      ,       .    ,    ,      ,               .

,    ,   .     ,   ,    ,    ,       [105 -  . .471474.].

       .        ,      ,      .          ,   ,          [106 - .: CookM. Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong In Islamic Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.].  ,         ,        .           .      ,        .     ,        ,     ;   ,         ,     .            .

 1836.    - ,            I.        ,     ,    ,  ,  .              ,     ,      .     ,        ,    :     .          ,     1828. (      15: 13)      .     ,               ;     ,     ,   [107 - HauptmannP. Die Katechismen der Russisch-orthodoxen Kirche: Entstehungsgeschichte und Lehrgehalt. G?ttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1971. S.253255; . 3; .   : . .:  , 1936. .5961.].

    ,  ,    ,  .    ..     ,  ,  .  ,        ,  ,     ,     .      - ,   ,       ,                ,       .

  ,        ,        ,    ,   ,             .    ,      XVI. , ,       ,    [108 - . 3; ,    ,  ,      ,      ,    : WirtschafterE.K. From Serf to Russian Soldier. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990. P.78; . 34; Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. P.71, 148158.].

         .  ,                  ,    , ,           .      ,     .  ,     ,  ,   :    ,         [109 - . 4.].

        ,     ,    ,  ,  .     ,    1840?.  [110 - WirtschafterE.K. From Serf to Russian Soldier. P.8.].           .   1840? 1850?.       ,   ,          .   1849.           (  18401862.). Ѡ I           .       ,      ,    ,    .    ,        ,     .   ,             ,    .      ,    ,     ,          ,              .

,       蠫    蠫 ,    [111 - . .I-295. .3. .2615. .23, 3.4.].

       ,        .           ,       , ,  ,   ,     ,    [112 -  . .44.].       .

    ,     ,        .       ,  ,  ,      ,              .    .    ,  ,    , ,   , ,  ,  ,         .    ,           ,   , ,       .  ,       .

ʠ       .    ,               .  :                                         .

     ,     ,  ,   ,    []  []  []            [113 -  . .9., 10.11.     .: .    . .:  II  ..., 1850. .8.].

       .      ,   ,       .         ,       .            頖      .

         .       .       ,     .   ,        ,       ,          .    ⠫    ꠫        .      ,       ,          .          ?    .   ,        .            ,     ,   [114 - . .I-295. .3. .2615. .1313.].

      ,     .   ,   , ,   ,                                           .

    ,        ,           .  1831.     ,    .  :           ࠖ  [115 -  . .1414., 15.].

 ,  ꠫ ,    ,      .         . ,    ,     : Π!   ,        ,  ,   ,    ,    .    :         ,      ,       .       .       ,       .    ,            .   ,      ,   [116 -          ,             . Hauptmann P. Die Katechismen. S.228, 300;    : . .I-295. .3. .2615. .1516. ( ).].

            .

,    ,  ,            ,        .            .   ,     ,   ,  .     ,     .

        ,        .  1824.  ..             :  ,        ()    ,   ,       .   , ,      ,       ,       ,     .     ,     ,     .        ,      ,      .      ()        ,     󠖠,  ,      -,  ,  .        ,   ,      ,   [117 -     . .310; . .38. 28891. 25 1822. .3637;  .: SchimmelA. Mystical Dimensions of Islam. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1975. P.109110; SternM.S. Al-Ghazzali on Repentance. New Delhi: Sterling, 1990; . 2-. .20. 19283. 15 1845. .971972.].

 ,   ,           ,     .  ,   ,        .  1856.  ,    ,    .      ,     , ,    .     ,     .     ,    ;     ,     .     ,    .          .    ,      .  ,       ⠫  ,    [118 - . .I-295. .3. .3977. .30.].

  ,    .         堖  .    1944 2077  ,   ,     .  ,        ,      ,      ,        ,    [119 -  . .31.32, 36.].


* * *

            .                .       ,      -.               .             . , ,  ,       ,           [120 - WortmanR.S. Scenarios of Power.].   ,        ,      ,   .                   ,      .

               .                (),    .             .           ,           ,  [121 - WensinckA.J. Khutba// Encyclopaedia of Islam. New ed. 5: 7475; LapidusI.M. Muslim Cities in the Later Middle Ages. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1967.].

Ѡ XVIII.          .             .             ,           [122 -          25 1796.,    ,  , -,   . .: -  XVIII XIX.:  / . ... .:, 1988. .289290. . : . .I-295. .3. .35; -  XVIIIXIX (17711867):   . -: , 1964. .207; CurtissJ. Sh. The Russian Army under NicholasI, 18251855. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1965. P.255272.].     XVI.       .   ,   ,   ,        .  XIX.         .                   .            ,    .

    , ,     ,        .      ,           ,    ,    ,  .     ,                 .   XVIII XIX.  ,              .  ,   -    ,        ,       -. ,        ,   ,    XVIXVII.

  ,          . , ,    ,      ,    ,         .  , ,  ,    ⠖    ,          ,  ,   ()     .

 -,          ,   .      ,         .    ,         ,  ,             .           ,              [123 - MasudM. Kh. The Obligation to Migrate: The Doctrine of Hijra in Islamic Law// Muslim Travellers: Pilgrimage, Migration and the Religious Imagination/ Ed. Dale F.Eickelman, James Piscatori. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990. P.2949, 36.].      XVIIIXIX.,         ,      ,               .

          .          . Ƞ       ,       ࠖ,  ,  .     ,    ,     ,     .       ,        .      , ,     ;    ,      .               . Ѡ ,          ,          -;           [124 - .: HardyP. The Muslims of British India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1972. P.107115; MasudM. Kh. The Obligation to Migrate.].        ,          .

  ,   ,   ,            .           .      ,             .              .   ,     ,          .

  XIX.          .  -  ,  ,  , 1798.    ,      ⠫ -.  ,      ,  ,   ,      ,           [125 - Kemper M. Entre Boukhara et la Moyenne-Volga. P.45;  . Sufis und Gelehrte. P.290299; .,  .  . .234;       ?    ??   ?- ? (17541834).].      ,           ,      .          ,      ()   (),     [126 - Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.299307.].      ,   .

    ,  .      ,           .       ,       ,      .       1827.       ,     ,      .

 ,        .     ,             .            ,  .    , ,       ,          .  1848.                  ,    .    ,      ,   ,   ,    ,  ,   ...    ,       .          軠,  ,   -.    ,         ,     :       [127 -  . .147171;     .: . .I-295. .3. .2487. .100101.; . .I-295. .2. .43. .54.57., 387., 789790.].

    .            .  ,      ,      .     ,           . ,       .         ,         .      ,   .       .         .    ,          ,   -  .        , ,        ,   ,    .

           ,             ,  .       .       -     ,      ,       .        ,           .           ;     ,     .




 2

  



  1793.               .  ,   ,    -,  ,      , ; -,       ; [] -,     .          .  ,         ,     .         蠫   ,    ,    , ࠫ        ,       [128 - . 5: 567568.].

             .           ,  ,       , - , ,        .        ,        .      ().    1823.   ,       .              ,       [129 - Π    .: FrankA.J. Muslim Religious Institutions in Imperial Russia: The Islamic World of Novouzensk District and the Kazakh Inner Horde, 17801910. Leiden: Brill, 2001. P.174; KappelerA. Russlands Erste Nationalit?ten: Das Zarenreich und die V?lker der Mittleren Wolga vom 16. bis 19. Jahrhundert. Cologne: B?hlau Verlag, 1982. S.455481; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte in Tatarien und Baschkirien, 17891889: Der Islamische Diskurs unter russischer Herrschaft. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1998; Noack Ch. Muslimischer Nationalismus im Russischen Reich: Nationsbildung und Nationalbewegung bei Tataren und Baschkiren, 18611917. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, 2000. S.39109; .    :          XIX XX.// Acta Slavica Iaponica. 2017. Tomus 38. P.2350.].      .

          ,        ,   ,      .       ,       .  ,           ,  .               .   ,    .    XIX.             .     ,      ,       .   ,        ,       ,        .     ,    .               .


* * *

     ,      .        ,      .        ,        .       ,         .        , , ,  ,       ( ?),      ,    .          ,    :  ,     ,      .

          .         ,        ,  ,    ;         .          ,    .           ,    ,      .                 .

Ѡ       ,             .    ,   ,    ()          .  ,   ,  ,    .   ,        , , ,  .

      ,  .             ,   ,     . Ƞ,           ,       .        ,         .        -[130 - , ??? ? ?. . 2003. 12. .49; FrankA.J. A Chronicle of Islamic Communities on the Imperial Russian Frontier: The Tavarix-i Alti Ata of Muhammad Fatih al-Imini// Muslim Culture in Russia and Central Asia. Vol.3/ Ed. A. von K?gelgen, A.Muminov, M.Kemper. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 2000. P.473.].       ,    ;     . -,      ,          .  ,        .

      .  ,     ,     ,    .       ,        . ,         ,         .     ,         ,            .

  ()   .           ,      ࠖ,           . ,     ,   ,    ,      .           .

         ,    .  , , ,      ,                 (),    XVIII XIX. .        , , , , , ,   .              . ,           ,           ,      [131 - .: EickelmanD.F. Changing Interpretations of Islamic Movements// Islam and the Political Economy of Meaning: Comparative Studies of Muslim Discourse/ Ed. W.R.Roff. London: Croom Helm, 1987. P.2027; RoffW.R. Islamic Movements: One or Many?// Political Economy of Meaning. P.3152. Π  .: ..    . .:  , 2013.].

        1,        ,          .         , ,  .  ,  ,        .

            ,       .         .     ,    ,   -    .          ,     .        () 蠖 , ,  , , ,    .      -          .     .

            .       , ,   .     ,     ,    頖  .            .            ,     ,   , ,   .

     , ,      -    ࠖ  ,     ,           . ,      ,  .   .          .     -   .          , ,  ,   , ,  ;   ,      (, )       [132 - KaiserF.B. Die russische Justizreform von 1864: Zur Geschichte der russischen Justiz von Katharina II. bis 1917. Leiden: Brill, 1972. S.189; ..      ( XVIII  XIX.). :     , 2002; (.);   / . ? ?, ? . . 1998. 12. .108113.].

 ,    ,      ,   , ,    ,  ,              .    ,  ,    ,   ,    [133 - FischerM.M. J. Iran: From Religious Dispute to Revolution. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1980. P.138; RafeqA.-K. Public Morality in 18th-century Ottoman Damascus// Revue du monde musulman et de la Mditerrane. 1990. 5556. Nos 12. P.180196.].

    , , ,            () .        .     ,   ,         [134 -          ,     . .: .   . .:  , 1936.      ., : .   -   -   :    // Ab Imperio. 2012. No.1. P.2946;  .    :          XIX XX.// Acta Slavica Iaponica. 2017. Tomus 38. P.2350;         (XVII XX.): . / . .., .., ... :   . .  , 2014; Bustanov.K. 'Abd al-Rashid Ibrahims Biographical Dictionary on Siberian Islamic Scholars//  / Kazan Islamic Review. 2014. No.1. P.1078. Π     .: CookM. Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong in Islamic Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.].      ,   ,         ,  .      ,      ,      .         ,      ,        .  ,     ,      .




 ?


        ,               [135 - .: FreezeG.L. The Soslovie (Estate) Paradigm and Russian Social History// American Historical Review. 1986. 91. No.1. P.1136.].      ,       .       ,    ,  .

    ,            .       ࠖ,     򠖠     .         ,  ,        [136 - LapidusI.M. Muslim Cities In the Later Middle Ages. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1967. P.108; MottahedehR.P. Loyalty and Leadership in an Early Islamic Society. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980. P.136150.]. , ,   , ,  ,  , , , ,  ,  ,        , ,  .     ,   ,       ,      .                 , ,   .      ,         .                 .

       ,          .     1788.        .              . ,   ,   ,      .          .         .  1829.  ,    蠫 , ,     . ,     ,     , ,   , 207 128    64 000 187.   ,   ,    ,      .       1730.,   1832.    .    ,  1844.  75,          (  )[137 -    .:    . .: - , 1937. .259; ??? ? ?// . 2003. 12. P.4559; Fakhraddin oghli R. Athar. .10. :  .-... 1905. .102.].

       .          .               ,    .              ,     ,   ;        ,             .

  , ,    -,  .             .           .  ,       ,         ;      ,    ,   .        ,        .        ,   ,        .  1843.         [138 - Π  .: .. ,           , 1769 1770. .:    , 1770. .5; .. [].  // . 1860. 81. .269270, 281284; KefeliA. The Role of Tatar and Kriashen Women in the Transmission of Islamic Knowledge, 18001870// Of Religion and Empire: Missions, Conversion, and Tolerance in Tsarist Russia/ Ed. R.P.Geraci, M.Khodarkovsky. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2001. P.250273;   . 22 1844. .321.],       .

         ,  .  ,       ,    ,          .    ,      ,       .  1785. ,             .  1801.       ,       .  1822.      ,        , ,  ,  ,  -   ,   ,   [139 - . .26. 19885. 22 1801. .655.     1822.,   17 1796.        ,   . . .38. 28891. 25 1822. .3637.].

     ,       .    ()        . Ѡ1811.      -,   ,    ,   [140 -    . . 1231. .11. .1. 857. .:      .  , 1857. .223; . .31. 24819. 18 1811. .872.].             .

 1826.     ,       .   ,      .  ,                ,      .        ,     .    , ,   ,    ,   ;       .  1849.         ,               . -        .          ,        [141 - . 2-. .1. 715. 1 1826. .12641265;  . .24. 23259. 21 1849. .284.].

   ,  1793.  ,          .            .        ,    ,      ,  ⠫ [142 -  . .1. 564. 31 1826. .911912; . .6. .4. .9958. .88.].

,  1820? 1830?.  I  ad hoc,        .   1834.    ..    ,   . Ӡ       ,        ,          ,           [143 - . .I-295. .3. .1096. .11.].

      ;          1840.        ,   ,          .       ,-,    ,   .    ⠫ ,  ,  , ,      [144 - . .I-295. .3. .1096. .2626.].

        .     ,     . Ѡ1829.      ,    .    .        [145 -  . .27.],        .      ,     ,    ().

        .            ,         .          .       .  ,        ,        .         .         .     ,               . ,   ,               [146 -  . .28.29, 2929.].


* * *

              ?  -   ,       ,    .      ,    ,    ,     -.   ,        , ,   ,       , ,     [147 - .: StanislawskiM. Tsar Nicholas I and the Jews: The Transformation of Jewish Society in Russia, 18251855. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1983. P.133134.].

            ,          .                .     -     ,    . ,   ()      蠖,   ,       .  , ??      ???  ? ?- (. 1831.), ,      ,       -.     ,      .      [148 - ., : ? . ??-?  ?  ?  ( h?  ??   ???)/ . ?..?. : . . ?., 1989. .278279; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.60;   .: FrankA.J. Islamic Shrine Catalogues and Communal Geography in the Volga-Ural Region: 17881917// Journal of Islamic Studies. 1996. 7. 2. No.P.265286.].

           .       ,       . ,           (    )    [149 - ?. ??-?. .283, 288.].

         .  XVIII.     ,     .    1789.             .  ,             ,               [150 - . : ..             XVIIIXIX. . . . . , 1994. .34.].        ,         ,    ,    .          ,  .

 1841.  , ,      ,         .                    ,    .  ,        ,   ,     .       ,       ,      .           ,          [151 - . .I-295. .3. .1692. .1;  1827. I     ,      . .:StanislawskiM. Tsar Nicholas. P.19.].

  ,      ,         .     ,    31 1826.   .        ,    ,         .           ,    1826.      .     -  ,      .  ,              .  ,    , ,     ,   ,     ,   ,      [152 -        (. 2-. .1. 564 [31 1826], 911912); . .I-295. .3. .1692. .1.2., 1415.].

     -        .  ,             ,     ,        .      .           




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=54123561)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


Zemon DavisN. Society and Culture In Early Modern France. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1975. P.152187. Π .: PolitkovskayaA. A Small Corner of Hell: Dispatches from Chechnya/ Transl. Alexander Burry and Tatiana Tulchinsky. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003. P.9194 ( : ..  . .:, 2003.. .).




2


., : BaberowskiJ. Der Feind ist ?berall: Stalinismus im Kaukasus. Munich: Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt, 2003.




3


Π  , ,      .: McChesneyR.D. Central Asia: Foundations of Change. Princeton, NJ: Darwin Press, 1996. P.3.       ,               . ., : BennigsenA., HenzeP.B., TanhamG.K., WimbushS.E. Soviet Strategy and Islam. Houndsmills, UK: Macmillan, 1989,   : BullietR. The Case for Islamo-Christian Civilization. New York: Columbia University Press, 2004.




4


.: Abu ZahabM., Roy O. Rseaux Islamiques: La connexion afghano-pakistanaise. Paris: Autrement, 2002; Rashid A. Jihad: The Rise of Militant Islam in Central Asia. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2002;    :  / . ., . . .:  , 2001; Uzbekistan: The Andijon Uprising// International Crisis Group Asia Briefing. 2005. No.38. May 25.




5


.: WortmanR.S. Scenarios of Power: Myth and Ceremony In Russian Monarchy. 2vols. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995, 2000 (. . .: .  .    .  2./ . .. .:, 2004.. .).




6


.: KappelerA. Russland als Vielv?lkerreich: Entstehung, Geschichte, Zerfall. 2nd ed. Munich: C.H.Beck, 1993; LievenD. Empire: The Russian Empire and Its Rivals. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2001; LeDonneJ.P. The Russian Empire and the World, 17001917: The Geopolitics of Expansion and Containment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.




7


., : SunyR.G. The Empire Strikes Out: Imperial Russia, National Identity, and Theories of Empire// A State of Nations: Empire and Nation-Making in the Age of Lenin and Stalin/ Eds R.G.Suny, T.Martin. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001. P.2366; . : SlocumJ.W. Who, and When, Were the Inorodtsy? The Evolution of the Category of Aliens in Imperial Russia// Russian Review. 1998. 57. No.2 (April). P.173190.




8


BullietR. Islam: The View from the Edge. New York: Columbia University Press, 1994. P.194.




9


         2004.




10


.: DeWeeseD. Islamization and Native Religion In the Golden Horde: Baba T?kles and Conversion to Islam In Historical and Epic Tradition. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1994; FrankA.J. Varieties of Islamization In Inner Asia: The Case of the Baraba Tatars, 17401917// Cahiers du monde russe. 2000. 41. No.23 (AprilSeptember). P.245262.




11


  :  , , / . ... .: , 2001. .324327.




12


., : BrooksW. Russias Conquest and Pacification of the Caucasus: Relocation Becomes a Pogrom in the Post-Crimean War Period// Nationalities Papers. 1995. 23. No.4. P.675686; ReynoldsM.A. Muslim Mobilization in Imperial Russias Caucasus// Islam and the European Empires/ Ed. D.Motadel. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014. P.187212.




13


MazowerM. Violence and the State in the Twentieth Century// American Historical Review. 2002. 107. No.4. October. P.11581178, .  .1163.       .: KemperM. Khalidiyya Networks in Daghestan and the Question of Jihad// Die Welt des Islams. 2002. 42. No.1. P.4171; Habi?ogluB. Kafkasyadan Anadoluya G??ler ve Iskanlari. Istanbul: Nart Yayincilik, 1993; MeyerJ. Turks Across Empires: Marketing Muslim Identity in the RussianOttoman Borderlands. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.   ,      1891 1904.  312 000: SwietochowskiT. Russia and Azerbaijan: ABorderland in Transition. New York: Columbia University Press, 1991. P.1022. Π       ., : . .400. .1. .2329, 3692, 4009; . .187. .485. .684; SiegelJ. Endgame: Britain, Russia and the Final Struggle for Central Asia. London: Tauris, 2002; ..       . .: , 2009.




14


     -    ⠫    ,       ,      ,       . .: KhalidA. The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform: Jadidism in Central Asia. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998;        .: KemperM. Herrschaft, Recht und Islam in Daghestan: Von den Khanaten und Gemeindeb?nden zum gihad-Staat. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag, 2005. . : .., .., .. .    :  . .:, 2017.




15


Kennan Jr. E. L. Muscovy and Kazan: Some Introductory Remarks on the Patterns of Steppe Diplomacy// Slavic Review. 1967. 26. No.4 (December). P.548558; WhiteR. The Middle Ground: Indians, Empires, and Republics in the Great Lakes Region, 16501815. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991. P.52.




16


.: Napoleon in Egypt: Al Jabartis Chronicle of the First Seven Months of the French Occupation, 1798/ Ed. R.Tignor, transl. Sh. Moreh. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener, 1993; Molla und Diplomat: Der Bericht des Eb? Sehil Num?n Efendi ?ber die ?sterreichisch-osmanische Grenzziehung nach dem Belgrader Frieden 1740/1741/ Transl. and ed. E.Prokosch. Graz: Verlag Styria, 1972. S.9192. Π      - .: Motadel. Islam and the European Empires; Sel?uk Esenbel. Japans Global Claim to Asia and the World of Islam. American Historical Review. 2004. 109. No.4 (October). P.11401170; Naimur Rahman Farooqi. Pan-Islamism in the Nineteenth Century. Islamic Culture. 1983. 57. No.4 (October). P.283296; FischerF. Germanys Aims in the First World War. New York: W.W.Norton, 1967, .  .121. Π    (puissance musulmane) .: RobinsonD. Paths of Accommodation: Muslim Societies and French Colonial Authorities in Senegal and Mauritania, 18801920. Athens: Ohio University Press, 2000;   .: DoniaR.J. Islam under the Double Eagle: The Muslims of Bosnia and Hercegovina, 18781914. New York: Columbia University Press, 1981.




17


       , , ,   ,  : CrewsR. Empire and the Confessional State: Islam and Religious Politics in Nineteenth-Century Russia. American Historical Review. 2003. 108. No.1 (February). P.5083. . : WerthP. The Tsars Foreign Faiths: Toleration and the Fate of Religious Freedom in Imperial Russia. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.




18


        , ,        ,    ,    . .: Nathans. Beyond the Pale: The Jewish Encounter with Late Imperial Russia. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2002. . : Slezkine Yu. The Jewish Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2004.




19


.: h ?. ??-?  ?  ?  ( h?  ??   ???)/ . ..??. : . . ?., 1989,   1900.; Rida'addin Fakhraddin oghli. Athar. : , 19041909.




20


..  . .:   III. . ..., 1848. .9192, 144; ..  / . ... .: , 1999. .517;   .: TaruskinR. Entoiling the Falconet: Russian Musical Orientalism in Context// Cambridge Opera Journal. 1992. 4. No.3 (November). P.253280.




21


..  . .:   , 1961. .9294; ..   :      XIX. :   , 2002;   / . ..;     ( XVIII XX.):  . .:: 2006;           XVIII XX./ . . . ... :   . .  , 2011;       (XIX  .): / . ... .:  , 2013;    :  / . . ... .: , 2016.




22


O               .: NaganawaN. The Hajj Making Geopolitics, Empire, and Local Politics: AView from the Volga-Ural Region at the Turn of the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries// Central Asian Pilgrims: Hajj Routes and Pious Visits between Central Asia and the Hijaz/ Eds A.Papas, Th. Welsford, Th. Zarcone. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 2012. P.168198; CrewsR.D. An Empire for the Faithful, A Colony for the Dispossessed// Cahiers dAsie Centrale. No.17/18; Turkestan russe: une colonie comme les autres?/ Eds S.Gorshenina, S.Abashin. Tashkent; Paris: Collection de lIFEAC, 2009. P.79106;  : Muslim Networks, Imperial Power, and the Local Politics of Qajar Iran// Asiatic Russia: Imperial Power in Regional and International Contexts/ Ed. Uyama Tomohiko. London: Routledge, 2012. P.174188;  : The Russian Worlds of Islam// Islam and the European Empires. P.3552; KaneE. Russian Hajj: Empire and the Pilgrimage to Mecca. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2015.




23


., : Lieven. Empire;          .,  : ?i?ek K. Tanzimat ve Seriat: Namaz Kilmayanlar ve I?ki I?enlerin Takip ve Cezalandarilmasi Hakkinda Kibris Muhassili Mehmet Talat Efendinin Iki Buyruldusu// Toplumsal Tarih. 1995. March. .2227.




24


PetersR. State, Law and Society in Nineteenth-Century Egypt: Introduction// Die Welt des Islams. 1999. 39. No.3. P.267272,  .




25


DeringilS. The Well-Protected Domains: Ideology and the Legitimation of Power in the Ottoman Empire, 18761909. London: Tauris, 1999; ZamanM.Q. The Ulama in Contemporary Islam: Guardians of Change. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002.




26


ChanockM. Law, Custom, and Social Order: The Colonial Experience in Malawi and Zambia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985; RobertsR., MannK. Law in Colonial Africa// Law in Colonial Africa/ Eds K.Mann, R.Roberts. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1991. P.358.      .: AsadT. The Idea of an Anthropology of Islam// Center for Contemporary Arab Studies, Georgetown University, Occasional Paper Series. 1986 (March). 15 (. .: .   // Islamology. 2017. 7(1). P.4160.. .); Genealogies of Religion: Discipline and Reasons of Power in Christianity and Islam. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993. P.2754.




27


., : KarpatK.H. The Politicization of Islam: Reconstructing Identity, State, Faith, and Community in the Late Ottoman State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001; KaraA. T?rkistan Atesi: Mustafa ?okayin Hayati ve M?cadelesi. Istanbul: Da Yayincilik, 2002; MarasI. T?rk D?nyasinda Din? Yenilesme (18501917). Istanbul: ?t?ken, 2002.




28


ZamanM.Q. The Ulama in Contemporary Islam.




29


BrubakerR. Ethnicity without Groups. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2004,  .727;      ,       . Π     .: Kemper. Khalidiyya Networks.




30


., : BowenJ. Does French Islam Have Borders? Dilemmas of Domestication in a Global Religious Field// American Anthropologist. 2004. 106. No.1 (March). P.4355. . : KastoryanoR. Negotiating Identities: States and Immigrants in France and Germany// Transl. B. Harshav. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002.




31


Π        ., : ChandrasekaranR. How Cleric Trumped U.S. Plan for Iraq: Ayatollahs Call for Vote Forced Occupation Leader to Rewrite Transition Strategy// Washington Post. 2003. November 26; TylerP.E. After the War: Baghdad// New York Times. 2003. June 5.




32


FriedmanY. Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi: An Outline of His Thought and a Study of His Image in the Eyes of Posterity. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 1971; AlgarH. A Brief History of the Naqshbandi Order in: Naqshbandis: Cheminements et situation actuelle dun ordre mystique musulman// Historical Developments and Present Situation of a Muslim Mystical Order/ Eds M.Gaborieau, A.Popovic, Th.Zarcone. Istanbul: Isis Press, 1990. P.344.




33


   ,    , .: Rida'addin Fakhraddin oghli. Athar. .6. :  .-.., 1904. .276, 317; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte in Tatarien und Baschkirien, 17891889// Der islamische Diskurs unter russischer Herrschaft. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1998. S.82212; ?. ??-?  ?  ?  ( h?  ??   ???)/ . ?..?. : . . ?., 1989. .270; AlgarH. Shaykh Zaynullah Rasulev: The Last Great Naqshbandi Shaykh of the Volga-Urals Region// Muslims in Central Asia: Expressions of Identity and Change/ Ed. J.-A. Gross. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1992. P.113114.




34


., : MerleA. Le miroir ottoman: Une image politique des hommes dans la littrature gographique espagnole et fran?aise (XVI


XVII


si?cles). Paris: Presses de lUniversit de Paris-Sorbonne, 2003.




35


 . P.197




36


.  . .:, 1990. .157.




37


 . .326, 333.




38


SumnerB.H. Peter the Great and the Ottoman Empire. Hamden, Conn.: Archon Books, 1965; .. ..   / ...  . .362.




39


..  . . 1: 4758; LeDonneJ.P. The Grand Strategy of the Russian Empire, 16501831. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004. P.74;  / . .. .: , 1716;   . .:  ., 1784.




40


KhodarkovskyM. Russias Steppe Frontier: The Making of a Colonial Empire, 15001800. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2002. P.189201 (. . .:  .   . .:  , 2019); NolteH.-H. Religi?se Toleranz in Russland 16001725. G?ttingen: Musterschmidt Verlag, 1969. S.5489; KappelerA. Russlands erste Nationalit?ten: Das Zarenreich und die V?lker der Mittleren Wolga vom 16. bis 19. Jahrhundert. Cologne: B?hlau Verlag, 1982. Π  : . .12. 8978. 22 1744. .157158.




41


. .9. 6890. 11 1736. .743; .12. 8978. 22 1744. .158159.




42


GilyazovI. Die Islampolitik von Staat und Kirche im Wolga-Ural Gebiet und der Bat?r?ah-Aufstand von 1755// Muslim Culture in Russia and Central Asia from the 18th to the Early 20th Centuries. Vol.1/ Eds M.Kemper, A. von K?gelgen, D.Yermakov. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1996. P.6989; ..    XVIII :   . : - , 2001;    .: FrankA.J. Muslim Religious Institutions in Imperial Russia: The Islamic World of Novouzensk District and the Kazakh Inner Horde, 17801910. Leiden: Brill, 2001. P.165173.




43


WortmanR.S. Scenarios of Power: Myth and Ceremony in Russian Monarchy. Vol.1. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995. P.110146 (. . .:  .  . .1. .:, 2002); FisherA.W. Enlightened Despotism and Islam under Catherine II// Slavic Review. 1968. 27. No.4. P.542553.




44


Russia under Catherine the Great/ Ed. and transl. P.Dukes. Vol.2. Newtownville, Mass.: Oriental Research Partners, 1977. P.104105; MadariagaI.de. Russia in the Age of Catherine the Great. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1981. P.151163, 503518 (. . .: . .    . .:  , 2002).




45


SchwarzK. Vom Nutzen einer Christlichen Toleranz f?r den Staat: Bemerkungen zum Stellenwert der Religion bei den Sp?tkameralisten Justi und Sonnenfels// Im Zeichen der Toleranz: Aufs?tze zur Toleranzgesetzgebung des 18. Jahrhunderts im Reiche Josephe II, ihren Voraussetzungen und ihren Folgen/ Ed. Peter F.Barton. Vienna: Institut f?r protestantische Kirchengeschichte, 1981. S.8689;    .: RaeffM. The Well-Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 16001800. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1983. P.5669; ...    ,         . . 3. .:    , 1777. .3042.




46


Π .: SchreinerK. Toleranz// Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe: Historiches Lexikon zur politisch-sozialen Sprache in Deutschland. B. 6/ Eds O.Brunner, W.Conze, R.Koselleck. Stuttgart: Klett-Cotta, 1990. S.505.




47


.: FreezeG.L. The Rechristianization of Russia: The Church and Popular Religion, 17501850// Studia Slavica Finlandensia 7. 1990. P.101136;   .: BartlettR.P. Human Capital: The Settlement of Foreigners in Russia 17621804. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979.




48


.: MadariagaI.de. Russia P.510515.          Religionspolizei.    ,  ,       . .: Schwarz. Vom Nutzen S.8990.




49


.: LeDonneJ. The Russian Empire and the World, 17001917: The Geopolitics of Expansion and Containment. New York: Oxford University Press, 1997; MadariagaI.de. Russia P.187204.




50


Voltaire and Catherine the Great: Selected Correspondence/ Transl. and ed. A.Lentin. Cambridge: Oriental Research Partners, 1974. P.124, 128; .          XVIII  XIX. .:  , 2001. C. 34, 102.




51


..  :     (  XIX). .:  , 2000. .12;     II/ . .., ... .:  , 1995. .101133.




52


  Π      ,           ,     . . .19. 13996. 17 1773. .775776.




53


..   //         . 1859. 3. .61.




54


 -  , ,        ,      . .: .  , 1790. C. xiiixv.




55


  . .25.




56


  :         XVIII. .:   , 1985. .4041.




57


..       . -:     , 1769. .26, 3637. . : Mouradgea DOhsson. Tableau gnral de lempire othoman. Vol.4. Pt. 1. Paris: Firmin Didot, 1791. P.495530; .               1768 1769. .1. .:   , 1795. .179; ..  . .9.




58


.  ,   1800. .1. .: , 1802. .224227.




59


.: FreezeG.L. The Russian Levites: Parish Clergy in the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1977; FreezeG.L. The Parish Clergy in Nineteenth-Century Russia: Crisis, Reform, Counter-Reform. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983.




60


 .. . . 1: 6869; .., ..      . .1. .:, 1998. .462463.




61


FrankA.J. Islamic Historiography and Bulghar Identity among the Tatars and Bashkirs of Russia. Leiden: Brill, 1998. P.2139;     / . ... :    , 1993. .26 (    ), 71 (. .).




62


..    . . 1: 8485; .. , . . 1: 101102; . 5: 683; -  .: Mubadele: An Ottoman-Russian Exchange of Ambassadors/ Eds and transl. N.Itzkowitz, M.Mote. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1970;   .: FrankA.J. Muslim Religious Institutions. P.161217;    .: ..  . . 1: 50.




63


.: FisherA.W. Enlightened Despotism; Akdes Nimet Kurat. Rus h?kimiyeti altinda Idil-Ural ?lkesi// Ankara ?niversitesi Dil ve Tarih Cografya Fak?ltesi Dergisi. 1965. 23. Nos 34. .124125.        ecclesiastical,  spiritual,       .        ,   ,      1721. .: CracraftJ. The Church Reform of Peter the Great. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1971;      .: . .22. 16710, 16711. 22 1788. .11071108.




64


FisherA.W. Enlightened Despotism. . 5: 563564.       ,          .         .




65


. 5: 564566, 565.




66


 . 565.




67


 . 566.




68


..    . , 1: 84.        - (  ),    ( ),   ; . 5: 683.




69


. 5: 559560.




70


AzamatovD.D. The Muftis of the Orenburg Spiritual Assembly in the 18th and 19th Centuries: The Struggle for Power in Russias Muslim Institution// Muslim Culture in Russian and Central Asia from the 18th to the Early 20th Centuries. Vol.2/ Eds A. von K?gelgen, M.Kemper, A.J.Frank. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1998. P.355384; . 5: 683684.




71


. .6. .3. .2411. .7980.




72


 . .85., 82., 7576.




73


        ,  ,     . .: Akg?nd?zM. XIX. asir Baslarina Kadar Osmanli Devletinde Seyh?lisl?mlik. Istanbul: Beyan, 2002.




74


.: Masud Kh. M. Adab al-mufti: The Muslim Understanding of Values, Characteristics, and Role of a Mufti// Moral Conduct and Authority: The Place of Adab in South Asian Islam/ Ed. B.D.Metcalf. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984. P.124151.




75


. .6. .3. .2411. .121123., 126126.




76


 . .127128.




77


. .31. 24819. 18 1811. .872; . .6. .4. .8085. .4949., 69.




78


. 2-. .7. 5500. 14 1832. .498505.




79


. .6. .3. .4744. .1.2; ..         XIX.//  : , , / . ... .:, 2003. .195223.




80


. .6. .2. .724. .135.




81


 . .135135. -      -   - (17671843); ? . ??-?. .232, 260; Fakhraddin oghli Rida'addin. Athar. .9. :  .-.., 1905. .7; Kappeler A. Russlands erste Nationalit?ten. S.460.




82


? . ??-?. .260261.




83


Fakhraddin oghli R. Athar. .9: 7.




84


? . ??-?. .261; Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.59.




85


    ?      ,     (    )   ,   .




86


? . ??-?. .261262; Fakhraddin oghli R. Athar. .9: 7.




87


KemperM. Entre Boukhara et la Moyenne-Volga: Abd an-Nasir al-Qursawi (17761812) en conflit avec les oulmas traditionalistes/ Transl. S.Dudoignon// Cahiers du Monde russe. 1996. Nos 12. Jan.June. P.42; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.59.




88


SchachtJ. Abu l-Layth al-Samarkandi// Encyclopaedia of Islam. 1: 137.        : ?.. XVIII?砖 ?    ???. : ? ?, 1998. .121123.




89


. .6. .2. .724. .135.136; .6. .2. .1026. .55.; Algar. Shaykh Zaynullah. P.113114; Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.5859.




90


. .6. .2. .1026, .4.    : ,  , ,      ,  ;  . .99., 2121.




91


      ?  ?    ??? ?-?? ?-. .: KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.7073.




92


. 2-. 1827. .2. 893 (). .168169. Π (  ? ?-) .: ? . ??-?. .273; ., .  :      ( XVIII  ). : , 1995. .118; AzamatovD.D. The Muftis. P.364365;      ( )  . . 2-. 1830. .5. 3659 (13). .396.




93


. .I-295. .3. .303. .3.4.     7 1734., 22 1763. 18 1797.,   17 1773.,  494 496  ,  62    124   ;  . .5.




94


. .I-295. .3. .303. .1., 77.      ,         ,     .  . .8.




95


. 2-. .5. 3659. 13 1830. .396, 397.




96


 ; StanislawskiM.S. Tsar Nicholas I and the Jews: The Transformation of Jewish Society in Russia, 18251855. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1983.




97


.     . :   , 1844. .7273; SmithJ.I., HaddadY.Y. The Islamic Understanding of Death and Resurrection. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1981. P.3161.




98


.: . .I-295. .3. .303. .1313., 2023, 23.        :  . .1516, 24., 34, 3737.




99


Osmanli devleti ile Azerbaycan T?rk hanliklari arasindaki m?n?sebetlere d?ir arsiv belgeleri. Vol.1. Ankara: T.C.Basbakanlik Devlet Arsivleri Genel M?durl?gu, 1992. P.191200; JersildA. Orientalism and Empire: North Caucasus Mountain Peoples and the Georgian Frontier, 18451917. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 2002. P.15.




100


. 2-. .11. 8881. 1836. .133134.




101


..  :    / . ... 2003. 155. 7. .105107;     軠// . 2002. 5. .1819.




102


 . Π  .: KaneE. Russian Hajj: Empire and the Pilgrimage to Mecca. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2015.




103


. :  . . .; .:   , 1961. .7778, 84.




104


.., ..   .377378, 464465.




105


 . .471474.




106


.: CookM. Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong In Islamic Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.




107


HauptmannP. Die Katechismen der Russisch-orthodoxen Kirche: Entstehungsgeschichte und Lehrgehalt. G?ttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1971. S.253255; . 3; .   : . .:  , 1936. .5961.




108


. 3; ,    ,  ,      ,      ,    : WirtschafterE.K. From Serf to Russian Soldier. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990. P.78; . 34; Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. P.71, 148158.




109


. 4.




110


WirtschafterE.K. From Serf to Russian Soldier. P.8.




111


. .I-295. .3. .2615. .23, 3.4.




112


 . .44.




113


 . .9., 10.11.     .: .    . .:  II  ..., 1850. .8.




114


. .I-295. .3. .2615. .1313.




115


 . .1414., 15.




116


         ,             . Hauptmann P. Die Katechismen. S.228, 300;    : . .I-295. .3. .2615. .1516. ( ).




117


    . .310; . .38. 28891. 25 1822. .3637;  .: SchimmelA. Mystical Dimensions of Islam. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1975. P.109110; SternM.S. Al-Ghazzali on Repentance. New Delhi: Sterling, 1990; . 2-. .20. 19283. 15 1845. .971972.




118


. .I-295. .3. .3977. .30.




119


 . .31.32, 36.




120


WortmanR.S. Scenarios of Power.




121


WensinckA.J. Khutba// Encyclopaedia of Islam. New ed. 5: 7475; LapidusI.M. Muslim Cities in the Later Middle Ages. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1967.




122


         25 1796.,    ,  , -,   . .: -  XVIII XIX.:  / . ... .:, 1988. .289290. . : . .I-295. .3. .35; -  XVIIIXIX (17711867):   . -: , 1964. .207; CurtissJ. Sh. The Russian Army under NicholasI, 18251855. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1965. P.255272.




123


MasudM. Kh. The Obligation to Migrate: The Doctrine of Hijra in Islamic Law// Muslim Travellers: Pilgrimage, Migration and the Religious Imagination/ Ed. Dale F.Eickelman, James Piscatori. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990. P.2949, 36.




124


.: HardyP. The Muslims of British India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1972. P.107115; MasudM. Kh. The Obligation to Migrate.




125


Kemper M. Entre Boukhara et la Moyenne-Volga. P.45;  . Sufis und Gelehrte. P.290299; .,  .  . .234;       ?    ??   ?- ? (17541834).




126


Kemper M. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.299307.




127


 . .147171;     .: . .I-295. .3. .2487. .100101.; . .I-295. .2. .43. .54.57., 387., 789790.




128


. 5: 567568.




129


Π    .: FrankA.J. Muslim Religious Institutions in Imperial Russia: The Islamic World of Novouzensk District and the Kazakh Inner Horde, 17801910. Leiden: Brill, 2001. P.174; KappelerA. Russlands Erste Nationalit?ten: Das Zarenreich und die V?lker der Mittleren Wolga vom 16. bis 19. Jahrhundert. Cologne: B?hlau Verlag, 1982. S.455481; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte in Tatarien und Baschkirien, 17891889: Der Islamische Diskurs unter russischer Herrschaft. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 1998; Noack Ch. Muslimischer Nationalismus im Russischen Reich: Nationsbildung und Nationalbewegung bei Tataren und Baschkiren, 18611917. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, 2000. S.39109; .    :          XIX XX.// Acta Slavica Iaponica. 2017. Tomus 38. P.2350.




130


, ??? ? ?. . 2003. 12. .49; FrankA.J. A Chronicle of Islamic Communities on the Imperial Russian Frontier: The Tavarix-i Alti Ata of Muhammad Fatih al-Imini// Muslim Culture in Russia and Central Asia. Vol.3/ Ed. A. von K?gelgen, A.Muminov, M.Kemper. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz Verlag, 2000. P.473.




131


.: EickelmanD.F. Changing Interpretations of Islamic Movements// Islam and the Political Economy of Meaning: Comparative Studies of Muslim Discourse/ Ed. W.R.Roff. London: Croom Helm, 1987. P.2027; RoffW.R. Islamic Movements: One or Many?// Political Economy of Meaning. P.3152. Π  .: ..    . .:  , 2013.




132


KaiserF.B. Die russische Justizreform von 1864: Zur Geschichte der russischen Justiz von Katharina II. bis 1917. Leiden: Brill, 1972. S.189; ..      ( XVIII  XIX.). :     , 2002; (.);   / . ? ?, ? . . 1998. 12. .108113.




133


FischerM.M. J. Iran: From Religious Dispute to Revolution. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1980. P.138; RafeqA.-K. Public Morality in 18th-century Ottoman Damascus// Revue du monde musulman et de la Mditerrane. 1990. 5556. Nos 12. P.180196.




134


         ,     . .: .   . .:  , 1936.      ., : .   -   -   :    // Ab Imperio. 2012. No.1. P.2946;  .    :          XIX XX.// Acta Slavica Iaponica. 2017. Tomus 38. P.2350;         (XVII XX.): . / . .., .., ... :   . .  , 2014; Bustanov.K. 'Abd al-Rashid Ibrahims Biographical Dictionary on Siberian Islamic Scholars//  / Kazan Islamic Review. 2014. No.1. P.1078. Π     .: CookM. Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong in Islamic Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.




135


.: FreezeG.L. The Soslovie (Estate) Paradigm and Russian Social History// American Historical Review. 1986. 91. No.1. P.1136.




136


LapidusI.M. Muslim Cities In the Later Middle Ages. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1967. P.108; MottahedehR.P. Loyalty and Leadership in an Early Islamic Society. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980. P.136150.




137


   .:    . .: - , 1937. .259; ??? ? ?// . 2003. 12. P.4559; Fakhraddin oghli R. Athar. .10. :  .-... 1905. .102.




138


Π  .: .. ,           , 1769 1770. .:    , 1770. .5; .. [].  // . 1860. 81. .269270, 281284; KefeliA. The Role of Tatar and Kriashen Women in the Transmission of Islamic Knowledge, 18001870// Of Religion and Empire: Missions, Conversion, and Tolerance in Tsarist Russia/ Ed. R.P.Geraci, M.Khodarkovsky. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2001. P.250273;   . 22 1844. .321.




139


. .26. 19885. 22 1801. .655.     1822.,   17 1796.        ,   . . .38. 28891. 25 1822. .3637.




140


   . . 1231. .11. .1. 857. .:      .  , 1857. .223; . .31. 24819. 18 1811. .872.




141


. 2-. .1. 715. 1 1826. .12641265;  . .24. 23259. 21 1849. .284.




142


 . .1. 564. 31 1826. .911912; . .6. .4. .9958. .88.




143


. .I-295. .3. .1096. .11.




144


. .I-295. .3. .1096. .2626.




145


 . .27.




146


 . .28.29, 2929.




147


.: StanislawskiM. Tsar Nicholas I and the Jews: The Transformation of Jewish Society in Russia, 18251855. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1983. P.133134.




148


., : ? . ??-?  ?  ?  ( h?  ??   ???)/ . ?..?. : . . ?., 1989. .278279; KemperM. Sufis und Gelehrte. S.60;   .: FrankA.J. Islamic Shrine Catalogues and Communal Geography in the Volga-Ural Region: 17881917// Journal of Islamic Studies. 1996. 7. 2. No.P.265286.




149


?. ??-?. .283, 288.




150


. : ..             XVIIIXIX. . . . . , 1994. .34.




151


. .I-295. .3. .1692. .1;  1827. I     ,      . .:StanislawskiM. Tsar Nicholas. P.19.




152


       (. 2-. .1. 564 [31 1826], 911912); . .I-295. .3. .1692. .1.2., 1415.


