 
 


           ,    ,     ,            .

    New York Times   2017             ,       .





 

 


 ,  ?      ?,      ,    



       : Daniel Crosby. The Behavioral Investor. Harriman House.



Originally published in the UK by Harriman House Ltd in 2018, www.harriman-house.com

Cover design  Harriman House Ltd.

 ,    .  , 2023







 ,               - .     ,   ,           ,   .

      ,         ,        .  ,       ,        ,   .

    :

     ,    ,     .      ,      ,  , ,   ,      .

       ,     .   , ,   ,              .      ,             .

      ,      ,       ,    .                  . ,  ,        .  .

          ,        ,                .           ,        .  ,         .    , , ,         ,        .

     ,   ,      ,    .  ,               ,             .

  !



 




 

 





 1





         .

 .   

   ,         ,         .          ,         .             .       , ,         ,      ,       .

         ,      ,       ,      ,     .    ,     ,     .  ,        ,     .   , ,    ,         .        ,    ,       :  !   !  ,   ,        .

   ,      100    .  ,  ,     .   .   ,      ,         .      -  .

,    .    !

     ,           :   .   ,   ,    ,      .




  


    ,   18 ,       ,    ,  ,       .           .   ,             ?      ,   ,            ,     ,   .  ,        ,        ,      ,   .

                    TED   [1 - Yuval Noah Harari, Bananas in heaven, TEDx (2014).]. ,      1000   1000 ,        .     ,        ?  , .        ,             .        .

,  ,           ,        .   ,    ,          ,    .       ,      ,       . ,   ,        ,        ,    .  ,        150,       -.      100 .          ,       ,   ,         .

            ,       ,                 .  ,     ,     ,   .        :   ,         ,     ,     [2 - Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens (Harper, 2015), p. 24.].   :    ,        ,          .

            ,         .  ,  ,    ,                  ,                 ,    .             ,    ,       ,    ,       [3 - Harari, Sapiens, p. 25.].

           ,            .   :             - [4 - Harari, Sapiens, p. 180.]. ,       ,       ,   .         ,   ,   .     ,             .      .




  


        :     ,       .        .        ,    ,     ,       !          ,       ,        ,    ,      ,       [5 - Hugo Mercier, The Enigma of Reason (Harvard University Press, 2017).].

    ,    ,         .     ,     ,    ,    ,    ,       .       :  ,  ,     .      -  .      ,    ,             .         ,       .         .     :   .   ,      ,   ,    .

    ,     ,      .   ,     -   ,   .      ,    -.  ,   .    ,     .

     ,       .    ,  ,           ,         .       ,    ,        .

   .        , ,       .          , ,   ,     ,      .    ,  ,    ,    ,    ,        [6 - Elizabeth Kolbert, Why facts dont change our minds, The New Yorker (February 27, 2017).].




  


      ,      .  ,    ,      .        ,        .     ?,         ?.   , ,        ,   .  ,         .     ,    .




   


     ,  1988,        ,         ,    ,     ,       :



-        .  ,     ,  ,   ,      ,   .     ,         : ,    , .        ,      .  ,  :     ?  ,  ,   .     ,     ,      [7 - Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time (Bantam, 1998).].


,         ,       ,     ,        .    .             ,          ,     .     :



  -         :    .     ,         ,   .     ,           .     ,         [8 - Lewis Thomas, Late Night Thoughts on Listening to Mahlers Ninth Symphony (Penguin, 1995).].


 ,      ,  ,   ,     ,     .

           . ,  ,   (,   ,  )  ,       .               .     ,        ,   .   ,   ,             .  ,    ,      .    ,       , ,  ,    ,      -  .

 ,       ,      ,       ,     .       ⠫  ,      . -,               . -,           .       . .     ,  1954[9 - Leonard J. Savage, The Foundations of Statistics (Wiley, 1954).].    ,         ,      .

   ,       ,     .        ,        .         ,     ,      .        ,    ,                .   ,     ,               ,     .           ,  ,    ,    ,     .

   ,     ,   -   .             ,             .    ,   ,   ,  .     .       .      ,      .

      ,        ,  ,       .  ,  ,  , ,  ,   .   ,      ,      ,     .




 


                .

     , ,       .

    ,    ,    ,  .

      .

  ,            .




 2

  



    , .

      .

  .  

     ,         .            ,       ,         .      ,   ,  ,          ,    .

   , -        ,     .    ,        .        ,       ,     .




,   


   ,   .

       .

   ,     !

              .       -  ,     ,       ,    .      ,        .              .           ,   .







,       ,             .      ,      ,   .           :



Homo sapiens    200   .        .  1997       Homo sapiens,  154  .  ,    ,   1450     ,    ,    [10 - Jason Zweig, Your Money and Your Brain: How the New Science of Neuroeconomics Can Help Make You Rich (Simon & Schuster, 2008), p.62.].


 ,           150  ,  ,     ,  .  ,    ,   400  ,      ,       .

       ,      .           ,         .   ,     , ,       ,     ,  ,   ,     .     ,    ,          .          ,       ,        [11 - Lisa Kramer, Does the caveman within tell you how to invest? Psychology Today (August 18, 2004); and M. J. Kamstra, L. A. Kramer, D. Levi and R. Wermers, Seasonal Asset Allocation: Evidence from Mutual Fund Flows (December 2013).].

 ,     ,        .    ,      ,   ,     . ,   ,     ,    , ,     ,       .       ,     ,    ,      .         ,      . ,       ,     ,     - .

   Vanguard     ,        ,    ,    - . ,          ,    .          ,  ,        4     -       .      .      ,     ,   1,5        ,     .

,                    .     ,    ,           . ,     45  ,  ,      -   67 .         ,         ,    .             1,4   .     ,        2,3.   ,        .     ,             -       .







 ,      ,         ,          .      ,     ,       ,      ,        .        ,      .         ,   .     ,                     .   ,     ,    ,   ,      [12 - Camelia M. Kuhnen and Brian Knutson, The influence of affect on beliefs, preferences, and financial decisions, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis (June 2011).].







   ,          ,         .    iPhone,            .   23     ,        25   [13 - Harari, Sapiens, p. 9.]. -            ,       .            ,    ,             .  ,    ,    ,      .   ,   .           (       ,     ),         ,    .


* * *

    ,         .         .     ,        ,     ,         .       ,  .     ,  ,    ,  .       ,    ,        ,       ,      .




  


        ,   ,   ,     -    , ,       .  ,    ,   ,    .      ,     .

    :   ,    ,     .    100 .          ,     .       ,            ,       .       . ,      .         ?

  1:        50  .

  2:     99 ,    1 .

        .          .           ,     .         ,       .

    ?       , , -, :  ? , .    .    Harvard Business Review,     ,    ,   ,  .      ,    ,     [14 - Kabir Sehgal, What happens to your brain when you negotiate about money, Harvard Business Review (October 26, 2015).].

 ,          ,    . ,        !      ,      ,      ,    ,    . ,       ,         .   :    ,  -     ,     .     , ,         .

     ,  ,             .      ,      ,         ? ,    . ,  ,   ,         . ,       .

     ,     ,      ,    ,      ,      .     ,        ,        ,  ,    . ,        ,      .

      ,        ,      ,   .           ,         -      ,         .       ,  ,            .   , ,   ,          ,   .

           ,    ,     .           ,    ,      .            ,    .   ,  ,        ,   :    ,         ,  ,   ,  .    .     ,    [15 -  .].

 ,      ,         ,      . , , ,     ,    ,         .  ,     .




  


 ,         ,     ,     .        ,       .     ,       .

  1: , , ,  , , .

  2: , ,  , , , .

,   ,   ?   , , ,  ,     .   , ,   ,      .       .        ,       . ,      ,     .  ,    -     ,       .       .




  

       ,      .              ,     . :

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

    ,     .

 ,  ,   : ,  , -    - .         .     .

                   ,       .     ,      .            , , ,   .

      ,    ,      .


   ,      ,    ,             ,          ().      ,     ,         .       ,   : ,     ,    ,  .      :          ,      .

   ,       ,            ,  .   ,               ,     . , ,     ,     ,       .       -  ,         ,     -   (    ).    ,           ,      [16 - Jo?o Vieito, Armando F. Rocha and Fbio T, Rocha, Brain activity of the investors stock market financial decision, Journal of Behavioral Finance (November 2014).].

 ,         ,       . ,  ,       ,         ,       -    ,      . , ,     ,      ,        ,      . ,      2007 ,       ,     ,       1990- ,        ,    .

,                ,   ,   ,         ,     .




    


    ,    ,     ,        ,     ,   .        29    .     ,      ,    ,     ,     .     ,       .

 (    ) , ,    -,       .      ,      - .      ,         ,      .  ,   ,            .  , ,  500    ,        :    ,      .

     ,       ,   .           ,    (, ,    ..),     ,      ,          .   ,   :   ,      ,            ,  . ,   ,    ,    [17 - Zweig, Your Money and Your Brain, p. 35.].         .   ,     ,  ,      ,  .        .             ,     .

       ,  ,    ,                ,      .         :            ,       ?   ,           . -,      ,         .  ,     ,    ,       .

           .                  ,      - ,    ,     ,    -    .  ,         ,   !  ,           -    ,       ,     . ,     ,        ,             .

    ,     ,      .               ,    .                 .        .            .         ,    :     ,  ,    .   ,          ,       .        ,      ,                      .




  ?

                :      ?    ?   , , .  ,          ,      . ,  ,      1000   , 51  ,     ,      ,    3000   ,     24 . -,      ,    , ?      .   ,             75  .

 ,    75    ,      ,   .          ,   75    ,       .   ,  75   ,   ,     ,        .           ,     .   , ,   750  ,     ,  ,   75 ,               .   ,             .





 


       ,    .       ,       .         ,     .       ,      .          :



            . ,      ,    ,          ,   ,        ,     .         [18 - Richard L. Peterson, The neuroscience of investing: FMRI of the reward system, Brain Research Bulletin (2005).].


  ,           ,     .         . ,    ,    , ,        .

  ,       ?

 ,                , ,          :     .     ,     ,        .       .

      ,  ,   ,           .       ,        ,     .       ,          . ,    ,    ,    ,      .

 ,   ,   ,      .       ,    ,               .    ,     ,        .    ,    ,       .




 


   (  150  )  ,   (  400  ),     .

 ,     23    ,  25   .

    ,  ,    ,   .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=69040291)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Yuval Noah Harari, Bananas in heaven, TEDx (2014).




2


Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens (Harper, 2015), p. 24.




3


Harari, Sapiens, p. 25.




4


Harari, Sapiens, p. 180.




5


Hugo Mercier, The Enigma of Reason (Harvard University Press, 2017).




6


Elizabeth Kolbert, Why facts dont change our minds, The New Yorker (February 27, 2017).




7


Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time (Bantam, 1998).




8


Lewis Thomas, Late Night Thoughts on Listening to Mahlers Ninth Symphony (Penguin, 1995).




9


Leonard J. Savage, The Foundations of Statistics (Wiley, 1954).




10


Jason Zweig, Your Money and Your Brain: How the New Science of Neuroeconomics Can Help Make You Rich (Simon & Schuster, 2008), p.62.




11


Lisa Kramer, Does the caveman within tell you how to invest? Psychology Today (August 18, 2004); and M. J. Kamstra, L. A. Kramer, D. Levi and R. Wermers, Seasonal Asset Allocation: Evidence from Mutual Fund Flows (December 2013).




12


Camelia M. Kuhnen and Brian Knutson, The influence of affect on beliefs, preferences, and financial decisions, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis (June 2011).




13


Harari, Sapiens, p. 9.




14


Kabir Sehgal, What happens to your brain when you negotiate about money, Harvard Business Review (October 26, 2015).




15


 .




16


Jo?o Vieito, Armando F. Rocha and Fbio T, Rocha, Brain activity of the investors stock market financial decision, Journal of Behavioral Finance (November 2014).




17


Zweig, Your Money and Your Brain, p. 35.




18


Richard L. Peterson, The neuroscience of investing: FMRI of the reward system, Brain Research Bulletin (2005).


