:    
 


 
              .         , -   ,         :  ,  , ,    .               ,   .   ,         ,        ,             ,       .





 

:    



    .  .

 : .



   .



         - (Amor Vincet Omnia), 16011602.   , . : Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain Mark



LOVE: A HISTORY IN FIVE FANTASIES (1st Edition)

By BARBARA H.ROSENWEIN

 Barbara H.Rosenwein, 2021

This edition is published by arrangement with Polity Press Ltd., Cambridge





 .,   , 2023

 .,  , 2023

 OOO   , 2023


* * *


 





		
		  ,  ,   

		
		    ,
		     ,
		, , ,
		, ,  ,
		      
		 ,    .

 .    .  V,  2 (. .-).









        ,      (    ) ,     ,       .

 ,       , ,   ,      .   ,  ,   ,  ,  ,     ..    .,          4,       .

    ,     ,        ,   ,           ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  -,  ,   ,  ,  ,   ,   ,  -,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  .,  ,     .

        -          ,       ,     .  ,          Polity Press,              ,        .

        :       ; ,     ,   ;   ,       ,             .             FaceTime     ,     .       .       ,    .




  


 ,   ,    ;       .             (  ).                .  ,            ,           .     : The New Oxford Annotated Bible: New Revised Standard Version with the Apocrypha. An Ecumenical Study Bible / Ed. by M.D.Coogan with M.Z.Bretter, C.A.Newsom and P.Perkins. 5


 edn. Oxford, 2018.  ,   ,    ,      ,      .







  ,     ,  . ,     ,       ,      . ,        ,        ,    .      ,  ,        :            .  ,  ,   (history)   ,      (story),       .  :         .

   ,    ,      ,   ,          .  ,       ,        -,     廠  ,    . ,  ,     ,   ,   . , ,   ,      ,      ,  ?            ?                   ?   ,   ,          .

             . ,      .      ,  ,     ,    ,     ,      ,     .                    ,    ,         .   ,     :  ,   .    ,        ,  .

           .    1995 ,  -                .      ,   ,           ,     .

         .              ,       ,     ,                   .    ,     ,  ,          ,     ,      .

       ,       .  ,   ,           ,   .         ,     軠 ,             ,          ,     .          ,       (    ),          ,         .

              . ,  - : ,                -  -,      ,    .       ,      :    ,         ?       ,             ,          ,      .

 ,      ,               ,               [1 - Angers Past: The Social Uses of an Emotion in the Middle Ages / Ed. by B.H.Rosenwein. Ithaca; New York, 1998.].            ,         ,       ,   .     [2 - BurkeJ. Fear: A Cultural History. Emeryville, 2005; McMahon D. M. Happiness: A History. New York, 2006; RosenweinB.H. Emotional Communities in the Early Middle Ages. Ithaca; New York, 2006.]. ,      .     ,  ,     (   )      ,       ,      .

     . -,               ,    600  1700 [3 - RosenweinB.H. Generations of Feeling: A History of Emotions, 6001700. Cambridge, 2016.].       ,               ,     ,  ,           , , , .          :       ,    ,         ,   ,    - ,  ,       . ,        :        [4 - Id. Anger: The Conflicted History of an Emotion. London, 2020.].

          ,      .        ,  ,         , ,     :



   .

  .

 ,   .

    .

   .

      .

   ,   .

   .

   .

   .

 ,      .

  .

  .

   .


  ,          ,   . ,  ,      ,    .       ,       ,      : , , , , , , , , .        :    , , ,  , ,  .       ,     ,     .

          ,               ,       .   ,   ,     ,      ,  , ,         .  ,   ,                  ,   ,        .

 ,      :         (narratives),  ,     ,   ,         .                 , ,                 ,  ,     ,    .

   ,       ,      ,       .       ,     , ,  , ,   .         ,     ,         .      ,              ,          :    [5 -     . . .],  ,      ,    . ,      ,         ,      [6 - HochschildA.R. Strangers in Their Own Land: Anger and Mourning on the American Right. New York, 2016. P. 6, 135.].  ,          :             ,  ,      ໠   ,        .     ,      ,    ,          ,  .           ,  , ,   ,      .

      ..  ..,  ,    ,        ,   .       .        ,  ,        ,    , ,    .      ,             [7 - AngusL.E., GreenbergL.S. Working with Narrative in Emotion-Focused Therapy: Changing Stories, Healing Lives. Washington, 2011; J??skel?inen I. P., KlucharevV., PanidiK., ShestakovaA.N. Neural Processing of Narratives: FromIndividual Processing to Viral Propagation // Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 14. 2020, doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2020.00253; DidionJ. The White Album // We Tell Ourselves Stories in Order to Live: Collected Nonfiction. New York, 2006. P. 185 (  (19342021)  ,      ,    ,      . . .).].

 ,                  ,     ,  ,   ,     - .  , ,   ,    ,      .     ,  -       ,       .     New Yorker   ,          ,            [8 - DaiM. The New Yorker. 2019. December 16. P. 37.].        ,   ,    , ,  ,       .     (,     )      . , ,  ,  : ,       , ,     ,  ,    ,       .    ,      ,    ,    ,       ,     .     ,   ,     ,      [9 - May S. Love: A History. New Haven, 2011. P. 2.].       ,            .

,               .            ,       ,       ,    -     .              .           ,       ,           ,   , ,          ,     .

     ,      ,   .   ,    ,    ,   ,     ,    ,   ,         .                    .        ,      ,     ,   ,           ,       .

       .           ,          ,      -  .          ,        ,      ,        .          ,       .      ,  ,       ,      ,         ,     ,     .

     ,            ,     ,   ,    ,     ,     .




 1

 



            (   )     (   ).     ,  ,      ,  ,            .                   .        ,     :    ,     [10 -  ,  1,  6, . : bit.ly/3kxjA4x.].

 ,  .         ,     ,  ,      .  ,       ,               .        ,            . ,     , ,     ,      .         , ,     ,      .







       ,       .  (   ,          ,     ,       VIII   ..)            .      :  ,   ,  ,  ,  ,     ,         ,     ,            .   ,                   ,     (phil?tes)   (XXIII, 300)[11 - Homer. The Odyssey / Transl. by P. Green. Oakland, 2018,        (. : .  / . . . ., 1981. . 345, 5455, 107, 346;         ,        ,    .             . . .).].

  phil?tes, philos  philia   .    ,              ,       ,      .  ,    ,          , ,   ,      :

		  ,    ,   ,
		   ,     ;
		  ,   ,  ,
		   ,    

(III, 126129).
     ,      .           ,        .      :       ,       .    ,     ,     .

,        ,        ,   ,        .    ,      ,      .      :

		,       ,
		        ,
		   !    ,
		  ,   ,
		  ,    , 
		     (VI, 180184).

 ,   ,   ,    ,          .            ,          ekluon [   .]   ,      [12 - Ellen D. Reeder, Pandora: Women in Classical Greece. Princeton, 1995. P. 23.].           ,    ,     .                   .    ,  ,   :

		       .
		 , ,     ,
		      
		 :  ;  
		  ,     

(XXIII, 354358).
,        (      4),        :                ,      .          ,    ,        ,      ,   .

                   .       ?   ,   .         ?      ,      .


* * *

,        ,      ,     ,     .          ,    ,     .    ,        ,       .    ,    ,   ,   , ,  ,     ,      .   ,         ,           .   ,      ,    ,    (    )        ,    [13 - Plato. Laws (8.836a837d) / Transl. by T. J. Saunders // Plato: Complete Works / Ed. by J. M. Cooper. Indianapolis, 1997. P. 14981499 (. .: .  // . . . . ., 2014. . 273275; . . ).].        ,    ,     .      ,      ,     .     ,    ,                    .          :              .

         , , ,     .         .    (Symposium)      (symposia)[14 -   ???-?????? ()   ,  ???-      ,  ?????  . . .],      ,    -,     .           ,  .  -,  ,      ,       ,  .           - ,        .

,  ,         ,      .      ,       :      ,     ,      .    ,   ,  ,  .      ,   ,     ,       (190b)[15 - Plato. Symposium / Transl. by A. Nehamas and P. Woodruff. Indianapolis, 1989;     (. : .  / . .  // . . .:  4. . 2. ., 2007. . 119122).].       ,          ,    .        ,   ,          ,      (191a).     ,            ,    .        ,  , ,   ,        .

    :        ,            ,              (191c).  ,     ,    (191e).       ,     ,   ,    ,   - :   :           (192c).            ,      :    ,           . ,        :         (192c)      ,       (192e).         :      ,        .

         .          ,       ,    ,           .

,         ,   ,          (. 322   ..),      ,    .          ,     ,       .        ,  ,             .         philia     .       ,    ,     ,     .   :            .    ,   ,   ,     ,     .  ,           ,     ,       .  ,    ,       (     ),       .       ,   ,       (1171a5)[16 - Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics / Transl. by T. Irwin. 2nd ed. Indianapolis, 1999;     (. : .   // . .:  4. . 4. ., 1983. . 263; . . ).].  ,   ,    ,     ,                .          ,             .      ,           (1170b).

,      ,      ,     ,       .          ,    ,     ,          . ,       ,  :       ?     ,     ,        ,         :    ,    ,    .  ,  ,        ,   .    []  ,   ,      (1162a205). ,           .


* * *

 ,        ,           .          ,     (. 43   ..),        .           ,         ?      ,            ,                 .   ,        ,       . ,  ,   ,    ,          ,      . ,           ,     ,     .                .  ,    ,       ,      ,        :   ,        (XIV, 51)[17 - Cicero. Laelius on Friendship // Cicero. De Senectute, de amicitia, de divinatione / Transl. by W. Armistead Falconer. Cambridge, 1923;       (. :   .   //   .  .  .   / . . ,  . ., 1974. . 44, 29, 43, 3435, 48, 51).].

       ,       (       )         .              (IX, 32)     .            ,  ,  .   ,     ,     ,   ,          ,          ,  ,  ,   (IX, 29).        benevolentia     (goodwill [.:  ])   ,      ,         : ti voglio bene,   .  ,    ,       ,   .  ,  ,       ,    ,   ,   ,   ,  - .

          ,         .     :          ,           ,   (XIII, 48).

          ,      [18 -    (188128/125  ..)   ,       ,           . . .].                      .     ,       .   :         ,  ;       ,  ,  ,          ,    (IV, 15).

   ,         .        ,              .    ?   , ,      ,        - ,         [19 - Williams C. A. Roman Homosexuality. 2nd ed. Oxford, 2010.].            (XIX, 69),          ,                    .  , ,           .

,       , ,  ,       .   ,     ,    ,   .       ,       ,        ! (XXI, 8081).

       ,          ,           .      ,       .          :          ,            .           ,   ,     ,   ,   .     ,       ,        .    ,          .        ,    ,          .    ,      .   ,       ,     .

      ,       ,      .         ,       .      .  ,      ,            .     ,   ,      ,         .     :   ,           ,      ,     ,      ?[20 - Cicero. Letters to Atticus / Ed. and transl. by D. R. Shackleton Bailey. Vol. 1: 6859 bc., 18. Cambridge, 1965. . 171173 (. :   .  24.   ,   //   .   , ,  , . . . 1,  6851 / . . . .; ., 1949. C. 68).] ,     ,       .




   


     ,         .       IV   ,    ,   ,     ,       .        ,  ,           ,        ,         .

 (. 430 ),        ,      .                 , ,           . ,       ,           . ,      :  ,    ,   ,    ,     ,  .    ,   ,   ,   ,   ,  :                   (IV, 6)[21 - Augustine. The Confessions of St. Augustine / Transl. by R. Warner. New York, 1963;       (. :  .  / . . . ., 1991. . 110, 107).].

     ,  ,    :  ,     .   ,   ,  ,         ,      ,     (IV, 4).      .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=69310417)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


Angers Past: The Social Uses of an Emotion in the Middle Ages / Ed. by B.H.Rosenwein. Ithaca; New York, 1998.




2


BurkeJ. Fear: A Cultural History. Emeryville, 2005; McMahon D. M. Happiness: A History. New York, 2006; RosenweinB.H. Emotional Communities in the Early Middle Ages. Ithaca; New York, 2006.




3


RosenweinB.H. Generations of Feeling: A History of Emotions, 6001700. Cambridge, 2016.




4


Id. Anger: The Conflicted History of an Emotion. London, 2020.




5


    . . .




6


HochschildA.R. Strangers in Their Own Land: Anger and Mourning on the American Right. New York, 2016. P. 6, 135.




7


AngusL.E., GreenbergL.S. Working with Narrative in Emotion-Focused Therapy: Changing Stories, Healing Lives. Washington, 2011; J??skel?inen I. P., KlucharevV., PanidiK., ShestakovaA.N. Neural Processing of Narratives: FromIndividual Processing to Viral Propagation // Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 14. 2020, doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2020.00253; DidionJ. The White Album // We Tell Ourselves Stories in Order to Live: Collected Nonfiction. New York, 2006. P. 185 (  (19342021)  ,      ,    ,      . . .).




8


DaiM. The New Yorker. 2019. December 16. P. 37.




9


May S. Love: A History. New Haven, 2011. P. 2.




10


 ,  1,  6, . : bit.ly/3kxjA4x.




11


Homer. The Odyssey / Transl. by P. Green. Oakland, 2018,        (. : .  / . . . ., 1981. . 345, 5455, 107, 346;         ,        ,    .             . . .).




12


Ellen D. Reeder, Pandora: Women in Classical Greece. Princeton, 1995. P. 23.




13


Plato. Laws (8.836a837d) / Transl. by T. J. Saunders // Plato: Complete Works / Ed. by J. M. Cooper. Indianapolis, 1997. P. 14981499 (. .: .  // . . . . ., 2014. . 273275; . . ).




14


  ???-?????? ()   ,  ???-      ,  ?????  . . .




15


Plato. Symposium / Transl. by A. Nehamas and P. Woodruff. Indianapolis, 1989;     (. : .  / . .  // . . .:  4. . 2. ., 2007. . 119122).




16


Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics / Transl. by T. Irwin. 2nd ed. Indianapolis, 1999;     (. : .   // . .:  4. . 4. ., 1983. . 263; . . ).




17


Cicero. Laelius on Friendship // Cicero. De Senectute, de amicitia, de divinatione / Transl. by W. Armistead Falconer. Cambridge, 1923;       (. :   .   //   .  .  .   / . . ,  . ., 1974. . 44, 29, 43, 3435, 48, 51).




18


   (188128/125  ..)   ,       ,           . . .




19


Williams C. A. Roman Homosexuality. 2nd ed. Oxford, 2010.




20


Cicero. Letters to Atticus / Ed. and transl. by D. R. Shackleton Bailey. Vol. 1: 6859 bc., 18. Cambridge, 1965. . 171173 (. :   .  24.   ,   //   .   , ,  , . . . 1,  6851 / . . . .; ., 1949. C. 68).




21


Augustine. The Confessions of St. Augustine / Transl. by R. Warner. New York, 1963;       (. :  .  / . . . ., 1991. . 110, 107).


