 .       
 


.      
     ,    The Economist.   ,    ,    ,        .   ,    ,  ,           ,     ,               .

  PDF A4   .





 

 .       



WE SEE IT ALL:

Liberty and Justice in an Age of Perpetual Surveillance

Jon Fasman

 2021 Jon Fasman.



  ..,    , 2023

 .   , 2023


* * *


      


      ,          ,        .

 
 










  

     .

10  2020     -  -.    .   The Economist            ,                    ,  COVID-19     .      -,      ,       ,      ,    ,     ,              .

              .                ໠      ,       .    :      .      :         Delta Biometrics,      .    ,   ,  :         . ,            .  delta.com,      .

                 .    :     ,     ,  ,     ,      .  , ,           ,      .            .   2019   ,     --.  93%     ,   - ,  72%    .

         ,     ,       .  ,  -          :     ,    ,  ,       .   .    - ,             ,    - .

      :   . ,        .        .   ,      .       ,           ,      .  ,         ,    :    ,      .

          ,    ,       .       ,          .    :   2017        The Economist         .       .   .

  -,      .  ,       The Daily,    - .      ,       .     ,         [1 - Kashmir Hill, The Secretive Company That Might End Privacy as We Know It, New York Times, January 18, 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-privacy-facial-recognition.html.].           .  ,          ,        ,   .

        Clearview AI,      .         ,   ,    .       Clearview,        ,     YouTube           ,    .

 ,   , ,      ,   ,   .      ,  ,   Clearview. ,     Clearview  ,     ,   .   ,    : , ,       ,     ,     .

   ,  Clearview    ,      (Clearview  ,  ),         . ,              [2 - Kashmir Hill, Before Clearview Became a Police Tool, It Was a Secret Plaything of the Rich, New York Times, March 5, 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/03/05/technology/clearview-investors.html.].           Clearview.      ,     ,      -.  ,          ,   . (   Haagen-Dazs,  .    .)

   Clearview:   ,     .          .    ,          habeas corpus,       ,      .

   Clearview   ,        ,    .  ,  ,       Clearview,    .    :    , ,     ,    .   ,   ,    . ,        - ,     . ,  ,     -     ,         .

Facebook[3 -  ,      .]      -  ,  Clearview    .  ,    Google,  2011  ,      ,  Google, ,   ,   ,        [4 - Hill, Secretive Company.].

 Clearview  -    .      ,    ,   .   ,   -    ,      ,   :     .    ,  -, -,     .

    ,  -,        .  ,   ,       ,     ,       ,     .  ,    -      ,   .    .            .        .         ,   ,      .

   ,    .   ,     ,   Burts Bees  Toms of Maine (   Clorox  Colgate-Palmolive),      ,     .   Clearview AI                   (          )     .  :      ,       ,  ,    Clearview.

    ,        ,     .    ,            ?  ,      .       ,     .

     ,     The Economist    2018 .   ,       ,  ,   [5 - John Fasman, Data Detectives, The Economist, Technology Quarterly: Justice, June 2, 2018.].         ,    , ,       .   ,           ,             ,, , ,    . , ,    ,  ,               ,   .   ,       .

     The Economist,                .       . -       ,,  2017          .       .    Clearview ,       .

  ,    ,     ,       .     .   ,   :       .       ,         .     .        ,                     . ,         ,   ,   ,     - ,     .

       .  ,     ,      ,    .    ,      ,            (    ,     ).

    ,   ,     ,   ,      ,   ,           .       ,   ,   .     ,     ?          .




1.  



            ?

      .    ,     .      -, -    .        ,           .     .            ,        Newark Star-Ledger.  ,   ,  ,      .       ,        .

       ,          .  ,    .  ,              .      ,    ,   .    ,   (,  ),      .

  .     ,     .     -   .      ,    , , ,     ,  . ,    ,   ,  : ,    .    [6 -  ,       ,       ,         1970-           . . .]  ,   ,    :      -,           .

            ,         ,          , ,   ,             .    -     ,     .              ,                    .

       ,   ,     -,  ,        .     ,       :  ,         .

          .      -   .           .          (  ) .  , ,    -        :      ,  ,   ,   ,    ,     .     ,    :    -,     ,  ,            ,    , ,   ,           .      ,    ,      ,      : , ,      .    -    ,     [7 - Philip Roth, The Counterlife (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1986), 237.].

     ,        , ,    ,     ,            .     ,  ,           ,     ,   .       .        .     ,   ,   ,     .

          ,    ,     .  ,             .      .     , ,   ,     ,      : ,  ,  ,  ,   .          :    ,          ,      .

  ShotSpotter,      2019           [8 - ShotSpotter, 2020 Annual Report, available at https://ir.shotspotter.com/annual-reports.].   :                 .            .     -   ,       ,      ShotSpotter.  ,     ,         .     :  ,     .

  ,     .        .    ,              .

 ,      ,   .     ,      .     .  ,        .          :    .   .

  ,       :     ,         .  -        .        ,       ,  ,     .

,   ,      .   ,    .                 ,     . (      ,       ,    .)

, , ,     ,      .          1986 .    ,    ,    ,    .            .      ,     .    ,          :    ,  .

       ,   .   ,         :      ,        .  :       ,   ,   ,   ,   ,       ,   .                .

  ,   ,       .     .  GPS   .    ,      .  ,        ,          ,          .

 ,               .     ,    ,            .               - (NYPD)   ,      [9 -       -,      ,      ,        ,   ,     . ,              -      -, 959 F.Supp. 2d 540 (2013),          ,          .     , ,  .]. , ,    ,    .

   ,   . ShotSpotter    .      .      ,     , ,  - , ,     .  , ,  ,           . ,   .       ,        .  ShotSpotter     ,     ,   , ?

   ?   ,          ,   ,   ?     ,  ,    ,   :   .         ? ,    ,   ShotSpotter,             ,   .   ,     .      ,    .


* * *

        ,     Persistent Surveillance Systems.            ,         .

,       ,         -,  .      ,            -.  ,           11  2001 ,          .

 ,   ,   ,   ,   ,    ,  ,   .         -.

    ,          .  ,     ,   ,     .        .          .      :     ,     ,  ,   .

 ,       ?    ?       ,    ,      -   ?  ,      ?      ?   ,        ?

,  ,     ,   ?        ?         ,   ,        ?     .  ,               ,   ?                  ,      :       -,  ?

       ,     ,   :          ?

  ,       .


* * *

 ,         ,   .     ,      ,    ,    .    ,  ,      . , , ,   :     ,    .    .

    ?  ,      ,       ,          .

       ?  Persistent Surveillance      ,        (  ,  ,      ) ,       - .

   ,     .   :      ,      .  ,   ,   ,    ,       .      .          ,                   .

   , Persistent Surveillance     ,   ,                .   ,     .         ,  ,    .      .   , ,    .         .  : ,         .         ,    .       .

   (BPD)  Persistent Surveillance     2016 .          ,   ,        .           ,     .       ,  Bloomberg Businessweek         BPD :   ,     ,       [10 - Monte Reel, Secret Cameras Record Baltimores Every Move from Above, Bloomberg Businessweek, August 23, 2016, www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-baltimore-secret-surveillance.].

    BPD :  ,  Persistent Surveillance,    -  ,      .              ,   , /     , ,  , ,    ,     BPD    [11 - Jay Stanley, Baltimore Aerial Surveillance Program Retained Data Despite 45-Day Privacy Policy Limit, American Civil Liberties Union, October 25, 2016, www.aclu.org/blog/privacy-technology/surveillance-technologies/baltimore-aerial-surveillance-program-retained.].         :       ,              .

         ,     ,   ,       .   ,               ,    .  ,         .               .

           (ACLU).   ,          -  ,  , ,            .      .    Bloomberg Businessweek,  ,         ACLU,    ,              .   :      .     ,     .

- :                 .   ,              . ,    , :     ,    ,     .  , ,    -,            ,     -.

,     Persistent Surveillance   .         ,     . ,   ,    , ,    ,    .            ,      .     .  cookie     . ,     , ,      .    ,     ,     ,                ,     ,        ?

   ,  ,      ,         .     2020 , ,      ,        .  90000    COVID-19         -.     ,            .        .

        COVID-19      ,              260 .           ,       330 .       ,                    ,    ,      .            .

,         :   , ,            ,   ,     .      ,      ,        COVID-19.   :        .              ,                        .      ,     ,   ,    ,   ,  ,    .

       ,         COVID-19.               (    )    ,   ,      .      (,       ),       .   ,       ?    ,  .


* * *

,            2018 ,      ,        .      ,    :     ,           .  -    ,        .    ,        .

   .      .     ,    .     , , ,     . ,     ,    ,        .

       , -,    ( ),    - ( )  - ().               .    ,   ,       .

  ,    ,         , ,,  ,     ,    .     :  ,    .   ,          ,    ,              . (   ,             -  ,    .)  ,   ,    ,    .

 ,    .   ,         , ,    (), , ,    .               .    , ,  .     ,        .

          ,    ,       .            ,    ,         ,      .

,         .      ,    ,     (    ,    , SMS-,    -,    ),   ,        ,   :    ,   ,   ,    .

      ,         .    :      (,   )         [12 -  Lawfare,     ,  -        : Michael Bahar, David Cook, Varun Shingari, Curtis Arnold, Third-Party Party-Crashing? The Fate of the Third-Party Doctrine, October 19, 2017, www.lawfareblog.com/third-party-party-crashing-fate-third-party-doctrine.].      , ,        .        ,       ,     -     .

     . , ,    ,      ,    , , ,       ,     . ,        .

      ,   ,  ,           ,      .         :   ,       ,        (      ).

  ,          (       )     .         ,    IP-    ,  ,       .

  2019  ACLU        ,            (FOIA)         [13 - ACLU  USDOJ,   19-cv-00920-EMC,           (-) 6  2019 .].           ,                 .    ,          ,         ,    Persistent Surveillance.      ,        , ,         ,      , ,     .

      ,           .   ,    ,      .   ,       .        . ,    ,       ,    ,     .                  .

  :    ,     (      )    . ,           :  ,      ,              .     ,     . ,     ,     .    , ,    ,      ,     .

   (  ):    ,     .          .          ,     .   , ,   ,                  .

     ,       .      ,  ,        .           ,         .          ,    ,  ,                     . .          .

   ,                .    ,        .  , ,       ,    .      ,    ,      ,     ,     90%  .             ,    .  ,   ,   ,     ,     .


* * *

     ,         .      .         .     ,          ?           ,       ,      - ?      ?           ?   -  ,   ,           .       , ,  ,            ?        ,    .

       (ALPR) ,       ,          .       ,      ,     .   ,       ,       .       , ,   ,      .  ,       ,     ,       .

                     .           ,        ,    .         ,                 .  ALPR     ,   .

       ,     .      ALPR.            ?     ?      ?     :            ,       ?

         ,           .        :              ,      .   ,   ?           ?     ?    ,       ?  ,   ?     ?    :  ,         ,            ?

    ,      .       .     ,          .         ,   -  .         ,    ,  .    .

     ,        .            ,    ,   (   ):    ,     , ,         ,      .           ,     ,     .

       ,    , , ,       .     ,      -    ,   ,   .        ,        .    .         .

   ,       ,     ,   ,        ,      .     ,        .   ,                : , ,   ,       ,         .

       ,        .       , ,  ,           ,        .

     ,           .     ,         ,   WhatsApp  Signal:           .          .

      ?     Stingray,        ?     ,   ,       .       ,    ?

    ,   ,           ,        .         ,   ,     ,        ,        .   ,           .        :         ,        .

, ,    ,                      .  ,  ,   .

      . . ,  .       .  ,           .    ,     .

        ,   .     ,     ,    ,        .      ,     ,      .   ,          ,     - .     ,   , ,             .

,             .

-, ,         .                 ,  ,    ,   , .      ,   , ,   , ,      ?

    ,        N                ? ,  ? ,    ? ,  ?         ?   ,     ,      ?

       ?  ,     ?          ,                 .      :     ,     ,  ,           .

      ,   ?   ,      .         ,            .

-, ,             .      ;   ,    ;            ?

Stingray  ,       ()  ,          ,     .  Stingray       , ,  ,   , ,    , ,    ,   . Stingray          ,, -,    .      ,, ,               .

          .          ,      ,       ,  .          ,        .

   ,       ,      ,          :   ,    .   ,   ,  ,   ,    .              .    ,    ,  ,     ,        .  ,     -         .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/book/dzhon-fasman/obschestvo-kontrolya-kak-sohranit-konfidencialnost-v-epohu-to-69622183/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Kashmir Hill, The Secretive Company That Might End Privacy as We Know It, New York Times, January 18, 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-privacy-facial-recognition.html.




2


Kashmir Hill, Before Clearview Became a Police Tool, It Was a Secret Plaything of the Rich, New York Times, March 5, 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/03/05/technology/clearview-investors.html.




3


 ,      .




4


Hill, Secretive Company.




5


John Fasman, Data Detectives, The Economist, Technology Quarterly: Justice, June 2, 2018.




6


 ,       ,       ,         1970-           . . .




7


Philip Roth, The Counterlife (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1986), 237.




8


ShotSpotter, 2020 Annual Report, available at https://ir.shotspotter.com/annual-reports.




9


      -,      ,      ,        ,   ,     . ,              -      -, 959 F.Supp. 2d 540 (2013),          ,          .     , ,  .




10


Monte Reel, Secret Cameras Record Baltimores Every Move from Above, Bloomberg Businessweek, August 23, 2016, www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-baltimore-secret-surveillance.




11


Jay Stanley, Baltimore Aerial Surveillance Program Retained Data Despite 45-Day Privacy Policy Limit, American Civil Liberties Union, October 25, 2016, www.aclu.org/blog/privacy-technology/surveillance-technologies/baltimore-aerial-surveillance-program-retained.




12


 Lawfare,     ,  -        : Michael Bahar, David Cook, Varun Shingari, Curtis Arnold, Third-Party Party-Crashing? The Fate of the Third-Party Doctrine, October 19, 2017, www.lawfareblog.com/third-party-party-crashing-fate-third-party-doctrine.




13


ACLU  USDOJ,   19-cv-00920-EMC,           (-) 6  2019 .


