:         XVIII 
  


Historia Rossica
      ,         .  ,                     .   , ,             XVIII .  ,         ,     ,   ,        .          .           . Igor Fedyukin THE ENTERPRISERS: THE POLITICS OF SCHOOL IN EARLY MODERN RUSSIA, FIRST EDITION





 

         XVIII 





   


                    .      . .   . .,         XVIII                .

     ,     ,                      .   ,        ,      . .  ,         XVIII ,    , ,   ,       ,   ,            ,    .         . . ,      ,      ,      .

         . . ,    2013       . . .             .         Ӡ         ,   . . , . .   . . ,          , ,    .            . .. . .         .

,     ,                   ,   - ,    - ,    ,     .              OeStA/HHStA    Riksarkivet  , .    . . ,           .

         .  ,            ,     (CERCEC),         20102012 .                   ,       2015          .                  -  ,      .

                   (IWM)          .     ,       IWM,        ,           .                   . ,                ,        ,    -,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,     ,    .

 , ,             -,       .      . . ,                  XVIII . . . ,  , . . , . .   . .        ,   ( )  .        ,  ,             .

 -           . ,          .               . . ,       . .   ,     ,        .      ,    . .,    ,                   . ,    ,                     . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . ., . .          .

           .            .     ,       .   ,            .   ,        ,       .         ,                       .

     , ,      ,           ,               ,       .

 ,          .          1999          .            XVIII ,         ,    .  ,       : ,    .     .


* * *

   . .             .              , ,  ,    ;      ,     ;      -  .

      (  15-01-0148)           ( ) 20152016         5-100.







           11  1691 .           :  ,    ,        ,     ,     .       :    ,       . , ,             . , ,   :   ,         ,    [1 -   .:  . .  .    . ., 1896;  .  .           XVII . , 1895;  . .   :     . ., 1990. . 233382;  . .  //       /  . . . . ., 1993. . 3: XVIII . . 3: ϖ. . 354361.  .:  . .  . . 338.].

 ,       ,      ,          [2 -   .:  . . -     XVII . ., 2009. . 190213.     . 223231.].  ,      1681 ,      .          ,     ,    .  -  ,            :   ,                    [3 -  . . . . 356358.].  , ,         ,              .     ,       ,   ,     ,        .     1689           [4 -  . . - . . 214217.            (  ,     ).  , , ,                   . Potter C. J. The Russian Church and The Politics of Reform in The Second Half of The Seventeenth Century. PhD diss. Yale University, 1993. . 384394.       .: Chrissidis N. A. An Academy at The Courts of The Tsars: Greek Scholars and Jesuit Education in Early Modern Russia. DeKalb, IL, 2016 ( :  .    . :   .   ).      1689 . .:  . .    .            16821869 . .:  , 1999. . 157190.].

      .      ,             . ,    1689       ,         ,      ,          ,   . .    . ,          ,         - .    ,            .  ,         ,        ,   ,    .

   ,             .               -      .  ,    , ,          ,  ,    ,       .         ,     ,    ;   ;           .  ,   , ,  ,  -     , ,       ,           .        ,     ,     ,   . ,           , ,  ,                  .

,      ,    ,    ,          .         ,       (16291680)[5 -  . .   //       /  . . . . ., 1993. . 3: XVIII . . 3: ϖ. .362379.],             , ,      ,                ,     ,      .      . . ,  ,                 ,      [6 -  . . - . . 208211, 214215.   . 215;    .: . 103173;  . . . . 355356;  . .   ( ) //       /  . . . . ., 1992. . 3: XVII . . 1: . . 128131.].


,   ?

              :      ,         .    ,    ,                ,      . ,                ,                  , , ,     .         .         , ,     (1755)    (1773),        ;    ;   .        ,      ,           . ,       ,   ,            .

                   ,   I    . ,   ,      ,     ,       .  ,       ,    ,         .                   XVIII     ,     ,  [7 -  : Raeff M. Origins of The Russian Intelligentsia: The Eighteenth-Century Nobility. New York, 1966; Okenfuss M. J. Technical Training in Russia under Peter The Great // History of Education Quarterly. 1973, Winter. Vol. 13. 4. . 325345; Black J. L. Citizens for The Fatherland: Education, Educators and Pedagogical Ideals in Eighteenth Century Russia. Boulder, CO, 1979; Kusber J. Eliten- und Volksbildung im Zarenreich w?hrend des 18. und in der ersten H?lfte des 19. Jahrhunderts: Studien zu Diskurs, Gesetzgebung und Umsetzung. Stuttgart, 2004 ( :  .         XVIII    XIX . , , . ., 2018);  . .            XVII    XVIII. ., 2008.]. ,         ,    , , , .       ,          .

          .  XVII                [8 -         : Kosheleva . . Education as a Problem in Seventeenth Century Russia // The State in Early Modern Russia:New Directions / Ed. P. Bushkovitch. Bloomington, IN., 2019. P. 191217.].         ,  ,  ,   :    ,     .        ,   (    ),          .         II  1762        ,             XIX .       ,  ,  ,  ,   ;         ;       .  ,        .        ,           ,  , . ,      ,   ,       ,  ,    ,       .

       ,        .          XVIII ,           -.     ,       I   ,         .        ,      ,   ,   , ,  ;       , ,    ,            .  ,   ,  - , ,     ,             ,          ,   [9 - Black J. L. Citizens for The Fatherland. . 3.              :  . .   .   XVIII . . 1. ., 2014.]. ,   ,  I                  .           ,           [10 - ., :  . .          XVIII . ., 1997. . 152154; ,  :  . .    I:  o   .    , , , ,    . .; ., 1945. . 1;  . .    .           XVIII . ., 2017.].             Deus ex machina,             [11 - Bushkovitch P. Peter The Great: The Struggle for Power, 16711725. Cambridge, 2001. . 3.     , . .       ,             ( . .  :     3040-  XVI . ., 2010. . 610).].

        -,     ,    .    ,    I     -    ;  ,      ,      ,     .                     ,         .            :   ,          ,         .     ,  ,         ,     ,      .  ,    ,                .           ,  ,         .

,     , , ,       ,    XVIII          ,             .         ,  ,       :    ,    ,        .  , ,          . ,     ,      ,    :      ,    ,     ,        ,   .        , corps du gnie,      ,   ,     [12 - Artz F. B. The Development of Technical Education in France, 15001850. Cambridge, MA, 1966. P. 4446.]. ,    ,       ,      .  ,   ,              ,    ,  ,              [13 - Ley F. Le Marechal de Munnich et la Russie au XVIIIe si?cle. Paris, 1959. P. 4.].

       XVIII          :       ,               .     ,     ,     ,               .          ,  ,   ,  ,  ,            XVII      II.


      

 ,  ,      ,        ,     .           ,        ,         .                  [14 - Beik W. The Absolutism of Louis XIV as Social Collaboration // Past & Present. 2005. Vol. 188. 1. P. 195224.].   ,            XIV,        ,   ,         ,            .  ,            ,      ,    ,    .   ,       -,      :             - . ,           -   ,              [15 - ., : Kettering Sh. Patrons, Brokers, and Clients in Seventeenth-Century France. New York, 1986; Mettam R. Power and Faction in Louis XIVs France. New York, 1988; Campbell P. R. Power and Politics in Old Regime France, 17201745. London, 1996; Adams J. The Familial State: Ruling Families and Merchant Capitalism in Early Modern Europe. Ithaca, 2005.].             ,       -        ,    .

                .     ,             ,     .               ,      ;  ,         ,         .              ,    ,   ,    ,      ,     [16 - .: Martin R. E. The Petrine Divide and The Periodization of Early Modern Russian History // Slavic Review. 2010, Summer. Vol. 69. 2. P. 410425.           . : Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Architecture. Chicago, 1988; Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Imagery. Chicago, 1997; Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Culture. Cambridge, MA, 2004.].                   XVII ,      [17 -      . : Zitser E. A. Post-Soviet Peter: New Histories of The Late Muscovite and Early Imperial Russian Court // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 2005, Spring. Vol. 6. 2. P. 375392.].

  ,       .          -          ,        [18 - Ransel D. L. The Politics of Catherinian Russia: The Panin Party. New Haven, 1975. P. 12.].           ,             [19 -   /    .: Crummey R. O. Aristocrats and Servitors: The Boyar Elite in Russia, 16131689. Princeton, 1983; Kollmann N.Sh. Kinship and Politics: The Making of The Muscovite Political System, 13451547. Stanford, 1987; Kivelson V. A. Autocracy in The Provinces: The Muscovite Gentry and Political Culture in The Seventeenth Century. Stanford, 1996; Berelowitch A. La hirarchie des gaux: La noblesse russe dAncien Rgime (XVIe  XVIIesi?cles). Paris, 2001; Poe M. T. The Russian Elite in The Seventeenth Century. Helsinki, 2004. Vol. 1. The Consular and Ceremonial Ranks of The Russian Sovereigns Court, 16131713; Krom M. Formen der Patronage im Russland des 16 und 17. Jahrhunderts: Perspektiven der vergleichenden Forschung im europ?ischen Kontext // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. Neue Folge. 2009. 57. P. 321345.  ,       ,  : Meehan-Waters B. Autocracy & Aristocracy: The Russian Service Elite of 1730. New Brunswick, NJ, 1982;  . .      : C    //      XV   XX . .      /  . . . . ., 2007. . 366386;  . .          XVIII :           // Cahiers du Monde russe. 2009. 50. . 699736;  . .            XVIII  // Cahiers du Monde russe. 2010. 51. . 259280;  . .    17001725 .:         I //            (16821750) /  . . . , . . ., 2013. . 4562.].     . .           XVII ,        ,      ,     ,         ,       [20 -  . .   :    XVII . ., 2006; Bushkovitch . Peter The Great.].          ,     XVII      .        ,         [21 - .: Zitser . . The Transfigured Kingdom: Sacred Parody and Charismatic Authority at The Court of Peter The Great. Ithaca, NY, 2004 ( : .  :       . ., 2008).].  ,      XVIII ,  ,       ,    [22 -  . .         :      17111727 . , 2007.].

,  ,   ,       XVIII     ,                         ,    [23 - Beik W. Absolutism of Louis XIV. P. 208.].    ,  ,                  ,         .                         ,     ,    ,    . ,   ,   ,  (agency)   ,              ,          ,            ,    [24 -    ,     ,     : Ermakoff I. Rational Choice May Take Over // Bourdieu and Historical Analysis / Ed. P. Gorski. Durham, NC, 2013. P. 89106; Ermakoff I. Theory of Practice, Rational Choice and Historical Change // Theory and Society. 2010, August. 39. . 527553. . : Aya R. The Third Man; or, Agency in History; or, Rationality in Revolution // History and Theory. 2001, December. Vol. 40. 4. P. 143152.]. ,   ,  ,         ,   ,     ,          .  ,    ,              ,      .

          :     XIV;         ;                   1700- ;     ,  -    ,    ,       [25 - Rowlands G. The Dynastic State and The Army under Louis XIV: Royal Service and Private Interest, 16611701. Cambridge, 2002; Soll J. S. The Information Master: Jean-Baptiste Colberts Secret State Intelligence System. Ann Arbor, 2011; GrahamA. Corruption, Party, and Government in Britain, 17021713. Oxford, 2015; Wakefield A. The Disordered Police State: German Cameralism as Science and Practice. Chicago, 2009. P. 138.].          :             XIV      ,      ,            [26 - Rowlands G. The Dynastic State. P. 1, 266.]. ,   ,        ,         ,  [27 - Wakefield A. Disordered Police State. P. 16.]?

   XVIII ,  ,    .  ,              ,        .     ,          ,        ,        -              .  ,       ,       ,  -            -   . ,      ,           ,       ,            .  , ,    ,     ,             [28 - Ransel D. L. The Politics of Catherinian Russia. P. 7, 134.        XIX      (Rieber A. J. Bureaucratic Politics in Imperial Russia // Social Science History. 1978, Summer. Vol. 2. No 4. P. 399413)   ,   .  ,               19001920- .,            ,     ,        (Holquist P. In Accord with State Interests and The Peoples Wishes: The Technocratic Ideology of Imperial Russias Resettlement Administration // Slavic Review. 2010, Spring. Vol. 69. 1. P. 151179).  .      ,      ,               ,                ,             , ,        (Boeck B. J. Imperial Boundaries: Cossack Communities and Empire-Building in The Age of Peter The Great. Cambridge, 2009. P. 3, 7, 117).].

    ,   ,         . . .   ,    ,              ,  ,      [29 -  . .  . . 4647.].                ,    . .  (16631721),           [30 -  . .    : . .       I //   . ., 2009. . 13. . 314376.                 : Ivanov A. V. Reforming Orthodoxy: Russian Bishops and Their Church, 17211801. PhD diss. Yale University, 2012.]. . .                         [31 -  . .  :        I. , 1996.].      , . .  ,             ,      ,      [32 -  . .  . . 616. . :  . .   . . 3033, 31, 4245, 345346, 551.].

   ,           ,     XVIII         ,   .       :     ,      ,         ,       .            ,   ;    ,             ,    ;  ,   ,  ,    ,    ,   ,      [33 - North D. C. Institutions, Institutional Changes, and Economic Performance. Cambridge, 1990. P. 16.].   ,  ,       ,            ,  ,    .         ;            ,        , , ,    ,    .      ,          ,    ,  -    .      ,   ,      .


  Ƞ 

  XX               .  :     ,      ,         .         ,     :              . ,       ,              ,      .  , ,    ,        ,       [34 - .: Shaw D. G. Recovering The Self: Agency after Deconstruction // Sage Handbook of Historical Theory / Eds. S. Foot, N. Partner. London, 2012. P. 474494; Cabrera M. A. Postsocial History: An Introduction. Lanham, MD, 2004. P. 119; Cabrera M. A. The Crisis of The Social and Post-Social History // The European Legacy: Towards New Paradigms. 2006. Vol. 10. 6. P. 611620.    ()   .   Agency after Postmodernism  History and Theory (2001, December. Vol. 40. 4).].          ,    (    ),  ,       ,   ,   ,           ,     ,       [35 -     .: Norris S. M., Sunderland W. Introduction: Russias People of Empire // Russian Peoples of Empire: Life Stories from Eurasia, 1500 to The Present / Eds. S. M. Norris, W. Sunderland. Bloomington and Indianapolis, 2012. P. 117.                  (self-fashioning),               . .: Zitser E. A. The Vita of Prince Boris Ivanovich Korybut-Kurakin: Personal Life-Writing and Aristocratic Self-Fashioning at The Court of Peter The Great // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. 2011. Vol. 59. 2. P. 163194,        .     ., : Alexopoulos G. Portrait of a Con Artist as a Soviet Man // Slavic Review. 1998, Winter. Vol. 57. 4. P. 774790.].

,       ,     .               ,      .        ,   ,      :  , ,               ,       ,     ,     ,   ,   [36 - Johnson S. Projectors Injudiciously Censured and Applauded // The Adventurer. 1753, October 16. P. 99.].   ,      .   ,             ;  ,       ;        ,           .          ,         ,          [37 - Glete J. Warfare, Entrepreneurship, and The Fiscal-Military State // European Warfare, 13501750 / Eds. F. Tallett, D. J. B. Trim. Cambridge, 2010. P. 307316.].

                , ,   ,       .  ,     ,  ,     ,    ,   ,  ,   ,      .    ,       ,  ,   .    , ,                  .                    -[38 - Schumpeter J. A. Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy. London, 1994. P. 132133; Cassis Y., Minoglou I. P. Entrepreneurship in Theory and History: State of The Art and New Perspectives // Entrepreneurship in Theory and History / Eds. Y. Cassis, I. P. Minoglou. Houndmills; Basingstoke; Hampshire, 2005. P. 5.].

 ,                ,      (policy studies).    ,                ,         ,      [39 - Steeck W., Thelen K. Introduction: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies // Beyond Continuity: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies / Eds. W. Steeck, K. Thelen. Oxford, 2005. P. 17.].           ,      ,                  ,   ,    [40 - Lawrence T. B., Suddaby R. Institutions and Institutional Work // Sage Handbook of Organization Studies / Eds. S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy, T. B. Lawrence, W. R. Nord. 2


ed. London, 2006. P. 215.].      ,  ,    , ,     ,   ,    ( ),          [41 - DiMaggio P. Interest and Agency in Institutional Theory // Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment / Ed. L. Zucker. Cambridge, 1988. P. 322.].    ,       (policy entrepreneurship)         .     ,    ,      ,           [42 - : Roberts N. C., King P. J. Policy Entrepreneurs: Their Activity Structure and Function in The Policy Process // Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory. 1991. Vol. 1. 2. P. 147175; Mintrom M. Policy Entrepreneurs and School Choice. Washington, DC, 2000; Mintrom M., Norman P. Policy Entrepreneurship and Policy Change // The Policy Studies Journal. 2009. Vol. 37. 4. P. 649667; Teodoro M. P. Bureaucratic Ambition: Careers, Motives, and The Innovative Administrator. Baltimore, 2014.].

          ,       .          (embedded agency):   ,                ,     ,      ,  ,    ,            [43 - : Battilana J., Casciaro T. Change Agents, Networks, and Institutions: A Contingency Theory of Organizational Change // Academy of Management Journal. 2012, April. Vol. 55. 2; Battilana J., Leca B., Boxenbaum E. How Actors Change Institutions: Towards a Theory of Institutional Entrepreneurship // Academy of Management Annals. 2009. 3. P. 65107; Battilana J. Agency and Institutions: The Enabling Role of Individuals Social Position // Organization. 2006. 13. P. 653676; Battilana J., DAunno T. Institutional Work and The Paradox of Embedded Agency // Institutional Work: Actors and Agency in Institutional Studies of Organizations / Eds. T. B. Lawrence, R. Suddaby, B. Leca. Cambridge, 2009. P. 3158; Battilana J., Leca B. The Role of Resources in Institutional Entrepreneurship: Insights for an Approach to Strategic Management That Combines Agency and Institution // Handbook of Research on Strategy and Foresight / Eds. L. A.Costanzo, R. B. MacKay. Cheltenham, UK, 2009. P. 260274.].      (institutional work),        ,  ,  ,       ,    ,   ,         .             ,      ,        [44 - Lawrence T. B., Suddaby R., Leca B. Introduction: Theorizing and Studying Institutional Work // Institutional Work: Actors and Agency in Institutional Studies of Organizations / Eds. T. B. Lawrence, R. Suddaby, B. Leca. Cambridge, 2009. P. 6.].        ,           ,   ,       .         ,       ,      ,       .       ,              ,       .    ,             ;                [45 - Mokyr J.A Culture of Growth: The Origins of The Modern Economy. Princeton, NJ, 2016. P. 5968.       ,   ,   ,     : Ibid . 59.      ,    ,         (leadership-driven changes in social norms),      ,    ,    ,    (norm antipreneurs),     (  )     (Acemoglu D., Jameson M. O. History, Expectations, and Leadership in The Evolution of Social Norms // Review of Economic Studies. 2015. Vol. 82. 2. P. 423456; Bloomfield A. Norm Enterpreneurs and Theorizing Resistance to Normative Change // Review of International Studies. 2016. 42. P. 310333).].

     ,                ,        ,                (, ,   - ),         . ,             ,  , ,        ,  ,     , ,         , ,        .    ,      :          ( ,   )      ,      ,     ,      .            ,              ,    ,           ,    ,      .       ,   ,   ,         ,       .  ,       ,  .   ,  ,             .

         ,           ,   , ,  ,    .      ,    ,     .         ,     ,   XVIII              .   ,   ,    ,               , , .        1700-           ,    ,    ,     .             XIV   ,          :               ,        [46 - Rowlands G. The Dynastic State. P. 88108.].   ,       ,        ,   .        I,            ,      ,   ,  , ,          .

                   ,        .  ,           ,    ,              ,    -       [47 - . : Adams J. The Familial State.].        ,              . ,       ,         ,  ,   ,    [48 - Parrott D. The Business of War: Military Enterprise and Military Revolution in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge, 2012; Parrott D. From Military Enterprise to Standing Armies: State, Society and Military Organization, 16001700 // European Warfare, 13501750 / Eds. F. Tallett, D. Trim. Cambridge, 2010. P. 7495.].           ,            .       ;   ,   ;    ,     ; ,     ,   [49 - Smith D. K. Structuring Politics in Early Eighteenth-Century France: The Political Innovations of The French Council of Commerce // Journal of Modern History. 2002, September. Vol. 74. 3. P. 490537.      ,                     (Rowlands G. Agency Government in Louis XIVs France: The Military Treasurers of The Elite Forces // War, Entrepreneurs, and The State in Europe and The Mediterranean, 13001800 / Ed. J. Fynn-Paul. Leiden, 2014. P. 216217).].

           ,      .    , ,      ,   ,              :            .  ,  ,               [50 - Weber M. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology / Eds. G.Roth, C. Wittich. Berkley, 1978. Vol. 2. P. 1029.].   ,            ,    ,        ,     ;                    .        ,    ,        .   ,        ,      ,    ,      .        ,      ,     ( )       ,            . ,    ,            ,             .

   ?  , ,   ,    ,   ,         ,           ,          .              . -,       ,   ,         .  I, ,        :                   (     )   .         , ,          .                      .

-,       ,      ,        .       ,           , , ,      .         ,       .   ,     ,      .    ,            ,    ,                  [51 -     .:  . .   : ,      XIX . //  . 2006. . 9. . 548.].    ,        ,          . ,        ,       ,       ,   I   XIV.        ,        -     .  ,   ,    ,        ,                     .         .

,                     .      ,       ;  ,   ,       .             ,    ,      ,   ,   .   ,             ,         ,            ,       .          :     ,       ,        .   ,                       ;           .    ,                 ,         ,            ,        .        ,                 .

 ,       ,         .   ,  ,    ,     ,      .      ;       ,  ;  -;  ,    ;      .   ,     ,    ,   ,        (, )           .       ,        . ,                                .   ,   黠 ,                      ,      ,         .


 

    ,             :       [52 -    . : Novak M. E. The Age of Projects / Ed. M. E.Novak. Toronto, 2008. P. 328; Graber F. Du faiseur de projet au projet rgulier dans les Travaux Publics (XVIIIe  XIXe si?cles): Pour une histoire des projets //Revue dhistoire moderne et contemporaine. 2011. Vol. 3. 583. P. 733; Thirsk J. Economic Policy and Projects: The Development of a Consumer Societyin Early Modern England. Oxford, 1978. P. 122.                     . : NovakM. E. The Age of Projects  Graber F. Du faiseur de projet, .,   : Projektemacher. Zur Produktion von Wissen in der Vorform des Scheiterns / Ed. M. Krajewski. Berlin, 2004; Yamamoto K. Taming Capitalism before its Triumph: Public Service, Distrust, and Projecting in Early Modern England. Oxford, 2018.].  ,  ,   :   1697        ,                  ,      . ,   ,  ,          ,         ,    ,           [53 - Defoe D. An Essay upon Projects / Eds. J. D. Kennedy, M. Seidel, M. E. Novak. New York, 1990. P. 711, 17.].           XVII          ,         [54 -       .: Ratcliff J. Art to Cheat The Common-Weale: Inventors, Projectors, and Patentees in English Satire, ca. 16301670 // Technology and Culture. 2012. 53. P. 337365.].   ,    ,  ,  ,       ! ,   [55 - Novak M. E. The Age of Projects;  . .,  . .        //            (XVIXVIII .). .  /  . . . , . . . ., 2013. . 716.].   ,         .      :       ,        ,                   .      , ,      ,    .

               .   ,   ,    ,          ,   ,           .        .   ,       ,     ,       :    ,   ,   ,      ,  ,     ,      ,        .      1753     ,      []      ,       ,      .       ,      ,        ,       ,       컠   ,         .  ,        ,        - [56 - Johnson S. Projectors.].        1755          :    ,     ,    ,     ,    [57 - Johnson S. A Dictionary of The English Language. 2vols. London, 1755; repr.: New York, 1979.].                  ,        ,       [58 - Pesciarelli E. Smith, Bentham, and The Development of Contrasting Ideas on Entrepreneurship // History of Political Economy. 1989. Vol. 21. 3. P. 524.].

            ,       . ,                  [59 -  . .      //    . 1915. . 3. . 116.].    I, ,      .          ,  ,  ; ,  ,          ,      .      ,             ,    ,      ,   ,          [60 -         . :  ..         //  XVIII :  . ., 2008. . 1. . 3233.].   ,              - ,          ,  -         , ,   ,   ,        ,      .

   , ,         .  . . -,               ,  -  ,   ,        ,      ,       .          ,     .     -   ,        ;              ,      [61 - - . .       . ., 1897; .: ., 2011. . 1617.].     -           .              (    -      ),            ,  ,     ,       : ,      ,   ,    .  ,  ,           ,      ,    .

. .        ,       ,               .     -, - ,   [62 -  . .       XVIII    . ., 1905. . 383384, 542543.].                   ,                 [63 -  . .  . . :   ? // - . 1995. 4. . 7881;  . .,  . .   / . . . . ., 2010;  . .  :   .. . ., 2011;  . .          I //            (XVIXVIII .) /  . . . , . . . ., 2013. . 323337;  [] . .      :       XVIII  //    :        XVIII  /  . . . , . . . ., 2014. . 3468.].              ,     ,   I,  XII        .        ,          ,            .       II,         ,        .  ,  ,                      ,      :                       ,           [64 - Bartlett R. Projects and Peasants: Russias Eighteenth Century. London, 2000; Bartlett R. Utopians and Projectors in Eighteenth-Century Russia // Russian Culture and Society and The Long Eighteenth Century: Essays in Honour of AnthonyG.Cross / Ed. R. Bartlett, L. Hughes. M?nster, 2004. P. 98115.].


  ,  Ƞ

    ,  ,       1705         [65 -  . .,  . .,  . .       XVIII . ., 1972. . 389.].          (   ),       ,  ,    .   ,   ,      ,            ,    ,        ,   .

      XVIII   .        ,   ,           .        ,      ,                   ,          , , ,     ,       .       1720-    1730        ,   ,          ;   ,         [66 -    .:  . .   :     , 17251762 . , 2003;  . .,  . . 19   25  1730 . , , . ., 2010.].

   XVIII         ,    .         17671768 ,   ,     , ,   .                ,     .        ,           ,       .            ,                     ,          [67 -  . .  . C. 1323, 172193.].         ,        ; , ,           .      ,   ,   ,   .               .

    ,                   ,    .                 . ,           ,       ,   ,         , ,       ,    .               ,      .          ,      ,            ,    [68 - ,   . . :  . .  . C. 11.].                   , ,             ,        .

      ,        ,    ,      .      (  )           , ,            .            ,   :         ,  ;   ,     ;    /     .        ;        ;   ,     ;  .     ,         ,       .

               ,               :  ,   .         .   , ,  ,                 .          ,  ,  ,      ,     -       ,         <>  ,     ,  [69 -        .: Ben-David J. The Scientists Role in Society: A Comparative Study. Chicago, 1984. P. 105.         ,         . . :  . .      :        //  . . .  /  . . . . ., 2010. . 2. C.400442;  . . .   -   . ., 2020.].

        [70 - .: Ash E. H. Introduction: Expertise and The Early Modern State // Osiris. 2010. Vol. 25. 1. P. 124       .].  ,    ,   -    ,   , ,           .            ,            .         ,   ,  ,     .          -     : ,           ,       .            : ,   ,                      . ,          .      ,   ,    ,          .   ,      ,           ,  .

 ,    ,       ,        (  ),         .             .                      ,            .   , ,          ,         .        ,    ,  ,          .              .      ,       ,           ,  .        .   ,           :        ,           .  ,                      .           ,                  [71 - .: Biagioli M. Galileo, Courtier: The Practice of Science in The Culture of Absolutism. Chicago, 1993. P. 3777.          : Werrett S. The Schumacher Affair: Reconfiguring Academic Expertise across Dynasties in Eighteenth-Century Russia // Osiris. 2010. Vol. 25. 1. P. 104126; Usitalo S. A. Lomonosov: Patronage and Reputation at The St. Petersburg Academy of Sciences // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. 2011. Vol. 59. 2. P. 217239; Ospovat K. Mikhail Lomonosov Writes to his Patron: Professional Ethos, Literary Rhetoric and Social Ambition // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. 2011. Vol. 59. 2. P. 240266.].

        ,        .                . -,         ,      ,        ,                 . -,            .    ,    ,      ,              . , ,     ,                    . ,    , ,          .  ,   ,       ,                  [72 -      .: The World of The Favourite / Eds. J. H. Elliott, L. W. B. Brockliss. New Haven, 1999; Scott H. M. The Rise of The First Minister in Eighteenth Century Europe // History and Biography: Essays in Honour of Derek Beales / Eds. D. E. D. Beales, T. C. W. Blanning, D. Cannadine. Cambridge, 1996. P. 2152.        .:  . . . ., 2006. . 97109; Bitter M. Count Ernst Johann B?hren and The Russian Court of Anna Ioannovna // The Man Behind The Queen: Male Consorts in History / Eds. C. Beem, M. Taylor. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014. . 103124.].     ,    ,    ,   ,      .             ,        .         ,           - .         , , , ,    ,    :        ,   II        1787 [73 -     II   .: Griffiths D. M. Catherine II Discovers The Crimea // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. Neue Folge. 2008. Vol. 56. 3. P. 339348. ( :  .    //  .  II   :   . :   , 2013. . 369385).].

           .       ,        ,      ,  .        :       ,       ,         ;       ,          .     ,       ,        ;         ,           . ,      .           , ,       ,         . ,               ;             .  ,         ,         ,     .

,        컠   ,   ,    .        .       -   ,       , .           . ,         ,           - ,     ,       ,  ,        ;             .                  , ,        .        ,     -    ; ,      ,       . ,      ,  ,  ,            .    ,          , ,         ,         .


* * *

   , ,    -         .              XVIII ,               .                ,                 .             ,             .         ,      ,          ,     .          I   .   ,  ,         ,   ,       ,  ,    ,      .     ,   ,     ,            ,  ,        (  )      .




 1

, ,    : Ҡ  


 ,         ,   ,      ,       .       ,    ,      ,   .       :           ,   ,  .       ;    ,     .  ,  ,   ,   ,         .       ,      :   ,      . ,     ,           1698 ,   , , -  1711   .      ,      :  ,   , ,   ,         [74 -      .: Okenfuss M. J. Russian Students in Europe in The Age of Peter The Great // The Eighteenth Century in Russia / Ed. J. G. Garrard. Oxford, 1973. P. 133136;  . .          I //  . 1973. 5. . 4659;  .   . .    ,     . ., 1911. . 3. . 2740; . .,  . .     :     , 16972006 /  . . . ., 2008. . 3132 ( 53),   ,  :  . . 149, 153, 179, 181, 202, 218219, 222, 229, 300, 322.    ,    ,  :   . .   , 16971699 /  . . . , . . . ., 1992. C.116117.       17   ,   ,               [].].

     , ,   ,         ,                   .  ,            ,  ,      .       :          .    ,       ,      ,        ,   .          ,    ,    ;           .    XVIII       ,       .      ,        ,         (,    ),       .    ,          [75 - Okenfuss M. J. Russian Students in Europe. P. 134135.          .: Rodger N. A. M. The Wooden World: An Anatomy of The Georgian Navy. Annapolis, MD, 1986. P. 203205, 382394; Dickinson H. W.Educating The Royal Navy: Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century Education for Officers.Hove, Sussex, UK, 2007. P. 1021; Dainville De F. Linstruction des Gardes de la Marine ? Brest en 1692 // Revue dhistoire des sciences et de leurs applications. 1956. 9. P. 323338; Verg-Franceschi M. Marine et ducation sous lAncien rgime (17521792). Paris, 1991. P. 153172; BruijnJ. R. The Dutch Navy of The Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. Columbia, 1993. P. 96113.           .: Schotte M. E. A Calculated Course: Creating Transoceanic Navigators, 15801800. PhD diss. Princeton University, 2014.  ,            , .: Ash E. H. Introduction; Long P. O.Artisan/Practitioners and The Rise of The New Sciences, 14001600.Corvallis, 2011.].            ,       ,  ,         .                    -   ,    ,   ,       ,   .


     ?

            .           ,        ,             XVII ,    ,           [76 -                 ,  . . : Kosheleva O. E. Education as a Problem.].    ,   ,               ,            . . . ,              , ,          XVII    40        1520  ;           .    , ,            - 35 ,       , ,      1670    55 [77 -  . .    XVXVII . ., 1892; Carol B. S. Belgorod  Notes on Literacy and Language in The Seventeenth-Century Russian Army // Russian History. 1980. 7. P. 113124;  . .    .      XVII . //     . 1997. , 1998. . 3439;              XVII  /  . . . . ., 1989. . 6065; Marker G. Literacy and Literacy Texts in Muscovy: A Reconsideration // Slavic Review. 1990. 49. . 7489; Mironov B. The Development of Literacy in Russia and The USSR from The Tenth to The Twentieth Centuries // History of Education Quarterly. 1991. 31. . 229252; Witzenrath C. Literacy and Orality in The Eurasian Frontier: Imperial Culture and Space in Seventeenth-century Siberia and Russia // The Slavonic and East European Review. 2009. 87. . 5377.    .:  . .,  . .        //      :    . .   /  . . . . ., 1983. . 94104;  . .      XVII  //      :    . .   /  . . . . ., 1983. . 104111; Brown P. B. Muscovite Arithmetic in Seventeenth-Century Russian Civilization: Is It Not Time to Discard The Backwardness Label // Russian History. 2012. 39. . 393459.].              .              ,   (.   ,    ). ,     -  - .   ,        ,     .           ,    ,    ,        .    ,           XVII       .

 ,  ,        XVII      .          ,           ,    .        ;  ,        .   , ,  ,              ,   ,       ,    ,          .       . .    ,         XVII ,         []        [78 -  . .       XVII. //      .         /  . . . , . . . ., 1994. . 167.].

  ,        ,      ( ,   ),     -  ,  ,         .  ,         ,    ,    ,       .             :            .         ,               . . .                .  ,       , ,    ,      .   ,      XVII ,            [79 - Kosheleva . . Education as a Problem;  . .       // .   . 2010/2011. ., 2012. . 4772.]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/raznoe-4340152/prozhektery-politika-shkolnyh-reform-v-rossii-v-pervoy-polo/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


  .:  . .  .    . ., 1896;  .  .           XVII . , 1895;  . .   :     . ., 1990. . 233382;  . .  //       /  . . . . ., 1993. . 3: XVIII . . 3: ϖ. . 354361.  .:  . .  . . 338.




2


  .:  . . -     XVII . ., 2009. . 190213.     . 223231.




3


 . . . . 356358.




4


 . . - . . 214217.            (  ,     ).  , , ,                   . Potter C. J. The Russian Church and The Politics of Reform in The Second Half of The Seventeenth Century. PhD diss. Yale University, 1993. . 384394.       .: Chrissidis N. A. An Academy at The Courts of The Tsars: Greek Scholars and Jesuit Education in Early Modern Russia. DeKalb, IL, 2016 ( :  .    . :   .   ).      1689 . .:  . .    .            16821869 . .:  , 1999. . 157190.




5


 . .   //       /  . . . . ., 1993. . 3: XVIII . . 3: ϖ. .362379.




6


 . . - . . 208211, 214215.   . 215;    .: . 103173;  . . . . 355356;  . .   ( ) //       /  . . . . ., 1992. . 3: XVII . . 1: . . 128131.




7


 : Raeff M. Origins of The Russian Intelligentsia: The Eighteenth-Century Nobility. New York, 1966; Okenfuss M. J. Technical Training in Russia under Peter The Great // History of Education Quarterly. 1973, Winter. Vol. 13. 4. . 325345; Black J. L. Citizens for The Fatherland: Education, Educators and Pedagogical Ideals in Eighteenth Century Russia. Boulder, CO, 1979; Kusber J. Eliten- und Volksbildung im Zarenreich w?hrend des 18. und in der ersten H?lfte des 19. Jahrhunderts: Studien zu Diskurs, Gesetzgebung und Umsetzung. Stuttgart, 2004 ( :  .         XVIII    XIX . , , . ., 2018);  . .            XVII    XVIII. ., 2008.




8


        : Kosheleva . . Education as a Problem in Seventeenth Century Russia // The State in Early Modern Russia:New Directions / Ed. P. Bushkovitch. Bloomington, IN., 2019. P. 191217.




9


Black J. L. Citizens for The Fatherland. . 3.              :  . .   .   XVIII . . 1. ., 2014.




10


., :  . .          XVIII . ., 1997. . 152154; ,  :  . .    I:  o   .    , , , ,    . .; ., 1945. . 1;  . .    .           XVIII . ., 2017.




11


Bushkovitch P. Peter The Great: The Struggle for Power, 16711725. Cambridge, 2001. . 3.     , . .       ,             ( . .  :     3040-  XVI . ., 2010. . 610).




12


Artz F. B. The Development of Technical Education in France, 15001850. Cambridge, MA, 1966. P. 4446.




13


Ley F. Le Marechal de Munnich et la Russie au XVIIIe si?cle. Paris, 1959. P. 4.




14


Beik W. The Absolutism of Louis XIV as Social Collaboration // Past & Present. 2005. Vol. 188. 1. P. 195224.




15


., : Kettering Sh. Patrons, Brokers, and Clients in Seventeenth-Century France. New York, 1986; Mettam R. Power and Faction in Louis XIVs France. New York, 1988; Campbell P. R. Power and Politics in Old Regime France, 17201745. London, 1996; Adams J. The Familial State: Ruling Families and Merchant Capitalism in Early Modern Europe. Ithaca, 2005.




16


.: Martin R. E. The Petrine Divide and The Periodization of Early Modern Russian History // Slavic Review. 2010, Summer. Vol. 69. 2. P. 410425.           . : Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Architecture. Chicago, 1988; Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Imagery. Chicago, 1997; Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Culture. Cambridge, MA, 2004.




17


     . : Zitser E. A. Post-Soviet Peter: New Histories of The Late Muscovite and Early Imperial Russian Court // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 2005, Spring. Vol. 6. 2. P. 375392.




18


Ransel D. L. The Politics of Catherinian Russia: The Panin Party. New Haven, 1975. P. 12.




19


  /    .: Crummey R. O. Aristocrats and Servitors: The Boyar Elite in Russia, 16131689. Princeton, 1983; Kollmann N.Sh. Kinship and Politics: The Making of The Muscovite Political System, 13451547. Stanford, 1987; Kivelson V. A. Autocracy in The Provinces: The Muscovite Gentry and Political Culture in The Seventeenth Century. Stanford, 1996; Berelowitch A. La hirarchie des gaux: La noblesse russe dAncien Rgime (XVIe  XVIIesi?cles). Paris, 2001; Poe M. T. The Russian Elite in The Seventeenth Century. Helsinki, 2004. Vol. 1. The Consular and Ceremonial Ranks of The Russian Sovereigns Court, 16131713; Krom M. Formen der Patronage im Russland des 16 und 17. Jahrhunderts: Perspektiven der vergleichenden Forschung im europ?ischen Kontext // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. Neue Folge. 2009. 57. P. 321345.  ,       ,  : Meehan-Waters B. Autocracy & Aristocracy: The Russian Service Elite of 1730. New Brunswick, NJ, 1982;  . .      : C    //      XV   XX . .      /  . . . . ., 2007. . 366386;  . .          XVIII :           // Cahiers du Monde russe. 2009. 50. . 699736;  . .            XVIII  // Cahiers du Monde russe. 2010. 51. . 259280;  . .    17001725 .:         I //            (16821750) /  . . . , . . ., 2013. . 4562.




20


 . .   :    XVII . ., 2006; Bushkovitch . Peter The Great.




21


.: Zitser . . The Transfigured Kingdom: Sacred Parody and Charismatic Authority at The Court of Peter The Great. Ithaca, NY, 2004 ( : .  :       . ., 2008).




22


 . .         :      17111727 . , 2007.




23


Beik W. Absolutism of Louis XIV. P. 208.




24


   ,     ,     : Ermakoff I. Rational Choice May Take Over // Bourdieu and Historical Analysis / Ed. P. Gorski. Durham, NC, 2013. P. 89106; Ermakoff I. Theory of Practice, Rational Choice and Historical Change // Theory and Society. 2010, August. 39. . 527553. . : Aya R. The Third Man; or, Agency in History; or, Rationality in Revolution // History and Theory. 2001, December. Vol. 40. 4. P. 143152.




25


Rowlands G. The Dynastic State and The Army under Louis XIV: Royal Service and Private Interest, 16611701. Cambridge, 2002; Soll J. S. The Information Master: Jean-Baptiste Colberts Secret State Intelligence System. Ann Arbor, 2011; GrahamA. Corruption, Party, and Government in Britain, 17021713. Oxford, 2015; Wakefield A. The Disordered Police State: German Cameralism as Science and Practice. Chicago, 2009. P. 138.




26


Rowlands G. The Dynastic State. P. 1, 266.




27


Wakefield A. Disordered Police State. P. 16.




28


Ransel D. L. The Politics of Catherinian Russia. P. 7, 134.        XIX      (Rieber A. J. Bureaucratic Politics in Imperial Russia // Social Science History. 1978, Summer. Vol. 2. No 4. P. 399413)   ,   .  ,               19001920- .,            ,     ,        (Holquist P. In Accord with State Interests and The Peoples Wishes: The Technocratic Ideology of Imperial Russias Resettlement Administration // Slavic Review. 2010, Spring. Vol. 69. 1. P. 151179).  .      ,      ,               ,                ,             , ,        (Boeck B. J. Imperial Boundaries: Cossack Communities and Empire-Building in The Age of Peter The Great. Cambridge, 2009. P. 3, 7, 117).




29


 . .  . . 4647.




30


 . .    : . .       I //   . ., 2009. . 13. . 314376.                 : Ivanov A. V. Reforming Orthodoxy: Russian Bishops and Their Church, 17211801. PhD diss. Yale University, 2012.




31


 . .  :        I. , 1996.




32


 . .  . . 616. . :  . .   . . 3033, 31, 4245, 345346, 551.




33


North D. C. Institutions, Institutional Changes, and Economic Performance. Cambridge, 1990. P. 16.




34


.: Shaw D. G. Recovering The Self: Agency after Deconstruction // Sage Handbook of Historical Theory / Eds. S. Foot, N. Partner. London, 2012. P. 474494; Cabrera M. A. Postsocial History: An Introduction. Lanham, MD, 2004. P. 119; Cabrera M. A. The Crisis of The Social and Post-Social History // The European Legacy: Towards New Paradigms. 2006. Vol. 10. 6. P. 611620.    ()   .   Agency after Postmodernism  History and Theory (2001, December. Vol. 40. 4).




35


    .: Norris S. M., Sunderland W. Introduction: Russias People of Empire // Russian Peoples of Empire: Life Stories from Eurasia, 1500 to The Present / Eds. S. M. Norris, W. Sunderland. Bloomington and Indianapolis, 2012. P. 117.                  (self-fashioning),               . .: Zitser E. A. The Vita of Prince Boris Ivanovich Korybut-Kurakin: Personal Life-Writing and Aristocratic Self-Fashioning at The Court of Peter The Great // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. 2011. Vol. 59. 2. P. 163194,        .     ., : Alexopoulos G. Portrait of a Con Artist as a Soviet Man // Slavic Review. 1998, Winter. Vol. 57. 4. P. 774790.




36


Johnson S. Projectors Injudiciously Censured and Applauded // The Adventurer. 1753, October 16. P. 99.




37


Glete J. Warfare, Entrepreneurship, and The Fiscal-Military State // European Warfare, 13501750 / Eds. F. Tallett, D. J. B. Trim. Cambridge, 2010. P. 307316.




38


Schumpeter J. A. Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy. London, 1994. P. 132133; Cassis Y., Minoglou I. P. Entrepreneurship in Theory and History: State of The Art and New Perspectives // Entrepreneurship in Theory and History / Eds. Y. Cassis, I. P. Minoglou. Houndmills; Basingstoke; Hampshire, 2005. P. 5.




39


Steeck W., Thelen K. Introduction: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies // Beyond Continuity: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies / Eds. W. Steeck, K. Thelen. Oxford, 2005. P. 17.




40


Lawrence T. B., Suddaby R. Institutions and Institutional Work // Sage Handbook of Organization Studies / Eds. S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy, T. B. Lawrence, W. R. Nord. 2


ed. London, 2006. P. 215.




41


DiMaggio P. Interest and Agency in Institutional Theory // Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment / Ed. L. Zucker. Cambridge, 1988. P. 322.




42


: Roberts N. C., King P. J. Policy Entrepreneurs: Their Activity Structure and Function in The Policy Process // Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory. 1991. Vol. 1. 2. P. 147175; Mintrom M. Policy Entrepreneurs and School Choice. Washington, DC, 2000; Mintrom M., Norman P. Policy Entrepreneurship and Policy Change // The Policy Studies Journal. 2009. Vol. 37. 4. P. 649667; Teodoro M. P. Bureaucratic Ambition: Careers, Motives, and The Innovative Administrator. Baltimore, 2014.




43


: Battilana J., Casciaro T. Change Agents, Networks, and Institutions: A Contingency Theory of Organizational Change // Academy of Management Journal. 2012, April. Vol. 55. 2; Battilana J., Leca B., Boxenbaum E. How Actors Change Institutions: Towards a Theory of Institutional Entrepreneurship // Academy of Management Annals. 2009. 3. P. 65107; Battilana J. Agency and Institutions: The Enabling Role of Individuals Social Position // Organization. 2006. 13. P. 653676; Battilana J., DAunno T. Institutional Work and The Paradox of Embedded Agency // Institutional Work: Actors and Agency in Institutional Studies of Organizations / Eds. T. B. Lawrence, R. Suddaby, B. Leca. Cambridge, 2009. P. 3158; Battilana J., Leca B. The Role of Resources in Institutional Entrepreneurship: Insights for an Approach to Strategic Management That Combines Agency and Institution // Handbook of Research on Strategy and Foresight / Eds. L. A.Costanzo, R. B. MacKay. Cheltenham, UK, 2009. P. 260274.




44


Lawrence T. B., Suddaby R., Leca B. Introduction: Theorizing and Studying Institutional Work // Institutional Work: Actors and Agency in Institutional Studies of Organizations / Eds. T. B. Lawrence, R. Suddaby, B. Leca. Cambridge, 2009. P. 6.




45


Mokyr J.A Culture of Growth: The Origins of The Modern Economy. Princeton, NJ, 2016. P. 5968.       ,   ,   ,     : Ibid . 59.      ,    ,         (leadership-driven changes in social norms),      ,    ,    ,    (norm antipreneurs),     (  )     (Acemoglu D., Jameson M. O. History, Expectations, and Leadership in The Evolution of Social Norms // Review of Economic Studies. 2015. Vol. 82. 2. P. 423456; Bloomfield A. Norm Enterpreneurs and Theorizing Resistance to Normative Change // Review of International Studies. 2016. 42. P. 310333).




46


Rowlands G. The Dynastic State. P. 88108.




47


. : Adams J. The Familial State.




48


Parrott D. The Business of War: Military Enterprise and Military Revolution in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge, 2012; Parrott D. From Military Enterprise to Standing Armies: State, Society and Military Organization, 16001700 // European Warfare, 13501750 / Eds. F. Tallett, D. Trim. Cambridge, 2010. P. 7495.




49


Smith D. K. Structuring Politics in Early Eighteenth-Century France: The Political Innovations of The French Council of Commerce // Journal of Modern History. 2002, September. Vol. 74. 3. P. 490537.      ,                     (Rowlands G. Agency Government in Louis XIVs France: The Military Treasurers of The Elite Forces // War, Entrepreneurs, and The State in Europe and The Mediterranean, 13001800 / Ed. J. Fynn-Paul. Leiden, 2014. P. 216217).




50


Weber M. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology / Eds. G.Roth, C. Wittich. Berkley, 1978. Vol. 2. P. 1029.




51


    .:  . .   : ,      XIX . //  . 2006. . 9. . 548.




52


   . : Novak M. E. The Age of Projects / Ed. M. E.Novak. Toronto, 2008. P. 328; Graber F. Du faiseur de projet au projet rgulier dans les Travaux Publics (XVIIIe  XIXe si?cles): Pour une histoire des projets //Revue dhistoire moderne et contemporaine. 2011. Vol. 3. 583. P. 733; Thirsk J. Economic Policy and Projects: The Development of a Consumer Societyin Early Modern England. Oxford, 1978. P. 122.                     . : NovakM. E. The Age of Projects  Graber F. Du faiseur de projet, .,   : Projektemacher. Zur Produktion von Wissen in der Vorform des Scheiterns / Ed. M. Krajewski. Berlin, 2004; Yamamoto K. Taming Capitalism before its Triumph: Public Service, Distrust, and Projecting in Early Modern England. Oxford, 2018.




53


Defoe D. An Essay upon Projects / Eds. J. D. Kennedy, M. Seidel, M. E. Novak. New York, 1990. P. 711, 17.




54


      .: Ratcliff J. Art to Cheat The Common-Weale: Inventors, Projectors, and Patentees in English Satire, ca. 16301670 // Technology and Culture. 2012. 53. P. 337365.




55


Novak M. E. The Age of Projects;  . .,  . .        //            (XVIXVIII .). .  /  . . . , . . . ., 2013. . 716.




56


Johnson S. Projectors.




57


Johnson S. A Dictionary of The English Language. 2vols. London, 1755; repr.: New York, 1979.




58


Pesciarelli E. Smith, Bentham, and The Development of Contrasting Ideas on Entrepreneurship // History of Political Economy. 1989. Vol. 21. 3. P. 524.




59


 . .      //    . 1915. . 3. . 116.




60


        . :  ..         //  XVIII :  . ., 2008. . 1. . 3233.




61


- . .       . ., 1897; .: ., 2011. . 1617.




62


 . .       XVIII    . ., 1905. . 383384, 542543.




63


 . .  . . :   ? // - . 1995. 4. . 7881;  . .,  . .   / . . . . ., 2010;  . .  :   .. . ., 2011;  . .          I //            (XVIXVIII .) /  . . . , . . . ., 2013. . 323337;  [] . .      :       XVIII  //    :        XVIII  /  . . . , . . . ., 2014. . 3468.




64


Bartlett R. Projects and Peasants: Russias Eighteenth Century. London, 2000; Bartlett R. Utopians and Projectors in Eighteenth-Century Russia // Russian Culture and Society and The Long Eighteenth Century: Essays in Honour of AnthonyG.Cross / Ed. R. Bartlett, L. Hughes. M?nster, 2004. P. 98115.




65


 . .,  . .,  . .       XVIII . ., 1972. . 389.




66


   .:  . .   :     , 17251762 . , 2003;  . .,  . . 19   25  1730 . , , . ., 2010.




67


 . .  . C. 1323, 172193.




68


,   . . :  . .  . C. 11.




69


       .: Ben-David J. The Scientists Role in Society: A Comparative Study. Chicago, 1984. P. 105.         ,         . . :  . .      :        //  . . .  /  . . . . ., 2010. . 2. C.400442;  . . .   -   . ., 2020.




70


.: Ash E. H. Introduction: Expertise and The Early Modern State // Osiris. 2010. Vol. 25. 1. P. 124       .




71


.: Biagioli M. Galileo, Courtier: The Practice of Science in The Culture of Absolutism. Chicago, 1993. P. 3777.          : Werrett S. The Schumacher Affair: Reconfiguring Academic Expertise across Dynasties in Eighteenth-Century Russia // Osiris. 2010. Vol. 25. 1. P. 104126; Usitalo S. A. Lomonosov: Patronage and Reputation at The St. Petersburg Academy of Sciences // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. 2011. Vol. 59. 2. P. 217239; Ospovat K. Mikhail Lomonosov Writes to his Patron: Professional Ethos, Literary Rhetoric and Social Ambition // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. 2011. Vol. 59. 2. P. 240266.




72


     .: The World of The Favourite / Eds. J. H. Elliott, L. W. B. Brockliss. New Haven, 1999; Scott H. M. The Rise of The First Minister in Eighteenth Century Europe // History and Biography: Essays in Honour of Derek Beales / Eds. D. E. D. Beales, T. C. W. Blanning, D. Cannadine. Cambridge, 1996. P. 2152.        .:  . . . ., 2006. . 97109; Bitter M. Count Ernst Johann B?hren and The Russian Court of Anna Ioannovna // The Man Behind The Queen: Male Consorts in History / Eds. C. Beem, M. Taylor. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014. . 103124.




73


    II   .: Griffiths D. M. Catherine II Discovers The Crimea // Jahrb?cher f?r Geschichte Osteuropas. Neue Folge. 2008. Vol. 56. 3. P. 339348. ( :  .    //  .  II   :   . :   , 2013. . 369385).




74


     .: Okenfuss M. J. Russian Students in Europe in The Age of Peter The Great // The Eighteenth Century in Russia / Ed. J. G. Garrard. Oxford, 1973. P. 133136;  . .          I //  . 1973. 5. . 4659;  .   . .    ,     . ., 1911. . 3. . 2740; . .,  . .     :     , 16972006 /  . . . ., 2008. . 3132 ( 53),   ,  :  . . 149, 153, 179, 181, 202, 218219, 222, 229, 300, 322.    ,    ,  :   . .   , 16971699 /  . . . , . . . ., 1992. C.116117.       17   ,   ,               [].




75


Okenfuss M. J. Russian Students in Europe. P. 134135.          .: Rodger N. A. M. The Wooden World: An Anatomy of The Georgian Navy. Annapolis, MD, 1986. P. 203205, 382394; Dickinson H. W.Educating The Royal Navy: Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century Education for Officers.Hove, Sussex, UK, 2007. P. 1021; Dainville De F. Linstruction des Gardes de la Marine ? Brest en 1692 // Revue dhistoire des sciences et de leurs applications. 1956. 9. P. 323338; Verg-Franceschi M. Marine et ducation sous lAncien rgime (17521792). Paris, 1991. P. 153172; BruijnJ. R. The Dutch Navy of The Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. Columbia, 1993. P. 96113.           .: Schotte M. E. A Calculated Course: Creating Transoceanic Navigators, 15801800. PhD diss. Princeton University, 2014.  ,            , .: Ash E. H. Introduction; Long P. O.Artisan/Practitioners and The Rise of The New Sciences, 14001600.Corvallis, 2011.




76


                ,  . . : Kosheleva O. E. Education as a Problem.




77


 . .    XVXVII . ., 1892; Carol B. S. Belgorod  Notes on Literacy and Language in The Seventeenth-Century Russian Army // Russian History. 1980. 7. P. 113124;  . .    .      XVII . //     . 1997. , 1998. . 3439;              XVII  /  . . . . ., 1989. . 6065; Marker G. Literacy and Literacy Texts in Muscovy: A Reconsideration // Slavic Review. 1990. 49. . 7489; Mironov B. The Development of Literacy in Russia and The USSR from The Tenth to The Twentieth Centuries // History of Education Quarterly. 1991. 31. . 229252; Witzenrath C. Literacy and Orality in The Eurasian Frontier: Imperial Culture and Space in Seventeenth-century Siberia and Russia // The Slavonic and East European Review. 2009. 87. . 5377.    .:  . .,  . .        //      :    . .   /  . . . . ., 1983. . 94104;  . .      XVII  //      :    . .   /  . . . . ., 1983. . 104111; Brown P. B. Muscovite Arithmetic in Seventeenth-Century Russian Civilization: Is It Not Time to Discard The Backwardness Label // Russian History. 2012. 39. . 393459.




78


 . .       XVII. //      .         /  . . . , . . . ., 1994. . 167.




79


Kosheleva . . Education as a Problem;  . .       // .   . 2010/2011. ., 2012. . 4772.


