   ?   
 


,   
 ,   ,    - ,    ,      ,    .

   ,        ,   ,    40 .        ,      ,     ,    .





 

   ?   



Rosalind Miles

Who Cooked theLast Supper: TheWomens History ofthe World

Copyright 1988 byRosalind Miles



1988 byRosalind Miles

 ..,   , 2023

.   , 2023


* * *


 



     , ,  .

  



  ,    .     ,  .   ,           ࠖ ,  ,     ,     .     蠖   !

                   , , ,  .      ,    ,     ?     .

    ,  ,       ,     蠖    .

 



 ,  蠖    ,   ,     .     ,      ,  . ,   :    蠫  ,   .     .   : www.rosalind.net.



 



 ,      ,    .

TheTimes ofLondon



    堖 ,         .

Booklist



      .

Newsday



Ӡ  ,   . Ƞ      ,    ,       ,  .

Cosmopolitan



 ,  ,  ,     蠖  ,   .

New Society


  ,

    


  ;   .

  










   ?  ࠖ    ,       ?

        ,  ,     堖  .     ,   ,     ࠖ ,  . -        ; -    ; -,    ,  .  ,      .  ,  -    .

   ,    .     ,        .    ,       .  I  ,    - .   蠖     蠖     ;     ,   .     ,   ,  ,     .

Ƞ   ,   !   ? ߠ  . Ƞ      ?       .       ,    :  ?  ,  ,   .   . -,  , ,  ,  ,    !   !

  ,     ,    ,    . ߠ  ,    . , ,       .      .         (TheWomens History ofthe World)      .    ,       .     ;   ,  ,     .

Ƞ    ࠫ   .       .       ,   蠖  .     ,    :    .     ,       :    ,  . -  ,     ,    ,  :   ,     . ! .  ! ,  ,   :   -  ,  ,       ,    ,   ,       .   : [  ],   ,         .      蠖    ,     . ,      ,   .

   :   ,  ,    .       ,  ,    ,  .  ,              ,   .  ,         ,          .  :      .       ,  ,   ,    .

  ,       ,       .        : ,    ,   .  ,    ,   ;     ,     . ߠ      ,  .        , ,    . :            ,    .




   ?


   :      ?     ,    . ,    ,       .   :     ,       .       ࠖ      .      :      ,      .        .   ;         , ,      .      ;       .          蠖 ,          .     :        ,   .        .        ,   .   ,   ;   , ,      ,          .          . ,     ,  ,        ,  XVIII.    堫 , ࠫ 컠    ,    . Ƞ    ,     ,  , ,       ,        .

    ,            .   ,    , ?      ,        ? Ƞ      .          ? ,       ?          堖 ,  , , ,       , ?

Π         ,   -  : ,   .   2000       ,  ,    ,  .     ,    ,      ;  ,     .    ,   ࠖ ,  ,      ! ,   ,     :     ,    .  ,  -    . ,      .

 , ,            . ,       :      ? ,     : 堖 , ,  .        ,      ࠖ , ,  .   ,   ,     : , , 堖 ,  .  , , ,      ,           .

 : -       ,     ,        .    : ⠫     ,  . ,     ,       :      , ?     ,   ,        .   ,   ,  , ,  . ,  ,   . Ƞ    , ,  , .               , , ,      .   ,   ,     XX.    ,     ;     ,     ( ,     ,  ,     ?).  ,  ,       , , ,  ,  ࠖ        .        ;    ,   , -     .




  ?


Ƞ   ,         ,    ?  1960-     ,        .   ,    ,        .      -  .     ! Ƞ     .    ,  ,   ,  . -       ,  ,  ꠫ , , , .      ,  ,  , ,  ,  .  XX  ,   ,     .   , -,   .   蠖      ,     .

        , ,   .     ,     젖 , ,   -       .   ,    ࠖ       .       ,          ,  . -         ,   ,    ,    . Ƞ           .            ,     .    ,     ,      ,     ,   ,   ?   ,     , ,   ,   ,  ,   ? ,    :    -      ,      ?   - -,    ,   ,    ?   堖 ,       -?

-     .          ,    .  , , ,         ,    ,      . ,       .     , , ,  堖     .        ,          .               .

      ;       .       ,    ,    ,   .    ,  堖     ,   .    :        ,    ,     .  -         , ,  .  :  ,    .             ,  ,  .            : ,     ,      ,       . , 19841985           .   堖       ,     .    ,      , -     ,        , -   .              ,  .    -   ,        .    -    ,  .           :  ,   ࠫ   ⠖  , ,     .    ,   ,   .       ,    蠖         .

,          蠖  ,     :      . ,      :    ,      , -    .             . ,     ,      2047  ! ,     ,    ,      -  .         -,      ,    .

  : ,   ,       , ,      ,  ,  ,  頖       .      ,     ,      :    ,  ⠫  !  ,     ,   , , , ,    -  .       ໠ ,   ,        . Ƞ ,  -    -   , ,  , , ,          :    .

    .   , ,        ;               .   ,   ,    . ,  ,   - ,  ,  ,   ;       , ,   . ,   .    ,      ,     ,  ,  ,      .         , ,       ,       .         .  .

     .       ,   .  ,   ,     ,   .          :    , 滠       ,  ꠫ ,      .      ;        ,  ,        . ,       ,      (,  ;  - -747,  - ),  XXI    ,          .  ,   ,   ,      ,  ,      ,        ,      ,      ,      ,      .              ;     , -     .  ,    60-      ,      , , ,  47%;      ,       蠖     ꠫ .

,  .       ,         ,    ,        . , ,       ,  ,          , ,  .  ,  ,   ,   ,       ,       . Ƞ,         (,  ).            ,  . Ƞ   .    ,   , ;   ,        .   en masse  젖     蠫                ,  . Ƞꠖ  ,      .

    ,   ,  ,     .    ,        . ߠ,         ;     .   ,   ,    .   :  ,  ,    ,    堖 ,  24,    ,  .

Ƞ  . ,           ,  .       . Ƞ  .   ,      ,      .      ,  , - 蠫 ,   ,     , -, -, - . Π, , Ӡ,   , -.      ,    ,  ,  ,   ,  .        ,  .      . Π    蠖  .    :        .

            . Ƞ     :     ,   .        .   ,   -  ,      ;       .       ,  :              .       , ,   ,      -  .      ,      :   ?  젖   :   - ,    , ,      .  ,   ,       ;    ,      . ,    ,   젖 , , ,  ,  . Ƞ   ,   ࠖ - ,  ,  , , , , ,             .    ,       .   ,     堖    .  -           젖   ,    , : ,      ,    ,  . ,      ,   ,      .     ,   .

      ,     .  ,  ,  ,    ,     ,  ,  .  ,  .         : -     , , ,   ,         .     ,       ,    . ,           ,   .   ,      ,      .    :         .      ,        . ,        -  :    -?        -    .  ,    -  ,    ,   ,  . ࠖ    . ,             .

,     .  ,  :  ,      ,    , -     .         .

    ,  . ߠ          蠖  ,     .    ?      .   , ,     ;     ,  . ,    : ?  !   !    ,     -   .    : ,     ,  ,   ,    .         XIX蠖  ,       ,      ,     ,         .  ,        .  ,     .        ,   ,     ࠖ     ? Ƞ     ?

    ,   .    ,    ,    . Ƞ,   ,    .  ,     .



 ,
-, 2000




I. 


    ,  ,    ,      .

 




1. 



    ࠖ - -. ,          ,   ,     ,    .

  

     ,  .  ,  , , , .

 

   . ,        ;        ;         .    , ,    ,    ,  .             : -, -  , ࠖ  .         : , ,     .

    ,     ,     ,      [1 - Elizabeth Gould Davis, TheFirst Sex (1971), .3435. ,  Y-     -,   : . Francis Swiney, Women andNatural Law (1912).         ⠫ ̻ (TheSCUM Manifesto, NewYork, 1968)  :   Y-ࠖ       ,    ⅻ].       ՠ :           ,            Y,     , ,  ջ.  ,    ,   ,      ,   .    ,  ,  ;    .       :     ,        ;   ,   [2 - Amaury de Riencourt, Women andPower inHistory (1974,     1983), .52.].

    ?   ,        [3 - Nigel Calder, Timescale (1984), .1.]:      , , ,  .        : ,      ,     .     ,  ,      ,   ,          ,   .     ,    , , .     ,      .    300  ,     ,       ,  [4 -       : Listener, 27 February1986; Guardian, 3 March1986.].

 ,      ,     ,   .      ,     :  , ,    ,                .         .  ,   ,   ,      .        :         ,  --   .

,     ,     ꠫ , -  ,   .      Homo erectus     Femina erecta;     ,    .           ,         蠖  ,   ,    .

       .    頖     , -,   ,   ,  .    ,     [5 - Π     .:Marian Lowe andRuth Hubbard (eds.), Womans Nature: Rationalisations ofInequality (NewYork andOxford, 1983), .131.].            .  ,     ,   ,     :

.

 .

 .

 ,    .

 .

 .

 ,    .

    .

 ,  .

    ,  :   ,      ,   .

       ,   .

     , ,  :    .      ,  ,     ,     -. ,  ,      .      , ,    175 / .  97%     ,   3%     .       ,      .      , ,          ,      ,   , .        ,  .    ,    80%   .    , -      ,   ,      [6 - George P.Murdock, Our Primitive Contemporaries (NewYork, 1934); Social Structure (NewYork, 1949); World Ethnographic Sample, American Anthropologist (1957); Ethnographic Atlas: ASummary, Ethnology 6, No. 2, 109236.    Jo Freeman (d.), Women: AFeminist Perspective (Palo Alto, California, 1979), .94. .    : MantheHunter, eds. R. B. LeeandIrven De Vore (1968). ,            -: ,    ,      . ,   ,   堖        , , ,        .].

   ,   ,    蠖       . ,      ,  ;  ,   ,     , ,   , ,     [7 - Π     .: Elaine Morgan, TheDescent ofWoman (1972), .184; .: Calder, .156,    ,             .      60     ,   :            . ,     .      ,    ,  :           .].  ,       . -  -       [8 -   .:Kenneth Oakley, Man theTool-Maker (1947); R. Leakey andR. Lewin, Origins (NewYork, 1977); G. Isaac andR. Leakey, Human Ancestors (1979); B. M. Fagan, People ofthe Earth: AnIntroduction toWorld Pre-History (1980).].     ,   ,  ,    ,   堖   ,   ,    .     ;    -         ,      ,    ,     [9 - Elise Boulding, TheUnderside ofHistory (Colorado, 1976), .78,    ,  , ,    ,   ,    .].

,   ,   ,       ,    .  , -     ,    ,   -  .      蠖   ,      ,  , , ,    [10 - . Sally Slocum, Woman theGatherer: MaleBias inAnthropology.      .: Rayna Reiter (d.), Towards anAnthropology ofWomen (NewYork, 1975), MaryEvans (d.), TheWoman Question: Readings inthe Subordination ofWomen (1982).      .: Sheila Lewenhak, Women andWork (1980), .2021.].

        ,        ,   .     , ,  ,      , , , ,  .    ,  ;          .   ,          ;   ,    ꠖ         .  ,  ,   :      -,     .



 -     ,   ,     ,  .     ,       ࠖ ,   ,    .         ,    ,     .    蠖     ,   ,     .   :     ,    .       ,       .   ? ,    .

     ,     ,    .         ,  -. -,         ࠖ      :        . -,   ,    .         ,   ,   ;               . ,      蠖      !

          . -    -   ,         , ,            .     :



      ,     - ,    ,    젖     .      ,  ,   ,      [ ][11 - .].


         頖         ,  -/,   .  ,    ,      ,        (  , , ), ,      .    ,     ,   ໠ ,  ,           . ,  ,       .            -[12 -   -      ,  ,     . . LeeandDeVore (above); S. Washburn andC. S. Lancaster, TheEvolution ofHunting, inLeeandDeVore (eds.), Kalahari Hunter-Gatherers (Harvard, 1976); Sol Tax (d.), Evolution After Darwin, Vol.II: TheEvolution ofMan (Chicago, 1960); Josef Wolf andZdenek Burian, TheDawn ofMan (London andPrague, 1978); Robert Ardrey, African Genesis (1961), TheHunting Hypothesis (1976) - .].

      .   -   .       ,     ,   ,  .    ,    ,        :   ,   堖 -,   ,   [13 - Ardrey (1976), .9192.].        , ,      ,         .      ,          .   -    -  :  ,     .       ,   ,    .     : ,       .      ,    [14 - W.I. Thomas, Sex andSociety: Studies inthe Psychology ofSex (1907), .228.].

 ,     ,  ,    . ,      .   :     頖  , , 頖  [15 - Calder, .142143.]. Ѡ        , ,     .     ,  ,      .         ,          ,  ,   .

Ƞ,   ,      ,  .      .  -      ,   :          .         ,            . Ƞ   .  :  femina  erecta,      ,      ,     .      ,   ,  : ,   ,    [16 - Morgan, .5863.           ⠫  (Desmond Morris, TheNaked Ape (1967), .65,75).].      :   .   ,   - -  .  ,            ,       .

         .     ,     ,    .       .   ,   ,         ,    .

 ,    ⠖   .   , ,  ,        - .       ;      ,      .      - ,   : ,     ,  -. ,      .  ,     ,   .

     , ,   .   ,           ,     .        (TheWise Wound)          ,   , ,          ,    .   ,        ,      ,  : Ӡ    ໠   . ,         [17 - Boulding, .83.].  -      ,             ꠫  ,   .     --   : ?      ? -,   ,      [18 -        .: Joanna Russ, How toSuppress Womens Writing (Texas, 1983), .5152.].

 ,         , ,  ,  - .    ,    ,  ,  ,    , -    ,         .

    ,       ,  ,   ,    .    ?     ,  ?       -堖   ,  ,    ,  25    .     ,             ,    ,       .        .

    ;  , . ,         .   ,    ,    ,  ,   ,   .  ,        - ,  . Ƞ   ,     ,       .                  ,   [19 - Elaine Morgan, .116,     ; Sheila Lewenhak (.20, 2324)     ; Paula Weideger, Historys Mistress (1985), .133134   .].   , ,     ,       .

 :  ,      ,    .  ,     ?  ,    ,        .  ,        ,   ,   - ,   ꠫ 軠       .  : ߠ ,         [20 - Donald C. Johanson, Maitland A. Edey, Lucy: TheBeginnings ofHumankind (London andNewYork, 1981), .340.]. Ƞ  ,  ?

  -,  ,         ,    .          .  ,    ,    .     ,    .   ![21 - H. G. Wells, TheOutline ofHistory (1920), .94,118.]    蠖    .     , ,  , 蠖 ࠫ     ,     [22 - Ardrey (1976), .83.].     ;     ,  - .       .         ;            蠖      quid proquo.

     ꠫         . -,   , ,    .       ,       ,  .  ,        , ,       [23 - Morris, .65,75.]. ,        ࠖ ,  .

     ,        ,   .    젖      .      ,    .    ,     [24 - Ardrey (1976), .100.].     -  -젖 ,    , , ,   365 ,   ,         ,  .

     ,    ,    ,     -?         :   ꠖ  ,  ⠫      .   ,      (     , ),       ,  . ʠ1925     :            [-]      ,      ,   ,  :



       ,    :   ,  , ,  ,           ,  [25 - Charles Darwin, Onthe Origin ofSpecies byMeans ofNatural Selection (1859), TheDescent ofMan(1871); Thomas Huxley, Ethics andEvolution (1893); Herbert Spencer, Principles ofBiology (1864I867); Carveth Read, Origins ofMan(1925); Raymond Dart, ThePredatory Transition from Ape toMan, International Anthropological andLinguistic Review V.i., n. 4 (1953).].


,   -  ,       .   ,   . ࠖ ,     .      ,    :   ,  [  ??]    , -  [26 - Robert Ardrey (1961), .316; Konrad Lorenz, OnAggression (1966); Anthony Storr, Human Aggression (1968) .i.].          : ,  ,   ,     .  ,       ,     [27 - Wells, .7778; Ardrey (1978), .91.]. ꠫        ,     , ࠫ ,    ,     .

 ,      ,        ,       -.         : , , ,  ,      ,       .  ,   :          蠫 .            ,      ,  : , , , -    [28 - Washburn andLancaster, .303; Johanson, .65; John Nicholson, Men andWomen: HowDifferent Are They? (Oxford, 1984), .5.].

 -,          ,    .     :        ?   ? Π 蠖     ࠖ  .   ,    ,    ,   ,   ,  ,        [29 - De Riencourt, .6.]. ,  -,    , , ,   .  ,     !   ? ,  ,   ,   , ,        .

,         -,          ,      .        ,  ,  ,   ,   ,         .


    ,  

  :  ,   ,  蠖 , , ,   ⠖   [30 - Myra Shackley, Neanderthal Man (1980), .68.]. Ƞ    ,     ,     ,   . ,     ,   . , XVIII   砫     ,        , 堫    ,   [31 - Peter Farb, Mans Rise toCivilization asShown bythe Indians ofNorth America from Primeval Times tothe Coming ofthe Industrial State (1968), .3637.].




   


,     ,            .  ,  ,   ,   :        ( , ,     ),      (    )[32 - Shackley, .68.].        ,     :     .          ,    .       , ,   :          ,  ,    ,   ,   .


,         

      ,      , ,  ,       [33 - J. Constable, TheNeanderthals (1973).].     ,  , ,  , 頖 ,   ,     ,     .    :



      ,  ,   , ,     .   ,    .    ,   ,   ,       ,     ,             ,    ,        ?     ,  ,    [34 - Shackley, .206.].


, -    ,    .    ,     ,   :         ,      .  ,           ,  ,  ,      .

         ,        ,   ,     ,   -  ࠖ    ,   ,   .    ,   ,  ,    .    , ,     ,   :



        .   ,     蠖  .  ,    :     . ,       ,    ,      ,      [35 - , .94.].


     -,   ?[36 - Lowe andHubbard, .114115.] ,    ?

 ,       .   ()       ,  150 200  .   .    ,        ,   .        [37 - Shackley, .107108.].

    .   ( )   ,    :      , ,   ,   .    ,   堖  :  ,     ,    ,       ,  .           򻠖  ![38 - Robert Graves, TheNewLarousse Encyclopaedia ofMythology (1959), .6; . G.-H. Luquet, TheArtandReligion ofFossil Man (Oxford, 1930).]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=69555016)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Elizabeth Gould Davis, TheFirst Sex (1971), .3435. ,  Y-     -,   : . Francis Swiney, Women andNatural Law (1912).         ⠫ ̻ (TheSCUM Manifesto, NewYork, 1968)  :   Y-ࠖ       ,    ⅻ




2


Amaury de Riencourt, Women andPower inHistory (1974,     1983), .52.




3


Nigel Calder, Timescale (1984), .1.




4


      : Listener, 27 February1986; Guardian, 3 March1986.




5


Π     .:Marian Lowe andRuth Hubbard (eds.), Womans Nature: Rationalisations ofInequality (NewYork andOxford, 1983), .131.




6


George P.Murdock, Our Primitive Contemporaries (NewYork, 1934); Social Structure (NewYork, 1949); World Ethnographic Sample, American Anthropologist (1957); Ethnographic Atlas: ASummary, Ethnology 6, No. 2, 109236.    Jo Freeman (d.), Women: AFeminist Perspective (Palo Alto, California, 1979), .94. .    : MantheHunter, eds. R. B. LeeandIrven De Vore (1968). ,            -: ,    ,      . ,   ,   堖        , , ,        .




7


Π     .: Elaine Morgan, TheDescent ofWoman (1972), .184; .: Calder, .156,    ,             .      60     ,   :            . ,     .      ,    ,  :           .




8


  .:Kenneth Oakley, Man theTool-Maker (1947); R. Leakey andR. Lewin, Origins (NewYork, 1977); G. Isaac andR. Leakey, Human Ancestors (1979); B. M. Fagan, People ofthe Earth: AnIntroduction toWorld Pre-History (1980).




9


Elise Boulding, TheUnderside ofHistory (Colorado, 1976), .78,    ,  , ,    ,   ,    .




10


. Sally Slocum, Woman theGatherer: MaleBias inAnthropology.      .: Rayna Reiter (d.), Towards anAnthropology ofWomen (NewYork, 1975), MaryEvans (d.), TheWoman Question: Readings inthe Subordination ofWomen (1982).      .: Sheila Lewenhak, Women andWork (1980), .2021.




11


.




12


  -      ,  ,     . . LeeandDeVore (above); S. Washburn andC. S. Lancaster, TheEvolution ofHunting, inLeeandDeVore (eds.), Kalahari Hunter-Gatherers (Harvard, 1976); Sol Tax (d.), Evolution After Darwin, Vol.II: TheEvolution ofMan (Chicago, 1960); Josef Wolf andZdenek Burian, TheDawn ofMan (London andPrague, 1978); Robert Ardrey, African Genesis (1961), TheHunting Hypothesis (1976) - .




13


Ardrey (1976), .9192.




14


W.I. Thomas, Sex andSociety: Studies inthe Psychology ofSex (1907), .228.




15


Calder, .142143.




16


Morgan, .5863.           ⠫  (Desmond Morris, TheNaked Ape (1967), .65,75).




17


Boulding, .83.




18


       .: Joanna Russ, How toSuppress Womens Writing (Texas, 1983), .5152.




19


Elaine Morgan, .116,     ; Sheila Lewenhak (.20, 2324)     ; Paula Weideger, Historys Mistress (1985), .133134   .




20


Donald C. Johanson, Maitland A. Edey, Lucy: TheBeginnings ofHumankind (London andNewYork, 1981), .340.




21


H. G. Wells, TheOutline ofHistory (1920), .94,118.




22


Ardrey (1976), .83.




23


Morris, .65,75.




24


Ardrey (1976), .100.




25


Charles Darwin, Onthe Origin ofSpecies byMeans ofNatural Selection (1859), TheDescent ofMan(1871); Thomas Huxley, Ethics andEvolution (1893); Herbert Spencer, Principles ofBiology (1864I867); Carveth Read, Origins ofMan(1925); Raymond Dart, ThePredatory Transition from Ape toMan, International Anthropological andLinguistic Review V.i., n. 4 (1953).




26


Robert Ardrey (1961), .316; Konrad Lorenz, OnAggression (1966); Anthony Storr, Human Aggression (1968) .i.




27


Wells, .7778; Ardrey (1978), .91.




28


Washburn andLancaster, .303; Johanson, .65; John Nicholson, Men andWomen: HowDifferent Are They? (Oxford, 1984), .5.




29


De Riencourt, .6.




30


Myra Shackley, Neanderthal Man (1980), .68.




31


Peter Farb, Mans Rise toCivilization asShown bythe Indians ofNorth America from Primeval Times tothe Coming ofthe Industrial State (1968), .3637.




32


Shackley, .68.




33


J. Constable, TheNeanderthals (1973).




34


Shackley, .206.




35


, .94.




36


Lowe andHubbard, .114115.




37


Shackley, .107108.




38


Robert Graves, TheNewLarousse Encyclopaedia ofMythology (1959), .6; . G.-H. Luquet, TheArtandReligion ofFossil Man (Oxford, 1930).


