 
 


            ,       - ,      ,     .                .            ,   ,   .





 



 


   ,  ,   ,    ,   



 ,2023



ISBN978-5-0060-8940-2

     Ridero


:

 ,           ;

 ,  ,  ,       ;

   .



                 .







    ,     (  )      ,    ..      ,        ,      .           , , , :     ..       .           . ʠ, 80-      ,        ,           ,            .

    ,    ,  , ,   . ,   : ,  -  !

   ,       -     :  ,        .    ?    ? .    ,       .       .         ,  ,     . ,      XXI      ,  80-   ,    ...   ,   , , :   ,  ,   .

           .  ,   ,  , ,  () .   , ,   ⠫   .

   ,   .       ,  /  /     .    :         ,  ,  .               .  ,     ,  -     ,  .  .

 .  ()          .   :  ,  , , , ,  , .   ,  ,     ,  ,  .

  - , :  ,   ,  - ?  -,  ,  ,    , ,  ,   .    ,  :       ,    ,   . , , , , , ,  ,  ,   ,  , - .    -   ,  ,    .

   ,     .          :     ,         ,       ,           ,    ,           ,     .      ,     ,     - ,      .

   ,         ⠫ 蠫    .   ,   ,         .

,       ,   , ,  .   蠖    :  ,   ,   ,  .    ࠖ      .   ,  .

,  ,      . ,   ,         . ,            ,      , ,  .   ,     :  -   , -    , -    -.



 ,
 Ridero




,    ?


     2014,   ,      [1 - ..    .  1. .: CORVUS, 2018. 114.],           ( ..[2 -    [ ]. URL: https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/__ ( : 10.10.2023).]).        ,  堖 .

              .  ,     ..       .           . ʠ, 80-      ,        ,           ,            .

    2014     .          .             [3 -  .,  .,  .  :       . [. .]:  , 2022. 282.]    ,   ,    .

,  ()  ,  ,        ()         .     ,           ,  ,        .      .

           . ,   ,      .  , -, ,    ,  , . Ƞ        .      ,   ,   ,  .

-,    ,          .     , .               .

Ƞ,      .              .

 ,          堖   ,       ,  ,     [4 - .., ..  蠖  XXI  //  . 2. 2018, . 2. . 113127.].

         ⻠   ,           ,      ,   .     ,        ,         ,    [5 -  .,  .            //     . : , . 4(51). 2022. . 1724.].    ,      : ,     ; ,      ; , , ,      (      ).

     ,       ,        .

    .  ,   ,    , .       2,5  ,       ,    ,   .            .  XXI        ,   .

        ,  ,  .               .

 ,      ,   ,  2023.




 


 



  堖    ,   .     ,  ,     [6 - . :  .   .          / . ... .: ,  , 2019. .17.].



  (Peter Drucker),    ,      XX

     .  ,     ,           [7 -  .  :   ,      / [. .]. .: , 2016. .18.].



  (Amy Edmondson),
 
,   

6   [8 - Siang S. The 6Types ofQuestions Great Leaders Ask, Leading with Questions [website]. Publ. October 2, 2023. Available at: https://leadingwithquestions.com/leadership/the-6-types-of-questions-great-leaders-ask-2/ (accessed 10.10.2023). . ...]



   (Sanyin Siang),    / ,     Fuqua / Coach K   (Duke),     (Pratt School ofEngineering),   The Launch Book.



 ,       ,      ?   ,        :    Fortune 100  -.  ,     ,  ,     ,      . ,     .   ,         .       ,  ,      .  ,    ,   ,    ,   .  ,      ,     ,     ,    .



    , :

1.   , .

2.   .

3.     ,  .

4.  .

5.       .

6.    .

  



 蠖   (Bobb Biehl), , 1976    500   ().



     ( 堗Asking Profound Questions),  :          .



ʠ    :

 ;

  ;

  ;

  (. ...);

 ;

  .

    :

 ;

 ;

  ;

   (. ...);

  ;

  [9 - . :  .      / . .... : , 2015. .12.].

  ,   



 蠖   (Marilee Adams),,  Inquiry Institute ().



  ,     ,   ,  :     .

  ( 堖 Change Your Questions, Change Your Life)       .    ,   ,    ,   ,   :   ? ( );   ? ( );    ? (, ).          :  ?   ?  ?    ?    ?   ,  ?    ?   ?[10 - Inquiry Institute [website]. Available at: https://inquiryinstitute.com/ (accessed 10.10.2023). . ...]

 .     [11 - Alvesson M., Spicer A. The Stupidity Paradox: The Power and Pitfalls ofFunctional Stupidity at Work. IPS Profile Books, 2017. 288p.]



 蠖   (M. Alvesson),      ()   (A. Spicer),          .



       ,   .    ,      .   ,      ,   .

      ,       .

  ( 堖 The Stupidity Paradox: The Power and Pitfalls ofFunctional Stupidity at work)  :           ,   ?  :      ,   Fachidioten (.  ) ,    .

   ,   ,      ,     , - .

              -   .

      ,     .   : ?    젖 .

           .  :       ; : ?  ?   ?

 :   ,     



 蠖   (Paul Cherry),         .



 ( 堖 Questions that Sell. The Powerful Process for Discovering what Your Customer Wants)   ,            .

             .

    ,       .

    , :    ;     ;     ;           ;      ; ,      ,     ;      ,    [12 -  .  :   ,      / . . 2- ., . .:  , 2022. . 1617.].

  Β



   ,  ,   .



Ϋ         .  ,     :     ?..  ,       ? 蠫     ?[13 - .:  .   ,  ,    / . ... .:  , 2018. .265.].



   .   ,     ,  ,        . Ƞ     .  ,     ,     ,          Β ,        :   ?       ?     ?[14 - .. 265266.]

  :   



 蠖   (Edgar H. Schein),    (1928 2023).



   ( 堖 Humble Inquiry. The Gentle Art ofAsking Instead ofTelling)        .  ,        ,     :             ,    .    ,      [15 -  .   :    / . ... .: , , , 2015. . 1011.].

        ,          :

    -,       ?    ?   ,  ?.       ,     :   ?   ? Ѡ    ,    ?[16 - ..162.].

 :       -,    ?



 蠖   (Rob Fitzpatrick) ,  Founder Centric.



  ( 堖 The Mom Test: How toTalk toCustomers & Learn IF Everyone is Lying toYou)     ,    .  :  ,            [17 -  .  :       -,    ? /. ... .:  , 2017. .57.].

    ?    ,     .  ,           [18 - ..58.].

   :    ,     ,    .   ,    蠫   ,  !   ,   . Ƞ   ,  ,    ,      ,   ;        [19 - .. 5775.].

(Bob Tiede)



 11   LeadingWithQuestions.com,   ,     190,   Great Leaders ASK Questions, Little Book ofBig Leading With Questions Quotes, 262Questions Paul the Apostle ofChrist Asked.



  :       ,   ,    !.

    :      ( 堖 Leading with Questions: How Leaders Discover Powerful Answers)[20 -     .  (Michael J. Marquardt).]        .   ,          ,         .         : (1)   , (2)   , (3)   , (4)   , (5)   , (6)     (7)   ,    .     ,    ,   ,     ,    .

         蠖 .

    



 蠖     (John C. Maxwell) ,         .



   ( 堖 Good Leaders Ask Great Questions: Your Foundation for Successful Leadership)  ,      ,    , :

1.     ,  .

2.      .

3.       .

4.   .

5.     .

6.     .

7.     .

8.   [21 -  .      / . .... : , 2015. . 1023.].

    ,    ,         .  ,         ,         .          ,     ,     .

Boston Consulting Group



      Boston Consulting Group,   -  ,  Google, IBM, Ford Motor Company,  .



    , ,       , ,      ,     . ,   BIC             ?, , ,     ,  ,     . , ,   ,  ,     , :      BIC?,        ,    BIC, ,          , ,      ?.        , , ,   ,       ,         (,  , ) ,       [22 -  . ,  .    / . ... .: , 2019. . 402403.].

IDEO



-   , , ,  .  1991.     -.



   ࠖ   . , ,    - IDEO         ,    :

     ,    ?

     ?

      ?

        ?

       ?

        ?

    ?

    ?[23 - See: Big Questions: How were tackling some ofthe most complex global challenges, IDEO [website]. Available at: https://www.ideo.com/questions (accessed 10.10.2023).]







 



  

Ƞ,  ,

Ƞ  

  .??

 

,     ,  ;       .

 ,    ,  ,     [24 - . :   / [...]. .:  , 2009. .203.].



  , 

 



    (Ian Leslie) ,         ,   ,     ,   蠫[25 - Leslie I. Curious: The desire toknow and why your future depends on it. Quercus Books, 2014. 310p.].

          .

 ()     :   (,  ,  ),      ,  ,   ,     .      ,  , , -,     ( ),   ,   ; -,        ,      ,    [26 - ..ʠ   //  . 2. 2018. . 7889.].

 



   - ,   ,    , 4050-  XII .    - , ,  ,      [27 - ..  //    : [4.] /. . , - . . ( ); . ...[.]. .: , 19872017. . 1: XI   XIV . /..., .., 1987. . 215217.].

       . ,  4   ,   .       .   33  .   55     .     .   65 ,   ,    .  , ,  .   69  ,       [28 - ..// . ., 2014. . XXXIV:    , ,  . . 167170.].

 .     



    .     ,    ,   .



    ,   .  ,  , ࠫ ,   ,    ,   , ,  [29 -  .,  .  .      / . ... .: Evidentis, 2006. .22.].

   :

      ,  ,  ;

        ;

     [30 - ..26.].

 



   (JamesF.T.Bugental)   ,  -   (19152008).



  ( 堖 The Art ofPsychotherapist)   :



   -   ,      :    ?    ,   ?      : ,     ,    ,   ,       .    ,  ,   ,  ,   ,  , ,   ,  ,   .       ,    ,      ,     [31 -  .  . .:  , 2015. .14.].

 .. (Lau JoeY.F.)



-  .



        ,             ,       .      .

1.   ?

    ?       ?      ?      ?

2.      ?

 ,    .     .     .     ?

3.     ?

   ?     ?  ?  ?   -  ?

4.     ?

     ?    ,    ?[32 -  .     . .: , 2017. .20.]

  (Mortari Luigina)



  ,     ().



 堖       ,         .

,   蠖 ,  ࠖ    [33 -  .  . .: , 2009. .35.].

  (Mj?set Christer)



 .



     TED[34 - 4questions you should always ask your doctor, TED. Available at: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=949yOxz_x80 (accessed 10.10.2023).],        ,        ,       .

    ,      .  ,        ,  ,      -  ,      . , , : ,   ?

 ,      ,     ,  ,     . ,   ,     : ,   .

     ,       . ,  30%       .   ,  ,              .

  ,       ,  ,    .

           ,       :

1.   ?

2.  ?

3.    ?

4.  ,   ?

      ,     , ,   ,      .

  



 蠖  ࠖ   .



     ,          ,   .

       ?       ?     ,     ?  - , ?

(  ,      .       ,    .     - .  ,   . ,   , ,    .  :   ,   ,   ,    )[35 -  .    / . ... .: -, 2009. .107.].

  (Pennie Brian)



  ,         ,    .



  ,   ,      , .  ,     ,    ,  , - ,      ,    .    8 ,      . Ƞ ,     [36 - 8Great Questions You Should Occasionally Ask Yourself, Medium [website]. Available at: https://medium.com/mind-cafe/8-great-questions-you-should-occasionally-ask-yourself-ebc929094777 (accessed 10.10.2023).].

1.        ?

2.    ?

3.     ?

4. Π   ?

5.     -,     ?

6.    ?

7.     ,     ?

8.   ,   ?

  



   ,    (19291994).  - ,     ,    .



  ,         ,      ?   ?  ?         ?.  ,            ,   ,    ,  ,   , [37 -    : [..] /  .  //   .  ...: []. URL: https://www.fondgp.ru/old/gp/archive/texts/2.html ( : 10.10.2023).].







 



     - ,     .      ,        [38 - . :   / [...]. .:  , 2009. .57.].



..,   

 ,  .     ,     .    ,     .      ,    [39 -  [ ]. URL: https://aphorism.ru/comments/mi1pbd9cp4.html ( : 10.10.2023).].



 ,  

  ,  ,   



 蠖   (Frank Sesno) ,  , .



    ( 堖 Ask More: The Power ofQuestions toOpen Doors, Uncover Solutions, and Spark Change),   ,   :      ,      ,       ?[40 -  .   ,  ,    / . ... .:  , 2018. .276.]

Ƞ:      .   ,   [41 - .].

        :     .   ,        [42 - .].

        ,   ,   [43 - ..124.].

   .        



 2016           [44 - Securing democracy through education. The development ofareference framework ofcompetences for democratic culture. Final declaration ofCouncil ofEurope Standing Conference ofMinisters ofEducation. Available at: https://clck.ru/hptLB (accessed 10.10.2023).].       : ,  ,  ,     [45 - .:    .         /  , 2017. . 11[ c]. URL: https://clck.ru/hptby( : 10.10.2023).].

     ⠖ ,  ,    [46 - .: .].           ()  : ,  .     90  ,    :  ,    [47 - .: . .20.].         1506  ,   [48 -      .   . . 2    . :  , 2018. .41.],  1525       ,       ,   ,[49 - .: . .42.]  1719         ,         [50 - .: . .45.].  ,       , 2018         ,   ,       [51 -         ,       .].

 .      [52 -  .  / . .... : , 2014. 304.]



 蠖   (Warren Berger)   .



   ( 堖 AMore Beautiful Question: the Power ofInquiry toSpark Breakthrough Ideas)   , ,  ?

, , , ,  , , , , ,  , ,  ,  , , , .



      ,        -   .  ,  ,    .

     :

   ,   ?

,         ?

     ?

     ,  ,      ,   - [53 - ..14.].

 ?.     



 蠖   (Simon Sinek)     ,     ? 蠫  ,  -3 TED talks.



  ( 堖 Start with Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone toTake Action)  ,      ,  ?.  ,  ,             ,   :    ,   ?,      ,    ,     ;    ,    ?       -;    ,    ?,         .      ,   ,      - [54 -  .  ?:      / . ... .: , 2018. . 4562.].

,   ? Ƞ   



 蠖   (James E. Ryan)     .



  ( 堗Wait, What? and Lifes Other Essential Questions)    ,      :

1. ,   ?   ,       .

2.   ?.. , , ?..       .

3.   ?.. (,  /  /   )    ,    .

4.    ?      ,      .

5.  - ?    ,   , ,  ,     .

6.        ?  ,      [55 - .:  . ,   ? Ƞ    / . ... M.: , , , 2017. 130c.].





      (18281919).



         1 1812.,     :

  ,          .     ,          .     ,      , ,        .    :          ?    .   ,      .    .    .      ,    :    .   .    !   ,           .   ,  ,        . (     .)    ,    . ,       ,   .  :   .     ,  ,     ?        . (    .)[56 - .. .  4. . 3. .: , 2010. .229.]







 



   ,      ,   .        ,   ,         .    ,        ,    ,         ,            [57 - ... .:  (), 1947. .75.].



..,  

  



 蠖          -    .



 ,        ,       .  ,   ,     ,     ,   .   ,         ,     .

,        ,  ,    .     ,   ,  ,      .    ,    .   [58 - ..  . .: - ., -, 1991. .49.].

      [59 - .. :   - . .: , 1990. 118.],   ,  - :    ;    ;     .       ,  ,  (  )[60 -        (M. I. A. N.Prior) 1955.].

          :

  ,          ()   .                   [61 - .. /   :   .     .    /  ..., ... .:   ̻, 2015. C.92.].

 .   ,  .  



 蠖   (Michel Foucault)  ,    (19261984).     ,         .



  ,     , ,   ,     ,    ,     ,  ,    ,    ,    (      ),      (     )[62 -  .  .   ,  .    / ., . ... .: : .  , 1996. .323.].

   



 蠖  ⠖  ,   ,   .



     ,   -        ,            .

      ,     .      ,  ,        .  ,      ,         [63 - ..   . : , 1972. .62.].

      ,    ,

      .        ,       [64 -   . : , 1987. .3.].

  



  ,      .



堖   ,  ,  . 堖     




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/chitat-onlayn/?art=70015285)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


..    .  1. .: CORVUS, 2018. 114.




2


   [ ]. URL: https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/__ ( : 10.10.2023).




3


 .,  .,  .  :       . [. .]:  , 2022. 282.




4


.., ..  蠖  XXI  //  . 2. 2018, . 2. . 113127.




5


 .,  .            //     . : , . 4(51). 2022. . 1724.




6


. :  .   .          / . ... .: ,  , 2019. .17.




7


 .  :   ,      / [. .]. .: , 2016. .18.




8


Siang S. The 6Types ofQuestions Great Leaders Ask, Leading with Questions [website]. Publ. October 2, 2023. Available at: https://leadingwithquestions.com/leadership/the-6-types-of-questions-great-leaders-ask-2/ (accessed 10.10.2023). . ...




9


. :  .      / . .... : , 2015. .12.




10


Inquiry Institute [website]. Available at: https://inquiryinstitute.com/ (accessed 10.10.2023). . ...




11


Alvesson M., Spicer A. The Stupidity Paradox: The Power and Pitfalls ofFunctional Stupidity at Work. IPS Profile Books, 2017. 288p.




12


 .  :   ,      / . . 2- ., . .:  , 2022. . 1617.




13


.:  .   ,  ,    / . ... .:  , 2018. .265.




14


.. 265266.




15


 .   :    / . ... .: , , , 2015. . 1011.




16


..162.




17


 .  :       -,    ? /. ... .:  , 2017. .57.




18


..58.




19


.. 5775.




20


    .  (Michael J. Marquardt).




21


 .      / . .... : , 2015. . 1023.




22


 . ,  .    / . ... .: , 2019. . 402403.




23


See: Big Questions: How were tackling some ofthe most complex global challenges, IDEO [website]. Available at: https://www.ideo.com/questions (accessed 10.10.2023).




24


. :   / [...]. .:  , 2009. .203.




25


Leslie I. Curious: The desire toknow and why your future depends on it. Quercus Books, 2014. 310p.




26


..ʠ   //  . 2. 2018. . 7889.




27


..  //    : [4.] /. . , - . . ( ); . ...[.]. .: , 19872017. . 1: XI   XIV . /..., .., 1987. . 215217.




28


..// . ., 2014. . XXXIV:    , ,  . . 167170.




29


 .,  .  .      / . ... .: Evidentis, 2006. .22.




30


..26.




31


 .  . .:  , 2015. .14.




32


 .     . .: , 2017. .20.




33


 .  . .: , 2009. .35.




34


4questions you should always ask your doctor, TED. Available at: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=949yOxz_x80 (accessed 10.10.2023).




35


 .    / . ... .: -, 2009. .107.




36


8Great Questions You Should Occasionally Ask Yourself, Medium [website]. Available at: https://medium.com/mind-cafe/8-great-questions-you-should-occasionally-ask-yourself-ebc929094777 (accessed 10.10.2023).




37


   : [..] /  .  //   .  ...: []. URL: https://www.fondgp.ru/old/gp/archive/texts/2.html ( : 10.10.2023).




38


. :   / [...]. .:  , 2009. .57.




39


 [ ]. URL: https://aphorism.ru/comments/mi1pbd9cp4.html ( : 10.10.2023).




40


 .   ,  ,    / . ... .:  , 2018. .276.




41


.




42


.




43


..124.




44


Securing democracy through education. The development ofareference framework ofcompetences for democratic culture. Final declaration ofCouncil ofEurope Standing Conference ofMinisters ofEducation. Available at: https://clck.ru/hptLB (accessed 10.10.2023).




45


.:    .         /  , 2017. . 11[ c]. URL: https://clck.ru/hptby( : 10.10.2023).




46


.: .




47


.: . .20.




48


     .   . . 2    . :  , 2018. .41.




49


.: . .42.




50


.: . .45.




51


        ,       .




52


 .  / . .... : , 2014. 304.




53


..14.




54


 .  ?:      / . ... .: , 2018. . 4562.




55


.:  . ,   ? Ƞ    / . ... M.: , , , 2017. 130c.




56


.. .  4. . 3. .: , 2010. .229.




57


... .:  (), 1947. .75.




58


..  . .: - ., -, 1991. .49.




59


.. :   - . .: , 1990. 118.




60


       (M. I. A. N.Prior) 1955.




61


.. /   :   .     .    /  ..., ... .:   ̻, 2015. C.92.




62


 .  .   ,  .    / ., . ... .: : .  , 1996. .323.




63


..   . : , 1972. .62.




64


  . : , 1987. .3.


