 .    
 


Individuum. 
           ?        .      ,      .       ,    .       :   ,   ,        .     ,   ,   .      ,       :        ,     .  ໠  ,          ,           .

  PDF A4    .





 

 .    



Susana Mons

La zarig?eya de Schr?dinger

Cmo viven y entienden la muerte los animales

Plaza y Valds Editores

 Susana Mons, 2022

Published by arrangements with Plaza y Valds. All rights reserved. Translated by arrangement with Meucci Agency  Milan

  , , 2023

  , , 2023

   , 2023


    .    ,  .


 .        ,     .

 









       :  [1 -  . .].  ,    -    ,       .       .      .      .      .

  .     .   ,        .    , ࠫ໠       .         ?        ?    ,       .      ,   ? , .     ,    .

  ,    , , ,   ,  ,   ?     .   ,   . ,      .   ,         .   .     .          ,         .      ,   ,       ,   ,   ,    .

, ,  .   ,  . , ,    .      .          .        ,     .       .    , ,  ,       ,    .

                 .    ,   ?  ,    .       ,  ,   ,      . , ,        ,  . ,    ,     ?          ,   , ,  ,    ?

      ,        .    ,    ,    ?  , , , ,  ,   :   .

 







  2009 National Geographic  ,      ,   .            ,   ,    .        ,        (. . 1).   :    ,  ,             - ,   ,    .

  ,    ,   :    .    , , ,        .       ,       [2 - IrvineC. Chimpanzees grief caught on camera in Cameroon// The Telegraph. 2009. October 27. URL: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/wildlife/6444909/Chimpanzees-grief-caught-on-camera-in-Cameroon.html (https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/wildlife/6444909/Chimpanzees-grief-caught-on-camera-in-Cameroon.html) ( : 12.05.2021).].     ?  ,      ,    -    ?    ,   ?  ,  ,        ?

   ,        ,     ,      .           ,    .      ,  ,           ,                  .      ,         ,        ,    ,  , , ,      .






. 1.    (The grieving chimps),   



    ,       .       ,  ,    ,          ,   .  ,   ,       :  ,               .          ,       ,  ,      .

         ,  .  ,   ,         ,    ,   ,    .   ,        .    ,      ,    ,      ,   , , ,   .

  ,     ,     .         ,       .     :        ,  ,        .          ,    ,     ,           ,    .

        ,     .         ,              .           ,    ,      ,   ,          ,       .   ,        ,            ,                .

 ,     ,       ,        ,    ,      .      ,     ,       ,    .  ,            ,   .     ?      ,      ,    ,     ?       ,        ?

     .       :      -    . ,  ,   ,      ,      ,      ,    .      .   ,     ,         -.  ,         ,    ;   ,    ,    ,   .   ,        ,              ,         .

  ,   ?        ,   ,    ,      ,        .   ,          ; -                 .         ,                     .    ,     ,   ,  , ,      .

, ,    ,   ,          .    ,     ,              .   , ,    ,  ,    .     !      ,     ,        ,  ,       ,   . ,    ,           .

                    .              ,  ,      ,      .  ,    ,  ,  ,   (, ,   ).      ,    . ,     ,    . ,     , :   . ,  ,       ,     .  ,    .




 1

,    


    , -   .       ,     ,               :      .         ;     .

   ,   ,    ,   .      ,     ,       ,   .  ,     ,      :    ,   ,  . ,    -  .

-          .            ,  ,  ? ,  -     ,    .

      :     .          .          .     ,        ,     .

,       ,    ,     .     ,      .     ,          ,     ,  ,                   .  .   . .    -       .

 ,  ,   ,  .  -      ,      (  ,     ).      ?   ,      ?      .

 ,      ,     ,   ,  ,  ,     .       ,   ,   .  ,     ,     ,   .   .        .

    ,           , ,   ,   . ,  ,   ,   ,         .

    ,     ,      .     ,    . ,    ,              .        .

   ,       .  ,      ,    (  , , ,     ).   ,    ,           .    ,        (,     ,   ,  ,         ).  ,    ,    ,  ,   ,    . , ,              ,  - ,   .     ,         .

         ,         . -,     ,       .    [3 -   : NowbahariE. et al. Ants, Cataglyphis cursor, use precisely directed rescue behavior to free entrapped relatives// PLoS ONE. 2009. 4(8). P.e6573.         , ,   ,         .      ,        ,   ,        ,      .]   ,     ,     .          .   ,      .         ,   .  ,       :    ,       .

-,    ,     .   ,            .    .

   ,     ,       . ,     ,     ,   ,    ,     ,   ,   .        ,      .       ,   .

    .   ,   ,    .        .    ,     .             ,     . -        .             ,      .           [4 - Wilson E. O., Durlach N. I., Roth L.M. Chemical releaser of necrophoric behavior in ants// Psyche: A Journal of Entomology. 1958. 65(4). P.108114.].        ,      .

  ,       ,  ,       . ,   ,   ,    .      ,       ,      ,         .

     .     ,      ,       .  ,      ,    .        ,     .       -     :       ,    (  ,   ).  ,       ,    ,     [5 - Sun Q., Zhou X. Corpse management in social insects// International Journal of Biological Sciences. 2013. 9(3). P.313321.].     :   ,     ,    ,         .        - -   ,  -   ,       ,     [6 - Sun Q., Haynes K. F., Zhou X.2018. Managing the risks and rewards of death in eusocial insects// Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B:Biological Sciences. 373(1754). P.20170258.].

     ,       ,      ?      ,       ,    [7 -          :Mons S. How to tell if animals can understand death// Erkenntnis. 2019. DOI: 10.1007/s10670-019-00187-2  ,  :AllenC. Animal concepts revisited: The use of self-monitoring as an empirical approach// Erkenntnis. 1999. 51(1). P.537544; GlockH.-J. Animals, thoughts and concepts// Synthese. 2000. 123(1). P.3564; Newen A., Bartels A. Animal minds and the possession of concepts// Philosophical Psychology. 2007. 20(3). P.283308.].

       .  ,        蠫.   ,      ,  ,   ,     . ,        ,    ,       :     ?

   1982    ,       [8 - Davidson D. Rational animals// Dialectica. 1982. 36(4). P.317327.].    ,       .    ,         ,      .          .    ,           .   ,  ,  , :  ,    ![9 -      :Malcolm N. Thoughtless brutes// Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association. 1973. 46(September). P.520.]       ,    ,      .      .

  ,  ,     .         ,            .      - ,        .  ,       ,     ,  ,          .   ,     ,          ,  ,   ,     ,     .         ,     ,      .    , ,   ,    ࠫ    , ࠫ     ࠫ,       .    ,      .

  ,  ,       ,      ,       .    ,     ,      ,   :   ,     ,   ,    ,  ..     :  ,     ,  ,      ,  , ..     ,        ,              , ,  ,      ,     .  ,  ,    ,      ,    .

     [10 -       , , :Searle J. R. Animal minds// Midwest Studies In Philosophy. 1994. 19(1). P.206219; Glock. Op. cit.; Andrews K. Interpreting autism: A critique of Davidson on thought and language// Philosophical Psychology. 2002. 15(3). P.317332; Newen, Bartels. Op. cit.; Diguez A. Conceptual thinking in animals: Some reflections on language, concepts, and mind// Mart?nez-Contreras J., Ponce de Len A., eds. Darwins Evolving Legacy. Mxico y Xalapa: Siglo XXI y Universidad Veracruzana. 2011. P.383395; Rowlands M., Mons S. Animals as reflexive thinkers: The aponoian paradigm// Kalof L., ed. The Oxford Handbook of Animal Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P.319341.].   , ,    ,    ,    ,      .       ,        ,      ,    .        , , ,        . ,       ,    ,       ,   , ,       .

    ,      ,       .       ,      ,    ,         ,   .

 ,        ,   . ,   ,             ,       ,       : ,  ,        .

,  ,   ,      ,      ,    ,     ,       ,      .   ,      ,     ,     .

 , ,     ,      ,     ,  ,    ,    .    . ,  ,   ,      ,   ,        .  ,   ,        ,  ,     , ,   ,     ,  ,      . ,  ,  -   , ,  ,     ,      :       ,  ,      , .     ,  ,     ,     ,   .

 ,    ,   ,  .                  ,       .        ,      ,   ,       , ,  .  , , ,   ,     ,    .

       . ,    ,      .     ,       ,  ,    .        ,      ,  .  , ,       ,    , ,  ,    ,   .   , ,      .   ,          ,         .

,      .    ,     .          ?    ;     ,       [11 - Andrews K. Animal cognition// Zalta E. N., ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2012. Winter 2012. URL: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2012/entries/cognitionanimal/ (http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2012/entries/cognition-animal/).].

      ,   X     ,     ,  ,   X,    .  ,        ,       .   ,    ,  ,      ,  .           (    ),  ,          ,  ,  , , ,    ,      ,       .

       :              ,     ,  ,        . ,        ,  ,        ,   ,     .        ,              ,   ,     . ,  ,          ,     .    , ,   ,        ,    ,    , ,     ,  .    ,      ,   .

,             .     .       ,      .   ,       .     .  ,         ,        .      ,   , , ,   ,    ,   ,       ,     .   ,            ,    ,   ,       [12 -              : AndrewsK. The Animal Mind. 2-nd edition. Abingdon & New York: Routledge, 2020.].

 ,        ,    .   ,    ,         . , , ,    ,    ,    .           .  , ,   :    ,      .   ,     ,          .      ,    ,        ,     .

-, ,  - ,       ,     . ,     ,         ,     ,      ,     .   ,         .   ,     ,  , ,   , , , ,     ,     ,     .           ;        .   ,     ,       ,     ,   ,  ,    .

-,        ,     ,      ,  .   ,         ,      ,    .  ,  ,    ,   , ,            .  ,    ,           .      ,   蠫.

          . ,      ,    . ,  ,    ,    ,        ,       .  ,   ,       ,    ,    ,    , ,  . ,                ,      ,     .  ,       ,      ,             ,       .

-,            . , ,     ,  ,   ,       ,              .  ,    (   ,     ),     ,    ,  ,      ,  -  ,     .   ,        ,     ,        . ,  ,     -  ,       .

-,       .  ,   ,                ;           .  ,   ,      ,          . ,      ,  ,  -  .         ,   ,      .    ,      ,  ,      .        ,    .    , ,  :        :      ?          .        .

,      .         ,   ,   ,  , ,        ,      . ,      ,    ,  ,     ,       .       , ,      ,   ,        .  ,   ,      ,     . , ,         c  ,        , ,       ,      .

,       : 1)       ,    ; 2)    ,           ; 3)   ; 4)      ; 5)     .   ,         ,        ,       .               ,       ,    , ,   .

         ,    ,     ,    .          .    ,           ,    .           .            .   ,    ,      . ,       ,    ,        .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/chitat-onlayn/?art=69879601)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


 . .




2


IrvineC. Chimpanzees grief caught on camera in Cameroon// The Telegraph. 2009. October 27. URL: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/wildlife/6444909/Chimpanzees-grief-caught-on-camera-in-Cameroon.html (https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/wildlife/6444909/Chimpanzees-grief-caught-on-camera-in-Cameroon.html) ( : 12.05.2021).




3


  : NowbahariE. et al. Ants, Cataglyphis cursor, use precisely directed rescue behavior to free entrapped relatives// PLoS ONE. 2009. 4(8). P.e6573.         , ,   ,         .      ,        ,   ,        ,      .




4


Wilson E. O., Durlach N. I., Roth L.M. Chemical releaser of necrophoric behavior in ants// Psyche: A Journal of Entomology. 1958. 65(4). P.108114.




5


Sun Q., Zhou X. Corpse management in social insects// International Journal of Biological Sciences. 2013. 9(3). P.313321.




6


Sun Q., Haynes K. F., Zhou X.2018. Managing the risks and rewards of death in eusocial insects// Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B:Biological Sciences. 373(1754). P.20170258.




7


         :Mons S. How to tell if animals can understand death// Erkenntnis. 2019. DOI: 10.1007/s10670-019-00187-2  ,  :AllenC. Animal concepts revisited: The use of self-monitoring as an empirical approach// Erkenntnis. 1999. 51(1). P.537544; GlockH.-J. Animals, thoughts and concepts// Synthese. 2000. 123(1). P.3564; Newen A., Bartels A. Animal minds and the possession of concepts// Philosophical Psychology. 2007. 20(3). P.283308.




8


Davidson D. Rational animals// Dialectica. 1982. 36(4). P.317327.




9


     :Malcolm N. Thoughtless brutes// Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association. 1973. 46(September). P.520.




10


      , , :Searle J. R. Animal minds// Midwest Studies In Philosophy. 1994. 19(1). P.206219; Glock. Op. cit.; Andrews K. Interpreting autism: A critique of Davidson on thought and language// Philosophical Psychology. 2002. 15(3). P.317332; Newen, Bartels. Op. cit.; Diguez A. Conceptual thinking in animals: Some reflections on language, concepts, and mind// Mart?nez-Contreras J., Ponce de Len A., eds. Darwins Evolving Legacy. Mxico y Xalapa: Siglo XXI y Universidad Veracruzana. 2011. P.383395; Rowlands M., Mons S. Animals as reflexive thinkers: The aponoian paradigm// Kalof L., ed. The Oxford Handbook of Animal Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P.319341.




11


Andrews K. Animal cognition// Zalta E. N., ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2012. Winter 2012. URL: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2012/entries/cognitionanimal/ (http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2012/entries/cognition-animal/).




12


             : AndrewsK. The Animal Mind. 2-nd edition. Abingdon & New York: Routledge, 2020.


