     
  


       
          ,      .      ,  ,   ,  ,      ( ,  ),  , , ,      ,    ,   ,        .    , ,         .       , , ,  ,    , , ,   .





 

     



ASSOCIATION YURIDICHESKY CENTER



Theory and practice of criminal law and criminal procedure



A.D. Nazarov



INFLUENCE OF INVESTIGATIVE ERRORS ON JUDICIAL ERRORS



Saint Petersburg Yuridichesky

Center Press

2003



          

. .  (. .), . .  (. .), . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . .  (. ), . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , A A  Sis,   YefikScn 



:

 , ,  ,    , - ,       (),     ,    -  . . . ,   . . . , -   ,  .     .



Editorial Board of the Series Theory and Practice of Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure

R. M. Aslanov (managing editor), A. I. Boitsov (managing editor), B. V. Volzhenkin, Yu. N. Volkov, L. N. Vishnevskaya, A. V. Gnetov, Yu. V. Golik, I. E. Zvecharovsky, V S. Komissarov, A. I. Korobeev, N. I. Matsnev (managing editor), S. F Milyukov, M. G Minenok, A. N. Popov, M. N. Stanovsky, A. P Stukanov, A. V Fedorov, A. A. Eksarkhopoulo



Reviewers:

Head of the Department of Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Law, and Oriental Law of Passau University (Germany), Honored Professor of Krasnoyarsk State University, Honored Doctor of Law of St. Petersburg State University, Doctor of Law, professor Martin Finke Candidate of Law V. G. Zablotsky Procurator-Criminalist of the Procuracy of Krasnoyarsk Territory, Councillor of Justice. Siberian Law Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia V V Anikin



The present work is a complex examination of influence of investigative errors on errors that court commits in criminal procedure.

On the basis of the study of materials of criminal cases tried by courts as well as dismissed, suspended by the proceedings, investigated by investigative agencies of the Central Siberian Region (Krasnoyarsk Territory, the Republic of Khakassia), interviewing investigators, procurators, and judges the author shows the structure and reasons of investigative errors, their danger for the court, the ways to reveal, eliminate and prevent them at the pretrial stage of criminal procedure.

The book is recommended for researchers, teachers, post-graduates and students of higher and secondary law educational institutions.

It can be used in practical work by judges, procurators, investigators, agencies of inquiry, officers of operation subdivision of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Federal Security Service, Federal Tax Police Service, State Customs Committee etc.

 A. D. Nazarov, 2003  Yuridichesky Center Press, 2003



 !

  ,    ,           .

     -           ,       .     - ,  1  2002.    -  .

      ,   ,   .                   .        ,     ,   ,             .       ,     , - , ,    .

          -  .      -      , -      ,     ,         , - , ,    .

      ,     ,               ,         .

       ,     .

                    .              ,  ,             .

        . .   , . .   . .   , . .   , . .   , . .      , . .   . .  , . .        , . .      , . .   . .  .   - , . .     , . .   , . . , . . , . .   , . .       , . . , . .  : -   , . .    , . .    , . .   , . .          , . .        , . . , . . , . . , A. .     , . . , B. .  :   , . .  : -  , . .       ( ), 2- .,   , . .   -     :  , . .       :  - , . .        - , . .  : - , . . , . .        , . .   , . .   ,  .,        .

,      ,     -         .

 

 2002.







  ,          ,               ,    ,           .

       (    )           .                 .     ,     ,       .         ,          .          .          .              ,        .                   .

           :

1)       ,   ;

2)      , ,      (. 6 ). [1 -   ,     ,    -   ,   2001.;    -    ,        .,            ,    . ,   -    ,      (       ,    ,     ,       , ,     . 2 ).               .              ,           .]

   ,  ,                      ,           ,        .

        .       . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , . . , . . , . .    ,    ,    .

         70- .              . .        ,       [2 -       . .,],      ,            ,    80- .          [3 -       .]      . .   . . [4 -          . . . ., 1990; ,         . . . ., 1991.].

    ,    , ,  ,  ,  ,             -    ,     1993.,   ,     - ,      ,   ,             2001.   .         : 1997.     ,   1  1998.       .          ,    ,      .

        ,    ,         ,      .

     - ,      -  ,          .                    ,        .




 I

  ,        





1.1.     


       , , , , , ,  ,    ,      ..          , , , [5 -    . . 2. ., 1938. . 1088;  . .   . ., 1987. . 419.].

              .       , ,      .   ,              ,    .

                 :   ,   ,   [6 -      . 221         .],  ,  ,    (, ),      , - ,    ,    ,   ..   ,    .

 ,     ,      .

 -      .   -    ,    ,     .

     ໠  ,   ,        , ,   (),          ,    (    ).

         :  ,  ,   (    , , ,   ..).

  ,    ,        ,        .

 ,      ,         , ..     .

     ,         (. 413419  ).       , , ,      .          ,           ,           .           ,      .

,   ()          ,    ,    .     ,          ,   ( )   , .

    ,  ,         .       ,         ,        .

 -           .       .

 [7 -      : . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . .  ( ), . .  ( ), . . .]            .

                  , , ,           ,                [8 - ,         . . . ., 1991. .78.].

      ,         ,          (. 299  )[9 -   ,     ,        ( ).],       (. 300  ),   ,        (. 301  ),      (. 302  ),    (. 303  ),           (. 285  ),      (. 286  ),   (. 290  ),   (. 292  ),    (. 293  ).

  ( )     ,     ,      .

. .  ,         ,   ,     ,     ,        ,     [10 -  . .  .  . , 1988. . 63.].

     .       ,  , ,      ,         .              ,          ,              .

. .           ,     [11 -  . .            XXVII   //          . ., 1988. .1415.].        ,   ,     ,          .       ( ),     ,  ,              .

          .

, . .            ,                      [12 -  . .  ,          . , 1996. . 11.].

  ,      ,    ,      .  , . .         .     ,      ,   ( ) ,      ,   ,      .

   ,            ,       .

  . . ,         ,      ,      ,      .  . .      ,         ;    ;  ,      ,        ;         [13 -  . .   :    //    . 1981. 4. . 41.].

          - .

. .  ,     - ,     ,       ,     

        .   . . ,    -  ,       ,  ,  , ,  .   -  . .    :    -       ,      -      ,     ,    ,         [14 -  . .    -       .  . . . ., 1995. . 59.].

 ,  . . ,     ,       ,    -      , ,    ,    .

    . .    -      , ,   ,       .

    ,               ,   - ,    [15 - ,         . . . . 18.].

        ,  ,                       .             :

                ,      ,         ,           ,   - ,               ,     .


* * *

         ,       . ,     ,                   ,    ,        , , ,      .

,         ,     .

, . .       (    ,   )   (    ).        -;      ,    ,      ,      ,   ,   ;   (      ),  (           ,    ),   (              );  ,     ;    ,   , ,    ;  ,  , ;   ( )   ( ); ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  );    ,  ,   [16 -  . . 1)  .  . . 64, 92; 2)      //     . ., 1982. .112113.].

 ,         .

      ,     ,       .



I.   [17 -   ,         .]:

1) ,   ,    .

2) ,             .

3) ,     - .

4) ,      .



II.     ,  :

1)  ()  .

2)   ()      ;  ()      (),  ,     ();  ()        .

3)  ()    .

4)  () -    .

5)   .

6)  ()   (     ).

7)           .



III.     - ,   :

1) ,                 ,                ,     ,  ,    ,     ,    .

2) ,          ,       ,          ,            .

3) ,                 ,      ,      ,           ,   ,                  .

4) ,   ()       (   ,       , , ,  )                   ( ).

5) ,   , - ,             .

6) ,    -  (,   ..),    , , ,     .



IV.        :

1) ,   ,     , ,  ,      (.. ,         -,  , ,              ,                ).

2) ,         ,       ,        .

               , ,             -  ,     ,      ,   ,    ().

 ,    80- .      , ,              60,4%,   -   25,5%,      14,1%[18 - ,         . . . . 8.].

 ,      90- .,      :

,      59,7%;

         7,4%;

  -   17,3%;

     15,6%.

,                     .       - .         ,    (24,7%)       (25,5%)   - ,          .

    ,      80- .         .

   ,               .




1.2.  ,             





1.2.1.    ,                


                   .     ,   , ,    , 7,4%. ,       ,    .

    ,            ,   ,     ,       ,  .   ,   ,        ,      .        .  :

      ,                   .      .          (. 49  ).

      (. 1. 19  ).

       .    ( )   ,   ,           (. 1 . 2. 46  ).

        (. 1. 48  ).

      ,      (. 2. 50  ).

     ,      ,     .

         :

  (. 49  );

     (. 19  );

             ( )   (. 46  );

      (. 48  );

    (. 51  );

          (. 53  );

   , ,  ,  , ,     (. 22, 23, 25  );

    ()     (. 21, 50  ).

           ,        .


* * *

 48        ,     ,  ,   .

 ,   ,          ()    ,      .

           : , , ,    ,   .          , ,       ,   ,   .    ,  46,7%               .

     ,       , ,  ,      ,     . :

1)   .                   ,      .

   (. 49)      :

)      ;

);

), ,    ,                ;

),   ,    ;

),    ,           ;

),              .

 ,       (. 426),         (. 405),     ()   ,        .

   (. 51, 438)          , ,       ,      ,               ,   ,              .

         ,    ,      ,       .

          -      . .,    ,  . 2. 145, . 3. 148  ,         .     ,         . 16    л,  ,            ,           ,     ,      .

       . .    .,       : .  .  , .      . ,  . .    .   ,    -   ,          [19 -    . 1996.   1-392.].

2)        ,     ,    ,         .   ,         ,            [20 -    ,    . . . ., 1995. . 18.].

              () ,      (       )  .              ,           .

 ,              ,     .

,       ,           ,   10       .

3)              ,            .       .

-,    ,                .   ,     ,      , ,                ,        .            ,     .       ,   ,      . ,                        .

-,          .        .   ,   81      18, ..   77,8%   .    ,   ,  .

4)           .

      .-.,    ,  . 15, . 4. 117  ,       .  ,     . 201       .  ,  . 17  1996.            175 .    .          16- ,             .     -        [21 -    . 1996.   06-353.].

 ,                             ,          ,        ,   ,       ,     . ,              .


* * *

 51        .

1.      ,     ,     .

2.           .

 ,     ,     ,  , ,   ,      ,      (      )   51                .  ,          . 51       ,          . 307        ,        . 308       .  ,   . 11       ,               .

     32%       . 51       ,  31%    . ,    ,  14%   ,                 . 51  ,   .

 . 3. 56      ,       (,  ,  , , , ,   ,   ). ,                  ;   ;    ; ;  ;   .

 ,     ,  ,       ,   ()     (. 42, 56  ).              ,    . 3 37. 1. 5  : ,       ,     , ,   , ,      ,       ( )    ,    ,    ().


* * *

 53   ,          .          .

    ,             .  ,      ,  ,    ,  ,     ,        .

    ,  ,     (     96% ).        ( 21%  )       ,      ,   .

              (1999.  36% , 2000.  38% , 2001.  40% ).     ,               ,          . 151, 1099, 1100  .

     ,   . 48               .   2%        7%              .

       ,            ,     ,        ,    (      ,        ).                       [22 -         ,  ,            . ,    .].

  ,         ,     ,  , , ,  ,        ( 9% ),      ( 11% ),                  .              ,      ,   ,      (  )     .

              [23 -  . .,  . .        . .  /  . . . . ., 1996.].

                    - ,       .           ,    ,                .             .

 ,              .             , , , ,        ,    ,        .

      ,    ,    1997.        ,      .                     ,        .       ,    ,          ,     ,     ,  ,  ,       , ,    ,     [24 -             ,       //  . 1995. 17.].

                . ,    - ,           ,          ,          (. 309).

                  .      ,   . 3. 11,       ,  ,      ,     ,      ,  ,          , , , ,               .

   ,     ,  :

1.    ,     ,  , ,   ,      ,    ,    ,      .         ,            ,          ,        ,    .    ,          (. 9. 166).

2.    ,        ,     , ,               ,           (. 2. 186).

3.              .    ,     ,  ,          ,    .  ,       ,     .     ,         ,         ,  ,      ,  ,      ,     .     ,    ,    .

                ,     .          (. 8. 193).

4.           ,         ,   ,     (. 4. 2. 241).

5.       ,  ,                ,        ,       .

           ,  ,          -                (. 5, 6 . 278).

    ,         ,          . 3. 11   (. 21. 2. 42; . 7. 4. 56).

                            .         ,     ,   .

      ,    ,    .  ,        ,   .         - .

       .                     .

           ,             ,    .            ,           .

       ,      ,      ,           .

                ,        .

       (. 139  , . 161  ),     ,       ,        .  ,         ,   ,                        .


* * *

    ,     22, 23  25  .

                     ,      ,     ,      ,  , ,    .

 ,   . 2. 6       ,  . 22      -         .

 2001.     .          .

 1  2002.  ,         . 122       72 .

 1  2002.    ,              48  (. 1. 10  ). ,      12 (. 9196)     ,              1  2004.

    ,            12      (. 3. 92  ).   ,                          48    ,    ,           ,      ,   (. 3. 94  ).

    (. 2. 29  )            ,  ,      .

,    ,   ,      . 107109  . ,     ,             .

       -    (. 10)        1  2004.             .                ,         (   , ,   , ).             .   ,   ,    . 10  ,          .

           . 220


, 220


       ,         .   ,                  ,         .

   ,    ,           ,       ,    ,    ,     .

,  29%          . 122           ,              ,        ,           .

          ,  72   1997.   58  (81%),        31 (43%).         3  (4%),  .            12 (17%)  .

            .  ,        . 220-1, 220-2   :         9% ,      47% ,        7%.               7    (12%),  2  (3%)                 .    27 ,   , 12 (44%)  ,     .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/d-a-nazarov/vliyanie-sledstvennyh-oshibok-na-oshibki-suda/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


  ,     ,    -   ,   2001.;    -    ,        .

,            ,    . ,   -    ,      (       ,    ,     ,       , ,     . 2 ).               .

              ,           .




2


      . .,




3


      .




4


         . . . ., 1990; ,         . . . ., 1991.




5


   . . 2. ., 1938. . 1088;  . .   . ., 1987. . 419.




6


     . 221         .




7


     : . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . .  ( ), . .  ( ), . . .




8


,         . . . ., 1991. .78.




9


  ,     ,        ( ).




10


 . .  .  . , 1988. . 63.




11


 . .            XXVII   //          . ., 1988. .1415.




12


 . .  ,          . , 1996. . 11.




13


 . .   :    //    . 1981. 4. . 41.




14


 . .    -       .  . . . ., 1995. . 59.




15


,         . . . . 18.




16


 . . 1)  .  . . 64, 92; 2)      //     . ., 1982. .112113.




17


  ,         .




18


,         . . . . 8.




19


   . 1996.   1-392.




20


   ,    . . . ., 1995. . 18.




21


   . 1996.   06-353.




22


        ,  ,            . ,    .




23


 . .,  . .        . .  /  . . . . ., 1996.




24


            ,       //  . 1995. 17.


