,   .      , , . - 
 


  ?      ?  ,    ?     ?       ,    .

           , , , ,  ,  堖 ,   .

      ,  ,       , ,   .   - ,       ,      ,    .





  -     .    ࠖ      .





,     ,  ,        ,    .

      頖 , , ,  .





 

,   .    , , . - 



  

        :  ,  ,  ,  ,  

  

  . 

  . 

   . 

 . , . 

  . 



  .         () .  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,       .  ,   ,    ,  ,        ,     ,  ,     .

,     ,  ,  ,      () ,      ,   .



Lawrence Howells, 2022

Authorised translation from theEnglish language edition published byRoutledge, amember ofthe Taylor & Francis Group

  , , .   , 2023


* * *








 蠖 ,   










 !

  ,   .       ,      ,   .     ,        .  10        ,  .   ,     ,   .    ,     ,     .

 ,  ,  ,    .    (,  ), ,   (  ),   .       (-, -, ),   .    ,      .      .

    .        (  14 25).      ,  ,   ,  . ,   ,    ,  ,     ,      ?      ,     ,       ⠫, ,   !

     .       , ,          .     , ,    ,     .     ,  ,    ,       .        ,  -  ().     ,      ,   .

,  ࠖ  ,    .       .     ,     ,       . :

?  ?

?     ?

?,      ?

? ,   ?

?     ?



        .     ,         ,    -,   .     ,     , ,      , ,    .      ,       :  ,       .         . -     ,      .   ,    ,   ,       .      .   ?  堖     .

,        .   : ,     .     ,      (    !).

  ,          .    :         . , ,      !

     .         ,   ,    .         ,    .                 ,   . ,          ,    .












,    ,       ,   .   ,      , ,  ,  .  ,    -  ,   .        ,   . ,   (   ) ,     .    ,     ,    .

  ,    ,  蠖    . Ӡ     ,      .     , ,  ,  ࠖ   .      .

  ,   ,  .     ,     , ,     ,      ,   .  ,  ,  ,     ,    .      ;     -  ().      ,   :   ,       ,    .

    .    :     ,       ,     ,    .

   ,        ,     .




 


   ,      ,      ,  .     ,  [1 -      (Scarantino & de Sousa, 2018).].      , , ,  蠖    .   0.1     ,     (   ).    ,      .



 0.1.

   ?

  ?

   ?

  ?


      ,      ,      .       .    14 , , [2 - 14 ()     (II.111);   7    ( ,   ..). ..]:  , , , , , , , , , , , ,  [3 -      (Aristotle, 1984).].      : , , , , , ,  [4 - Plutchik, 1984.].       ,   ,   ,  ,  .       ,    ,  ,   .        ,  ,   ,       [5 - Ekman andKeltner (1997),       ,         (Jack etal., 2014).].

      : , , , ,  ,  [6 -   ,       ,     ;      ,      (, Izard, 2009, .  10).      :   ,                  .].     ,       ,     ,   ,     .




  


    堖      .     ,    - -;      ,   ;        ,  ,  .   ,     - .            .          ,      .      ,    ,     .

         . ,  ,          .     頖   - ,       ,     ,    .




  


     .  頖  ,  .    ,  ,   ,    ,     .     ,   0.1?  ,   - ?       .


:  

      .  ,     .   ,      :    ,           ,   蠫  .       .


 

     蠖    .      ,    -    ()  [7 -  ()  ࠖ    ,    .    , . . ..].            :  .

     :      .      :     ,  ,     ,     .   ,    ,       .  :    ,  . ,   ,    .  ,     ,  ,  ,   .        ࠖ      .

      :      ,  ,   ,  .   ,  ,   .      ,    .      蠫 .  ,     ,  .




     [8 - .    (, Ekman & Keltner, 1997).].   ,  ,    ,    ,    .

       . ,    ,  ,       .  ,   ,   ,   ,    .


/

    蠖   .    ,   ,    .     .    ,    ,    .     .

,    ,  .     -:

1.Ӡ  .          .

2.  .    .

3.  .      .

4.  .   .



       .



      .





    젖   .    , , ,  - ,  .      ,  ,  , ,  .       .


 

        : ,  , ,  [9 -        ࠖ .         (.Cannon, 1927).   ,    蠖     :     ,   .       ,    ,       ,    ,       (Cannon, 1927).    ,           (  ࠖ ).    ࠖ  (Schachter & Singer, 1962) ,   ,           .  (Lazarus, 1991)    ,      .].        ,   ;    .       ,        [10 -   ,     ,      (.Izard, 2009), ,       ,   .  ,      (Barrett, 2017),  ,      ,    .            . ,      :      ,     ,  .].            .



 ,   ,   , , /  .





 


 ,     ,       .     ,       ,    ,    .  ,      ,       ,     [11 - Darwin, 1872.].  ,  ,   .

 0.2  ,     ,  - -  [12 -    ,      .         ,  .].      ,       . ʠ , -,         ?



 0.2.

  

      .

 ,    ,      .

     ,   . ,  ,    , ,   ,  , ,    .     ,    .


   頖  .            .       .       ,   ,      .   , ,   .      ,   .

     ,      .  ,      0.2,    ,  :     .   ,     .



          .


  0.2        .    ,  . ,     .        頖 , , ,    ?  ,      ,      :   ,   ,   , , .

     : 蠖  .   ,   ;     .       ,       .    ,   ,    .       (   ,    ),    .      .



     .





 


       ,          .        ,   .     ,       [13 -      (Paul MacLean, 1990),  ,      .           ,  . Ѡ     -    ,      .      ,       ,  .   ,               (Cory, 2002).].       ,    .   ꠫ [14 - Siegel, 2015.].








 ,         .    : ,  ,    ,      .


 

  (   )  蠖     .     , ,   .        蠖   300.      :   , ,    [15 -        ,   ,      Four Fs ( F),     flee, fight, feed, fornicate (, , , ). ..].


 

 ,  ,   ,  .   ,  ,         200.       ,  堖  ,   ,   ,   .       .


 

           , .      80%  ,          .      :  Homo sapiens   200000 .      ,    ,  , ,   .     ,    ,   ,         .


 

        .            .

     .    ,      .     .    ,  ,   ,     .       (1)  (3).  :     ,     .     (2).        ,  ,    .




    


Ӡ ,    ,    .     ,        ,  ,   .         ,     .       ,    [16 -      . Schnittker (2017), Davies, 2013, Szasz, 2013.].         ,    ,  , ,    .  ,              .       .

   ,     ,  .  0.3      ,    .



 0.3.

  ?

  ?  ?

     (    ),    ?     ?  ?

    ,   ?

    ,    ?       ?

 -    ,     ?    ?


砖   ,  .      .     ,     ꠫.

 ,   .     :

? ,

? ,

?  ,

? .



    .         ,   .     ,   .   ,    ,   .



     .     .


    ,   :     .    砖   ,   ,    [17 -           ,     (TheMyth ofMental Illness),   1961.               :     ,   (Cracked: Why psychiatry isdoing more harm than good) (Davies, 2013).].      ,     .

,      :

??      ,

?  ,

?  ,

?  ,

?   ,    .



    .     ,  ,     ,   ,      .   ,     ,   .    ,         ,    ,     .      頖      [18 - Van Os etal., 2003, Johnstone, 2014.].    :   ,    ,  ,   ,      .



    .


 , ,  :    ,    蠫 ,     ,    ?

    ,        .     ,      . ,  ,     ,            ,  -,   [19 -     ,       ().     ; ., ,         (NICE)  www.nice.org.uk (http://www.nice.org.uk/).].  ,      ,  ,  ,   ,    [20 -        (  ,   ) ,          , , ,   . 12        ,  ,   ,   .   , ,        ,     .    ,         (Lewis etal., 2019).].     ,     [21 -      .   ,     ,   (, Whitaker, 2004).  ,         (, Sohler etal., 2016).].

 , ,      蠫, ,  ,      ,     . ,     ,    ,    [22 -         (Kirsch, 2014).].



,   ,   .





  ?


    ,       ,    .  ,   ࠖ      ,  .     ,  ,      [23 -    ,       11-  (-11). ,  ,     .          .  , ,    ,       (Perkins etal., 2014).].    ,     , ,     .      ,       .

-,   [24 -   ,      ⠖      (DSM),     . Ѡ2022.   DSM-5-TR. ..]  541[25 - DSM-5   541 ,       128 (Blashfield etal., 2014).]    .  ,   ,    . ,      ,      ,   [26 -    ,   ,      ,   14   (,  , , ). ,    ,            .  - ,       (McManus etal., 2016).]. -,     - ,    ,      ,  ,    [27 -   ..  ࠖ ,     (,  )     . ,           ,   .           ,    (Ruskin etal., 1998),           (Matuszak & Piasecki, 2012). ʠ,  ,     ,  ,  ,     ,     (Saunders etal., 2015).]. -,        ,     [28 -      ,    ,      (Johnstone etal., 1992).]. ʠ      ,    .




 


  :  ,    ,    ,      [29 - Kessler, 1997.].         [30 - Matheson etal., 2013; Weich etal., 2002.].     ,   , ,   .   ,  砖  ,   [31 - APA, 2013.], .. -   ,  ,   .           .     ,     ,  ,   .  0.4   ,    ,   .



 0.4.

 

렖 ,         . ,   ,  ,      . , ,  ,   - .  ,             .  ,          .      ? ,  ,   ?

ࠖ  .     .  ,       :     ,     .   ,    .      ? ,  ,   ?


     ,     ,   .         ,     ,  ,   [32 -       ,    .     TheLancet        (Thornicroft etal., 2016).].      :      .

 ,      ,     堖   . Ӡ     ,       [33 -             ,  ,     (, Corrigan etal., 2006).       (Link etal., 2001), ,  ,   . ʠ           ,      (Lysaker etal., 2008).].            - [34 - , Corrigan etal., 2006.].

  0.4     ,   ,     , 렖 .        ?           ?  ,           ,      堖 ,    .    , ,   ,        .




 


        :    ,   ,       .         , ..   .   堖   :     ,   .

, ,  .  ,   ,  :      ,       . Ӡ,      ,   :   ,  .    - ,   . ,       , ,      ,     .    :      ,       .



    .


    ,       .     ,      . ,   ,    ,   ;         . ,     ,  :     ,   . 젖 젖  ,   ,  ,    .        ,  .      ,     :  ,   蠫,    ,    .








  ,    , ?  .      :       蠫    .        ࠖ          .      ,       ,   ,  蠫  .   , ꠫       ,   ,        ,  - .




   


 ,       . ,    ,   ,      ,    ,     ,    .      ,  ,     ,    .     ,    .    ,          ,  ,      .

      .      ,    .  ,      ,      ,    .      ,   ,    -   , ,      .      ,       .    ,  -    ,   .   ,         .



  젖    ,     .







     ,   :     ,          .  ,       .       ,      .




  


         . , ,  蠖  ,          .   ,          .       ,        ,       蠫  , ,  .   , ,     , ,  -  ,       .

        : ,  ,             .      .         .




     


       (. ).       .   ,   :      ,    ,   .       .   ,     :     .   ,       .  堖      ࠖ    ,    ,   [35 -       (Siegel, 2015).].

      :     ;      ,       .       :        .   ,           .   -        [36 -            (Gratz & Roemer, 2004): 1)    ; 2)    ; 3)   ; 4)     ,  ; 5)      ; 6)        .].








   :    .    ,    ,    .     ,       .    ,      ,      ,      .




  


      .  蠖   ( )   ,           .     . ʠ,        ,      (     ).     ,      (   ).  蠖   ,     ,  .  ,      ,   .        ,      .       ,  -  ().  ,         .       ,    .



  ,       .     ,    .








       ,     .     ,     ,   .        ,    ,   ,    .       .







APA, 2013. Diagnostic andstatistical manual ofmental disorders (5th edn). Washington, DC: Author.

Aristotle, R., 1984. Thecomplete works ofAristotle: Therevised Oxford translation, Jonathan Barnes (ed.). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Barrett, L.F., 2017. Thetheory ofconstructed emotion: Anactive inference account ofinteroception andcategorization. Social Cognitive andAffective Neuroscience, 12(1), pp. 123.

Blashfield, R.K., Keeley, J.W., Flanagan, E.H. andMiles, S.R., 2014. Thecycle ofclassification: DSM I through DSM-5. Annual Review ofClinical Psychology, 10, pp. 2551.

Cannon, W.B., 1927. TheJames Lange theory ofemotions: Acritical examination andan alternative theory. TheAmerican Journal ofPsychology, 39, pp. 106124.

Corrigan, P.W., Watson, A.C. andBarr, L., 2006. Theself-stigma ofmental illness: Implications forself-esteem andself-efficacy. Journal ofSocial andClinical Psychology, 25, pp. 875883.

Cory, G.A., 2002. Reappraising MacLean's triune brain concept. Theevolutionary neuroethology ofPaul MacLean. Convergences andfrontiers. Westport, CT, London: Prager, pp. 927.

Darwin, C., 1872. Theexpression ofemotions inman andanimals. London: John Murray.

Davies, J., 2013. Cracked: Why psychiatry isdoing more harm than good. London: Icon BooksLtd.

Ekman, P. andKeltner, D., 1997. Universal facial expressions ofemotion. InU. Segerstrale andP.Molnar (eds.), Nonverbal communication: Where nature meets culture. Oxon: Routledge, pp. 2746.

Gratz, K.L. andRoemer, L., 2004. Multidimensional assessment ofemotion regulation anddysregulation: Development, factor structure, andinitial validation ofthe difficulties inemotion regulation scale. Journal ofPsychopathology andBehavioral Assessment, 26(1), pp. 4154.

Izard, C.E., 2009. Emotion theory andresearch: Highlights, unanswered questions, andemerging issues. Annual Review ofPsychology, 60, pp. 125.

Jack, R.E., Garrod, O.G. andSchyns, P.G., 2014. Dynamic facial expressions ofemotion transmit anevolving hierarchy ofsignals over time. Current Biology, 24(2), pp. 187192.

Johnstone, E.C., Frith, C.D., Crow, T.J., Owens, D.G.C., Done, D.J., Baldwin, E.J. andCharlette, A., 1992. TheNorthwick Park 'functional' psychosis study: Diagnosis andoutcome. Psychological Medicine, 22(2), pp. 331346.

Johnstone, L., 2014. Astraight-talking guide topsychiatric diagnosis. Monmouth: PCCS Books.

Kessler, R., 1997. Theeffects ofstressful life events ondepression. Annual Review ofPsychology, 48(1), pp. 191214.

Kirsch, I., 2014. Antidepressants andthe placebo effect. Zeitschrift f?rPsychologie, 222(3), p.128.

Lazarus, R.S., 1991. Cognition andmotivation inemotion. American Psychologist, 46(4), p.352.

Lewis, G., Duffy, L., Ades, A., Amos, R., Araya, R., Brabyn, S., Button, K.S., Churchill, R., Derrick, C., Dowrick, C. andGilbody, S., 2019. Theclinical effectiveness ofsertraline inprimary care andthe role ofdepression severity andduration (PANDA): Apragmatic, double-blind, placebo-controlled randomised trial. TheLancet Psychiatry, 6(11), pp. 903914.

Link, B.G., Struening, E.L., Neese-Todd, S., Asmussen, S. andPhelan, J.C., 2001. Stigma asa barrier torecovery: Theconsequences ofstigma forthe self-esteem ofpeople with mental illnesses. Psychiatric Services, 52(12), pp. 16211626.

Lysaker, P.H., Buck, K.D., Taylor, A.C. andRoe, D., 2008. Associations ofmetacognition andinternalized stigma with quantitative assessments ofself-experience innarratives ofschizophrenia. Psychiatry Research, 157(1), pp. 3138.

MacLean, P.D., 1990. Thetriune brain inevolution: Role inpaleocerebral functions. NewYork, NY: Plenum Press.

Matheson, S.L., Shepherd, A.M., Pinchbeck, R.M., Laurens, K.R. andCarr, V.J., 2013. Childhood adversity inschizophrenia: Asystematic meta-analysis. Psychological Medicine, 43(2), p.225.

Matuszak, J. andPiasecki, M., 2012. Inter-rater reliability inpsychiatric diagnosis: Collateral data improves thereliability ofdiagnoses. Psychiatric Times, 29(10), pp. 1213.

McManus, S., Bebbington, P.E., Jenkins, R. andBrugha, T., 2016. Mental health andwellbeing inEngland: Theadult psychiatric morbidity survey 2014. London: NHS Digital.

Perkins, A., Ridler, J., Browes, D., Peryer, G., Notley, C. andHackmann, C., 2018. Experiencing mental health diagnosis: Asystematic review ofservice user, clinician, andcarer perspectives across clinical settings. TheLancet Psychiatry, 5(9), pp. 747764.

Plutchik, R., 1984. Emotions: Ageneral psychoevolutionary theory. InK. R. Scherer andP. Ekman (eds.), Approaches toemotion. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., pp. 197219.

Ruskin, P.E., Reed, S., Kumar, R., Kling, M.A., Siegel, E., Rosen, M. andHauser, P., 1998. Reliability andacceptability ofpsychiatric diagnosis via telecommunication andaudiovisual technology. Psychiatric Services, 49(8), pp. 10861088.

Saunders, K.E.A., Bilderbeck, A.C., Price, J. andGoodwin, G.M., 2015. Distinguishing bipolar disorder from borderline personality disorder: Astudy ofcurrent clinical practice. European Psychiatry, 30(8), pp. 965974.

Scarantino, A. andde Sousa, R., 2018. Emotion. InEdward N. Zalta (ed.), TheStanford encyclopedia ofphilosophy (Winter 2018 Edition). https://plato-stanford-edu.uea.idm.oclc.org/archives/win2018/entries/emotion/.

Schachter, S. andSinger, J., 1962. Cognitive, social, andphysiological determinants ofemotional state. Psychological Review, 69, pp. 379399.

Schnittker, J., 2017. Thediagnostic system: Why theclassification ofpsychiatric disorders isnecessary, difficult, andnever settled. NewYork, NY: Columbia University Press.

Siegel, D.J., 2015. Thedeveloping mind: How relationships andthe brain interact toshape who we are




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=69452047)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


     (Scarantino & de Sousa, 2018).




2


14 ()     (II.111);   7    ( ,   ..). ..




3


     (Aristotle, 1984).




4


Plutchik, 1984.




5


Ekman andKeltner (1997),       ,         (Jack etal., 2014).




6


  ,       ,     ;      ,      (, Izard, 2009, .  10).      :   ,                  .




7


 ()  ࠖ    ,    .    , . . ..




8


.    (, Ekman & Keltner, 1997).




9


       ࠖ .         (.Cannon, 1927).   ,    蠖     :     ,   .       ,    ,       ,    ,       (Cannon, 1927).    ,           (  ࠖ ).    ࠖ  (Schachter & Singer, 1962) ,   ,           .  (Lazarus, 1991)    ,      .




10


  ,     ,      (.Izard, 2009), ,       ,   .  ,      (Barrett, 2017),  ,      ,    .            . ,      :      ,     ,  .




11


Darwin, 1872.




12


   ,      .         ,  .




13


     (Paul MacLean, 1990),  ,      .           ,  . Ѡ     -    ,      .      ,       ,  .   ,               (Cory, 2002).




14


Siegel, 2015.




15


       ,   ,      Four Fs ( F),     flee, fight, feed, fornicate (, , , ). ..




16


     . Schnittker (2017), Davies, 2013, Szasz, 2013.




17


          ,     (TheMyth ofMental Illness),   1961.               :     ,   (Cracked: Why psychiatry isdoing more harm than good) (Davies, 2013).




18


Van Os etal., 2003, Johnstone, 2014.




19


    ,       ().     ; ., ,         (NICE)  www.nice.org.uk (http://www.nice.org.uk/).




20


       (  ,   ) ,          , , ,   . 12        ,  ,   ,   .   , ,        ,     .    ,         (Lewis etal., 2019).




21


     .   ,     ,   (, Whitaker, 2004).  ,         (, Sohler etal., 2016).




22


        (Kirsch, 2014).




23


   ,       11-  (-11). ,  ,     .          .  , ,    ,       (Perkins etal., 2014).




24


  ,      ⠖      (DSM),     . Ѡ2022.   DSM-5-TR. ..




25


DSM-5   541 ,       128 (Blashfield etal., 2014).




26


   ,   ,      ,   14   (,  , , ). ,    ,            .  - ,       (McManus etal., 2016).




27


  ..  ࠖ ,     (,  )     . ,           ,   .           ,    (Ruskin etal., 1998),           (Matuszak & Piasecki, 2012). ʠ,  ,     ,  ,  ,     ,     (Saunders etal., 2015).




28


     ,    ,      (Johnstone etal., 1992).




29


Kessler, 1997.




30


Matheson etal., 2013; Weich etal., 2002.




31


APA, 2013.




32


      ,    .     TheLancet        (Thornicroft etal., 2016).




33


            ,  ,     (, Corrigan etal., 2006).       (Link etal., 2001), ,  ,   . ʠ           ,      (Lysaker etal., 2008).




34


, Corrigan etal., 2006.




35


      (Siegel, 2015).




36


           (Gratz & Roemer, 2004): 1)    ; 2)    ; 3)   ; 4)     ,  ; 5)      ; 6)        .


