   .         
 

 


-
   .     ,   ,        .       ,           . ,     ,      ,    ,   .

     ,         .

          ,              .

 ,         ,        .

,        ,    ,    ,   4     .

                  Triad Consulting.      , Citigroup, Honda, Johnson & Johnson, Time Warner, Unilever   .



  PDF A4   .





 ,  

   

        




      



      , ,   ,                 .

 , The New York Times



   ,   ,      ,  ,    ,    .                        .

Strategy + Business



       .        ,              ,  ,       .                  .

T + D Magazine



            ,            ,              .

Parents Magazine



       .   ,       ,          ,   .      ,           :      - ?

The Guardian (London)



     .       ,        .

Evening Standard



   .     ,     .    ,      .   ,   .

Financial Times



       .         .           ,                 ,       .         .         ,     .    .

Kirkus Review



 ,       .      .         ,             .              ,       ,     .

 .,       -  



    .              .        ,    ,     .        .

 ,   ,     



  ,       .   .     . ,  ?       ,    .

 ,        Coca-Cola   Duke Corporate Education



  ,      - .

 , -  Merck



    ,      .       

 .,     Novartis,    ,     



           .    ,    ,  ,   .

. ,        , Time Warner Inc.



      ,     . ,      .

 ,  New York Times      



         .

 ,  IBM Management Development



      .    ,         !        ,       .             .       , ,          .

., -,   



    ,    .       .           ,  ,   .           .  ,           .          .      ,        .

 ,  International Rugby Coaching


    ,    .       .



, ,       ,      ,     , ,  ,   .










 ,  


    ,   ,       ,   ,          , :    .

 ,   . ,    .   ,      .       .



     .

          300  ,   .               .  2     ,        .   40        ,  71%   ,       .        ? 255   ,  877      [1 -      6  17 ,  ,     3  58  (www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/Do-Kids-Have-Too-Much-Homework.html),    180  (www.nces.ed.gov/surveys/pss/tables/table_15.asp).  ,      - ,     ,    ,  300     ,     .          (www.statisticbrain.com/youthsports-statistics).   98817   (www.nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=84)  19%   (18775)     (www.nces.ed.gov/surveys/frss/publications/2002131/index.asp?sectionid=3).        .        (www.press.collegeboard.org/sat/faq),         (www.statisticbrain.com/college-enrollment-statistics).   40        ,  71    ,        (www.statisticbrain.com/online-dating-statistics).        ? 255    (www.skybride.com/about),  877       (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/dvs/national-marriage-divorce-rates-00-18.pdf).        ,      , , , ,   .           1.1  (https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2011/compendia/statab/131ed/births-deaths-marriages-divorces.html)].

       . 12    ,      ,     .  500   ,   600   .   ,  -        .    [2 -     ,  2010      12645000   (    ).         . (https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2012/econ/2012-sbo.html).     ,   20092010   533945    593347  (www.sba.gov/advocacy/849/12162).].

 ?   ,     50  90%   ,    ,   ,        .    825    (94 000 !)         .           .     ?[3 -  .   ,        (www.westchestermagazine.com/914-INC/Q22013/Improving-Performance-Review-Policies-for-Managers-and-Employees).   91%   ,          (www.worldatwork.org/waw/adimLink?id=44473).  ,    ,    .    .     ,      3,3   (https://www.ilo.org/employment/Whatwedo/Publications/working-papers/WCMS_152690/lang  en/index.htm).        - ,     30 ,    94178 . ,   ,    ,       .]



    .      :      ?



           .



     .          ,   .



       [4 -   360 ⻠       ,    .        ,     ,     .].    ,    :          .



             ,   , ,   .          .    ,     ,      .       ,               .


* * *

 1999              :    .              ,     .       : , ,   , , , , , ,  , , , ,    .      .

        .           ,      . ,       ,  ,     .  ,      ,  ,    .     ,    .    -   ,       .  , ,  ,    . ,         ,    ,    - ?

  -    ,         .     .      .       . ,   ,      .  ,   ,     ,        .  ,    ,  ,   .    ?

.     ,   ,      .    ,    ,       .

   :        ?      ,        ,        .       ,   ,      ,   ,  ,   .   ,          ,     ,        .


    ?

     ,     .    ,                .   ,   ,    .       . ,    ,        ,          , ,    .          ,  ,     .    ,  ,     ,  ,          .

      .   ,  ,   .       ,   ,   ,    ,     ,    .

    :   ,      .     ?   ?   -     ?    ,     ,        ?   ,       ?      ?   ,   ?!


   

      60-  XIX ,    .      ,         [5 - Merriam-Websters Collegiate Dictionary, 9th ed. (1986).].  1909                .                 ,            .

              .              ! , ,     ,   .

           ,   ,  ,      .     .     ,        .         [6 - ,   2011   Globoforce, (https://www.cornerstoneondemand.com/sites/default/files/research/csod-rs-cornerstone-kelton-2013-employee-survey-results.pdf).  Cornerstone on Demand   51%.].

      .  28%  ,      ,    . 63%  ,       ,         ,     [7 -  ,      ,   Globoforce 2010 ,    .     750 .    2010   Sibson Consulting and World at Work.  20%  ,        ,         .   40% ,             . (http://www.sibson.com/publications/surveysandstudies/2010SPM.pdf).].

-  .         ,        .         ,   .         .   .

 ,      .


 ,  

    ,      .    .           ,        .  ,      ,    .    ,    ,   .     .     ,    .

         .     ,  - .           .       .

    ,  ,   ,  .

     ,     .                  .      ,       ,   .         .        ,   ,        , ,        .

   ,    ,   :         .    .         (  ,      ).         .       .          ,     ,    .      ,    ,     .  -           .        .        ,          ,     .


    

,       .   ,     .        .     ,      ,         .   ,           .

      ,  ,         .      ,             .         ,  -  .



           .         .     ,  ,      .



    ,             .          ,           .   ,      .



    ,       .     .     ,     ,       .



,     ,       .

  ,        ,  ,   ,      .    ,          .        . ?

.     .        ,        ,    .    ,    ,     .   ,  ,  .  ,  ,                    ,  ,     .     ,          .

 .    .   ,      ,  ?       ,     ?     ?

  .

   .       .            ,     .     ,       .     .      ,   ?      , , ?      ? , ! , ! , ! , !   !  !

                .    ,      ,    - .                   ,   .  ,          ,  ,   .   ,       ,    .   ,    .


    

     ,      .           ,     ,         .                  .  ,       10,       .

     :   ,  .       ,   .              ,     .      .

        ,          .       ,   ,           .            [8 -       . Michiel Crommelinck and Frederik Anseel, Understanding and Encouraging Feedback-Seeking Behavior: A Literature Review, Medical Education 2013; 47: 232241, doi:10.1111/medu.12075.              Z.G.Chen, W.Lam, J.A.Zhong, Leader-Member Exchange and Member Performance: A New Look at Individual-Level Negative Feedback-Seeking Behaviour and Team-Level Empowerment Climate, J Appl Psychol 2007;92 (1):202212,     S.J.Ashford, A.S.Tsui, Self-Regulation for Managerial Effectiveness  the Role of Active Feedback Seeking, Acad Manage J 1991;34 (2):25180. ,  Promoting Creativity Through Feedback, in J.Zhou, C.E.Shalley, eds Handbook of Organizational Creativity. New York, NY: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 2008; 125146; DEM De Stobbeleir, S.J.Ashford, and D.Buyens, Self-Regulation of Creativity at Work: The Role of Feedback-Seeking Behavior in Creative Performance, Acad Manage J 2011; 54 (4):811831.       : E.W.Morrison, Longitudinal Study of the Effects of Information Seeking on Newcomer Socialization, J Appl Psychol 1993;78 (2):17383; C.R.Wanberg and J.D.Kammeyer-Mueller, Predictors and Outcomes of Proactivity in the Socialization Process, J Appl Psychol 2000;85 (3):37385; E.W.Morrison, Newcomer Information-Seeking  Exploring Types, Modes, Sources, and Outcomes, Acad Manage J 1993;36 (3):557589.].

,  .  ,      -,     .       .      ,        .    ,    .

      ,      .        .       ,    .              .     ,                ,      [9 - S.Carrere, et al. Predicting Marital Stability and Divorce in Newlywed Couples, Journal of Family Psychology 14 (1) (2000): 4258. .  www.gottman.com.  ,               .     ,  ,       .].

    ,     ,      ,   .              .       ,    ,            .      ,        .        .  ,  .

   ,   ,  .    :    ,           ,    ,   .    ,     .    .     ,       ,   ,   ,   ,  [10 - Thomas Friedman, Its a 401 (k) World, New York Times, May 1, 2013.].

 ,       .

 ,      ,    .             ,       .        ,    .         ?  ,       .            .

        .    ,        .       ,        .     ,       .             .        ,  ,     .    ,       .  .   ,   .            .


 

     ,           .            .

  ?  ,     .

 !   ,    .  ,  -  !

        .    .  -    .




 1

  





 1.  

   



    .       .      .       ,   .    ,     ,   .      .    ,    ,     .

        ,       .        ,   ,     .   ,         ,     ,      .   ,    ,  - .

      .       ,   .    ,  ,  ?      ?      ?

    .  ,  ,     .      .      ,    ,  ,   .     ,  ,   ,     ,     .   ,    .

     ,        .    ,         ,      .

,      .      ,  ,      .                    .

     .


   

        ,     ,  ,       .   :

  .

    ,     .      ,      .

      ,    ,    .    ,      .     ,   ,   -        . ?!   ,      ?     .   .

    ,      .       .         (     !)     ,      (        ,     ?).          (        ?).

          ,   ,   .     .     ,   ,     ,        .  ,     .    .  ,    ,    ,     .      ,    .     .     ,          .    .

    ?     ,     ,        ,     ?

  .

       -  .   ,          .          .   ,    ,  , ,   ,  ,   .           ,           .

   ,    .     ,    ,  ,    ,   .          .              .

        .    ,             ,     .


      

        ,   ,     .




 :   , , 


      ,     .  ,  ,        .  ,     .      ,     .

           .         .



 ,   

       ,       ,     .    ,    ,         . ,     . ,     ,     .

     ,          .       ,    .      ,    .       .      ,    .

  , ,   , ,     .       :  (),  (   )   (  ).         ,  ,   ,     .  -    ,  ,  .         .  ,  - : !    .         ,   .

    -.      ,      ,   ,    : !    .      ?

 ,   ,  ,   .    .



  

     .   ,     ,  ,     .   , , , ,    .    .     .            .   ,     ,   ,   .    .

,   .    ,        .   ,         .  ,     .

     .    ,      .    (     )     .    ,     ,     ,     .

        .   ,       ? .  ,          .    ,      ,     .

  ,      .  :     ,             .          .        .      .

  ,     ,    :   ,      .            .               .   ,    .

    .     ,      .  . ,    ,     .



  

      . ,     ,    ,      ,   .    .        ,          .        .

         .   ,     ,  .          .

    .    ,    .        .  ,               ,  ,       .

    ,       .      .   .   , ,     ,    ,       .         .

     ,  .      ,    ,       .   ,          .

      .      ,   .   ,     ,  ,   .     ,     90  ,   10     ,    .




 :      


     (   )  ,   .             ,   ,      .        ,     .    ?        ( ?  ?)?       ,    ?        . ,  ,      ,         .



  :    

   ,    .   ,        ,    ,          .

       .   ,            .    ,     :       (  ),       (      ).     ,     .      .

     -.   ,      .

  , ,    ,     ,     :   ,    ,     -?       ,    ,        ,     ,   .

       ,     ,                 .          ,     .       ,   .         .

       ,             .        ,    .



  

         :   ,    ;     .   ,         .  ,             .

          ;     .        ,   .     (      )  .  ,    ,   :  ,   ?  ,    ,      .    ,    ,   ,     .

 :      ,   .     ,  .      ,        ,      .        .     ,      .      ,        ,        .

         -   .      .    .    ,     ,    .   .      .  ,   ,      .      :    ?        ?




 :     ,     


     ,        .      .     ,  ,      .   ,    .      ,             .           .



,        

           .        :        -,       -    ,  -    .    ,      .  ,         .             ,      ,     .



 

  .   ,     ,      .       ,      .      ,       .

  ,         ,   , ,   ,     .  ,    ,  ?  ,      ?      ,  ,                ,  .    ,    .            .

    (  ),      ,       .          .  ,     .       ,        .



  

     .      :       .      ,    ,        .       , , .   -         (   !),       ,     -  .

,    ,     .    ,    ,   .    ,    .        ,   ,        .    ,  :  ,  .     ,        .

 ,       ,    .      .      ,     .   ,     .













    ,   .    ,       .   .          .               .    ,    .


* * *

  29      ,         .   1011      ,            .   12             .

, ,   13           .     , ,   ,   .       ,         .           .

  ,   ,     ,  . ,     ,   ,       .




 2

    



     .          ,     .   ,    .  ,       ( 2),      ( 3)     ( 4).

  2         ,    ,      ,     .      .

  3     ,    :   ,    ,     .  ,      ,    ,    .

  4       ,    ,   .  ,           ,    .  ,       ,   .

  ,     : ,     ,   ,      ,     ?   4,   .




 2.  ,   



  .

  -,   ,  ,     .     ,  ,    .

  .       ,   .  ,       .   .    ,           ,  :

   !    !

  , ,   .       .

 !  . -,   !

      .



 ,  

 .  ,       ,         .      ,  ,    ,   .  ,       .

     .      .        ,     .

  .       .       ,    .      .

        .       , ,  .   ,    , , , .            ,    .    ,   ,    ,   , .




   


,    ,  .   ,   .   ,          .         .

-    ,          , .  :

     ,       ,  .        .    ? ?

,   ,   .    .

  .        .         .    ,     .

   ,      .

    ,   .

,  .   ,      .     ,       .     .

  :

  .    .  ,      .

   .   .        .    ,    .

  ,      -,      ,  .     .      ,   ,             .

      ,    .  ,          .     ,      ,        .      ,      .   :

      ,          ?

       ,  ,      :  ,    ?

       ?    .        -,  ?

 !     ,    ,     .

      ,         : ,   .       ,    ,      [11 -   ,       .      John Richardson, Roger Fisher, Alan Sharp, Getting It Done: How to Lead When Youre Not in Charge (HarperBusiness, 1999).].




  ,      ,  .

        .

     .       .   .  ,    .    .

      .             . ! ! !  ,     ,   ,   ,   - : , -  !       :   .   .    .

  .     ,     .  - ,        ,   ,   ,       .    .   .




     ,   .        , , .      ,     , , ,  ,   .          ,     .   ,        ,        ,    .

   ,   ,  ,        ,   ,            .     , , , ,    . ,  ,      .      ,           .

     .              .         , , ,         .

             .      . - , -   .     .   , , , , ,   .     ,    ,   ,   :        !,      ?,        ? ,       ,         .




  ,           ,   (  , ).    .  , .   ,     ,         .    ,  ,  黠   .       .

             .    滠     :       ,             ,        .

  ,       .     ,       .         ,   .      ( )      (   ).

   ,     .      ,      ,  ,     .    .           .   ,    .    (  )    ,    . ,             ,    . , ,     .




  

           ,      .   -   ,        .    .           ,    .

      .      ,        .     ,     :       .            .      .

    ,   ,     :   ?        ?

 .

       :                .     .       .        :             .         ,     - .       ,  .       .





  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=63842707)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


     6  17 ,  ,     3  58  (www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/Do-Kids-Have-Too-Much-Homework.html),    180  (www.nces.ed.gov/surveys/pss/tables/table_15.asp).  ,      - ,     ,    ,  300     ,     .          (www.statisticbrain.com/youthsports-statistics).   98817   (www.nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=84)  19%   (18775)     (www.nces.ed.gov/surveys/frss/publications/2002131/index.asp?sectionid=3).        .        (www.press.collegeboard.org/sat/faq),         (www.statisticbrain.com/college-enrollment-statistics).   40        ,  71    ,        (www.statisticbrain.com/online-dating-statistics).        ? 255    (www.skybride.com/about),  877       (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/dvs/national-marriage-divorce-rates-00-18.pdf).        ,      , , , ,   .           1.1  (https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2011/compendia/statab/131ed/births-deaths-marriages-divorces.html)




2


    ,  2010      12645000   (    ).         . (https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2012/econ/2012-sbo.html).     ,   20092010   533945    593347  (www.sba.gov/advocacy/849/12162).




3


 .   ,        (www.westchestermagazine.com/914-INC/Q22013/Improving-Performance-Review-Policies-for-Managers-and-Employees).   91%   ,          (www.worldatwork.org/waw/adimLink?id=44473).  ,    ,    .    .     ,      3,3   (https://www.ilo.org/employment/Whatwedo/Publications/working-papers/WCMS_152690/lang  en/index.htm).        - ,     30 ,    94178 . ,   ,    ,       .




4


  360 ⻠       ,    .        ,     ,     .




5


Merriam-Websters Collegiate Dictionary, 9th ed. (1986).




6


,   2011   Globoforce, (https://www.cornerstoneondemand.com/sites/default/files/research/csod-rs-cornerstone-kelton-2013-employee-survey-results.pdf).  Cornerstone on Demand   51%.




7


 ,      ,   Globoforce 2010 ,    .     750 .    2010   Sibson Consulting and World at Work.  20%  ,        ,         .   40% ,             . (http://www.sibson.com/publications/surveysandstudies/2010SPM.pdf).




8


      . Michiel Crommelinck and Frederik Anseel, Understanding and Encouraging Feedback-Seeking Behavior: A Literature Review, Medical Education 2013; 47: 232241, doi:10.1111/medu.12075.              Z.G.Chen, W.Lam, J.A.Zhong, Leader-Member Exchange and Member Performance: A New Look at Individual-Level Negative Feedback-Seeking Behaviour and Team-Level Empowerment Climate, J Appl Psychol 2007;92 (1):202212,     S.J.Ashford, A.S.Tsui, Self-Regulation for Managerial Effectiveness  the Role of Active Feedback Seeking, Acad Manage J 1991;34 (2):25180. ,  Promoting Creativity Through Feedback, in J.Zhou, C.E.Shalley, eds Handbook of Organizational Creativity. New York, NY: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 2008; 125146; DEM De Stobbeleir, S.J.Ashford, and D.Buyens, Self-Regulation of Creativity at Work: The Role of Feedback-Seeking Behavior in Creative Performance, Acad Manage J 2011; 54 (4):811831.       : E.W.Morrison, Longitudinal Study of the Effects of Information Seeking on Newcomer Socialization, J Appl Psychol 1993;78 (2):17383; C.R.Wanberg and J.D.Kammeyer-Mueller, Predictors and Outcomes of Proactivity in the Socialization Process, J Appl Psychol 2000;85 (3):37385; E.W.Morrison, Newcomer Information-Seeking  Exploring Types, Modes, Sources, and Outcomes, Acad Manage J 1993;36 (3):557589.




9


S.Carrere, et al. Predicting Marital Stability and Divorce in Newlywed Couples, Journal of Family Psychology 14 (1) (2000): 4258. .  www.gottman.com.  ,               .     ,  ,       .




10


Thomas Friedman, Its a 401 (k) World, New York Times, May 1, 2013.




11


  ,       .      John Richardson, Roger Fisher, Alan Sharp, Getting It Done: How to Lead When Youre Not in Charge (HarperBusiness, 1999).


