     
. . 


           ,        ,     .                    (  )       .





     

Si vis pacem, para bellum

. . 



. . ,2016



     Ridero







     ,    ,    ,    ,      ,     ,   .   ,            ,         .

        ,    ,     ,         .

 ,             ,    ,   , ..            .

ʠ     ,     ,       .

,      ,        , -   ,     .

 ,              , .. 1990- . ,    ,   [1 -       : .., .., ..].       .

      ,    ,            - ,          (). , ,   ,      ,     .

 ,     ,        ( M.,  M.)[2 - Smith M. Humanitarian Intervention: An Overview ofthe Ethical Issues. Ethics and International Affairs, Vol. 12, 1998; Walzer M. Just and Unjust Wars: AMoral Argument with Historical Illustrations. 2nd., Basic Books, New York, 1992.],              (.,  .)[3 - Simma B. NATO, the UN and the Use ofForce: Legal Aspects. European Journal ofInternational Law, Vol. 10,  l, 1999; Charney J. Anticipatory Humanitarian Intervention inKosovo. Vanderbilt Journal ofTransnational Law, 32, 1999.],        ,    ( .)[4 - Hoffman S. The Politics and Ethics ofMilitary Intervention. Survival, Vol. 37, 4, 1996.].

     . , .., . , ..,  ,              XVIXX .[5 - Thomas ѠNew States, Sovereignty and Intervention Gower, 1985, Abiew F ʠThe Evolution ofthe Doctrine and Practce ofHumanitarian Intervention The Hague, 1999, Wheeler N Saving Strangers Humanitarian Intervention inInternational Society Oxford, 2000, MacFarlane S N Intervention m Contemporary World Politics N Y, 2002.]           , ,  -   ,       .

. , . , .    ,       ,    ,       [6 - Humanitarian Intervention and the United Nations/Ed byR  Lillich Charlottesville, 1973, Donnelly J Human Rights, Humanitarian Intervention and American Foreign Policy Law, Morality and Politics // Journal ofInternational Affairs Winter 198437, Ramsbotham ΠSomething Must Be Done Towards an Ethical Framework for Humanitarian Intervention m International Social Conflict Bradford, 1993, Ramsbotham , Woodhouse T Humanitarian Intervention inContemporary Conflict aReconceptualizahon Cambridge, 1996, World Orders inthe Making- Humanitarian Intervention and Beyond / Ed. byJan N Ficterse London, 1998, Humanitarian Intervention Ethical, Legal and Political Dilemmas /Ed b> J L Holzgrcfe and R.Keohane Cambridge, 2003.].      ,         ࠖ         .    -   .   ,      ,         ,         .

..         ,        ,    [7 - Vincent R J Non-intervention and International Order Princeton, 1974, Vincent R J Human Rights and International Relations Princeton, 1986.].       ,     .

 ,            ,   . ,  , ,      ,            [8 - Roberts A. Humanitarian War: Military Intervention and Human Rights // International Affairs. 1993.3.].

            ,    .

              (.., ..)[9 - TesonF.R.Humanitarian Intervention: an Inquiry into Law and Morality. New York: Transnational Publishers, 1996. p. 4; Abiew F.-K. The Evolution ofthe Doctrine and Practice ofHumanitarian Intervention. The Hague, London, Boston: Kluwer Law International, 1999. p. 5; DengF.M.Sovereignty as Responsibility. Washington D.C: Brookings Institution Press, 1996.].            ( A.,  .,  .)[10 - Cassese A. Ex iniura ius oritur: Are We Moving Towards International Legitimation ofForcible Humanitarian Countermeasures inthe World Community?. The European Journal ofInternational Law, 10, 1999; Momtaz D. Lintervention dhumanite de IOTAN au Kosovo et la regie du non-recours ala force. Revue international de la Croix-Rouge, 837, 31mars 2000;  , Long S. Humanitarian Intervention: ANew Role for the United States?. International Peacekeeping, 2, 1995.]. ʠ   ,  ,    ,                   .

          ,            ,      .

,            . ,               (     ,   ,       ).

  ,   .     ,           : 1)       ; 2)       ; 3)         [11 - Kune V. Humanitarian Intervention inInternational Law // European Journal ofInternational Law. 1999.4.].

 ,     ,                  ,       .

      ࠖ    .                   ,        (Greenwood Ch.)[12 - Greenwood Ch. Is there aRight ofHumanitarian Intervention? // The World Today. 1993.2.].

      ,     - ,  ,  ..        ,        ,       (Falk Richard A.)[13 - Falk Richard A. Intervention Revisited Hard Choices and Tragic Dilemmas / The Nation. 1993. 20December.].

      ,  ,  ,           ,       .

                ,      ,            XX.

    ..  :  [14 - .. :  . ., 2000.],             .  ,  ,  ,  ,           ,     .

    ..,    -         (2000.)[15 - ..-        .., 2000.] 蠫      (2000.)[16 - ..     .., 2000.].             ,        .       .  , .. ,           ,      .

           ...     ,    ,           :    [17 - ..        .    : . . . . ., 1998.].      ,       ,    .

              . ,     [18 - ..    . ., 1998.] ..            ,       ,   ,    ,               .

           .       :   [19 -  :    /  ... ., 1999.] 蠫:   [20 - :    /  ... ., 1999.].           ,        ,       ,     .

          ,       -        ,      .

..        :  [21 - ..        : . . . . , 2003.],  ..           90- . XX [22 - ..          90- . XX : . . . . . . .., 2005.]      .                   .

          ...       [23 - ..     //  . 1999. 11. . 104112]    -       ,      ,   ,        .    ..,  ,        .

            -   ,     :   (. , . , . )[24 - .., .., ..  : -  . ., 2001.].   ,       ,         ,    .     ,   .. ...

                 .

 ,    ,     ,   ,:

-,            ,   .

-,             XVIXX .,     .

-,       ,         .

    ,     ,    -, , ,     ,         .  ,  ,        ,      ,      , ,  ,         XXI .

   ,      XX .  XXI .         ,             (XVIXVII .).

          .         :

1)      ;

2)   -         ;

3)        ;

4)      XX.;

5)        XXI.;

6)        .

   - ,     ()   ,         ,      [25 -  1973   // UN Doc. S/Res/1973(2011) // http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N11/268/41/PDF/N1126841.pdf?Open Element (  11.05.2013);     687//  . S/Res/1441(2003);     377  . // http://www.un.org/Depts/dhl/landmark/pdf/ares377r.pdf (  10.01.2014);     1441// UN Doc. S/Res/1970(2011) // http://www.docme.ru/doc/16923/rezolyuciya-oon-1970 (  04.05.2013);  1634  1633(2008)      // http://www.coe.int/t/r/parliamentary_assembly/%5Brussian_documents%5D/%5B2009%5D/%5BJan2009%5D/Res1647_rus.asp) (  10.03.2014).];    ,      [26 - Annan, Kofi A. The Question ofIntervention: Statements bythe Secretary General. New York: United Nations, 1999;     31.01.1992.     //   A/47/277-S/24111;     25.01.1995.     , . 23//   /50/60-S/1995/1.];     ,     [27 - NATO Press Release (1999) 040// www.nato.int/docu/pr/1999/p99-040e.htm (  19.04.2013);   .  //   /55/305 S/2000/209.].

        [28 -   23 1995. 93- Π                (  7 2011.) //    . 1995. 26. . 2401.]  ,          [29 -    12.05.2009537Π     2020 //   . 2009. 20. . 2444;      (.   12.02.2013) //    (www.kremlin.ru  11.01.2014);       21.06.19941361            -  //     . 1994. 6;      (.   12.02.2013) //    (www.kremlin.ru  11.01.2014).].

         [30 -       // http://ria.ru/world/20110303/341739540.html (  19.05.2013);     // http://www.nirsi.ru/125 (  11.04.2014);  .       // http://top.rbc.ru/politics/19/06/2013/862328.shtml. (  11.04.2014);          // http://rus.delfi.ee/daily/abroad/ssha-prizyvayut-rf-otmenit-mery-po-podderzhke-abhazii-i-yuzhnoj-osetii.d?id=18712153) (  10.03.2014);       ..    // http://interaffairs.ru/read.php?item=8760 (  11.01.2014).],           .




 1.    ()   





1.1.     


 ,      ,      .  XX  XXI .      ,       .

    (peace-making)   -     ,   ,  ,    ,      (, ,  .),  ,        ,   ,     ,      [31 - . , .., , .., , ..  : -   / .., .., ... ., 2001. . 96.         -        ,  ,    .       -  . ,   19.06.1992.,         ,       (        19.06.1992. //   .   . ., 1994).].

 ,      (),       ,           ( VIII  ),        [32 - .].

   -           .

          ,     .     ,       (,       2000.[33 -      . ,      , .:   /55/305 S/2000/209.],       ,     :    2004.[34 - .:   /59/565. ,   ,   . .]).

  ,         2000.,        ,     ;  ; [35 - . . 10:   /55/305 S/2000/209.].   ,     ,  ,       ,        [36 -  ,                 ,      .     ,  ,  ,  ,          .    ,    堖   蠫.     ,         (  VII  ),    (.:     25.01.1995.     , . 23:   /50/60-S/1995/1).].

       ,   2004.       ,     ( ) ,    . ,        [37 - . . 227:   /59/565(  10.01.2014).],    ,     [38 - . . 216, .].

  ,       ,  ,    ,    .             ͠.       (1992.)[39 - http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N92/289/17/IMG/N9228917.pdf?OpenElement (  10.01.2014).].          , : 1)  [40 -     ,       ,   .      ,      VI  :  , , , ,    .   ,      ,     (, ,  .),    (.    31.01.1992.    , . 20:   A/47/277-S/24111).]; 2)  [41 -    (preventive diplomacy)       ,            ,          ,   .       : 1)   (  ,        ,  ,  ,   ); 2)     (  ()             ,  ,   ),            ,    .]; 3)  [42 -       ( )    , -    ,     ,      ,     (.: , ..-    . /... ., 1997. .21).]; 4)  [43 -         (. 1 )   .        maintain (    ),  wahrung ( ),           ,     ,    .].           , : ,   [44 -      : .:     25.01.1995.     , . 23:   /50/60-S/1995/1.].

       ,    (peace-keeping)[45 - .     31.01.1992.    , . 20:   A/47/277-S/24111.          , . 12.  ,   peacekeeping ( )     ,                 ,       .          ,       (.: Verdross A., Simma . Universelles VOlkerrecht. Theorie und Praxis. Dritte Auflage. Berlin, 1984. S. 152- 153).].    ,       ,        ,  ,      ,         [46 - , ..   / .. //  . 1998. 3. .5.].  ,    ,                   [47 - .: , .., , :  XX . /...  , 2002. .297.],              [48 -  ,    (      ) ,        ,    ,     (.: http://www.un.org/russian/peace/Dko/Deaceque.htm (  10.01.2014).]. (.: 1)

  ,    ,  ,        .       ,             [49 -      :       ,  ,     (   ࠖ   );          ;      ;         ,   ;        ;        ;      ;   -        ;  ,   .].

     ,      ,   ,      ,   .          ,      .  ,   ,     ,           .             ,      .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/v-d-goncharenko/institut-gumanitarnogo-vmeshatelstva-v-sovremennyh-mezhdunarodnyh-otnosheniyah/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


      : .., .., ..




2


Smith M. Humanitarian Intervention: An Overview ofthe Ethical Issues. Ethics and International Affairs, Vol. 12, 1998; Walzer M. Just and Unjust Wars: AMoral Argument with Historical Illustrations. 2nd., Basic Books, New York, 1992.




3


Simma B. NATO, the UN and the Use ofForce: Legal Aspects. European Journal ofInternational Law, Vol. 10,  l, 1999; Charney J. Anticipatory Humanitarian Intervention inKosovo. Vanderbilt Journal ofTransnational Law, 32, 1999.




4


Hoffman S. The Politics and Ethics ofMilitary Intervention. Survival, Vol. 37, 4, 1996.




5


Thomas ѠNew States, Sovereignty and Intervention Gower, 1985, Abiew F ʠThe Evolution ofthe Doctrine and Practce ofHumanitarian Intervention The Hague, 1999, Wheeler N Saving Strangers Humanitarian Intervention inInternational Society Oxford, 2000, MacFarlane S N Intervention m Contemporary World Politics N Y, 2002.




6


Humanitarian Intervention and the United Nations/Ed byR  Lillich Charlottesville, 1973, Donnelly J Human Rights, Humanitarian Intervention and American Foreign Policy Law, Morality and Politics // Journal ofInternational Affairs Winter 198437, Ramsbotham ΠSomething Must Be Done Towards an Ethical Framework for Humanitarian Intervention m International Social Conflict Bradford, 1993, Ramsbotham , Woodhouse T Humanitarian Intervention inContemporary Conflict aReconceptualizahon Cambridge, 1996, World Orders inthe Making- Humanitarian Intervention and Beyond / Ed. byJan N Ficterse London, 1998, Humanitarian Intervention Ethical, Legal and Political Dilemmas /Ed b> J L Holzgrcfe and R.Keohane Cambridge, 2003.




7


Vincent R J Non-intervention and International Order Princeton, 1974, Vincent R J Human Rights and International Relations Princeton, 1986.




8


Roberts A. Humanitarian War: Military Intervention and Human Rights // International Affairs. 1993.3.




9


TesonF.R.Humanitarian Intervention: an Inquiry into Law and Morality. New York: Transnational Publishers, 1996. p. 4; Abiew F.-K. The Evolution ofthe Doctrine and Practice ofHumanitarian Intervention. The Hague, London, Boston: Kluwer Law International, 1999. p. 5; DengF.M.Sovereignty as Responsibility. Washington D.C: Brookings Institution Press, 1996.




10


Cassese A. Ex iniura ius oritur: Are We Moving Towards International Legitimation ofForcible Humanitarian Countermeasures inthe World Community?. The European Journal ofInternational Law, 10, 1999; Momtaz D. Lintervention dhumanite de IOTAN au Kosovo et la regie du non-recours ala force. Revue international de la Croix-Rouge, 837, 31mars 2000;  , Long S. Humanitarian Intervention: ANew Role for the United States?. International Peacekeeping, 2, 1995.




11


Kune V. Humanitarian Intervention inInternational Law // European Journal ofInternational Law. 1999.4.




12


Greenwood Ch. Is there aRight ofHumanitarian Intervention? // The World Today. 1993.2.




13


Falk Richard A. Intervention Revisited Hard Choices and Tragic Dilemmas / The Nation. 1993. 20December.




14


.. :  . ., 2000.




15


..-        .., 2000.




16


..     .., 2000.




17


..        .    : . . . . ., 1998.




18


..    . ., 1998.




19


 :    /  ... ., 1999.




20


:    /  ... ., 1999.




21


..        : . . . . , 2003.




22


..          90- . XX : . . . . . . .., 2005.




23


..     //  . 1999. 11. . 104112




24


.., .., ..  : -  . ., 2001.




25


 1973   // UN Doc. S/Res/1973(2011) // http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N11/268/41/PDF/N1126841.pdf?Open Element (  11.05.2013);     687//  . S/Res/1441(2003);     377  . // http://www.un.org/Depts/dhl/landmark/pdf/ares377r.pdf (  10.01.2014);     1441// UN Doc. S/Res/1970(2011) // http://www.docme.ru/doc/16923/rezolyuciya-oon-1970 (  04.05.2013);  1634  1633(2008)      // http://www.coe.int/t/r/parliamentary_assembly/%5Brussian_documents%5D/%5B2009%5D/%5BJan2009%5D/Res1647_rus.asp) (  10.03.2014).




26


Annan, Kofi A. The Question ofIntervention: Statements bythe Secretary General. New York: United Nations, 1999;     31.01.1992.     //   A/47/277-S/24111;     25.01.1995.     , . 23//   /50/60-S/1995/1.




27


NATO Press Release (1999) 040// www.nato.int/docu/pr/1999/p99-040e.htm (  19.04.2013);   .  //   /55/305 S/2000/209.




28


  23 1995. 93- Π                (  7 2011.) //    . 1995. 26. . 2401.




29


   12.05.2009537Π     2020 //   . 2009. 20. . 2444;      (.   12.02.2013) //    (www.kremlin.ru  11.01.2014);       21.06.19941361            -  //     . 1994. 6;      (.   12.02.2013) //    (www.kremlin.ru  11.01.2014).




30


      // http://ria.ru/world/20110303/341739540.html (  19.05.2013);     // http://www.nirsi.ru/125 (  11.04.2014);  .       // http://top.rbc.ru/politics/19/06/2013/862328.shtml. (  11.04.2014);          // http://rus.delfi.ee/daily/abroad/ssha-prizyvayut-rf-otmenit-mery-po-podderzhke-abhazii-i-yuzhnoj-osetii.d?id=18712153) (  10.03.2014);       ..    // http://interaffairs.ru/read.php?item=8760 (  11.01.2014).




31


. , .., , .., , ..  : -   / .., .., ... ., 2001. . 96.         -        ,  ,    .       -  . ,   19.06.1992.,         ,       (        19.06.1992. //   .   . ., 1994).




32


.




33


     . ,      , .:   /55/305 S/2000/209.




34


.:   /59/565. ,   ,   . .




35


. . 10:   /55/305 S/2000/209.




36


 ,                 ,      .     ,  ,  ,  ,          .    ,    堖   蠫.     ,         (  VII  ),    (.:     25.01.1995.     , . 23:   /50/60-S/1995/1).




37


. . 227:   /59/565(  10.01.2014).




38


. . 216, .




39


http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N92/289/17/IMG/N9228917.pdf?OpenElement (  10.01.2014).




40


    ,       ,   .      ,      VI  :  , , , ,    .   ,      ,     (, ,  .),    (.    31.01.1992.    , . 20:   A/47/277-S/24111).




41


   (preventive diplomacy)       ,            ,          ,   .       : 1)   (  ,        ,  ,  ,   ); 2)     (  ()             ,  ,   ),            ,    .




42


      ( )    , -    ,     ,      ,     (.: , ..-    . /... ., 1997. .21).




43


        (. 1 )   .        maintain (    ),  wahrung ( ),           ,     ,    .




44


     : .:     25.01.1995.     , . 23:   /50/60-S/1995/1.




45


.     31.01.1992.    , . 20:   A/47/277-S/24111.          , . 12.  ,   peacekeeping ( )     ,                 ,       .          ,       (.: Verdross A., Simma . Universelles VOlkerrecht. Theorie und Praxis. Dritte Auflage. Berlin, 1984. S. 152- 153).




46


, ..   / .. //  . 1998. 3. .5.




47


.: , .., , :  XX . /...  , 2002. .297.




48


 ,    (      ) ,        ,    ,     (.: http://www.un.org/russian/peace/Dko/Deaceque.htm (  10.01.2014).




49


     :       ,  ,     (   ࠖ   );          ;      ;         ,   ;        ;        ;      ;   -        ;  ,   .


