    . . .    - 
  


 
    ,   ,    ,  60-    .          ()  29   2  2004  .





    . . .    - 

   





   . . 

. . 


 ,    . . , ,  ,           :    - ,      .        .    .        ,        .

  . .       ,         -  -.    .    ,        .       ,          ,   , .

,     ,     .  ,   .        ,  ,      . .

   ,   ?

      , ,  ;     20-      ,           .                    ,          ,      .            ,       ,        [1 - .. ,   . . :   ┻,  . . : pro et contra.          . . ., 2003, . 59.]. , , . . .    ,    ,  ,     ,   ,  .       ,   (!) ,     ,      ,    . ?

. .  ,         ,     ,          ,     ,     ,    ,   ,          , ,      [2 - . . ,   (18291830).  ,       , . 1. ., 1991, . 326, 327.].           ?

,       . ,          .   -   ,  ,  -  .     , ,     .       ,     .   ,     ,    [3 -   ,   , ,         ,     . . ,  .  :        ,         ,     .   .      ,  ,          ,     .          .     .            .         .      .    ,    .   ,   (. . ,      XIX-  ,   , 2001, 1. . : http://www.atheism.ru/ (http://www.atheism.ru/) library/Semenov_2.ht.m).   ( ,       ), , ;   ,           .].

    .

1.. .  ,       -            ,         .     ,          ,     ,     [4 - . . , Ibid., . 15.],       .           :       .

2.        ,          . ,              ,   - ,        .       ,    .          ,         ,          .

  ,                  ,        ,     ,              .    ,            ,     ,   ,    ,               ,      ,     ,    ,          .   ,            ,       ,       [5 - Ibid, . 22.].

3.       ,                 ;                   .        (, ),        ,               [6 - Ibid, . 25, 34.].

4.. .       ,          .           ,  ,    ,                             .    ,                . ,       ,    ,     :           ,  . ,         ( ) .  ,      -  ,       [7 - Ibid., . 36, 48.].

5.    . .     ,      . ,   ,     [8 - ,     (1935.). .  : . . ,  :       () (  ); . , -   ,  , , .  ,  125-   .  . ., 1999, . 109128.].   ,     ,     .                   .     . :         ,    ,          -  .

:          (  ),     .     .      . .       :          .  ,  ,    ,     ,     ,  .  ,  ,       ,      .

    ,  ,    ,    ,    ,        .         ,    ,               .

   ,      . . .      .   III     ,     ,    ,  ,   ,    (         -?),   :   ,           .

             ( ?)      ,     ,                          ,        ,         ,    ,        -          ,    ,           ,  ,   ,     ,              - , ,     [9 - . . ,    ,   . , 2001, 2. ., 2001, . 11, 12.].

         ![10 - . ,  ,     , . I. ., 1990, .592593.]      ,      - ,                 [11 - . , . ., 2003, . 327.].       , ,  .   ?

 ,   . .       .           .       ,  .


* * *

         ?          ?

1.,       ,          .          ,  .   , ,   ,  -        .  껠      ,          ,   . -         .    󻠖          .

  ,  ,  ,      ,  (  )        ;            .     ,      ,           .      .            ,       .   ,          ,        , [12 -        .   ,      .       ,     .      ,    .          . , , , ,           (A. Maslow, The Farther Reaches of Human Nature,  The Journal of TranspersonalPsychology, 1969. . : http://www: nat-soul.ru/masla01.htm. . . . ).        .  ,  ,   ,           .   ,    ?             ,      .  ,         ,   .       ,      . ,     . . .].

2. ,     .             credo?   .

,       (     )  (    !)       . ,  . .   ,        ,  -    .        ,      ,   .        ,    ,     ,      [13 - . , .   ,   . ., 1989, . 92.]. ,     ,       ,  ,   . . ,   :             ;   ,   ,               ,     .

,   ,   ,  ,        [14 - . . , ,  . ,    , . 2. ., 1990, . 802, 803.].        ,  ,     :  , ,       - ,    ,        ,            ,       ,                :   ? ,    [15 - F. Nietzsche, Werke: In3 Bd6, M?nchen, 1982, S. 830.]    ,    腻[16 - . . ,  :  ,  . ,    , . 1. ., 1990, . 30.].

 , ,     ,           ,   , .       , ,  , . , , ,      . ,  , ,           ,  ,   ,         ,       .    ,           [17 - . . ,   ,     , . 2, ., 1993, . 148.].       ,         .         ,          ,      .                , ,  ,    .[18 - . . ,          ,     , . 2. ., 1993, . 37.].   ,        , .   .

, ,               .         ,         ,      -     XXI .       ,    ,        ,       [19 - . . , Ibid., . 21.].

 ?   ,   ,            .  , . .     ,     .       ,         ,            .  -     !

3.     .      ?       ?      .       ?          .      . ,       ,    .

 - -      ,   -   ,    ;           [20 - .: . . ,     ,     , . 2. ., 1993, . 25.].

. . ,  ,     ,    , :      ,  ,       .   ,      ,    .        ,        [21 - . . ,  ,  . . : pro et contra.          . .-, 2003, . 395, 396.].      ,              ,     .                   : ,   ,   ,  [22 - Ibid, . 397.].

      . ,       ,        . ,     ,    .    ,  ,  ,           .

          ?

    . .    ,  , ,      ,       ,   [23 - . ,    .   . ,   . ., 1993, . 108.].        ,      ,     ,     .               ,   .  ,          ,      [24 - .: . . , . , .    ,  , (2002), . 7. 4, .504522; .   . :   ,   , 2004, 2, .148159;      (. .  ..) (  ).].

     :      . ,   . ,  . [25 - .: . ,      ,    .      . .-, 1999, .373387.],          ?           [26 -  ,          ,  , , ,  , -       ,  ,      ,            , , , ,     .           , , ,  ,       (. . ,     ? (.    . ),       ..-, 1999. . : http://www: universalintemetlibraryru/stat/Blue-eyes_3.htm).]      ?

4., ,         ,            .

     , ,     . ,             ,   ,   .         ,         ,     .  ,  ,  . .     [27 - .: . . ,  . ., 1996;  . ., 1999.],           ,     ;           (   . . [28 -     . .  ,   -  (. . . , ,   . , 1991, . 301).]).   .  ,            ,        [29 - .: .  ,        .  . , 1997.];        ,         . . ,                 ,      .  : ,     ,     ,        ,                 [30 - K.Barth, Philosophie und Theologie. Philosophie und christliche Existenz,  Festschrift f?r . Barth, Basel, 1960, S. 101. . : . . ˸,    :  ,  , 1992, 1, . 162.].       :               ,    .         , ..   .    ,       .[31 - . . ,  ,     , . 1. ., 1993, . 388.].         ,                     (  ,   ),               -[32 - . .   ,           (. . ,   . ., 1991, .275276).].  ,   .       [33 -      ,    ,    (. . ,  ,    , . 1. ., 2000, . 219).],           .

5.         . ,       ,    ,  :   ,     ,     ,    ,    ,      [34 - ,        ,        ,         ,                 .].

 ,   -       [35 -   : . .       . -,    ,              :           .       . -, . .  ,   -    ,     ,  , ,     , ,   (. . ,      . . ,  . . : pro et contra, . 262).   ,  ,  .        . . .       . ,         . .].      . ,  60- .        ,      , -           ,     80-       .     XXI ,    ,         ,      , ,    ,      ,     .

  , ,              ,   .       .      -             .       ,       ,  ,      - ,              .        (        ),               .     ; ,             .

 . .  :    ,   ,  ,    [36 - . . ,     (1828-1850- ),       , . 1. ., 1991, . 506.].     (  ,  ,       )    ,     ,     ,           ,      ,     [37 - . . ,   ,   , . 216217.].       .  :       .        ,    ,         ,       [38 - Ibid, . 227.].

 .     ,            [39 - Ibid, . 231.].         .   ,    ,   .     [40 -   ,  1923 ,           .          . ,  1917 ,     ,    ,           (. . , , . 301). , , ,           ,             . .: .  (),   . . (  ).].

  .  ,             .   ,    .              .    ,        .      ,    .     .

     .  ,     .  ,      .      .     .

:                 ,   ,    .       , .       ,      .

  ,       .

1.. .     ,       . . ,    ,   ,        .     ,          .         ( ).    ,  ,     ,       ,        .           ,           ,  ,  ,    .

     . ,         ,      , :            ?       ?

,     ,   :    ,       .          .     ,    ,    .  ,       ,       ,      ,     [41 - . . ,  , . 387.].

   ,              (        ,     ),     ,      .

 򻠖      ,   , ,  . ,  .    ,    .     ,       .       .     .

   , ,    ,    .      ,     ,     ,     . ,     ,       ,    .

2.          .       ,   ,      ?     ,              ,         .   ,      , ,   ,   ,        .             .

       ,   ,     ,   ,  .          ,        ,    ,    ,               .       :     ,         ,           ,       ,     .   ,   ,           .  -    ,   仠    ,         ,   ,      .

   ,   ,    .   :       .                    .     .

3.            ,            .    .      ,     .   ,          ,    ,      , !    -             ,         .     -,   ,      .            ,       .           ,     ,         .

,    ,      ,    , .     [42 -      ,         (. . ,     ,   . , 1991, . 121; . :  .  ,  Ibid., . 199).].      :    ,         ,    ,  .   ,       .          [43 - . . ,   ,     , . 2. ., 1993, . 127.].  ,     ,  ,       ,   .          : ,       ,  ,   ,    ,         ;          ,    .     ( , ,         ) ,   ,    [44 - Ibid., . 128.].

      .      : ,           ,       .

4.        ,             .       . ,  ,                 ,    - ,   .

      .     ,       .             .            ,          ?[45 -    -  ,    ,   ;    ;  ,   ,    ,        ,     ;    ,     .   ,       , ,   ,    ,   .      ,      ,          ,    ,       ; ,      ,        (. . ,     , . 123).     ,      .]

   ,      ?    ,     ,      ,   ,      ,      .     ,           ,       [46 -         ,       (. . ,  .  , . 199). ,      ,  ,    :          .].

5.                .             : ,   ,    , ,  ,  ,    ,    ;           .         -    .              .                 , ,        .

          . ,     ,       ,          (      ,    , ,    ,    ,   ,     ). , ,       , ,             .

          ,     ,     .            ,       ,   .        . . ,     ,   ,     ,      ,       [47 - . . ,  ,     , . 2, . 519.]. ,    ,   ,         ,   ,        ,   .



      .              : ! ,  !    ?     ,     ,    ?    - ,         ?[48 - . . ,   . Pro  contra.  ,     . . 2. ., 1993, . 625.]

        .       .      .

          ,        .     .    .  ,  . .           :

, ! ,   ,  ,   ,      -,  ?   ,   ,     ,          ,  ,       ,  ,   ,  , ,   ,   ,  !    ,    ,    ,  [49 - . . ,  .  , . 194.].

  ,  .  ,    ,    .     .




I.         





   . .         II  

. 


          ,           ,  II  .

   ,     ,          II  .      (nouvelle theologie)  ,       (             )           ,       ,           .

,    ,          .

              (   ),     ,     .

         ,         ,      ,         .   .

     I       1936.   [50 -  . .      : Thesen ?ber die Kirche,  Proc?s Verbaux du Premier Congr?s de Theologie Orthodoxe ? Athbnes, 29 nov. 6dec. 1936, publie par les soins du President Prof. H. S. Alivisatos, Athenes 1939, .127134.           .],    .

  :

              .



1.   .

     ,  ,   ,            .

       ,    .       ,    (  )    .



    (Lumen gentium,   LG)       .

      (mysterum),              (LG Nr.1).



2.  .

    , ,         ,       .  ,        ,            .

 , ,    ,     ,    .                .

            .      ,      ,   .  ,       ,    .      :         ( 1:4)!

   ,   ,    ,      ( 3:9),   , ,   (2  5:1),  ,     ( 8:18),  ,       ( 21).



           .        :         .

  , ,     ( )   ,   .

       ,        ,  , ,   ;   ,  .

      ,   ,       ;        .

     :   ,    ?  : .  !  .   ?

   :    .  :     ?   ,      ,      .

??? ??? ?????, ????: ? ????????, ?????. ????? ????: ????? ??? ??????????; ???, ?????, ?????? ????? ???????, ??? ????? ??????????; ??? ?? ??? ?????? ? ?????? ??????????. Et ego dixi: Quis ergo est? Et ait mihi: Ecclesia est. Et dixi ei: Quare senior? Et ait mihi: Quoniam prior omnium creata est, propterea senior est, eo quod propter ipsam saeculum creatum est.

    :   ,       (!),       .

 -  .

        ,    ,      ,   .       ,     ,    .

    .      ,      .  ,     ,  , ,   ,       .

? ??? ??????, ?? ??????? ??????????????, ??? ???? ? ????????, ? ??????? ??? ??? ??? ?? ????????. Turris enim quam vides, quae aedificatur, ego sum, Ecclesia, quae parui tibi modo et antea.



3.  .

  ,    ,      .        ,       ,  .

       (1  12:27,  1:23; 4:12,  1:24),          (1  3:1617; 6:19,2  6:16).

        ,        .           ,            .

        ,       ( 5:32,  21:9; 22:17)              , ,      .

             ,           .       ,   .

            ,     .



       ;          ,    ,              .  ,      ,  ,   ,      ,        (LG Nr. 2).

        ,         ,    ,            (LG Nr. 50).



4.  .

 ,   ,                 ,    ,      .  ???????v?,      ,       ,            (    ).

     - ,           ,     .               (2  3:17);           ( 4:16).

        (   ,    ,         ????????).            .



 (communio)      (     ,   ) .      -  ,    ,            (Notapraevia Nr. 2 LG).



5.   .

     ,  ,         ,            .

   ,      ,       .

   , ,    ,        ,     .   ,      .

               (.  22:2627).    ,   ,             ,      .

            ,       ,         ,     .



6.  .

       ,        ,       .         ,     ,        .

           (ex sese, non autem ex consensu ecclesiae)    .

    ,        ,     .          :               .         ,   ,    ( ).       ,        ;   ,     ,       .

 ,   ( 3:8),      ,          :     .



           (Nota praevia Nr. 4 LG).

  ,      ,    (ex sese, non autem   ).

 I   :    ,         ,               ,      ex Gathedra    ,  -  ,     .

  I  ,       ,  ,    ,      II  ,           .               .



7.  .

    (   )         .             .             ,      .

                (, ,    ).              ex opere operato,          ex opere operantis.

      ,     ,         .



8.   .

       ,             .

          ,      .    ()        .        ,         .           .

                    (   , ,    ..).

          .             .        ,           ,     .

       (, ),   -     .



  (ecclesiae particulares),           ,    .

     ,      .     ,          ,    ,       (vere inest et operatur) , ,    .



9.  .

,    ,       .

   ,   ,       ,       ,              .

 :          ,           .                ,   .

     ,           .           ,     ,          ,     .

      (  )     (, 1936).



10.Ecclesia extra ecclesiam.

  ,    .   ,  ,  ,     ,    (,  ,  ,  extra ecclesiam nulla salus).

               ,      .    ,             ,   .

  extra ecclesiam nulla salus    ,    ecclesia extra ecclesiam (     ).

      ,    ,              .



11.   .

,    ,       .  ,       ,  ,        .

     ,   ,       .           : ,    .

    -     -  ,            ,  ,   .  ,       ,      ,       .



12.  .

,     ,     .       ,       ,      .

     ,   ,       ,  ,     ,       ,  ,   ,           ,      .

     ,      .



               .

   ,    . ,     ,      .    ,        ,     ,       ,   (LG Nr.63).

           ,      ( 5:27),     ,   ,   . ,     ,            (LG Nr.65).




 :        .   . 

. 


  ;   ,  .

(2  3:17)


:      

    ,     .      ,       ,       ,             ,       .       ,        ,       . ,  ,   (??),   (??????), ,  , ,          [51 -   ,       ,      ,    ,      ,  ,           , ..   ,      , ,    (, . V. 1. 6. ., , 1995, . 129,  . . . ). .  ,       (.: L. Kola-kowski, MetaphysicalHorror, Oxford, NY 1988). . : . , . ., 2003, .412416, 447452.].               ,              .                ,      ,         

  ,    ,      ,            .

     ,   ,         ,      .      ,           ?                     ?

          ,         ,    (1  1:20)[52 -      .],          -               (        ( 1:4)).      ?  ,        ,     ( 13:8),     ,    ,   ,     ,    ( 2:8)?  ,  ,    ,  Theatrum gloriae Dei (  )[53 -  ,    :       ,     ,        ,    ,      (Totum mundum hoc fine condidisse, ut gloriae suae theatrum foret) (J. Calvin, Concerning the Eternal Predestination of God [De aeterno Praedestinatione Dei or Consensus Genevensis] [=De aet. Dei. Praed.]. Trans. J. K. S. Reid, Louisville, Kentucky, 1997 [1552: Vol. 8, 294 of Calvins Works], . 97.], ,                ,   ,         ,       .          ,   ?       ,     ,   ,    ?


 ,    ,     

 ,    ,     ,            ,    .             [54 - R. Williams, (ed., trans., and Introd.), Sergii Bulgakov: Towards a Russian Political Theology, Edinburgh, 1999, р. 168169.].         ,    -,  ,          , , ,   ,         ,            [55 - .: . ,  . ., 2000, .148151.]. ,  ,      , ,    ,  ,  ,           ,     [56 - R. Williams, 169n.]. ,    ,       ,     ,   ,    .

    ? ,       -  (     [57 -  1931. .       ,  ,   ,   .       (.: H.-O. Friedrich, Lieber Feoder Iwanowitsch: Aus Briefen von Nikolai Berdjajew und Georges Florovsky an Fritz Lieb,  Stimme der Orthodoxie, 1997, B. 3, S. 166171),           1930. (: M. D. Peterson, Georges Florovsky and Karl Barth: The Theological Encounters,  Summary of Proceedings  Forty-seventh Annual Conference of the American Theological Library Association. Ed. by Joanne Juhnke. Vancouver, British Columbia, 1619 June, 1993. V. 47. Philadelphia: American Theological Library Association, .141165; E. Busch, Karl Barth: His life from letters and autobiographical texts. Trans.John Bowden. Philadelphia, 1976. P. 215; A Arjakov-sky La generation des penseurs religieux de lemigration Russe: La Revue 'La Voie (Put), 19251940. Kiev, Paris: LEsprit et la Lettre, 2002, . 387).],        ,      ,   [58 -               (18921970),       ,   ,          , ,  (.: K. Bambauer, The Letters of Nikolaj Berdjajew to Fritz Lieb. http://www.berdyaev.com/berdiaev/bambauer/Fritz_Lieb.html)  .  ,  ,     (  ) Orient und Occident. .       (.: F. Lieb, Sophia undHistorie: Aufsatze zur ostlichen und westlichen Geistes  und Theologiegeschichte, Zurich, 1962),        (.: Die Lehre von Christus bei Sergej N. Bulgakov,  Theologische Blatter, B. 13 (Jg. 1934), S. 212217  Bulgakow Sergej Nikolajevitsch,  Die Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart. Handworterbuch f?r Theologie und Religionswissenschaft. Hrsg. von Kurt Galling. 6volumes, Tubingen: 19571962; RegBd. 1965. 3


 Ed. B. I, S. 1505.   .      .: A. Arja-kovsky, Op. cit, .207209, 385386.]). ,  ,      ,      ,       컠           [59 - ., ,   . , Die Krisis des Protestantismus und die Russische Orthodoxie,  Orient und Occident, 1929, 1, S. 1125.]    ,       ,     [60 -      ,  19291938.,         (M. Stricker, Nachlass Fritz Lieb, Basel, 1990, S. 35).].             .

-,      (,     )     ,      ,          . -,        ,      (       )         .    .        ,           30- :         (1933)      (1935)[61 -     ,        .     : B. Geffert, Sergii Bulgakov, The Fellowship of St. Alban and St. Sergius, Intercommunion and Sofiology,  Revolutionary Russia, 17:1 (June 2004).      : Anglicans & Orthodox Between the Wars. PhD dissertation. University of Minnesota, May 2003, .172204. . : S. V. Nikolaev, Spiritual Unity: The Role of Religious Authority in the Disputes between Sergii Bulgakov and Georges Florovsky Concerning Intercommunion,  St. Vladimirs Theological Quarterly [=SVTQ] (forthcoming)      : A. Gal-laher, Bulgakovs Ecumenical Thought,  Sobornost, 24.1 (2002), .2455; Bulgakov and Intercommunion,  Sobornost, 24.2 (2002), .928; CatholicAction: Ecclesiology, The Eucharist and the Question oflntercommunion in the Ecumenism of Sergii Bulgakov, St Vladimirs Orthodox Theological Seminary, May 2003.        : M. Plekon, Still by Jacobs Well: Sergius Bulgakovs Vision ofthe Church Revisited.   2005. SVTQ.   ,  , .   : . , . .   . . :       ,  . . : - :   ,  130-   . 57  2001.  . .   .  (-  :   . . 4). , 2003, .86114.].            ,     .             . ,           , .   .   ,    ,      [62 -      : P. Valliere, Modern Russian Theology: Bukharev, Soloviev, Bulgakov: Orthodox Theology in a New Key, Michigan, 2000, . 1,     : Role of Honour,  St Vladimirs Seminary Quarterly, 1954, V. 2, . 6.],     ,   ,        per se      .       , ,       ,       . ,             ,     .    ,  , ,      .   ,        ,       .         (Being as Communion)   ,        <>;            ,   ; <>          ,               [63 - J. Zizioulas, Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church,  Contemporary Greek Theologians, 4, N.-Y., 1997, .26.].

,      ,        ,        (, ,   ..),      .        , , ,    .   ,   ,       ,  ,    ,    .     ,  ,               .  ,        ,                   

[64 - .: . ,   ,   :   , , 1937, .924.].                ,     ,  .     ,         ,          .        ,       ,         ,   ,     , ,      .


I.        [65 -         .   (Paul Fiddes), : P. S. Fiddes, The Creative Suffering of God, Oxford, 1988, . 112 ff.]

           ,             extra Calvinisticum[66 -      : B. McCormack, Grace and Being: The role of Gods gracious election in Karl Barths theological ontology. The Cambridge Companion to Batrh. Ed. John Webster, Cambridge, 2003. 95-101 [92-110]. . : E. D. Willis, Calvins Catholic Christology. The Function of the So-called Extra-Calvinisticum in Calvins Theology, Leiden, 1966.].    ,          ,     Logos asarkos ( )  extra carnem ( ),       (Logos ensarkos),    () ,   [67 -               ,    ,       .     :       , ,   ,      ,        ;   ,    ,  ! (J. Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion. 2 Volumes. Trans. Ford Lewis Battles, Philadelphia, 1960. Vol. 1, II.13 4 p. 481; . : Vol. 2, 4.17.30 p. 1402).].  ,                 . , ,    intra Luthera-num (  totus intra carnem et numquam extra carnem          ) ,     ,   (  )       ,      , ,    communicatio idiomatum ( ),       ,            .  ,    ,         ,     ,     (, )   [68 - ,    ,        []  ,   , , .    ,                      28:18:         ,   c.    2:9:         (Formula of Concord. Trans. by F. Bente and W. H. T. Dau. The Symbolical Books of the Ev. Lutheran Church, St. Louis, 1921, .503529; . : http://www.ctsfw.edu/etext/boc/fc/fce08.asc (http://www.ctsfw.edu/etext/boc/fc/fce08.asc).  . : http://skatarina.ru/library/credo/formsogl1.htm (http://skatarina.ru/library/credo/formsogl1.htm).].      ,        logos asarkos (      ),   ,        , ,  [69 - . Barth, Church Dogmatics, Edinburgh, 19561975. IV/1, . 181.].  ,  ,      (extra carnem)     . ,  ,    ,           , , ,             ,       ,  [70 - Ibid., II/1, . 26.].    ,  ,            ,  .

,   ,      [71 - .: Ibid., II/2, . 63 ff.],       ,    [72 -      ,     ,   ,    .       ; ,     ,     . ,              ,             (J. Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, Vol. 2, III.21.5 p. 926; . III.21.7).]          ,       [73 - ,    ,      ,         .      ,        ,      ,      .       ,    ,       (De aet. Dei. praed. . 96, 127; ., .102103).].  ,             ,        :   ,      ,       [74 - Instit. Vol. 2, III.21.7, . 940.].     ,    ,          ,      ,     ,    , ,         ,        ,        ,    ,  [75 - . Barth, Church Dogmatics. II/2, .103106.].             ,              ,      :  ,           .  ,  ,          ,    ,    [76 - Ibid. II/2. . 167.].

             ,            ,     .

        ,   ,      ,     [77 - Ibid. II/2. . 164.],             ,   ,             ,          [78 -          ,  .        .     ,    .       ,           .   ,  decretum absolutum.   ,   ,      <>.      ,   ,  ,      (Ibid., II/2. 115).].

                Logos asarkos[79 - Ibid, II/1, . 321.]:          .        ,  ,   [80 - Ibid., II/2. . 169.].               , , ,   ,       [81 -     ,   , :       ,          .  ,  ,    ,  theatrum gloriae Dei,   .     ,     ,    ,   ,     ,        , , ,  .                 .       ,        (. Barth, A Theological Dialogue,  Theology Today, 19.2 (July 1962), . 172. . : http:// theologytoday.ptsem.edu/jul1962/v19-2-article2.htm.].    ,          ,      ,     ,     ,      ,      [82 - Ibid. III/1. 94ff. and 228 ff.; .: H. U. von Balthasar., The Theology of Karl Barth: Exposition and Interpretation, San Francisco [1951] 1992, .121 ff.].   , ,  ,     , ,    [83 - . Barth, Church Dogmatics. III/1, . 51;   :    ,       (Ibid., p. 51).].                    .  , ,    , ,   ,    ,         .      ,            ,   .

        ,   ,   ,        , ,                 ,     ,    ,   ,     ()    ,    ,     .    ,      [84 - Summa Theologicae, N.-Y. I, 41, 2 (.: I, 19, .35).]   ,      ,   ,        .            ,      ,      ,   ,        [85 - ,    ,  - ,           ;          ;        ,   ,         (Summa Theologicae, N.-Y., 1981. I, 41, p. 2).].

   -- (aseity      . . .)        ,   ,    ,       ,            .      ()   ,    ,       .   ,      ,  e???? ????? (    ??????     ????     ),    ,    e???? ???????[86 - K. Barth, Church Dogmatics. I/1, p. 434.].               ,    , ,    ,    ,     [87 -    e???? ???????   ,       , ,   , ,   ,       (Ibid.).].  ,        ,        (..       ),         ,       (..      ).

        .   ,    ,        ,            .  ,      ,         .     .   ,    ,           (),    , ,       .     [88 -   ,          .      : -      ,       ; -,     ,    ,        ,        , ,   ,    .           .         ,  ,   .    ,      ,      :      ,            (Summa Theologicae. I, 41, 2),        :     necessitate coactionis (    . .),  necessitate immutabilitatis (    . .) (D. Hollaz, Ex. Theol. acroam, 1706, I, 2, . 37; . : K. Barth, Church Dogmatics. I/1, . 434).].    ,           , , ,    .     ,                      [89 -     ,   ,       ,  ,      ,     ?     ,   ,     ?],   ,     (   )   ,             .     ,      , ,          ,            ,          ?[90 - . Barth, Church Dogmatics, II/2, . 115.]

       .    ,  ,             , , ,     .       ,     ,           .   ,      ,         (..    ),           ..              ,      ,    ,   ,    ,      .  ,                            .      ,   ,    ,    ,   ,    ,          ,  (        )[91 - Ibid., II/2, . 115.]  ,    ?

   ,     .    ,          ,  [92 - Ibid. II/1, . 280 ff.].         .  ,       ,    ,  ,    ,         .        ,           .   ,     ,    ,       ,           ,  ,      ,     ,    (),     ,      .  ,      [93 - Ibid. II/1, . 303.]     ,   ().

   ,         ,       ,          [94 - Ibid. II/1, . 303.],   ,    ,      [95 -         ,      <>.  ,       (Ibid., III/1, . 196.           : .: II/1, . 462, 470, 473).     (. Latts, The Trinity in the Later Barth: amajor shift?,  Trames  AJournal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 1997, 1, Vol. 1 (51/46), .7891)   ,    - (     -,     -  )       (.. ,   Church Dogmatics. I/1).       (    ,  )   , ,  ,             ߻ (ChurchDogmatics, I/1, . 351). ,               ,            ,       (.: . Latts, Doctrines of the Trinity in Eastern and Western Theologies: A Study with Special Reference to K. Barth and V. Lossky,  Studies in the Intercultural History of Christianity, 114, Frankfurt am Main, 1999),            (. Latts, The Trinity, p. 88).],       [96 - ,     ,                 ,  ,    ;          , ,   ,       , ..          ,           ,     ,       ;  ,          ,        ,       <>     , ..      <..>      ,           <>     ,                 (Ibid., I/1, .319320).],          .           ,     ,                [97 - Ibid., II/1, . 321; . IV/1, . 187; . Torrance, The Trinity,  The Cambridge Companion to Barth. Ed. John Webster, Cambridge, 2003, . 87.].             , ,    ,       ,   (  ,     )[98 - Church Dogmatics, II/1, . 321.].    ,  ?   ,                    ,   ,    ,             [99 -  .   ,      ,      ,         .        .     .     ,  ,     ,   ,     (Ibid., II/1, . 321).].

       ,      :   ,      ,    (  ,     ),                   ?  , ,             (     ,     extra Calvinisticum),       ,          ,  , ,  ,    ,      ,  ,        ,    .                   .          ,   , ,           .  ,            ,  ,  ,     ,     [100 -            .   : Gottes ewiger Ratschluss, in der ganzen Freiheit seiner Liebe,       (free),      : kraft keener anderen Notwendigkeit gewiss als seiner Liebe (. Barth, Die Kirchliche Dogmatik. 4 vols, Zurich, 19321967. III/1, . 54).].      ,          :            , ,     ,           ,     ,        ,       [101 - Church Dogmatics, III/1, . 51;   :     ,       (Ibid., p. 51).].  ,   ,     ,      ,   ,   .

 .    ,              ,     , , ,   ,  ,           :        [102 - P. D. Molnar, Divine Freedom and the Doctrine ofthe Immanent Trinity in dialogue with KarlBarth and contemporary theology, London, NY, 2002, .6264, 150 ff., 274277, 312 ff. .   : The Trinity and the Freedom of God, Journalfor Christian Theological Research, Vol. 8 (2003), p.5966.].  , ,  ,         .   ,  ,     Logos asarkos,    , ..           .      ,     , ,  Logos asarkos  Logos ensarkos      :            .        Deus pro nobis,  ,  [103 - Church Dogmatics, IV/1, . 52.].

     ?  ,         ,         ,           Logos asarkos         [104 - Ibid., IV/1, . 181.].      ,     .     .


II.     -

,       , ,         ,   ,        . ,    ,    ,        ,          ,       [105 -   ,      ,      ,        ,    ,        .          .          .: F. M. Meerson, Sergeis Bulgakovs Philosophy of Personality,  J. D. Kornblatt and R. F. Gustafson (eds). Russian Religious Thought. L. Madison: 1996, .139153; The Trinity of Love in Modern Russian Theology: The Love Paradigm and the Retrieval of Western Mysticism in Modern Russian Trinitarian Thought (from Solovyov to Bulgakov) Studies in Franciscanism. Ed. Zachary Hayes, Quincy, II., 1998, .159186.].     .            .        ,     ,     .  ,   ,        ,   , ,    ,        ,  , ,    ( )  .       ,         -    .

 ,     ,   ,        ,      , ,     ,   :      ,    , Deus absconditus,   ,    ,      [106 - . ,  ,  151.   :     ,  ,      ,     ,     nonsens  (,  412).].  ,    ,     ,  [107 - Ibid., c. 448.].     ,      (      )     - [108 - . . ,  :   ,    :    , . 1. , .-, 1999, .116119.].  - ,     ,       .        , ,   ,    ,        [?? ???????? ??? ?????? ???????? ??? ?????????? ??????????, ???? ???? ??? ??????????][109 - Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite. Corpus Dionysiacum. 2Volumes. B. R. Suchla, G. Heil, A. M. Ritter (eds.). Patristische Texte und Studien. B. 33; . Aland and . Muhlenberg, (eds.). B. 36. Berlin, NY. 19901991    . : Pseudo-Dionysius: The Complete Works. Trans.: . Luibheid and . Rorem. The Classics of Western Spirituality. NY 1987. Divine Names, XIII. 3. 981A. 9-10, . 129.]. ,     ,     -,         [110 - Pseudo-Dionysius, Divine Names, XIII. 3. 981A.15, . 130.],        ,   ,    : ,   [111 - Divine Names, XIII. 3. 981A.17, . 130.].  ,       ,         .                    [112 - Th. A. Carlson, Indiscretion: Finitude and the Naming of God. Religion and Postmodernism Series, Chicago, 1999, . 186 ff.].      -,  ,   [113 -  , . 119.]:

     [??? ?????? ??? ??????????],     ,    ,       ,        [???? ??? ???? ????? ????? ????? ? ???????? ??? ??????? ??? ?????? ?????],, ,        ,    ,    ,       [???? ????? ?????????][114 - Pseudo-Dionysius, Mystical Theology, V. 104 8B. 69, . 141.].

  ,  ,    ,        ,       [115 - , . 448.].         ,    ,      ()           (-)[116 -       (.: . . ,   ,   .  . . .   . . . 2


 .   . ., 19111914.].     ,   ,      :

   ,          .   ,    ,       ,  .        ,   ,   ,     .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/raznoe/russkoe-bogoslovie-v-evropeyskom-kontekste-s-n-bulgakov-i-zapadnaya/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.. ,   . . :   ┻,  . . : pro et contra.          . . ., 2003, . 59.




2


. . ,   (18291830).  ,       , . 1. ., 1991, . 326, 327.




3


  ,   , ,         ,     . . ,  .  :        ,         ,     .   .      ,  ,          ,     .          .     .            .         .      .    ,    .   ,   (. . ,      XIX-  ,   , 2001, 1. . : http://www.atheism.ru/ (http://www.atheism.ru/) library/Semenov_2.ht.m).   ( ,       ), , ;   ,           .




4


. . , Ibid., . 15.




5


Ibid, . 22.




6


Ibid, . 25, 34.




7


Ibid., . 36, 48.




8


,     (1935.). .  : . . ,  :       () (  ); . , -   ,  , , .  ,  125-   .  . ., 1999, . 109128.




9


. . ,    ,   . , 2001, 2. ., 2001, . 11, 12.




10


. ,  ,     , . I. ., 1990, .592593.




11


. , . ., 2003, . 327.




12


       .   ,      .       ,     .      ,    .          . , , , ,           (A. Maslow, The Farther Reaches of Human Nature,  The Journal of TranspersonalPsychology, 1969. . : http://www: nat-soul.ru/masla01.htm. . . . ).        .  ,  ,   ,           .   ,    ?             ,      .  ,         ,   .       ,      . ,     . . .




13


. , .   ,   . ., 1989, . 92.




14


. . , ,  . ,    , . 2. ., 1990, . 802, 803.




15


F. Nietzsche, Werke: In3 Bd6, M?nchen, 1982, S. 830.




16


. . ,  :  ,  . ,    , . 1. ., 1990, . 30.




17


. . ,   ,     , . 2, ., 1993, . 148.




18


. . ,          ,     , . 2. ., 1993, . 37.




19


. . , Ibid., . 21.




20


.: . . ,     ,     , . 2. ., 1993, . 25.




21


. . ,  ,  . . : pro et contra.          . .-, 2003, . 395, 396.




22


Ibid, . 397.




23


. ,    .   . ,   . ., 1993, . 108.




24


.: . . , . , .    ,  , (2002), . 7. 4, .504522; .   . :   ,   , 2004, 2, .148159;      (. .  ..) (  ).




25


.: . ,      ,    .      . .-, 1999, .373387.




26


 ,          ,  , , ,  , -       ,  ,      ,            , , , ,     .           , , ,  ,       (. . ,     ? (.    . ),       .

.-, 1999. . : http://www: universalintemetlibraryru/stat/Blue-eyes_3.htm).




27


.: . . ,  . ., 1996;  . ., 1999.




28


    . .  ,   -  (. . . , ,   . , 1991, . 301).




29


.: .  ,        .  . , 1997.




30


K.Barth, Philosophie und Theologie. Philosophie und christliche Existenz,  Festschrift f?r . Barth, Basel, 1960, S. 101. . : . . ˸,    :  ,  , 1992, 1, . 162.




31


. . ,  ,     , . 1. ., 1993, . 388.




32


. .   ,           (. . ,   . ., 1991, .275276).




33


     ,    ,    (. . ,  ,    , . 1. ., 2000, . 219).




34


,        ,        ,         ,                 .




35


  : . .       . -,    ,              :           .       . -, . .  ,   -    ,     ,  , ,     , ,   (. . ,      . . ,  . . : pro et contra, . 262).   ,  ,  .        . . .       . ,         . .




36


. . ,     (1828-1850- ),       , . 1. ., 1991, . 506.




37


. . ,   ,   , . 216217.




38


Ibid, . 227.




39


Ibid, . 231.




40


  ,  1923 ,           .          . ,  1917 ,     ,    ,           (. . , , . 301). , , ,           ,             . .: .  (),   . . (  ).




41


. . ,  , . 387.




42


     ,         (. . ,     ,   . , 1991, . 121; . :  .  ,  Ibid., . 199).




43


. . ,   ,     , . 2. ., 1993, . 127.




44


Ibid., . 128.




45


   -  ,    ,   ;    ;  ,   ,    ,        ,     ;    ,     .   ,       , ,   ,    ,   .      ,      ,          ,    ,       ; ,      ,        (. . ,     , . 123).     ,      .




46


        ,       (. . ,  .  , . 199). ,      ,  ,    :          .




47


. . ,  ,     , . 2, . 519.




48


. . ,   . Pro  contra.  ,     . . 2. ., 1993, . 625.




49


. . ,  .  , . 194.




50


 . .      : Thesen ?ber die Kirche,  Proc?s Verbaux du Premier Congr?s de Theologie Orthodoxe ? Athbnes, 29 nov. 6dec. 1936, publie par les soins du President Prof. H. S. Alivisatos, Athenes 1939, .127134.           .




51


  ,       ,      ,    ,      ,  ,           , ..   ,      , ,    (, . V. 1. 6. ., , 1995, . 129,  . . . ). .  ,       (.: L. Kola-kowski, MetaphysicalHorror, Oxford, NY 1988). . : . , . ., 2003, .412416, 447452.




52


     .




53


 ,    :       ,     ,        ,    ,      (Totum mundum hoc fine condidisse, ut gloriae suae theatrum foret) (J. Calvin, Concerning the Eternal Predestination of God [De aeterno Praedestinatione Dei or Consensus Genevensis] [=De aet. Dei. Praed.]. Trans. J. K. S. Reid, Louisville, Kentucky, 1997 [1552: Vol. 8, 294 of Calvins Works], . 97.




54


R. Williams, (ed., trans., and Introd.), Sergii Bulgakov: Towards a Russian Political Theology, Edinburgh, 1999, р. 168169.




55


.: . ,  . ., 2000, .148151.




56


R. Williams, 169n.




57


 1931. .       ,  ,   ,   .       (.: H.-O. Friedrich, Lieber Feoder Iwanowitsch: Aus Briefen von Nikolai Berdjajew und Georges Florovsky an Fritz Lieb,  Stimme der Orthodoxie, 1997, B. 3, S. 166171),           1930. (: M. D. Peterson, Georges Florovsky and Karl Barth: The Theological Encounters,  Summary of Proceedings  Forty-seventh Annual Conference of the American Theological Library Association. Ed. by Joanne Juhnke. Vancouver, British Columbia, 1619 June, 1993. V. 47. Philadelphia: American Theological Library Association, .141165; E. Busch, Karl Barth: His life from letters and autobiographical texts. Trans.John Bowden. Philadelphia, 1976. P. 215; A Arjakov-sky La generation des penseurs religieux de lemigration Russe: La Revue 'La Voie (Put), 19251940. Kiev, Paris: LEsprit et la Lettre, 2002, . 387).




58


              (18921970),       ,   ,          , ,  (.: K. Bambauer, The Letters of Nikolaj Berdjajew to Fritz Lieb. http://www.berdyaev.com/berdiaev/bambauer/Fritz_Lieb.html)  .  ,  ,     (  ) Orient und Occident. .       (.: F. Lieb, Sophia undHistorie: Aufsatze zur ostlichen und westlichen Geistes  und Theologiegeschichte, Zurich, 1962),        (.: Die Lehre von Christus bei Sergej N. Bulgakov,  Theologische Blatter, B. 13 (Jg. 1934), S. 212217  Bulgakow Sergej Nikolajevitsch,  Die Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart. Handworterbuch f?r Theologie und Religionswissenschaft. Hrsg. von Kurt Galling. 6volumes, Tubingen: 19571962; RegBd. 1965. 3


 Ed. B. I, S. 1505.   .      .: A. Arja-kovsky, Op. cit, .207209, 385386.




59


., ,   . , Die Krisis des Protestantismus und die Russische Orthodoxie,  Orient und Occident, 1929, 1, S. 1125.




60


     ,  19291938.,         (M. Stricker, Nachlass Fritz Lieb, Basel, 1990, S. 35).




61


    ,        .     : B. Geffert, Sergii Bulgakov, The Fellowship of St. Alban and St. Sergius, Intercommunion and Sofiology,  Revolutionary Russia, 17:1 (June 2004).      : Anglicans & Orthodox Between the Wars. PhD dissertation. University of Minnesota, May 2003, .172204. . : S. V. Nikolaev, Spiritual Unity: The Role of Religious Authority in the Disputes between Sergii Bulgakov and Georges Florovsky Concerning Intercommunion,  St. Vladimirs Theological Quarterly [=SVTQ] (forthcoming)      : A. Gal-laher, Bulgakovs Ecumenical Thought,  Sobornost, 24.1 (2002), .2455; Bulgakov and Intercommunion,  Sobornost, 24.2 (2002), .928; CatholicAction: Ecclesiology, The Eucharist and the Question oflntercommunion in the Ecumenism of Sergii Bulgakov, St Vladimirs Orthodox Theological Seminary, May 2003.        : M. Plekon, Still by Jacobs Well: Sergius Bulgakovs Vision ofthe Church Revisited.   2005. SVTQ.   ,  , .   : . , . .   . . :       ,  . . : - :   ,  130-   . 57  2001.  . .   .  (-  :   . . 4). , 2003, .86114.




62


     : P. Valliere, Modern Russian Theology: Bukharev, Soloviev, Bulgakov: Orthodox Theology in a New Key, Michigan, 2000, . 1,     : Role of Honour,  St Vladimirs Seminary Quarterly, 1954, V. 2, . 6.




63


J. Zizioulas, Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church,  Contemporary Greek Theologians, 4, N.-Y., 1997, .26.




64


.: . ,   ,   :   , , 1937, .924.




65


        .   (Paul Fiddes), : P. S. Fiddes, The Creative Suffering of God, Oxford, 1988, . 112 ff.




66


     : B. McCormack, Grace and Being: The role of Gods gracious election in Karl Barths theological ontology. The Cambridge Companion to Batrh. Ed. John Webster, Cambridge, 2003. 95-101 [92-110]. . : E. D. Willis, Calvins Catholic Christology. The Function of the So-called Extra-Calvinisticum in Calvins Theology, Leiden, 1966.




67


              ,    ,       .     :       , ,   ,      ,        ;   ,    ,  ! (J. Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion. 2 Volumes. Trans. Ford Lewis Battles, Philadelphia, 1960. Vol. 1, II.13 4 p. 481; . : Vol. 2, 4.17.30 p. 1402).




68


,    ,        []  ,   , , .    ,                      28:18:         ,   c.    2:9:         (Formula of Concord. Trans. by F. Bente and W. H. T. Dau. The Symbolical Books of the Ev. Lutheran Church, St. Louis, 1921, .503529; . : http://www.ctsfw.edu/etext/boc/fc/fce08.asc (http://www.ctsfw.edu/etext/boc/fc/fce08.asc).  . : http://skatarina.ru/library/credo/formsogl1.htm (http://skatarina.ru/library/credo/formsogl1.htm).




69


. Barth, Church Dogmatics, Edinburgh, 19561975. IV/1, . 181.




70


Ibid., II/1, . 26.




71


.: Ibid., II/2, . 63 ff.




72


     ,     ,   ,    .       ; ,     ,     . ,              ,             (J. Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, Vol. 2, III.21.5 p. 926; . III.21.7).




73


,    ,      ,         .      ,        ,      ,      .       ,    ,       (De aet. Dei. praed. . 96, 127; ., .102103).




74


Instit. Vol. 2, III.21.7, . 940.




75


. Barth, Church Dogmatics. II/2, .103106.




76


Ibid. II/2. . 167.




77


Ibid. II/2. . 164.




78


         ,  .        .     ,    .       ,           .   ,  decretum absolutum.   ,   ,      <>.      ,   ,  ,      (Ibid., II/2. 115).




79


Ibid, II/1, . 321.




80


Ibid., II/2. . 169.




81


    ,   , :       ,          .  ,  ,    ,  theatrum gloriae Dei,   .     ,     ,    ,   ,     ,        , , ,  .                 .       ,        (. Barth, A Theological Dialogue,  Theology Today, 19.2 (July 1962), . 172. . : http:// theologytoday.ptsem.edu/jul1962/v19-2-article2.htm.




82


Ibid. III/1. 94ff. and 228 ff.; .: H. U. von Balthasar., The Theology of Karl Barth: Exposition and Interpretation, San Francisco [1951] 1992, .121 ff.




83


. Barth, Church Dogmatics. III/1, . 51;   :    ,       (Ibid., p. 51).




84


Summa Theologicae, N.-Y. I, 41, 2 (.: I, 19, .35).




85


,    ,  - ,           ;          ;        ,   ,         (Summa Theologicae, N.-Y., 1981. I, 41, p. 2).




86


K. Barth, Church Dogmatics. I/1, p. 434.




87


   e???? ???????   ,       , ,   , ,   ,       (Ibid.).




88


  ,          .      : -      ,       ; -,     ,    ,        ,        , ,   ,    .           .         ,  ,   .    ,      ,      :      ,            (Summa Theologicae. I, 41, 2),        :     necessitate coactionis (    . .),  necessitate immutabilitatis (    . .) (D. Hollaz, Ex. Theol. acroam, 1706, I, 2, . 37; . : K. Barth, Church Dogmatics. I/1, . 434).




89


    ,   ,       ,  ,      ,     ?     ,   ,     ?




90


. Barth, Church Dogmatics, II/2, . 115.




91


Ibid., II/2, . 115.




92


Ibid. II/1, . 280 ff.




93


Ibid. II/1, . 303.




94


Ibid. II/1, . 303.




95


        ,      <>.  ,       (Ibid., III/1, . 196.           : .: II/1, . 462, 470, 473).     (. Latts, The Trinity in the Later Barth: amajor shift?,  Trames  AJournal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 1997, 1, Vol. 1 (51/46), .7891)   ,    - (     -,     -  )       (.. ,   Church Dogmatics. I/1).       (    ,  )   , ,  ,             ߻ (ChurchDogmatics, I/1, . 351). ,               ,            ,       (.: . Latts, Doctrines of the Trinity in Eastern and Western Theologies: A Study with Special Reference to K. Barth and V. Lossky,  Studies in the Intercultural History of Christianity, 114, Frankfurt am Main, 1999),            (. Latts, The Trinity, p. 88).




96


,     ,                 ,  ,    ;          , ,   ,       , ..          ,           ,     ,       ;  ,          ,        ,       <>     , ..      <..>      ,           <>     ,                 (Ibid., I/1, .319320).




97


Ibid., II/1, . 321; . IV/1, . 187; . Torrance, The Trinity,  The Cambridge Companion to Barth. Ed. John Webster, Cambridge, 2003, . 87.




98


Church Dogmatics, II/1, . 321.




99


 .   ,      ,      ,         .        .     .     ,  ,     ,   ,     (Ibid., II/1, . 321).




100


           .   : Gottes ewiger Ratschluss, in der ganzen Freiheit seiner Liebe,       (free),      : kraft keener anderen Notwendigkeit gewiss als seiner Liebe (. Barth, Die Kirchliche Dogmatik. 4 vols, Zurich, 19321967. III/1, . 54).




101


Church Dogmatics, III/1, . 51;   :     ,       (Ibid., p. 51).




102


P. D. Molnar, Divine Freedom and the Doctrine ofthe Immanent Trinity in dialogue with KarlBarth and contemporary theology, London, NY, 2002, .6264, 150 ff., 274277, 312 ff. .   : The Trinity and the Freedom of God, Journalfor Christian Theological Research, Vol. 8 (2003), p.5966.




103


Church Dogmatics, IV/1, . 52.




104


Ibid., IV/1, . 181.




105


  ,      ,      ,        ,    ,        .          .          .: F. M. Meerson, Sergeis Bulgakovs Philosophy of Personality,  J. D. Kornblatt and R. F. Gustafson (eds). Russian Religious Thought. L. Madison: 1996, .139153; The Trinity of Love in Modern Russian Theology: The Love Paradigm and the Retrieval of Western Mysticism in Modern Russian Trinitarian Thought (from Solovyov to Bulgakov) Studies in Franciscanism. Ed. Zachary Hayes, Quincy, II., 1998, .159186.




106


. ,  ,  151.   :     ,  ,      ,     ,     nonsens  (,  412).




107


Ibid., c. 448.




108


. . ,  :   ,    :    , . 1. , .-, 1999, .116119.




109


Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite. Corpus Dionysiacum. 2Volumes. B. R. Suchla, G. Heil, A. M. Ritter (eds.). Patristische Texte und Studien. B. 33; . Aland and . Muhlenberg, (eds.). B. 36. Berlin, NY. 19901991    . : Pseudo-Dionysius: The Complete Works. Trans.: . Luibheid and . Rorem. The Classics of Western Spirituality. NY 1987. Divine Names, XIII. 3. 981A. 9-10, . 129.




110


Pseudo-Dionysius, Divine Names, XIII. 3. 981A.15, . 130.




111


Divine Names, XIII. 3. 981A.17, . 130.




112


Th. A. Carlson, Indiscretion: Finitude and the Naming of God. Religion and Postmodernism Series, Chicago, 1999, . 186 ff.




113


 , . 119.




114


Pseudo-Dionysius, Mystical Theology, V. 104 8B. 69, . 141.




115


, . 448.




116


      (.: . . ,   ,   .  . . .   . . . 2


 .   . ., 19111914.


