 
 


      ,        .        ,   .    :   ,    ?   ,     ?        ?    ?    ?    ?  ,  ?   ,      ,  ,  ,       .





 

 



H.Aschehoug&Co, 2010

 ., , 2015

 -, 2015


* * *


,   ,  , ,    ,    ,     ,    ,    .

  

, , , ࠖ ,           .      ,     .    ,        - .  . Ƞ ,  -  ,     . ,    : ,          ,       ,      . Ƞ,    ,            ,    .

      , ,      ,    ,  , ,         .  ,         .      , ,   .        ,  ,      ,  ,     , , ,          .        ,   ,     .        ,  ,      ,   ,           .

ߠ   ,      .    ,    ,    ,   ,        .      ,        .  ,         ,        ,        ,   ,  .  ,      .       ,          .

,      .  ,          .   ,  , ,   ,      . , -       ,   ,  , , ,  . ,      ,    ,  ,  ,     ,       .                . ߠ      ,        [1 - ߠ     : David Schmidtz, Jason Brennan. ABrief History ofLiberty. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2010; Orlando Patterson. Freedom. Volume I: Freedom intheMaking ofWesterm Culture. NewYork: Basic Books, 1991; Ben Wilson. What Price Liberty? London: Faber andFaber, 2009; A.C. Grayling. Towards theLight: TheStory oftheStruggles forLiberty andRights. London: Bloomsbury, 2007.        .    ,      ,    : Thomas Pink, Martin Stone (red.) TheWill andHuman Action: From Antiquity tothePresent Day. London: Routledge, 2003.      : Robert Kane (red.) TheOxford Handbook ofFree Will. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002; Gary Watson (red.) Free Will, 2


 ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003; Joseph Keim Campbell, Michael ORourke, David Shier (red.) Freedom andDeterminism. Cambridge MA/London: MITPress, 2004; Laura Waddell Ekstrom (red.) Agency andResponsibility: Essays ontheMetaphysics ofFreedom. Boulder CO: Westview Press, 2000; Ian Carter, Matthew H. Kramer, Hillel Steiner (red.) Freedom: APholosphical Anthology. Malden MA/Oxford: Blackwell, 2007.].      ,     , ,  ,  .      ,       .      ,  ,         ,    , , ,     .          ,      ,     ,       .     ,       , ,       ,     ,    [2 - Daniel C. Dennett. Elbow Room: Varieties ofFree Will Worth Wanting. Cambridge MA: MITPress, 1984. .3.     . Daniel C. Dennett: Freedom Evolves. London: Penguin, 2003.]. Ѡ ,     ,      .  ,       , ,   ,  ,   ,     ,     .

ߠ     ,      ,    ,      . ,      , ,       ,   ,            .   , ,        ,       1971,   -   ,   . ʠ,          ,     .      ,     ,    , ,     .              ,     .

,     ,   ,    .       ,   ,     [3 - Π    蠫  . Lars Fr. H. Svendsen. Hvaer flosof. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2003. 6.]. ,    . ߠ           ,          ,    ,       .        ,       ,    ,      . Ѡ  ,        蠫 ,   ,     , ,    ,     ,    .

        . I,  ,   ,       ,     , , ࠖ   (, 2004),    .     II  ,     .             ,   (Gauden-Kolbeinstveit, Lars (red.) Ytringsfrihet: 10 essays. Civita, Oslo, 2012) 蠫    ? Π    (Clemet, Kristin, Egeland, John O. (red.) Til forsvar forpersonvernet. Universitetsforlaget, Oslo, 2010).            (Stenstadvold, Halvor (red.). Georgs bok. Pax, Oslo, 2010. . 7991).            Liberalisme: Politisk frihet fra John Locke til Amartya Sen (Universitetsforlaget, Oslo, 2009).

     . ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,     .         -   .  ,       ,    Civita ,      .







    (1948) ..   ,        .      ,   ,    ,   .   , ,     , ,        ,      ,    . ,        ,       ,   . ,  ,       ,      [4 - B.F. Skinner. Walden Two. Indianopolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, 2005 (1948). .247.].  ,    .     ,       ,       .      ,  ,     ,       ,     .    ,     .  ,     .      . ,           ,   .  ,    ,    ,   ,   .  ,   ,  .

  (  )  ,      .               ? ,       ,     .   , ,   ,        ,       [5 - Colin Turnbull. TheMountain People. NewYork: Simon andSchuster, 1972.  ,       ,    ,          .].   ,     ,  . Ѡ           .  ,      , .     ,     .  ,               .  , ,  ,    ,          ,   . ߠ ,     ,      ,    .         蠫 ,   ,  , ,     .       ,  .

        ,    ,  ,    :    ,    . Ӡ           , ,  ,      .    ?  ,    , , ,  ,     ,  ?     ,   ,  ,      ?

   ,           .          ?      ,       ? ,  ,     , Y,     ,   .  .     ,     ?        -  .    ,    . ,     ,   .

 ꠫ ,  ,     .    ,    .  ,     ,      .      ,      ,              ,       .  ,     .         ? , , ,    ,      .  , ,  ,          ,   .       , ,        -.    ?       , ,          .          , ,    ,    ,  ,    ,      .  젖     .  , ,    ໠  ,          ,   ,    .        ,   ,        .

       ,      .  ,       ,  ,         . , , ,       ,          ,        ,    .      ꠫essentially contested concept (..   ),   ,     [6 - W.B. Gallie. Essentially Contested Concepts // Proceedings oftheAristotelian Society. 167/1956.].  ,       . -,     ,       . -,       . -,   ,     . Ƞ-,        ,     .      , - .    ,           .  ,    ,           ,    .         ,    .       .

      Π  ,       ,  [7 - Montesquieu. TheSpirit oftheLaws.    Anne M. Cohler, Basia C. Miller, Harold S. Stone. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005. .11.2, .154.].       1864    :



$$$     ,      .   ,  .   ,            ,          .    ,      [8 - Abraham Lincoln. Address atSanitary Fair, Baltimore, Maryland, April11, 1864 // Roy P. Basler (red.) Collected Works ofAbraham Lincoln. .7. NJ: New Brunswik, 1953. .310 .].



       ,      ,      [9 - Isaiah Berlin. Tobegreper om frihet // Lars Fr. H. Svendsen (red.) Liberalisme. Politisk frihet fra John Locke til Amartya Sen. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2009. .297.].        ,    .      ,    ,  ,      .     ,  ,      ,     ,     [10 -      .    , ꠫ 蠫,  ,       ; ,    ,   .  -    ,        ,   ,      ( ,      , ,   ). Ѡ       .     ,   ,        ,     . ߠ  ,            ,           . ,   ,      ,        .].          ,    ,  ,        .     ,   ,  .    ,       .         ,    ,   , ,  , .   : ,      ,    ,       [11 - John Dewey. Human Nature andConduct. NewYork: Henry Holt,1922. .303.].  ,    , ,      , ,       ,    .  :           . ʠ,    ,      ,           [12 - Isaiah Berlin. Liberty. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. .412, 16 , 29 , 265270, 322 .].   ,         .   , ,    ,     ,  ,   [13 - . Kathleen D.Vohs, Jonathan W. Schooler. TheValue ofBelieving inFree Will. Encouraging aBelief inDeterminism Increases Cheating // Psychological Science. 1/2008.].  ,   , ,     ,   ,   ,       ,   -   .

    [14 -      , ,         : liberty freedom,        . ,    ,     .     ,      ,     .          Hanna Fenichel Pitkin. AreFreedom andLiberty Twins? // Political Theory. 4/1988.  ,       ,              ,       . . Bernard Williams. From Freedom toLiberty: TheConstruction ofaPolitical Value // Philosophy & Public Afairs. 1/2001.],   ,      , , , , ,  ,  堖   . ߠ ,    ,   , . ,         蠫 ,   ,     ,   ,  ,  ,    ,  ,       .   ,      .         ,      ,       ,  [15 - ,         : Samuel Freeman. Illiberal Libertarians: Why Libertarianism IsNot aLiberal View // Philosophy & Public Afairs. 2/2002. ,         : David Boaz (red.) TheLibertarian Reader. NewYork: TheFree Press, 1997. ,        : Ronald Hamowy (red.) TheEncyclopedia ofLibertarianism. Thousand Oaks/London: Sage Publications, 2008.    Norman P. Barry. OnClassical Liberalism andLibertarianism. NewYork: St. Martins Press, 1987.     : Brian Doherty. Radicals forCapitalism: AFreewheeling History oftheModern American Libertarian Movement. NewYork: Public Afairs, 2007.].         , , ,     . ,    ,       [16 -   ,      .        ,       ,      .       ,       ,     .      ,          ,     .      .      ,  .  ,       .].    .  , ,    , .            , , ,     ,           [17 - ߠ         Lars Fr. H. Svendsen. Liberalisme. Politisk Frihet fra John Locke til Amartya Sen. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2009.          .  -  ,          : Hans Blokland. Freedom andCulture inWestern Society. London: Routledge, 1997; Alfonso J. Damico (red.) Liberals andLiberalism. Totowa: Rowman & Littlefeld, 1986; Katrin Flikschuh. Freedom: Contemporary Liberal Perspectives. London: Polity Press, 2007; Gerald F. Gaus. Contemporary Theories ofLiberalism. London: Sage Publications, 2003; John Gray. Liberlaism. 2


 edition. Buckingham: University Press, 1995; John Gray. TheTwo Faces ofLiberalism. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2000; Stephen Holmes. Passions andConstraint. Chicago: University ofChicago Press, 1995; Paul Kelly: Liberalism. London: Polity Press, 2005; Pierre Manent. Historie intellectuelle du libralisme. Paris: Calmann-Lvy, 1987; Ellen Frankel Paul etal. (red.) Natural Rights Liberalism from Locke toNozick. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005; Ellen Frankel Paul etal. (red.) Liberalism: Old andNew. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007; Paul Starr. Freedoms Power. TheTrue Force ofLiberalism. NewYork: Basic Books, 2007; Alan Wolfe: TheFuture ofLiberalism. NewYork: Knopf, 2009.].             蠖  ,    .      ,      ,          . ,      ,       . ,         ,   .

ߠ  ,   ,       , ,    -  ,     .       ,   ,   .        ,  -     ,              .      ,         [18 -         ,     ,   ,  ,   ,   ,   ,        . ߠ     ,        ,     . -       ,  ,    ,   ,     ,     ,       .].



    :

 .       , ,     ,    ,  ,      .       ,   ,    .          ,  ,   , ,    .  ,      ,      ,    .   ,   ,         .     -    ,        .         , , ,   ,      .      ,  ,     젖  ,     ,    ,      ,  ,     ,      ,     .           ,  ,       ,     .           ,        .   ,    ,  .

 .   ,  ,   ,      ,    .    ,    ,    ,   .       .              ,         .        .         ,   ,        ,   ,         .   ,           .         ,   ,        .   ,      ,        .     ,      .        .        ,       ;       , , ,       .       ,   [19 - . Gunnar C. Aakvaag. ? leve sitt eget liv. Etessay om frihet. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2012.].

 .      ,  ,    ,       ,       .    ,        .



             ,   ,         . ,      , ,     ,  ,          . ,  , ,      .




 





1

 


 ꠖ  ,     ,         .    -     . ,  ,     .      14 2010      ,  ,  ,    ,         ,    ,    ,  .

 ,    ,    ,  ,   ,           . ,  .         [20 -            Edward Payson Evans. Thecriminal prosecution andcapital punishment ofanimals. London: Heinemann, 1906.   : Jen Girgen. Thehistorical andcontemporary prosecution andpunishment ofanimals // Animal Law, 2003.].         , 1457    ࠫ    [21 - Grigen. Thehistorical andcontemporary prosecution andpunishment ofanimals, .110.].  ,      ,   .     ,     ,    .    ,    ,  ,       .        ,     .  ,           ,       .        XVII,          :     XX.

ߠ, ,   ,     . -       , ?  ,        ,       .  ,     ,        . Ӡ    ,  ,     ,   .     ,  ,      ,    . ,          [22 - Charles Darwin. TheDescent ofMan andSelection inRelation toSex. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1981. .1, .70.     :  .    . -:  .., 1908.].   :   ,        ,   [23 - Darwin. TheDescent ofMan. .1, .88 .], : Ӡ    , -     . 䠫        .  :   ,  [24 - ߠ       Lars Fr. H. Svendsen. Mennesket, moralen og genene en kritikk av biologismen. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2001.].                 .   ,     .       ,      , ,     ,       . Ƞ      -  .

     :



$$$     ,      ,  : ,   ,   ;          .    ,       (      ,         ).    ,   ,  ,   .       :      ,  ,   ..       [25 - Aristoteles. Politikken. .. Tormod Eidie. Oslo: Vidarforlaget, 2007. 1253a.     : .  // .  4. .4. : , 1983.].



  ꠖ  ,  ,    ,      .        ,        ,  .

       ,   . ,     ,         , ,  .     ,      ,      , ,    . ,          .    , , ,   ,     ,    . ,         ,  ,     .  ,     .

,  ,     .   :

$$$ , ,   , ,     ,    ,  ,      ,    -    ,  [26 - Aristoteles: Dennikomakiske etikk,  . ?yvind Rabb?s, Anfnn Steigen. Oslo: Bokklubben Dagens B?ker, 1999. III (1109b30f).     : .   // .  4- . .4. : , 1983.].

,      : (1) :    ,   . (2) :      ,        .        ,     蠫 ,     ,     .  ,        .  ,     ,        ,    . ʠ,  -     ,       ,   ,    .       ,     ,    . ʠ, ,   ,     ,      ,   ,     .      ,    .  ,    .

     .       ,   ,        ,     .    . ߠ        .    ,    .      , ,  ,   ,  ,       . Ƞ     , ,  ,    ,   ,    .        .    - , ?  ,   ,  (,    ,     ).   ,   - ,   ,       , ,   . ʠ,         ,     ,    ,    . ,        ,        ,     ,  ,  , ,    . Ƞ  ,   ,   .         ,  .     ,     .

,  ,   .               .       ,  ,     ,    ,  [27 - . Dominic Streatfeild. Brainwash. TheSecret History ofMind Control. London: Hodder & Stoughton, 2006.].       ,     ,           .      - .   ,         .      ,      ,    .

    ,     ,    .    ,              ,  ,           .  ,   ,  ,  ,        .   ,      ,  ,      ,       .      ,      , ,      . ,      !,       ,    .      ,      ,     ,  .  ,      , 頖 .          ,       .

 ,  ,     ,         .   ,    , ,        ,  ,    ,      .  ,   ,       .   ,     ,   ,    ,    . , ,    ,        ,       .      ,       ,     ,         .      ,       , ,      .   ?          ,      ,      ,          .  ,   ,          ,       ,  ,         ,     ?   ,          ,             ,    .  ,   ,         ,         .    ,  ,      ,    .

   ,        .     ,         .      ,    .     ?    ,    :   , , ,   ,      ⠖     ,    [28 - John Stuart Mill. Omfriheten.   . P?l Foss. Oslo: Vidarforlaget, 2010. .70.     :   . Π // Π:     (I XX). : -, 2000.]. Ƞ:       [29 - John Stuart Mill. Omfriheten. C.83.].   ,     ,    [30 - Immanuel Kant. P?dagogik // Kants gesammelte Schriften, . IX,Preu?ischen Akademie derWissenschaften (red.) Berlin/NewYork: De Gruyter, 1902. .463. . Immanuel Kant. Anthropologie inpragmatischer Hinsicht // Kants gesammelte Schriften, . VII, Preu?ischen Akademie derWissenschaften (red.) Berlin/ NewYork: De Gruyter, 1902. .149.].  蠖   .      ,      . ࠖ     ,    [31 - . Maurice Merleau-Ponty. Kroppens fenomenologi.   . B.Nake. Oslo: Pax, 1904. .   -.  . -: ; , 1999.].    ,           ,     .      .  , ࠖ  [32 - G.W.F. Hegel. Enzyklop?die derphilosophischen Wissenschaften I, Werke. .8. Frankfurt a.M.: Suhrkamp, 1986. 410.]. ࠖ  ,    ,     .    .       -  ,   . ʠ,      ,        .  ,     ?  ,           . , ,      ,     ,  .       ,          ,       [33 - Jonathan Jacobs. Choosing Character: Responsibility forVirtue andVice. Inthaka/London: Cornell University Press, 2001. .19.]. ,     ,        .      ,  ,    ,     .     .         . Ƞ,   ,   .    :

$$$  ,      .       ,      ,       ,  ,   ,    [34 -   .  //  .   . Geir Kjetsaa. .1. Oslo: Solum Forlag, 1993. .23.].

   ,     ,    , , ,  ,   .       ,     ,       ,   .

    ,    ,        .  , ,   ,       ,    . ߠ  ,       ,       .




2

 



    .   ,     ,  [35 -  .   20 1693 John Locke. Thecorrespondence ofJohn Locke. .4. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979.].    ,           ,       [36 - James Boswell. TheLife ofJohnson. London: Peguin, 2008. .681 (15 1778).].      ,    -      .    ,        . ʠ,     ,       ,    [37 - Edward O. Wilson. Consilience: TheUnity ofKnowledge. London: Abacus, 1999. .131.  Edward O. Wilson. OnHuman Nature. Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1995 (1978). .195.].     .    ,      ,     [38 - James Boswell. TheLife ofJohnson. London: Peguin, 2008. .681 (15 1778).].    .   ,    ,  ,   .     ,     ,       ,      , ,  ,  ,     , ,     ,     .

 ,        ,   .      ,    ,   ,      ,        .        , , , ,      : , ,  ,  - ,    .    ,  ,     ,     .    ,      .

   Π  ,         1839,   ,        ,   .  ,    , -    ,  ,    ,  ,  , ,   ,      ,    .    ,  ,  ,   ,   .      :

$$$ ,   : ߠ    (! , ),    ,   ,    (!   ),  ,   (! ),   , ,  (! ), ,  ,   (!   80);          . Ƞ ,      ,   ,     ,         :    , .   ,    ,   [39 - Arthur Schopenhauer. KanMenneskets frie Villie bevises af dets Selvbevidsthed.   Johan Fredrik Bjelke. Oslo: Solum, 1993. .79.].

     ,  .    ,    ,     . ,  ,    . Ƞ ,    ,    . ,  ,  .          ,     .    :  ,   堖  , ,   .

 ,   :      ,     . Ƞ,   ,     ,     [40 -      .  John R. Searle. Intentionality: AnEssay inthePhilosophy ofMind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983. .130.]. ʠ,       . ,       ,  .  ,   ,      ,      .  ,      - ,      ,       (  ).  . :

$$$ ,          ,    ,     ,     ,   ,    .   ,      ,  .  ,     ,      .  ,      ,     [41 - Daniel M. Wegner. TheIllusion ofConscious Will. Cambridge MA/London: MITPress, 2002. .317 .].

,        堖    .  ,  ,   , , , ,    ,      .  , ,   ,      [42 - Colin Blakemore. TheMind Machine. London: BBC Publications, 1988. .270.]. Ƞ    ,  .  ,  ,   ,    ,    ,   .       ,  ,     .       , ,   ,     .

,      - ,     ,        ,  ,      .         ,     [43 -        J?rgen Habermas. DasSprachspiel. verantwortlicher Urheberschaft unddasProblem derWillensfreiheit: Wie l?sst sich derepistemische Dualismus miteinenontologischen Monismus vers?hnen // Deutsche Zeitschrift f?rPhilosophie. 5/2006.  . Thomas Nagel. TheView from Nowhere. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986.].    ,                ,   .         ,    .




 


   ,         - .   ,       t        . ,   ,   t,      t. ,        t,    ,      ,        .  ,      . ,    ,   , . Ƞ     .      : ,   ,      ;    [44 - William James. TheWill toBelieve andOther Essays. NewYork: Dover Publications, 1956. .151. . :  .  . : , 1997.].

    -  :  . ,      ,       - [45 - ,   ,   .          : Helen Beebee, Christopher Hitchcock, Peter Menzies (red.) TheOxford Handbook onCausation. Oxford/NewYork: Oxford University Press, 2009.]. Ѡ     ,        ,      (  ).   ,     ,    .  X   , ,   ,   . ,  ,    .      ,  .  ,       , ,     .   ,   ,   ,           .

,           ,  , X   ,       X  .         ,   ,  .           ,  ,      .    ,      ,   ,         .

      ,     ,         , , ,   [46 - Ludwig Wittgenstein. Philosophical Occasions 19121951. Indianpolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, 1993. .42944. . :  .  . : , , 2011.].   ,  ,   ,    -      ,     . ,       ,     ,   , ,  ,     ,      ,    ,   ,  , ,   .  ,       ,      - .  ,  ,    ,     [47 - Ludwig Wittgenstein. Philosophical Occasions 19121951. .431.].       ,      ,     . ,     ,     ,  : ,       [48 - . .433.].     ,    , -   , ,   ,   :     [49 - Ludwig Wittgenstein. Filosof og kultur. Spredte bemerkninger.  . K.O.?m?s. Oslo: Cappelen, 1995. c.80.].       ,    .

   : ,    , ,  .    ,      ,   , ,    . ,        , ,          .      .   ,     ceteris paribus ,     , ࠖ     [50 - Nancy Cartwright. HowtheLaws ofPhysics Lie. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983.]. ,             ,  ,     ,          .                .

    ,        .        ,         .            ,      .         , ,  ,   ,        ,     .  ,     ,  .    ,  ,       .       ,      ,      .

 ,    ,        ,  ,         ,      . ߠ ,        ,        ,          , . Ƞ      ,      .    .      ,  .     ,       .           ,   .       ,    ,        .           .          , ,    ,    렖    ,     ,    [51 - Denis Noble. TheMusic ofLife. Biology Beyond Genes. Oxford/NewYork: Oxford University Press, 2006. .5.].  , ,      ,       ,    .       ,     ,  .   ,       ,     ,  .     ,        [52 - . Helen Stewart. AMetaphysics forFreedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.].         ,     ,         , ,     ,    ,     ,    .

,        ,     . ߠ      ,       [53 - Svendsen. Mennesket, moralen og genene.].   ,      ,         .   ,     ,         ,       .    ,   ,      ,           .        . ߠ, ,      ,  ,           ,  ,             ,      .

,      , :  , ,         ,  . Ѡ ,     ,    ,       .   ,     ,        .         - ,     .  ,     ,         ,  ,      . Ƞ   ,      . , ,     ,    , ,     . Ƞ    ,        , ,   ,    ,   .  ,            ,   . Ƞ ,            ,          .

        ,      .       ,   .   ,   ,   ,     ,     ,     ,       .

Ӡ      ,    ,     .   ,         ,    . Ѡ     ,          ,     Y Z.       , ,       , .   Π ,       , ,      ,     [54 - Lucrets. Omtingenes natur.   . Trygve Sparre. Oslo: Aschehoug, 1978. .2, . 21693. .  : . Π . : , 2012.].

     .      ,      X,  Y   ,  , , .  ,       .    ,     ,  ,      .     ,    ,     ,    ,  - .   ,   - ,     ,     ?     ,        ,      ,   .     ,     .  ,    ,   ,    , . ,      ,     ,    ,    ,       .

堖 ,  堖      .   ,  ,   .  ,   ,  ,     . , ,   /       ,    .      .

   ,       .      .        ,       .        .         . ,        . ,      ,    ,      , . Ƞ     .   , -        ,      ,      [55 - Patrick Suppes. TheTranscendental Character ofDeterminism // Midwest Studies inPhilosophy. 18/1993. .254.]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/lars-svendsen/filosofiya-svobody/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


ߠ     : David Schmidtz, Jason Brennan. ABrief History ofLiberty. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2010; Orlando Patterson. Freedom. Volume I: Freedom intheMaking ofWesterm Culture. NewYork: Basic Books, 1991; Ben Wilson. What Price Liberty? London: Faber andFaber, 2009; A.C. Grayling. Towards theLight: TheStory oftheStruggles forLiberty andRights. London: Bloomsbury, 2007.        .    ,      ,    : Thomas Pink, Martin Stone (red.) TheWill andHuman Action: From Antiquity tothePresent Day. London: Routledge, 2003.      : Robert Kane (red.) TheOxford Handbook ofFree Will. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002; Gary Watson (red.) Free Will, 2


 ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003; Joseph Keim Campbell, Michael ORourke, David Shier (red.) Freedom andDeterminism. Cambridge MA/London: MITPress, 2004; Laura Waddell Ekstrom (red.) Agency andResponsibility: Essays ontheMetaphysics ofFreedom. Boulder CO: Westview Press, 2000; Ian Carter, Matthew H. Kramer, Hillel Steiner (red.) Freedom: APholosphical Anthology. Malden MA/Oxford: Blackwell, 2007.




2


Daniel C. Dennett. Elbow Room: Varieties ofFree Will Worth Wanting. Cambridge MA: MITPress, 1984. .3.     . Daniel C. Dennett: Freedom Evolves. London: Penguin, 2003.




3


Π    蠫  . Lars Fr. H. Svendsen. Hvaer flosof. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2003. 6.




4


B.F. Skinner. Walden Two. Indianopolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, 2005 (1948). .247.




5


Colin Turnbull. TheMountain People. NewYork: Simon andSchuster, 1972.  ,       ,    ,          .




6


W.B. Gallie. Essentially Contested Concepts // Proceedings oftheAristotelian Society. 167/1956.




7


Montesquieu. TheSpirit oftheLaws.    Anne M. Cohler, Basia C. Miller, Harold S. Stone. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005. .11.2, .154.




8


Abraham Lincoln. Address atSanitary Fair, Baltimore, Maryland, April11, 1864 // Roy P. Basler (red.) Collected Works ofAbraham Lincoln. .7. NJ: New Brunswik, 1953. .310 .




9


Isaiah Berlin. Tobegreper om frihet // Lars Fr. H. Svendsen (red.) Liberalisme. Politisk frihet fra John Locke til Amartya Sen. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2009. .297.




10


     .    , ꠫ 蠫,  ,       ; ,    ,   .  -    ,        ,   ,      ( ,      , ,   ). Ѡ       .     ,   ,        ,     . ߠ  ,            ,           . ,   ,      ,        .




11


John Dewey. Human Nature andConduct. NewYork: Henry Holt,1922. .303.




12


Isaiah Berlin. Liberty. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. .412, 16 , 29 , 265270, 322 .




13


. Kathleen D.Vohs, Jonathan W. Schooler. TheValue ofBelieving inFree Will. Encouraging aBelief inDeterminism Increases Cheating // Psychological Science. 1/2008.




14


     , ,         : liberty freedom,        . ,    ,     .     ,      ,     .          Hanna Fenichel Pitkin. AreFreedom andLiberty Twins? // Political Theory. 4/1988.  ,       ,              ,       . . Bernard Williams. From Freedom toLiberty: TheConstruction ofaPolitical Value // Philosophy & Public Afairs. 1/2001.




15


,         : Samuel Freeman. Illiberal Libertarians: Why Libertarianism IsNot aLiberal View // Philosophy & Public Afairs. 2/2002. ,         : David Boaz (red.) TheLibertarian Reader. NewYork: TheFree Press, 1997. ,        : Ronald Hamowy (red.) TheEncyclopedia ofLibertarianism. Thousand Oaks/London: Sage Publications, 2008.    Norman P. Barry. OnClassical Liberalism andLibertarianism. NewYork: St. Martins Press, 1987.     : Brian Doherty. Radicals forCapitalism: AFreewheeling History oftheModern American Libertarian Movement. NewYork: Public Afairs, 2007.




16


  ,      .        ,       ,      .       ,       ,     .      ,          ,     .      .      ,  .  ,       .




17


ߠ         Lars Fr. H. Svendsen. Liberalisme. Politisk Frihet fra John Locke til Amartya Sen. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2009.          .  -  ,          : Hans Blokland. Freedom andCulture inWestern Society. London: Routledge, 1997; Alfonso J. Damico (red.) Liberals andLiberalism. Totowa: Rowman & Littlefeld, 1986; Katrin Flikschuh. Freedom: Contemporary Liberal Perspectives. London: Polity Press, 2007; Gerald F. Gaus. Contemporary Theories ofLiberalism. London: Sage Publications, 2003; John Gray. Liberlaism. 2


 edition. Buckingham: University Press, 1995; John Gray. TheTwo Faces ofLiberalism. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2000; Stephen Holmes. Passions andConstraint. Chicago: University ofChicago Press, 1995; Paul Kelly: Liberalism. London: Polity Press, 2005; Pierre Manent. Historie intellectuelle du libralisme. Paris: Calmann-Lvy, 1987; Ellen Frankel Paul etal. (red.) Natural Rights Liberalism from Locke toNozick. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005; Ellen Frankel Paul etal. (red.) Liberalism: Old andNew. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007; Paul Starr. Freedoms Power. TheTrue Force ofLiberalism. NewYork: Basic Books, 2007; Alan Wolfe: TheFuture ofLiberalism. NewYork: Knopf, 2009.




18


        ,     ,   ,  ,   ,   ,   ,        . ߠ     ,        ,     . -       ,  ,    ,   ,     ,     ,       .




19


. Gunnar C. Aakvaag. ? leve sitt eget liv. Etessay om frihet. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2012.




20


           Edward Payson Evans. Thecriminal prosecution andcapital punishment ofanimals. London: Heinemann, 1906.   : Jen Girgen. Thehistorical andcontemporary prosecution andpunishment ofanimals // Animal Law, 2003.




21


Grigen. Thehistorical andcontemporary prosecution andpunishment ofanimals, .110.




22


Charles Darwin. TheDescent ofMan andSelection inRelation toSex. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1981. .1, .70.     :  .    . -:  .., 1908.




23


Darwin. TheDescent ofMan. .1, .88 .




24


ߠ       Lars Fr. H. Svendsen. Mennesket, moralen og genene en kritikk av biologismen. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 2001.




25


Aristoteles. Politikken. .. Tormod Eidie. Oslo: Vidarforlaget, 2007. 1253a.     : .  // .  4. .4. : , 1983.




26


Aristoteles: Dennikomakiske etikk,  . ?yvind Rabb?s, Anfnn Steigen. Oslo: Bokklubben Dagens B?ker, 1999. III (1109b30f).     : .   // .  4- . .4. : , 1983.




27


. Dominic Streatfeild. Brainwash. TheSecret History ofMind Control. London: Hodder & Stoughton, 2006.




28


John Stuart Mill. Omfriheten.   . P?l Foss. Oslo: Vidarforlaget, 2010. .70.     :   . Π // Π:     (I XX). : -, 2000.




29


John Stuart Mill. Omfriheten. C.83.




30


Immanuel Kant. P?dagogik // Kants gesammelte Schriften, . IX,Preu?ischen Akademie derWissenschaften (red.) Berlin/NewYork: De Gruyter, 1902. .463. . Immanuel Kant. Anthropologie inpragmatischer Hinsicht // Kants gesammelte Schriften, . VII, Preu?ischen Akademie derWissenschaften (red.) Berlin/ NewYork: De Gruyter, 1902. .149.




31


. Maurice Merleau-Ponty. Kroppens fenomenologi.   . B.Nake. Oslo: Pax, 1904. .   -.  . -: ; , 1999.




32


G.W.F. Hegel. Enzyklop?die derphilosophischen Wissenschaften I, Werke. .8. Frankfurt a.M.: Suhrkamp, 1986. 410.




33


Jonathan Jacobs. Choosing Character: Responsibility forVirtue andVice. Inthaka/London: Cornell University Press, 2001. .19.




34


  .  //  .   . Geir Kjetsaa. .1. Oslo: Solum Forlag, 1993. .23.




35


 .   20 1693 John Locke. Thecorrespondence ofJohn Locke. .4. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979.




36


James Boswell. TheLife ofJohnson. London: Peguin, 2008. .681 (15 1778).




37


Edward O. Wilson. Consilience: TheUnity ofKnowledge. London: Abacus, 1999. .131.  Edward O. Wilson. OnHuman Nature. Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1995 (1978). .195.




38


James Boswell. TheLife ofJohnson. London: Peguin, 2008. .681 (15 1778).




39


Arthur Schopenhauer. KanMenneskets frie Villie bevises af dets Selvbevidsthed.   Johan Fredrik Bjelke. Oslo: Solum, 1993. .79.




40


     .  John R. Searle. Intentionality: AnEssay inthePhilosophy ofMind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983. .130.




41


Daniel M. Wegner. TheIllusion ofConscious Will. Cambridge MA/London: MITPress, 2002. .317 .




42


Colin Blakemore. TheMind Machine. London: BBC Publications, 1988. .270.




43


       J?rgen Habermas. DasSprachspiel. verantwortlicher Urheberschaft unddasProblem derWillensfreiheit: Wie l?sst sich derepistemische Dualismus miteinenontologischen Monismus vers?hnen // Deutsche Zeitschrift f?rPhilosophie. 5/2006.  . Thomas Nagel. TheView from Nowhere. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986.




44


William James. TheWill toBelieve andOther Essays. NewYork: Dover Publications, 1956. .151. . :  .  . : , 1997.




45


,   ,   .          : Helen Beebee, Christopher Hitchcock, Peter Menzies (red.) TheOxford Handbook onCausation. Oxford/NewYork: Oxford University Press, 2009.




46


Ludwig Wittgenstein. Philosophical Occasions 19121951. Indianpolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, 1993. .42944. . :  .  . : , , 2011.




47


Ludwig Wittgenstein. Philosophical Occasions 19121951. .431.




48


. .433.




49


Ludwig Wittgenstein. Filosof og kultur. Spredte bemerkninger.  . K.O.?m?s. Oslo: Cappelen, 1995. c.80.




50


Nancy Cartwright. HowtheLaws ofPhysics Lie. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983.




51


Denis Noble. TheMusic ofLife. Biology Beyond Genes. Oxford/NewYork: Oxford University Press, 2006. .5.




52


. Helen Stewart. AMetaphysics forFreedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.




53


Svendsen. Mennesket, moralen og genene.




54


Lucrets. Omtingenes natur.   . Trygve Sparre. Oslo: Aschehoug, 1978. .2, . 21693. .  : . Π . : , 2012.




55


Patrick Suppes. TheTranscendental Character ofDeterminism // Midwest Studies inPhilosophy. 18/1993. .254.


