   .    
 


 
                   ,            .  ,           ., ., ., ., ., ., . .,       ., ., ., ., ., . ., . ..   ,                    ,    ,    ,           .

       - .      :            .

        ,          ,      - .





 

   .    



 Routledge, 2018

 Joseph Soeters, 2018

  . .,    , 2021

    , ,  ̻, 2021


* * *


      ( ).

    ,    1940- . ,  ,           .   ,      - , -        .     46    .    ,    -    .         ,     .







 


                  . ,   ,     ,   .      , , ,         .  , ,   ,   , , , , , ,     .          ,       ,        .    -      ,  .

     ,    .         .     - ,    ,   ,      ,   .            .           ,   .  ,   ,         .          . ,   ,     ,        .         .       .

             ,   ,             .   :     ,         .                 .      .

 ,   , -      :     Facebook,         ,      .    :  -,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  -,    ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,       .  ,        -.

              ,         .  -    [  ],      .      .

         .          (Armed Forces and Society, AF&S)         (Inter-University Seminar on armed forces and society, IUS).           .              .        ,               .

     ,           .                  .

        ,    .                            .       . , ,       ,       .







  (        ), ,     ,   ,      ,     ,       .        ,         ,           ,    .       ,           [Latour, 1996: viii].

          ,      ,    ,     .




Latour, B. (1996) ARAMIS or the Love of Technology. Cambridge MA and London: Harvard University Press.




   


     :     [Soeters, 2018],     2018.  Routledge,      ,    .       .       ,    ,                  .   2021.     [, 2021]       .

         .           ,          (),       -     Routledge        ,      .

                        ,     .           ,                       .             ,     Presses Universitaires de Rennes.

     ,          ,     .             :         .         .

 ,       . ,       ,       ,          ,       .            .

 , ,    ,    -    ,     .          :        ,     ,       .      .    ,   ,    ,         .




Soeters, J. (2018) Sociology and Military Studies. Classical and Current Foundations. New York; London: Routledge.

 .    :      //  . 2021. 2. . 6780. DOI: 10.31857/S 013216250012680-1.







        ,    ,   ,    , ,     ,       .    ,              .

 XIXXX. ,  , ,  ,           .          ,      ,            ,   ,      .   ,   ,       ,        ,       .

                  [Mann, 2012: xiii].                    XIX  XX.,       ,     ,      .

       ,   .   ,    ,   .            , ,  , , ,   .             . ,      ,  ,        .

         - .         ,      ,       ,      ,    - ,      (   ),     .

       .                  [Bo?ne, 1995].                ,   40-  XX     [Segal, Burk, 2012].         , ,          [K?mmel, Pr?fert, 2000].        -               [Carlton-Ford, Ender, 2013].                     [Caforio, Nuciari, 2018].

     ,          ,             .  ,         ,                [Caforio, 2003].   ,        ,       ,    [Male?evic, 2010a; 2010b].  [Male?evic, 2010b] ,   -          ,     , ,   .      , ,    .            ,  ,           ,    ,    (   )     [Joas, Kn?bl, 2013: viii].  [Dandeker, 1990: 2930]  ,               .

   ,          -   ,    .              ,     [Male?evic, 2010a],    [Joas, Kn?bl, 2013],        .       (   )   (   ),        .               . -,     ; -,   ,                   ; -,       ,    .  [Stinchcombe, 1982].

   .     ,              ,       .     ,      .    ,       ,      .   .             ,           [Giddens, Sutton, 2013: 1028].    ,      .

      ,    ,       ,             ,    ,   ,     ,   ,    .

     ,           ,        (,    ,    ,   ,         ..),    .    ,            - .  ,    ,       (., , [Ritzer, 1998: 2029]).

    ,   ,      .   , ,   :   ,  ,  ,  ()    ,    ?            .

            [Mannheim, 1940: 58].         ,     .        .    ,  ,       ?          ?          , ,       ?  ,    ?     ?

      ,    , , ,         ,      .


 

       :                .       ,      (., , [Aron, 1989 (1967); Giddens, 1971; Nisbet, 1976; Coser, 1977; Turner, 1991; Levine, 1995; De Jong, 2007].       ,  ,   ,      .

   ,                .               ,    ,     , ,  ,     .       . ,     ,         .

        ,    .           ,       ,        .        .            .

         .      ,     -     [Adler, 2009].              -   ,    ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,      .     ,       [Adler et al., 2014]          .      ,   ,  ,     ,  - :   ,  ,      .      ,   ,    .

           ,          .      ,  ,   .         .           .            ,     ,   ,  ,      - .

    ,    ,     ,          .     .       ,  ,  ,  ,          ,    ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  .       .          ( ) ,      ,              .

        . -,    ,     . -,     ,       .          -.

           ,    .     ,   ,   ,          . ,             ,    -,      ,          .     ,    ,          ,    .

        ,         .        , ,            .   ,   ,              .            ,    ,    , ,   ,    .               ,           .     ,   ,            -.              .              ,     .      ,  -         .   ,      ,        .       .     ,   ,        ,    .

             .      .     ,    ,        ,     ,    .

     ,    ,  , ,     .             ,    ,    ,             .     .      .        .   ,  -     .        ,    ,     .

 ,          ,    [1 -       .        . (. .)],   .     .   ,   ,         . ,    ,    ,   ,     .      ,     ,     . ,  ,         .

 ,              .        ,   ,     .             ,       ,     [Obraztsov, 2019].            (connected sociologies),         ,         [Bhambra, Santos, 2017: 6].

,    ,         ,    -   ,      .       , , ,    -- .        ,       ,          ,    ,      , , , ,   ..

 ,  ,    ,      ,   , ,    ,          .        .




Adler, P.S. (ed.) (2009) The Oxford Handbook of Sociology and Organization Studies: Classical Foundations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Adler, P.S., P. Du Gay, G. Morgan and M. Reed (eds) (2014) The Oxford Handbook of Sociology, Social Theory and Organization Studies: Contemporary Currents. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Aron, R. (1989 [1967]) Main Currents in Sociological Thought. 2vols. New York: Anchor Books Doubleday.

Bhambra, G.K. and B. de Sousa Santos (2017) Introduction: global challenges for sociology. Sociology. 51(1): 310.

Bo?ne, B. (1995) Conditions demergence et de dveloppement dune sociologie specialise: le cas de la sociologie militaire aux Etats-Unis. Ph.D. thesis, University of Paris V Ren Descartes.

Caforio, G. (2003) Some historical notes. In G. Caforio (ed.) Handbook of the Sociology of the Military. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, pp. 726.

Caforio, G. (ed.) (2018) Handbook of the Sociology of the Military. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

Carlton-Ford, S. and M. Ender (2013) The Routledge Handbook of War and Society: Iraq and Afghanistan. London and New York: Routledge.

Coser, L. (1977) Masters of Sociological Thought. Ideas in Historical and Social Contex. Second Edition. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press.

Dandeker, Chr. (1990) Surveillance, Power and Modernity: Bureaucracy and Discipline from 1700 to the Present Day. Cambridge: Polity Press.

De Jong, M. (2007) Icons of Sociology. Amsterdam: Boom.

Giddens, A. (1971) Capitalism and Modern Social Theory: An Analysis of the Writings of Marx, Durkheim and Max Weber. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Giddens, A. and Ph. W. Sutton (2013) Sociology. 7th edn. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Joas, H. and W. Kn?bl (2013 [2008]) War in Social Thought: Hobbes to the Present. Princeton NJ and Oxford: Princeton University Press.

K?mmel, G. and A. Pr?fert (eds) (2000) Military Sociology: The Richness of a Discipline. Baden-Baden, Germany: Nomos Verlaggesellschaft.

Levine, D.N. (1995) Visions of the Sociological Tradition. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.

Male?evic, S. (2010a) The Sociology of War and Violence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Male?evic, S. (2010b) How pacifist were the founding fathers? War and violence in classical sociology. European Journal of Social Theory. 13(2): 193212.

Mann, M. (2012 [1986]) The Sources of Social Power. Volume 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Mannheim, K. (1940) Man and Society in an Age of Reconstruction. Studies in Modern Social Structure. London: Routledge.

Nisbet, R.A. (1976) The Sociological Tradition. London: Heinemann.

Obraztsov, I.V. (2019) The institutionalization of military sociology: the Russian path of gains and losses. Journal of Political and Military Sociology. 46(1): 124163.

Ritzer, G. (1998) The McDonaldization Thesis: Explorations and Extensions. London: Sage.

Segal, D. and J. Burk (eds) (2012) Military Sociology. 4vols. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Stinchcombe, A.L. (1982) Should sociologists forget their mothers and fathers? The American Sociologist. 17(February): 211.

Turner, J.H. (1991) The Structure of Sociological Theory. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.




 1.  : ,    



    (18641920)       ,       .        ,             . ,         ,    ,        .

  - ,            .        .          (. , [Tilly, 1992; Joas, Kn?bl, 2013].    ,     . ,            ,       [Kaube, 2015: 7374].            1980- ,        ,    .        ,       .                [Collins, 1995].      ,        ,   .       ,    -    [Portes, 2000].       .

    ,        . ,     (sinnhaft Verstehen),       ,         .        ,       (., , [Coser, 1977]).               .          .







          ,     .      [Lounsbury, Carberry, 2005],    [Du Gay, 2000; Shields, 2003].        .        ,       .         .        ,       ,        ,   .          .    .          ,       .

    ,  ,      ,       ,       , ,          [Gerth, Wright Mills, 2009: 196204; Weber, 1976 (1914): 124130].       ,     .    :

,       ;

  ;

 ,    ;

     ;

             ().

  ,   , ,     ,                 .       ,      ,    ,    .     ,              .     ,   ,           .  ,    ,   ,       (die Herren).               [Perrow, 1972: 4; Dandeker, 1990: 9].  ,     ,   ,            .     ,    / .

      ,       ,  ,   ,    ,            .   ,                        .     , , , , ,    .

        .             :        , ,  , , .        ,      ,      .           , ,              .

            ,         [Gerth, Wright Mills, 2009: 255261].   ,        ,    ,      .          ,        [2 -   () (Maurits van Oranje; 15671625),  ()   (15851625),        ,  ,     . (. .)]    [3 -  () - (Shaka kaSenzangakhona; 17871828),     ()   () (18161828),       -. (. .)]  ,              .         [King, 2013]     .

 , ,                        .             .              ,       .                  .   ,      .

    .     , ,       ,     ,     ,    ,    .      . ,     ,   ,     .          [Du Gay, 2000].   ,     ,   [Ritzer, 1993]  ,         .

           ,    ,   ,   -.      ,       :  ,       ,  -,            [Ender, 2009: 153].

       ,      .      ,        .  [Bauman, 1989] ,        , , -  , ,             (.  [Soeters, 2005]).  ,  ,      (     ) ,  ,   . ,  , ,  ,          ,          .

                      . -,      ,    , -,    (     ),  ,      .  ,   ,        , ,   ,         ,    .    ,           ,   ,     .    ,          .

, ,       .          ,        ,   ,       .        : , ,   ,  ,   ,   .     ,       ()    .     ,              ,     ?

     ,    :    ,         [King, 2013].          .       ,         [Male?evic, 2010: 221].   ,        :       ,      ,   ,      ?        ?

    (. .1.1)         ,        .      ,             .   , ,            ,    .  ,           .         ,     ,  .           .   ,           [Perrow, 1972: 15].



.1.1     






                 ,        ,  ,      ,       (., , [Davids, Soeters, 2009; Erikson Baaz, Verweijen, 2013]).

       .  [Talmadge, 2015].   ,   ,                   ,         ,          ,     .       :                     .      ,    ,     ,     ,        ,      ,      .  , ,             .      , ,   ,       ,          .     ,        [Talmadge, 2015: 811].

     [Haddad, 2015],      ,               .         ,   ,        ,  ,  .

       ,          ,   ,              .      ,          .       ,   .   :             ;              -;       ;       -        ,   .   :                   .       .        [Horowitz, 1985; Soeters, 2005: 2426].

,        ,     .            (., , [Crozier, 1964; Perrow, 1972; Masuch, 1985]).    (, ),   , ,  ,  ,            ,    ,      .  [Merton, 1968] ,          .  ,      ,        ,    .          [Davis, 1948; Feld, 1959],         .  ,    ,           [Ha?ek, 1973 (1923)]  -22 [Heller, 2004 (1955)].

          ,      ,      (., , [Adler, Borys, 1996].     ()      ,         ,   .   1959.              ,         ,        [Janowitz, 1959].




  

         ,     .            ,   .         ,   ,     ,   ,   -       .      ,      .        ,     .   ,   (  )   (    ).    ,        [Shields, Travis, 2017].

      :             ,            .         , .         ,       - ,         :   ,            .    ,              ,    [4 - :    ,     ,     ,     . (. .)]    ,              [Shamir, Ben-Ari, 2016].


, -, , ,         stahlhartes Geh?use[5 - Stahlhartes Geh?use (.)  . (. .)]         [Barker, 1993].          ,    ,    ,   .            .

        .      ,          . ,              .     ,      .  ,         .       -[6 - cole spciale militaire de Saint-Cyr (.). (. .)]        [Weber, 2012: 194].     [MacDonald, 2004]  ,                   .

   , ,              ,     ,   .   ,   ,    , .      ,           ,   ,  ,  .     ,  .




 ()  


    ,   ,       .      ,  ,                .  ,       [Weber, 1976: 130].    ,    ,          ,   ,    .     :   .           [Giddens, 1971: 154163].

-     ,       ,   ,       . -   ,                  .        ,     , ,   .  -  ,     ,   .

  ( ,   ) , ,   ,       ,     [Gerth, Wright Mills, 2009: 245252]. ,        ,      .          ,  ,      .    -       .     ,  ,             ,   :      ,      [,   ] [Gerth, Wright Mills, 2009: 245].

  ,   ,      .     ,               ,     <>, ,      ,  ,      [. : Joosse, 2014: 274].        ,      - . , ,  .       ,       .    ,    -,     ,           .

             ,     ,    [7 -   ()     . (. .)]    ,      .   , ,    ,           .                 .

,                    .      charismatische Kriegshelde (  ) ,         (., , [Moelker 2003]).         - ,      ,   ,     .           - .  ,  ,   ,              .     ,   ,   .

          ,      Fingerspitzengef?hl[8 - Fingerspitzengef?h (.) :    , . (. .).],  ,           .          .   . ,     ,            .   [9 -   (Stanley A. McChrystal; . 1954)  ()  (2009).     /      (20032008),        (ISAF) (20092010).  2010. . (. .)]     ,      . ,       ,       [Shamir et al., 1998].        (        ) [Reed, Bullis, 2009]. ,  ,  .     ,      [Gerth, Wright Mills, 2009: 248250].




  

             -       .   ,            -    .               ,    .    .  ,           ,           .      ,  -     .       ,  ,    .       .   ,              .       ,     - . -        ,        .     .         ,       ,    ,      [Hundman, Parkinson, 2019].      .


,             ,    - [Guzmn, 2015].      ,      (    ) .  ,   ,        .      - [10 - -    (),    ,      ,   ,       . (. .)]   ,          .

    [11 -   (David Howell Petraeus; . 1952)  ()  (2007).     (20082010),        (20102011),   (20112012).  2012. . (. .)] -     ,       ,      ,   ,    .   ,      ,          :       ,   ,         [Hajjar, 2014: 131].         ,           .

       ,           ,            [King, 2019].                   .     ,  .







      ,        ,   [Weber, 2010 (1911/1912)].                     .  ,        ,   ,    .   ,  ,  , ,            .              .  ,                 .

      .     .      :       (,  )     ,   -  - [Turley, 2001].             ,         ,    [Kemple, 2009].

     :      ,      ,     ,     .       ,        , ,           .          [Burk, 2008].              ,      (., , [Soeters, 2018]).   ,      ,             (      ,   ,         ,       ).

 ,                [Johnson, Cloonan, 2009: 3334].   ,         .            .

          . -          ,    .




  

       , ,     [Johnson, Cloonan, 2009; 2011].   ,     ,         .     ,    ,     .               :         .         .      , , ,     1990-          -  [Johnson, Cloonan, 2009: 148150].      ,       ,  ,      ,     ,            [Galloway, 2008: 225].








   -,    .        ,     ,       .       .  ,         ,           [Joas, Kn?bl, 2013: 118121]. ,    ,    ,    ,  ,   ,  [Cotesta, 2017].         -   .




Adler, P.S. and B. Borys (1996) Two types of bureaucracy: enabling and coercive. Administrative Science Quarterly. 41(1): 6189.

Baaz, M.E. and J. Verweijen (2013) The volatility of a half-cooked bouillabaise: rebel  military integration and conflict dynamics in Eastern DRC. African Affairs. 112(449): 563582.

Barker, J. (1993) Tightening the iron cage: control in self-managing teams. Administrative Science Quarterly. 38(3): 408437. Bauman, Z. (1989) Modernity and the Holocaust. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Burk, J. (2008) Military culture. In L. Kurtz (ed.), Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace and Conflict




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=66828338)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


      .        . (. .)




2


  () (Maurits van Oranje; 15671625),  ()   (15851625),        ,  ,     . (. .)




3


 () - (Shaka kaSenzangakhona; 17871828),     ()   () (18161828),       -. (. .)




4


:    ,     ,     ,     . (. .)




5


Stahlhartes Geh?use (.)  . (. .)




6


cole spciale militaire de Saint-Cyr (.). (. .)




7


  ()     . (. .)




8


Fingerspitzengef?h (.) :    , . (. .).




9


  (Stanley A. McChrystal; . 1954)  ()  (2009).     /      (20032008),        (ISAF) (20092010).  2010. . (. .)




10


-    (),    ,      ,   ,       . (. .)




11


  (David Howell Petraeus; . 1952)  ()  (2007).     (20082010),        (20102011),   (20112012).  2012. . (. .)


