             ,   , ,        
  


                    .      ,  ,      ,     .   , ,    ,    .





           ,   , ,      



  , 2007

- .   , 2007


* * *




 


       2023 2007. .   -              ,   , ,      .

       :      ,   . ..,    , -  ,   ,    ,      ,   ,    ,   ,   ,   ,    ,   ,   ,  , ,  .

         , -,  ,     .

 蠖          ,   ,         ͠     ,                   ,   , ,      .

     -,   , ,  ,  ,   .

         ,   ,   ,   ,     ,     ,       ,   , ,      .

       ,      ,   2001.

     ,   , ,                    ,   , ,      ,      .

       ,   ..;    , - . , . ..,     , - . , . ..; - . , .,     ..;      ..;    ..; . . ,         ..;      ..,      ,   .   ,         .. ...

      : - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - . , . .., - , . . .



..,
  ,   ,         .
, 2023 2007.




AnIntroductory Article


This publication of articles includes materials of International scientific-practical conference on thesubject Theconcept of development of judicial system and system of voluntary and compulsory execution of decisions of theConstitutional Court of theRussian Federation, courts of thegeneral jurisdiction, arbitration, thearbitration courts and theEuropean court under human rights which took place on April, 20232007 inSochi.

Theleading scientific centers of Russian Federation and of some foreign countries have been submitted: Institute of state and theright of theRussian academy of sciences, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow State Juridical Academy, St-Petersburg State University, Russian Academy of Law, theUrals State Juridical Academy, Institute of Philosophy and Law of Siberia Department of Russian Academy of Science, Tomsk state university, Saratov Academy of Law, Voronezh State University, theTver state university, Kuban State University, Kuban State Landed University, Southern federal university, theDagestan state university, and also Byelorussia (Byelorussian state university), Lithuania (University it M.Remerisa), Germany (University of I.V.Goethe, Frankfurt on Main) and theUSA (Center of comparative jurisprudence).

Participants of holding internal and inabsentia scientific discussion became many known scientists, expert-practice, and also those who takes thefirst steps ina science.

Organizers of conference faculty of civil procedure and thelaw of master and servant of a faculty of law of theKuban state university, dean's office of a faculty of law, administration KubGU and Center of civil researches of Institute of thestate and theright of theRAS have conditioned for theserious creative discussion, allowed to present inthepresent digest a wide spectrum of sights at actual problems of thejudiciary and system voluntary and enforcement of decisions of theConstitutional Court of theRussian Federation, courts of thegeneral jurisdiction, arbitral, reference tribunals and theEuropean court under thehuman right.

Information associates theRussian legal newspaper EZH-Yurist, magazines State and right, Legislation, Russian justice, Reference tribunal, Practice of executory process.

Theclose attention inthedigest is given to various aspects of theconcept of development of thejudiciary, to problems of her unity, questions of specialization of court procedure, uniformity of thejudicial opinion, features of consideration of separate categories has put, to alternative ways of theadmittance of civil disputes, and also problems of execution of decisions of theConstitutional Court of theRussian Federation, courts of thegeneral jurisdiction, arbitral, reference tribunals and theEuropean court under thehuman right.

This collection of articles is theseventh one of scientific works, published by thedepartment of civil process and working law, created inSeptember in2001.

Theeditorial board of thedigest is grateful to all authors who have presented thereports, articles, theses for publication and thetaken part ininternal and inabsentia discussions on actual problems of development of thejudiciary and system voluntary and enforcement of decisions of theConstitutional Court of theRussian Federation, courts of thegeneral jurisdiction, arbitral, reference tribunals and theEuropean court under thehuman right, and expresses hope for continuation of creative scientific cooperation.

We express our gratitude for support of our idea about holding of theconference to V.A.Babeshko, Rector of Kuban State University, academician of theRAS; I.A.Nikolaychuk, Dean of theLegal Department of Kuban State University, doctor of legal sciences, professor; V.M.Zhuikov, Deputy Chairman of theSupreme Court of theRussian Federation, doctor of legal sciences, professor, Honored Lawyer of Russia; A.D.Chernov, Chairman of Krasnodar Regional Court, doctor of legal sciences, professor; G.A.Mantul, Chairman of Arbitration Court of Krasnodar territory; L.G.Korzhinek, prosecutor of Krasnodar territory; N.I.Manyak, Chairman of collegiate organ under civil cases of theKrasnodar Regional Court; M.I.Rysinov, thehead of Central administrative board of Federal service of bailiffs across Krasnodar territory theMain bailiff, and also our partner of Open Society Meat plant Krasnodar, Open Company of agrarian and industrial complex Revival. We express gratitude for assistance inpreparation of publication to N.V.Roschina and A.K.Bakayeva, students of theLegal Department of Kuban State University.

TheConference could not take place without creative assistance of theleading specialists inprocedural legislation: ..Abova, doctor of legal sciences, professor; R.F.Kallistratova, doctor of legal sciences, professor; E.I.Nosyreva, doctor of legal sciences, professor; G.L.Osokina, doctor of legal sciences, professor; J.A.Popova, doctor of legal sciences, professor; I.V.Reshetnikova, doctor of legal sciences, professor; M.K.Treushnikov, doctor of legal sciences, professor; L.V.Tumanova, doctor of legal sciences, professor; V.M.Sherstiuk, doctor of legal sciences, professor; V.V.Yarkov, doctor of legal sciences, professor; P.Gilles, doctor of legal sciences, professor and others.



G.D.Uletova,
theassistant committee chairman, responsible editor of collection of articles, thehead of thedepartment of civil process and working law of Kuban State University.
Sochi, April, 2023, 2007




        



  !

          - ,         .

,    ,      .  ࠖ    ,     ,   .         .       ,    ,    ,    .

          ,  ,    -       . Ƞ , ,       ,      - .

,   ,  ,   ,    , ,  .      ,           .

   ,          .



 ,
..




       



  -             ,   , ,      

   - !

  -             ,        .

,          ,     ,     .

    -   ,   , ,  .



   ,  - , ,    , ..




       



   !

        . .  , -,   -         .

,              ,   , ,         ,     .

        -     .   ,            .             ,   .

          ,    ,   .         .

,   ,      ,     ,            .

 , ,                  .

     ,        .

.



..




 1

              





..[1 -   ,       . ...]

       20072011       


    21 2006. 583         20072011 (堖  , ).

       ,    ,        .

  ,         ;   ,        ;    ,   ;   ;     .

       (, ,  .).       ,       .     .

 ,        . Ƞ ,   ࠖ  ,               .      .

              20022006,      29 2001. 805 (.    6 2004. 49).   ,              ,  2002. ,            ,         .

       . 5 ,  ,         (     1995.),   .          .

            .     ,  . 18 ,       .

 ,  ,    .  ,        ,     :    ,  蠖 ,      ࠖ ,     ,     ,     ࠖ  ..

        ,    .      .      .          .

 . 18            ,     ,    .

,       ,       .

     : 1)   ,   ,   ; 2)     , ,  .

,   ,  ,                      .

   ,         ,    .          ,         ( ,   ).

       . 35 . 167     ,    .  ,  ,        ,    ,   ,  .      ,     ,   .              ,   ,   ,      .

,       ,    (. 124   1995.).

     ,    ,    ,      , ,     . ,       ,        (   )        .

   ,  . 22  ,           .    . 18   1995.

         (. 3 ),         (. 39  ),    (. 71  ),     ,       ,   ,  (. 155  ).

 . 10    1992. . 4 Π    1996.          ,    ,     .

  . 146   1995.        ,    .

           .  ,         , 䠫 ,      .  , ,   ,  ,     ,     . Ƞ ,       ,    .

         4 2003. Π            蓻,          .              .

,  ,    ,  頖    . ,                20022006.

Ƞ  ,    .

          堖           .

       .  ,      (   ), . , ,     ,        .         ࠖ   , ,   ,  .      .       ( ,  ,    ,  ) .    ,        -   . , ,       .

     ,    ,    .

 ,     :        , ,     ,   ,    ,      .

   ,       . ,       ,    , ,    (  . 7   ). ,     ,   .  ,    ,    ,        ,       ,         .

          ,    ,  ,    ( )  ,    ,       .         .

   ,               .                           (),     .

         ,  .

     ,                ࠖ ,   .       .

   . ,          -        ,      .      . ,        , .     , ,    ,    .       , ,      .

        . Ƞ ,       .    ,        ,          ,      ,       ,     ,       .

               ,        ,          .

                .

 ,    1992.,   1995. (  1964.)    ,                   .

    ,    ,             .

       2002.   ,            .

             : 1)           ; 2)         ( ).     ,         .

 ,               .       ,    .    ,  . 4. 11 ,  ,        ,  ,  ,    , , .

     ,     .      , , ,  ,      .

       .

   1995., . 8. 11   ,     .   ,       .

Π         . 164 ,    .

              .

 . 2  ,    ,            ,  ,     ,    ,          ,    ,     .

         ,  ,   .

                .

            . ,    ,   -     .         .

   ,            ,      ( ,   ),    .   ,    ,      ,  .

                ,    ,  ,   ,  . 7. 11 ,      (堖 )    ,   ,     ,           .         .

    ,                        . , . 3. 115   1995.   ,   (     , ,  , , , ꠫ , ,    )       ,   . - , ,         ,  .

    2000.       .. :     ,    .    .               .         ,      .

Ѡ      ,            ,     .  ,   ,      [1].

        .      ,  . 115   1995.,     ,         .

 ,    ,           ⠫      (. 307 ).

  . 196                   ,   ,  ,     ,     .

         ⠫        .

              ,  .             .        ,         ,       ,  . 2,   ,    ,    .         .. 6 2003. Π      ,    ,             ,      ,  ,      ,     ,          -  [2].

           .    ,     ,      ,         :

               ;

              ,         ;

           .

                   .

            .   ,      .     ,         .

             ,       ,          .

       ,      ,    ,  ,              .

                          (),     .

    ,    ,    ,     ,   , 頖   .

           . -,   , ,       ,   ,    ,  , ,                ,       .   ,  Π ,  Π       ,      .

  . 58    ,                .

    ,   ,      ,  ,    .

    ,  ,        ,         (         ,   ,   ,       ).           :       ,     ,   ,  ,  ,   ,       . Ƞ ,   ,   ,       ,     ,  Π ,  Π ,  ,   .    ( ) ,   .

     . Ƞ .           . Ƞ     2002.   . 15  .  .        .

 . 1. 138      ,       ,     .

    : ,    , ,  .

  ,       ,       ,             () [3].

          ,         (,    ).       ,     ,       [4].

ʠ      , ..      ,  .      ,        (),     .    ,      .   ,      .        [5].

         ,   .    ,    ,  ,     .

   ,     ( ),     ,     ,      , ,       .             ,    .

       ,     ,   ,   ,   ()  .

     .

     ()        :

                          ;

  ,     , ,  ,       ;

      ,                    Res DH (2006) 1    .

     .

       , ,    .                                ,       ,      .     蠖     .         .        . ,    ,     ?        ,       .

               ,   ,   ,       .  ,     .  . 4. 229    ,    ,       .

      ,  ,    ,    .

        20 2005. 89 Π        :   . 4. 229  ,   ,   ,   ,         ,     .

   ,  . 4. 229  ,               ,   .

 ,  ,      .

     .  ,         .          ,   ,     .         . Ƞ       5 2007. 2-     . 16, 20, 112, 336, 376, 377, 380, 381, 382, 383, 387 369           ,      蠫,         ,  . 41      ,      , -      .





1.  . 2001. 5.

2. . 2003. 8. .60.

3.   .: ..       //  .2004. 1. .163176.

4..: ..   -  : . . - . . , 2001. .56.

5..: .,  .., ..     . , 2000. .38.




..[2 -   , ,         ,    .]

     


 6                    ,  ,    ,         .        .

   ,     30 1998.  . 46  (   )           .  ,            ,  ,      ( ,     ),     (,     ,     ..).

 -   . 6, ..  ,           ,          .        , ,  - ,    [1].

,       ,        . ,  . 120          .    , ,  .

ʠ      ,      -   ,   , ,    ,  , , , ,  .          .

    ,        .

ʠ         ,       ,   ,              , ,          [2].

 ,  ,       ,   ,   :  ,      (. 121),      ,    (. 122).         (. 9).            .       .

        .     ,      .

      ,       [3].

         ,        .

     ,    ,             - ,   - , , ,   .           ⠖        ,   [4].

          :   ,    , ,   ,      .

   ,   ,       : 頖       ,       , 頖       -     ,  .

  ,  , ,   ,     .    ,     ,               .

   ,     . 1. 6     (  23 1996.    ),        ,    .             .      ,    .

   ,         :    ,   ,     ,       .         .   ,       ,     .     ,       .             ,    .    ,        (  24 1989.    ).        .

         ,  ,  ,    .   ,       .

     ,              ,     [5].

    . 3. 1. 16  ,   ,         ,     .

Ѡ              ,  ,    .  , ,  . 3. 1. 16  ,    .

Π     ,      ,  ,          (  )   .

        ,    ,     .         ,  ,  ;   , ,       ;     , ,        , ,     ;        ,     [6].

       . , ,     ,     .

   ,         .

,  A.B.,        ,    ,  ,   , ,  .        ,   ,     ,               (. 4. 2. 33  ).              ,         ,          ,  .      ,    ,    ,         .        (,   ,   )   .

   ,   ,    ,      -  .

     - ,    ,     (. 2. 19  ).         ,      ,   .

                   ,     ,    [7].

  .. ,     ,           .    .

      ,  .     ,      ,             .

  ,       ,     .

Ƞ     ..,     ,         ,      ,      ,        (              ,     ).  ,   ,       .           (52854/99,  24 2003.),                     ,  19911992.        (res judicata)             ,  .

,            .

       .

           ,       .

          ,             .

       . ,              ,             ,          ,      ,  ,   .

   ,    ,   .

 .. [8],                :   堖   堖   堖   蠖        .

           .

       ,    , ,       ,     ,      .

         .  , ,    ,     .             .         .. [9] ,  ,  ࠫ,      ,             ,            .

      .     .           .

        ,    ,  .

        ,     ,            .

 ,         :       ;     ;       .





1... -        5 6        ( ,     ): . . . . . ., 2005. .25.

2. :  / . ... ., 2003. .68, 69.

3.    / . . .., .., A.C. . ., 1994. .380, 381.

4...              : . . . . . ., 2006. .3, 4.

5...    .   . ., 2001. .111115.

6.      / . . ... ., 2003 (  ..). .47.

7.A.B.     . ., 2005. .251254.

8...       //  . 2006. 3. .5860.

9...      ,      //   . 2006. 36 (248). .57, 58.




..[3 -   , ,     .]

         


       (  30 1998.),                        . ʠ           -    (. 6).                   .     ,              .

         .      , ,    (. 118),          (. 125, 126),              .      ,      , 堖   ,     , 堖   ,     .           ,   ,   ,        .   ,       ,       ,  ,           ,         .

               ,     ,         (. 3. 118  ).       ,      (. 3. 118),          ,            . ʠ                   ,    ,     (. 15 (. 4), 17, 18, 46 (. 12)  ).         ⠖        ,               . 6      [1].

 . 6      ,             .  ,      ,             . 1. 6     ;        ,         [2].         .

   Π      . 125            .     Π    (. 4. 4, . 27)        () ,     .        ,         .         ,           ,      .  ,    ()   ,        ,       ,    .

    ()         - ,                     . ,         ()     . 1. 6     , ,     . Ƞ      ,            ,            .

,              ,  ,  ()    蠖 .             ,      .         ()  ,           .  ,    ,   ()  ,     ,      -      ,             ,         (. 1. 19  ) [3]. ,         ,       ()       .

    ,   ,   ()   ,          ,    [4].  ,        ()   ,      ,     .       ,     ,            ,      .           ,            .

        .    ,       Π л,   ,      ,  ,   .     ,   . 3. 118 . 3. 128  ,        .         Π   , Π   ,    ,         ,       ,       .    ,     ,    ,            .

,         .     ,        .              .       ,  20  ,    ,     10 .        .     ,        ,           (. 10       , . 2. 34  ).

         ,   .        ,    ,   .        ,      .            ,     ,      ()  .        ,   .  ,       ,         ,   ,        .

ʠ  ,       ,          .    ,         ,               [5].

          ,      .    , ..             .  ,           16 2003.,      ,              ,         [6].       ,   ,   ,   () ,    ,   ,          ,        .

                 .                .      ,      8 2006.              24 2003.      5 2005.    Res DH (2006)           .   ,           2007. [7].

     ,             ,                   ,  ,   ,        .                     [8].

                  , ,      ,                 .         ,      ,       ,       .

  ,  ,         ,             .          ,           .         ,       ,         .                 ,     .

        , ,      ,      .         . 2. 376       .            ,        ,       .

,             ,       .  ,          [9],                 .         .

      ,        ,     .          -       ,             6      ,    .

         -,    蠖   [10].             .             ,     .             ,             .            ,            .

            , ,  ,     .    ,             ,     .             ,             .                      .

        ,     .   ,      .       ,                ,  ,        .       ,       ,        .     ,               .         ,      .





1.  .     .    ,        .   1960 2002. ., 2004. .277280.

2.  . . . .280, 334, 335; ., .,  .       :  . ., 1998. .208.

3..  : ..  :   // -. 2004. 42. .5, 6.

4.Π           .: ..        (19902000.). ., 2001. .5159.

5..  : ..     //   ,    :  : . . . ; ., 2004. .130147.

6...     :   //     . 2005. 4. .7376.

7. www.coe.int (http://www.coe.int/).

8.., :  02.11.2006     // www.echr.int (http://www.echr.int/).

9. ,  ,      ,   .: ..     //   2002.:     : . . . . . ., 2004. .321323.

10.Π                .: ..     //   ,    :  : . . . ; ., 2004. .130145.




..[4 -   , ,      .]

            


  ()  蠖        .           .   ,          (, , ) .       ,    ,     ()  ,     .   蠖  ,   .

 ,  ()  ,     ,       .         (, ),   (, ).      : )  (閠 ); )  (       ); )    (堖 ); )    ( )  .

      ,    .           .  ,     堖   , ,    .              ,   .

ʠ        , -,             () . ,      ()    , , ,    .

                         ,   ,   ,      ,         .  ,    ,       (  ,   ).

-,                 .      ,      ()     (). ,            .                  .            ,     . , 2006.              ,   䠖        .        :     ,  , , , .          .          . ,               . ,   ,       , ,       .        堖  (    )  (  )   lex ferenda, ..  .            ,     .

            蠖       .

     - ,      . ,              27 1968.          .

  蠖  ,         -.         ,   ,          .      -   (..       ),      () .    :      ,     -     .    ,   .       ,      .         .

       ?

-,         ,         ࠖ   (.  蠫ܻ . 234 ,   ).

-,                Ѡ         (. b . 234).        ,  ,         ,        .     -         .          .  ,                ,    ( ).              , ..  ,     .

-,            젖     -  .       (   ),   ,          ,     ,      .   . 234       ,   -.    ,    ,     -, ,   .

      -       .    ,    (- )   ,   ,      -  .      .

  ࠖ   /,        ,   ,  : , ,  ..     , .. ,        (    ),      (. 3. 234 ,   ).       ,         .            . 3      27 1968.        (堖 ).    ,     ,       , ..    ,    .

        ,   .

         . ʠ  , :          ;     ;   ,      ,     ,     .

       :   . ,  19. 4    :           ,       .            .       . 3  1  211  12    :               ,   ,      , ,   ,       ,      .              ,        ,          .                ,      ,         .

,   ,   ,             ,       .

        ,       ,   ,     .

                .        .          .       ,   .  ,     ,      .                    .            ,  ,  ,  : )    (  ); )      ; )    .           .         .          .




..[5 -   ,        .]

          


      . 1. 304  Ԡ               ,   ,  ; . 389                              .

   ,              . Ѡ  . 387             .       20 2003.     ,  . 2. 364  .    ,           . 363     ,     .  ,  . 389         , ,       ,  ,  . 363, 364  ,       ,   .    . 1. 330  , . 24, 25       20 2003.

                 ,         ,   . 1. 304        (., ,         5 2006. . 59, 62, 65, 67, 71, 74, 77, 81, 84, 88, 93, 95, 100, 103, 105, 107,113,116).

 ,  ()     ,   ,         .   蠖    ,         ࠖ      .     (. 389  )    ,                .

  ,             ;         .    . 36  ,          ,   ,  . 4. 270, . 4. 288  , ꠫         (., ,        18 2005. 2943/06) [1].

       ,    ,    ,        ,       .   ,  . 2. 364  , . 4. 270, . 4. 288  ,     ,        ,    .          ,     ,  ,     (. 3. 156, .  . 170 ).    ,  . 2. 364  , . 2. 270, . 4. 288       . 3. 156 .

          -        ( ),   , ,    ( ,       20 2003.).  . ,  . 3. 156       ,        (    -     ,      ;        ).          ,              ()  .  ,                 .

        ,             .

                  (   ,  ()    ,   ,  ),    . ʠ,         ,       .   .           .               9 2003. Π ,                  ,   . 4. 1. 33  ;    . 1. 90   ,  . 441             -     ,    ,      ,  ,     -    ,    .

,  18 2003. Π       ,       ,       (. 5. 71   ),         ,  . 173  ,     ,     .

                     ,    (), ,    ,  ()      ,              ( )  ,         .

     . 4, 5  20 2003. ,     ,    (. 43  ). ,  20 2003.,       ,      ,     ( ),          ,      .      ,          , , . 43  ,     ,   . 5      [2].

,  .     ,                  ,  . 3. 3. 69   .   :

    ( ,  )             , - ⠖   ,      . 4. 1. 33  ;

       ,     . 4. 1. 33         ( ,  )  ,     ࠖ   .

         ,        .     ,     .

 ,                  ,      .         .  ,  ?    -  ,    ?

            ,            -.





1.  . 2005. 10. .154.

2.  . 2006. 12. .12.




..[6 -   , ,        .]

        


  - ,         20072011,        ,   .      [1], ,       ,    .

        20022006       .     ,   ,      .

         ,   ,    .  ,        2002. [2].

      .    . ,      (,  ),        .    , ,    ,    ,  ,    [3].

        [4].      .    ,     .      ,    , ..  ,  .

         .  ,  ,              .



 ,    ,        ,   . ,       ,   .

     , ..  ,    : )      ; )     ; )     ,      [5]. Ѡ   2002.    .      .   ,  4 2003.    28 1995. 1?    .  ,      ,       .                         ,    [6].

   ⠖      ,   -    -    .        ,    .

          .   ,     ,      ,        ,  .               .

     ,    :   -    - .       .

       ,         ,   .        ,      .    ,               [7],     .    - .   33       28 1994. ,         , .. ,    [8].

      Π    [9]     .        ,    ,    .         ,       ,   .

      ,    Π    蠫    [10].         ,     , ,   Π () [11].

   ,          . Ѡ         ,     ..    ,      :       ,      ,    ()     (. 3  ) [12].

              [13].                       .

      ,         .                    [14].

   10?    ,      ,            .

          .  ,  -          .     , ,  , ,   ,              ,      [15].

  (. 8)    ,   ,   ,   ,   ,    .        .

               , ,   .      젖   (. 7).

   -     .       -  ,   Ԡ      ,    Ԡ      .

        , ,          ,           ,         ,     [16].

  ,               ,  .   16 1998.     . 125127                ,   . 125                   .               .   ,  . 125127              . 125 (.  蠫 . 2)         ,     ,   .         .        [17].

                      ,   .

        .. ,    ,    ,        , ,  .         ,    . Ѡ   ..,         [18].

  ,                    . Ƞ   ,           ,      ⠖  .         , , ,    ,         :  ,    ,   , ,      .     ,   ,            ,     ,   ,    [19].

 ,  ,     ,    ,        ,       ,      ,        .

  ,       ,            ,         .     .

   ,   ,        .        .  ,  . 4 ,    ,         .

, ..  ,  . 4       [20].             .

  ,     ,  ,   ,      .  ,      .       ,     [21].

       ,            [22].   ,    ,                       . ,  ,  堖    [23].

       :        ,    , ,  .

              .    .    , ,    .

     ,     (. 292   2002.).

     2002.               .

  ,  ,  ,    , ,  ,    ,    [24].

          ,     1995. (. 180)                (      ,    ).          ,  ,     [25].

 ,       , , ,    ,       . 181       . 35      .          ,      . ʠ      1995.: . 177 ,             [26].

 ,        .     . 127  ,                          .

   2002.        ,     ,        ,     ,     [27].

    , ꠫  ,             .  . 34   ,        ,           ,   ,     [28].

  ,                    ,        .            ,      ,            [29].

      蠖   ,       -     . Ƞ      , , ,   ,     ,          . ,       ,    ,    .

     ,      ,     .             ,     ,   ,    .             ,     [30].              . Ѡ   ,       ,        [31].

   ,      2002.,   ,   ,     ,                 .





1.Π       20072011:    21.09.2006 583 //  . 2006. 41. . 4248.

2..: A.A.   : , ,  . , 2005. .67.

3..: ..        //   . 1997. 3. .377384.

4..: ..     //  . 1994. 2. .25.

5..:   .218.

6..

7..: A.A.  . .292, 293.

8..: ..    .515.

9.Π   :    31.12.1996 1?(. 05.04.2005 3?) //  . 1997. 1. . 1.

10.   :    28.04.1995 1? (. 04.07.2003, . 25.03.2004) //  . 1995. 18. . 1589.

11.Π ():   26.10.2002 127? (. 18.07.2006 116?, . 18.12.2006 231?) //  . 2002. 43. . 4190.

12...     . , 2004. .23.

13..:  ..          // . .   . , 1966. . 6. .148; ..     . , 1962. .62; H.A.   . ., 1962. .18; .?.   . ., 1966. .27, 28; B.C.    . ., 1999. .15.

14..: ..    .493.

15..: .. . . .49.

16.., : Π ,         :      12.11.2001 15,    15.11.2001 18//  . 2002. 1; Π       :      90,    14 09.12.1999 //   . 2000. 2; Π ,         :      41,    9 11.06.1999 //   . 1999. 8; Π ,        :      6,    8 01.07.1996 //   . 1996. 9; Π          Π          蓻:      12.11.2001 16,    15.11.2001 17 //  ; Π              :      13,    20 23.12.1997 //  .

17. . 1998. 25. . 54855488.

18. . 2003. 8. .2.

19.. .3.

20..:  ..,  .. . . .60.

21..: A.M., .., ..   : .  .  / . ... ., 1995. . 1. .42.

22..:     Π   . ., 1998. .21.

23.A.A. . . .292, 293.

24... . . .57.

25..

26..

27.. .45.

28.. .46.

29..:  CA., ..  -        //  . 1996. 12. .76.

30..: ..      //  . 2000. 10.

31..: ..    //    . 1991. 6. .26.




..[7 -   , ,        .]

       ()


            , , ,      .              ,  ,              ,     .

     ,           ,  -  ,     .       ,  ,  ,  ,  ,    .

 ,       :     , , ,  .      .    ,              , -    -     -   ,          ,   -  ,  , ,  ,     ,      ,           .

 ,      ,                . 12       ,         , ,     ,   , ..         .     ,    ,  ,    ,      ,    .      ,   ,   ,     ,   ,      ,  .

      , ,   .         ,     , ,    , ,   .        , ,    .

,       ,  .

   ,      ,    ,        .

Π              28 1994.   ,    .  ,       ,   :

1)  ,   ,           ,    ;

2)       .             .

        ,      :

    ,     ;

  ;

   ;

 ,   ,      ,  .

  ,          . 12     .

         .    -     .             ,    ,   - ,   ,   , ,   ,  .

        ,  ,   ,           .

      ,  ,    ,           (, , ,  ..).

          ,       ( , , ,  ..).

    . 3 Π  Ի 27 1996.   .            ,     ,   . 4 :   ;  ()   ;     ,     ,    ;    ,    ,  ,     ,     .

   (  )   ,   ,         .       . ,   ,          .

          ,             ,   .

    ,      ,         ,                :  , Π      .       ,   .

Ѡ         ,      ࠖ   .        ,    ,   ,  ,    ,    .     ,        (. 46).

Π,          ,      (堖 ).          ,       ,    ,  ,     .    ,      ,    ࠖ                 .  , ,  . 1. 6      4 1950.,  ,      ,      .

           . 6.            ,   .      1988.,            .       ,           10 2003. Π           Ի.    ,            ,                (. 12).         .

       -              .       ,        ,         , ,      ,  ,    .   7      ,         .           .

   ,           7  ,    ,  -,      ,       -  ,         -.        .

  ,          ,  ,   ,     . Ѡ       1998.   49.  .           .             .




..[8 -   , ,       .]

   :   


 ,        ,       .      1990?.,   .


* * *

    . 118  ,  ,      , ,   .

   ,   ,           .    ,         .

      ,  31 1996.,         , ,           (. 26).

      ,   .          ,  .

    ,   ()    ,   , ,  :

  ( ),    ;     ,       ;

 , , , ,     ,     [1].

 ,      ,       ,       ,     [2].

   ,   ,         ,      (, ),  (, ),  .

       .   ,  1995.         ,         .             .             ,  ,         .      ,    .

           ,    ,      .              .

 ,            ,   -      .

    , , ,  ,  ,        ,      .

   ,       ,       [3].

        .   , .., .., .., ,         ,                [4].

    ,                .   ..,            ,       ,    [5].

,                    [6].

           ,          .

         ,          23 1999. 1? Π    [7].       .

 ,       ,          -.      , 堖     .     ,      .

,     :

 ;

  ;

    ;

   .

 ,      ,       .     ,        (,  ).

           . ʠ :

1)  ,   - ,    ;    ,   ;

2)  ,   ;

3)   ,   ,    ;     ;

4)     ,   ;

5)  ,     ,    ,    [8].

    ,        .           .

,  ,    ,    :

1)  ;

2)  ;

3)     ;

4)   .

     ,      . ʠ    :

1)  ,  1928.;

2) ,  1971.;

3)  ,  1975.

       :

1) ;

2)  [9].

    . ,    ,       . ʠ     ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  .          ,     [10].

    ,     ,   ,       .

   .. ..,      ,     .          ,     ,    :

1)  ;

2)  ,    [11].

        -,                .

           .       ,   2000.        Π   Ի,    21            .

 ,         , 蠖      .

       ,     -  ,         .

     ,  - . ʠ       ,      ,  ,  ,  ,   ,    .            .

    ,      .

  ,     . ,           ,       .

     , , , .

  ,  -        ,  .          ,     .

,    ,   ,   ,    .   . 38    ,    ,         .

        ,   .

   , ,  ,   ,        .

          ,    .      ,        .

         [12],       .        ,   ,          - - .

       ,      , ,  .      ,    .        ,      ,   .

,       ,   .

      ,        .

 ,        , ..    .         ,   .

,    頖   ,   ,                 .

  ..,    ,     ,     ,    ,  ,      [13].

    ,                      .             , ,    .





1...     . ., 2004. .91.

2...   //   . ., 1986. .86, 87.

3...   : , , . ., 2006. .XII.

4.   / . ... ., 2004. .10 (  ..); ..      . ., 1997. .193, 194; ..      //  . 1998. 1. .6.

5...       // :    : . . . ., 2002. .67.

6. 80    . ., 2002.

7. . 1999. 26. . 3170.

8. . . . .118120.

9..X. . . .8991.

10...    //  . 2006. 4. .70, 71.

11..., ..   . ., 1988. .118120, 268271.

12.., : ..  :   ,   . ., 2001.

13... . . .6.




..[9 -   , , - ,     .]

      :  


,   ,     .     ,       ,   -     ,       /  - . , ,   ,    ,        .

 ,                 ,  -   .



,      ,    30. ,  , ,  -,   (?) .,    ,     ,  .     .  , ,     ,   : ,    ,       ?,    : , , .   :               ?,  ()   : . Ƞ :      ?,    :     . Ƞ ,   ,   ,      ( ,  ),      . -,    :      :   ,   .      , , ,  , ,              /  ?  ,       ,   ? ,    .

, ,  ,    .     , ,  .. , ,  .           ,    ,  䠖      ,   ,  ,         .         .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/raznoe/koncepciya-razvitiya-sudebnoy-sistemy-i-sistemy-dobrovolnogo-i-prin/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


  ,       . ...




2


  , ,         ,    .




3


  , ,     .




4


  , ,      .




5


  ,        .




6


  , ,        .




7


  , ,        .




8


  , ,       .




9


  , , - ,     .


