 .  ,    ,    ,     
 


 -     -,     .         ,      ,      .      , ,       .       ,    ,        ,   ,  ,  ,        :    . ,    ,           ,     ,        .





 

 .  ,    ,    ,     








         .         , :     , ,    ,   ,                      ,      ,      .

 .   ( ) . 571 ( )

  ,             .     ,   .        ,          -   -   .   ,       ,  , , ,    ,  ,    .  ,     - -,     ,  -       .

 ,   ,          .  ,   ,      ,    .  ,     .

 ,   ,        ,    .   ,     , ,    ,   .    ,      ,   ,       .        ,          ;            .     ,       .             .

  ,    .        ,       ,        .              .    -        :



    ,  , ,      .   []    . []     ,   ,     ,      ,     ,    , ,   [1 - Man is the result of a purposeless and materialistic process that did not have him in mind. He was not planned. He is state of matter, a form of life, a sort of animal, and a species of the order primates, akin nearly or remotely to all of life and indeed to all that is material (The Meaning of Evolution by G.G. Simpson).].


( ,     ,       ,      .)

  ,        ,  ,        (-   Man-centered universe,  ).     ,       .     ,            . ,       :  ,   ,         (     ),      ,     .       .

   ,    ,          ,    ,         ,    ,         ,    ,   .      ,    ,  ,     ,      .       ,      ,   ,        .

       .     ,     ,      ,     .  , , ,   ,     . ,        ,    . ,    ,       - ⻠ G-d of Gaps.  -         ,   ,        ,    ,     ,    .

 ,                 ,      .          ,       .       - , ,            ,     ?   ,      ,                . ,                ,    ,    ,       . ,  , ,         ,         .  - ,  ,  , !       ,       ,     -.  ,  ,    ,   , ,      ,         .

   ,       ,  , , ,     ,       .        ,      .                .  ,        ,     .                  ,        .          ,     ,          .

   ,      ,       ,      ,      ,   .     ;         ,       ,   ,           -. ,        ,       .   ,   , ,        :  80           .

    .       ,  The Poverty of Philosophy   .        The Philosophy of Poverty   .     ,      : The Poverty of Historicism   .        .    ,    ,        ,   ,   ,     ,           -.

   ,      ,       ,          ,                 .       ,           ( -) (       )    -  ( -).                 ;   ,        ,      .  ,           ,     .       ,     ,           .       ,  :   .          ,    .



*?*?*

        ,      .         , -    -      .             .



21  5770 (2010) ., 




1.   


Man sees the things that surround him long before he becomes aware of his own self. Many of us are conscious of the hiddenness of things, but few of us sense the mystery of our own presence. The self cannot be described in the terms of the mind, for our symbols are too poor to render it[2 -         ,    .        ,        .     ,        ,   .].

(The Wisdom of Heschel, Abraham Joshua Heschel, p. 124    .  . . 124)

         ,    .    -,     .     ,              .     .         ,   -        ,             .       :    ,       . ,      : ,     ,      .        , ,        ,    ,    .

 ,      ,     .   ,    ,        , .       ,     ,             .  ,     .    ,   ,    .         , ,     XXII .        ,  .       ,       ,  .      (omnipotence)   (omniscience) .

        , :        ?  ,            ,       ?          ,    .    ,           ,                .              ,     ! ,   , ,   ,        . ,    ,    ,            .    ,       ,      .       .

  ,        .          ,    .             , ,       .  ,      .   ,        ,    .   ,  ,       .            ,      ,   .     (     ,     0,01%),              .        ,   ,   . ,    ,    ,          .

           ,   ,  ;       -,      .      ,    ,    .  ,    ,      .    .              .          .     ,  ,  ,      .       ,          ,   .     - ,   . ,    ,     ,     ,     ,   ,     .        ,                ,    ,     .      ,    ,    ,     . -  -       .          .

   ,    ,    : ,  , , ;    ;       .      ,                  .     ? ,     , , ,          ,     .    ,   ,  . ,   ,     ,       ,      .

 ,      ,    .  ,     ,      ,   , ,    ,   ,  ,   .       ,         ,     ,   .        ,        . ,      ,    ,       .         ,      .        ,    .           .     ?   ,      .

 ,             ,   ,   ,   ,  .          .        .     ,           .       ,  ,   .      ,         ,       ,  ,      .    ,      ,     ,    .      .  ,       ,        ,    .      ,   ,          .   ,   .

     ,                , .     ,       .     ,    -  .   ,     ,   .     ,        ! -     , -     ,  ,      .       ,      ,       .     ,        ,     .    ,        ,     ,         .    ,  ,    ,   ,   ,  ,    ,   ,     .        ,     . ߻   ,  ,        .

        ,  .   ,       ,    -   - ;          .     ,      (John Eccles),         (The Self and Its Brain).       ,   ,     ,       .   ?       .   ,   ,     (  ).

  ,    (Ren Descartes, 15961650)     ,   : ,   ,    ,   ,   ,   .   ,     ,    (   , ,       ),      .             ,    .

    :   -, -, ,   ,       ,     . ,   ,     ,   XIII  (11941270),    : ,  -    ( )   ,   ,        [ ]     -,       ( 2:3).              (   ,  2:7).  , -  ,    ,   .  :        ,          ,      .    ,      ,       ,     ,     .      :        ,   ,   ,             .    :     컠  .        .

                , ,     .     ?     ?    ,         .   ,       ,   .      ?   ,      , ,   , ,    ,   ,      ? ,  ,   ,   .        ,     . -          ,       ,    .  ,     .     .         :   []     ,    [,  ,  ]      酻   ,      ,     :          .

      ,   ,     ,       . (   )    -,     .          .   :        .    ,  : -! ,    ,     ,     .        :          .     ?   黠  ?   ,     ,  ,            .   ,         .  ,           ,    ,  ,    ,     -.  廠    .    .

      ,  ,   ,  ,      ,    .           ,      .  ,  ,          .      ,    [3 -   .          ;   ,    ,       .].      ,       .     ,            .         -.         . ,      ,         .                       .         :     ,   ,     ,      ,     ,         .         .



    ,        .        ,    ,   ,     ,       ,   ,       .                 .

  ,      ,    ,         ?        . , ,   ,    . ,   ,   ,      ,  ,  -  .      ,       ,        ,   ,        .         ,  .    ,      .          ,  ,   - [4 - ,      (   , Dialogues concerning Natural Religion),     , ,  -  -.          - .       ,    ,    ,  ,   .].

      ,     , ,  ,          .   ,    . -      ,    .       .     ,         :   .      ,        .            .   ,         ,  .           .     ,  ,  ,      ,    ,     .       ,    .    , ,           ,      .     ,          -            .         .     ,            .

  ,        :      ,     ( 1:2),             .           ,      .   -:   -, -, ,    ( 2:7).  ,          ,    - ,       ,  .   ,   ,  ,  -  .  ,   ,    ,     ,  ,  ,  .     :  ,     ,   ,    ,    ,     () ( 17:3).

           ,  - ,        ,   ,     ,    ,   ,       .    ,   ,     .  ,     ,       ,   ,       ,   .       ,          .         ,   .

             , ,  ,     . ,      ,   ,       -    ,            ,  ,    ,    ,    ,  ?    ,   :     ,      ,    .    ,     ,     .    .




2.   





1. [5 -  ,           .        ,      .]


   , -,     ,    !

( 104:24)

    :   ,      ,  ,      ,         .      ,   -     ,  -  ,    ,     .    ,     ,    ,    .                     ,  -         ,  ,   .    , ,    ,     ,  ,  .    ,    ,    ,         ,   .



      , ,  ,  ,    ,    .        ,      .   ,   ,  ,           ,  ,      .        ,               .        ,     ,   ,      .   ,    ,       :        ,    ,    .


  , ,        ,  , ,  , .         . ,      384322   ..,    .  ,          .    ,      ,  XVI ,             ,    . , ,   1564      ,          .      (     ),       ,     .       .   ,    .

            .          ,     .   ,    ,      .     ,              .

       ,       .   ,    ,   . ,            . ,           ,      ,   ,    ,       ,   ,   .  ,     ,      ,     . ,  ,     ,  ,     .

 ,  ,          .  ,         .         ,         ,    ,         ,   ,     .   ,   ,    ,        ,  ,  ,         .

     ,    ,       ,    .           .   ,       ,        .      ,       ,        .

    ,         .     ,    ,      ,   .            .      ,     , ,  ,     .       :          .   ,   ,        . ,   ,     -    . ,        ,    .

      .      :      ,    ,    ,      .           ,                .



 

      .   ,   ,  ,  ,   .   ? ,   ,   ,      ,  .   .1,       .   V              .     ,      .  ,     ,    D,     .  ,     ,    . ,      ,    F,   .





  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/binyamin-fayn/nischeta-neveriya-o-mire-otkrytom-bogu-i-cheloveku-i-o-mnimom-mire-kotoryy-razvivaetsya-sam-po-sebe/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Man is the result of a purposeless and materialistic process that did not have him in mind. He was not planned. He is state of matter, a form of life, a sort of animal, and a species of the order primates, akin nearly or remotely to all of life and indeed to all that is material (The Meaning of Evolution by G.G. Simpson).




2


        ,    .        ,        .     ,        ,   .




3


  .          ;   ,    ,       .




4


,      (   , Dialogues concerning Natural Religion),     , ,  -  -.          - .       ,    ,    ,  ,   .




5


 ,           .        ,      .


