 ,      . 
  


 , , , ,         .                 , , ,     ,  ,  -     ,     ,    .





 

 ,      . 


 ,       ,     ,           .    .



         



           



      :

. .  ( ), . .  (  ),

A. . , . . , . .  (  ),

B. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . , C. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , B. . , . . , . . , . . , . .  (  ).

 :

. .  ( -  , . ),

. .  (   , . -),

. .  (   , . ),

. .  (   , . --)

: .. 



:

. . ,   ,  (        );

. . ,   ,  (    - )



E.N.Yakhshibekyan

Efficiency of Execution and Serving the Sentence in the Form of Compulsory Community Service



Monograph

Recommended to be published by the Editorial Board of the Bulletin Russian Criminological Outlook as a monograph



Recommended to be published by the Regional Public Organization The Union of Criminalists and Criminologists as a monograph



MOSCOW 2013

Moscow State Juridical University by O.E. Kutafin (MSJA)



The Editorial Board of the Series

Library of the Bulletin Russian Criminological Outlook:

O.V Starkov (Editor-in-Chief), V.N. Orlov (Assistant to the Editor-in-Chief), A.Y Grishko, I.M. Matskevich, E.F. Pobegailo (Deputies to the Editor-in-Chief), VM. Anisimkov, M.M. Babaev, A.Y Wilks, L.A. Voskobitova, YI. Gilinsky, YV Golik, G.N. Gorshenkov, A.B. Jurich, A.G. Kibalnik, D.A. Koretsky, A.N. Kostenko, S.Y. Lebedev, V V Luneev, S.V Maksimov, G. Meshko, S.F. Milyukov, M.G. Minenok, A.Kh. Mindagulov, VA. Nomokonov, A.I. Rarog, VI. Seliverstov, S.L. Sibiryakov, A.I. Rarog, M.E. Trufanov, D. A. Shestakov, VE. Eminov (members of the Edito-rial Colleague).



Responsible secretaries:

D.V Zakalyapin (within the North-Caucasian Federal District, Stavropol)

E. L. Radnayeva (within the Siberia Federal District, Ulan-Ude),

E.L. Sidorenko (within the Central Federal District, Moscow)

A.P Skiba (within the Southern Federal District, Rostov-on-Don)



Reviewers:

S. A. Borsuchenko, Candidate of Law, Associate Professor (Russian Law Academy of the Department of Justice of the Russian Federation);

I. A. Uvarov, Candidate of Law, Associate Professor (Nevinnomyssky State Humanitarian and Technical Institute)



The monography is devoted to the concept, the content, the objectives, the system, the objects and the subjects of the penal sanction in the form of compulsory community service. It is the first time the complex analysis of objective and subjective elements, execution and serving the sentence in the form of compulsory community service has been undertaken.

Intended for students, graduate students of the military academies, post-graduate students, lecturers of higher educational institutions and faculties of Law, practicing lawyers, people employed in the penal system and other law enforcement agencies. It can also be of interest for everyone who is interested in penal sanction.



 Yakhshibekyan E. N., 2013  Russian Criminological Outlook, 2013  Moscow State Juridical University ISBN by O.E. Kutafin (MSJA), 2013




  


 !

  ,    ,  :     䔻.    2008 .   : . .  ( ); . .  (  ); . . , . . , . .  (  ); . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . , . . , . . , . . , A. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . .  ( ); . . , . . , . . , . .  ( ); . .  ().

           -    .

 ,   ,          . .  (),       ,    ,      ,  -   ,      . .         .

    :   .  2- . . 1.  :  /  . . .  (., 2008);     -   :    1 . 2009 .:  . 2- ., . . / . . . , . .  (., 2009);  - .  2- . . 1.  :  /  . . . ,

B. .  (., 2010);  . .  : , , ,   :  (., 2011);   - .  2- .  1.  :  /  . . . , . .  (., 2012)  .

  ,    ,                : http://crimimlogy.ru, http://criminology.pro, http://. .

,        ,   , , ,     ,  ,    , -     ,    ,      , ,     ,      ,             .

,   ,     : 1)           : 121357, . ,  , 65, . 9; 2)     : olegstar@mail.ru; vlad-orlov@mail.ru

 ,    ,     .: 8-915-092-99-45           .: (499) 445-90-16; 8-915-051-16-15        .



   

. . 




To the reader


Dear reader!

You are holding the book which is a part of the series of works published under common title Library of the Bulletin Russian Criminological Outlook. The series has been established in 2008. The Editorial Board includes: O. V. Starkov (Editor-In-Chief), V. N. Orlov (Editor-In-Chief Assistant), A. Y. Grishko, I. M. Matskevich, E. F. Pobegailo (Deputies Editor-In-Chief), V. M. Anisimkov, M. M. Babaev, A. Y. Vilks, L. A. Voskobitova, Y. I. Gilinsky. Y. V. Golik, G. N. Gorshenkov, A. B. Dzhurich, D. A. Koretsky, A. N. Kostenko, S. Y. Lebedev, V. V. Luneev, S. V. Maksimov, G. Meshko, S. F. Milyukov, M. G. Minenok, V. A. Nomokonov, A. I. Rarog, V. I. Seliverstov, S. L. Sibiryakov, O. V. Filimonov, D. A. Shestakov, V. E. Eminov (members of the Editorial Board); D. V. Zakalyapin, E. L. Radnaeva, E. L. Sidorenko, A. P. Skiba (Executive Editors); A. O. Maguza (Assistant).

The proposed series of works is the first criminological library published under the aegis of a quarterly scientific practical journal Russian Criminological Outlook.

The authors of the books included in the series are associate professors of Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MLSU), the Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Academy of the Prosecutor Generals Office of the Russian Federation, the Russian Law Academy of the Russian Federation Ministry of Justice, National Research Institute of the Ministry of Interior of the Russian Federation, Herzen State Pedagogical University of Russia and other leading Russian and foreign institutions of higher education.

The following works are published in the series: Russian Criminal Law. In 2 volumes. Volume 1. General part: textbook / edited by E. F. Pobegailo (M., 2008); Article-for-Article Commentary to the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation: as of September 1, 2009: textbook. 2nd edition, revised and supplemented / edited by V. E. Eminov, V. N. Orlov (M., 2009); Russian Criminal Executive Law. In 2 volumes. Volume 1. General part: textbook / edited by V. E. Eminov, V. N. Orlov (M., 2011); Orlov V. N. Penal Sanction: Concept, Objectives, System, Objects and Subjects: monography (M., 2011); Russian Course of Criminal Executive Law. In 2 volumes. Volume 1. General part: textbook / edited by V. E. Eminov, V. N. Orlov (M., 2012), etc.

Full text of the books published in the series is available in the Criminological Library and can be downloaded for free on our website under the following domain names: http://criminology.ru, http://criminology.pro, ://. .

The works published in the series Library of the Bulletin Russian Criminological Outlook are intended for students, graduate students of the military academies, post-graduate students, lecturers of higher educational institutions and faculties of Law, practicing lawyers, people employed in the internal affairs agencies, criminal executive system and other law enforcement bodies. They can also be of interest for everyone who is interested in anti-crime issues, criminal, victim behavior and its causes, prevention of crime and criminal behavior as well as in theory and practice of criminal policy and criminal sciences.

Materials for publication, suggestions and comments are to be sent: 1) printed version or a manuscript: to Orlov Vladislav Nikolaevich  Apart.9, Building 65, Kutuzovsky Av., Moscow, 121357; 2) electronic version should be sent to olegstar@mail.ru; vlad-orlov@mail.ru.

You can find the information about the acceptance of the article for publication by the tel. (861) 222-16-99; 8-918-363-38-73 Editor-in-Chief Oleg Victorovich Starkov or (499) 445-90-16; 8-915-051-16-15 Editor-in-Chief Assistant Vladislav Nikolaevich Orlov.



In the name of the Editorial Board

V. N. Orlov







  ,        ,    ,       ,    .                     .             .              ,         ,       .

 ,       - ,                   .        . ,  2007 .    38 089 . (4,1 %    ), 2008 . 49 713 (5,4 %), 2009 . 66 480 (7,5 %), 2010 . 80 558 (9,6 %), 2011 . 90 444 (11,6 %)[1 -    (20072011):  . ., 2012. . 164.].

               - ,        -     2020 .,       14  2010 . 1772-.

         -   ,    - .  ,    ,          .

           ,      ,           ,         .

          ,                      28  2004 . 177-,           20  2009 . 142        -     .




 1

- ,          





1.1.         


  1996 .     (   )        .  ,      ,    ,       .      ,      ; ,       [2 - .:   . ., 1994. .362.].

  ,    ,       ,        ,      .     , , ,           [3 - .:  .          :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .- --, 1999.-. 87-107, 130182;  ..       (    ):  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2004.-. 84- 204;  ..         :  . . : 12.00.08. ., 2011. . 16^42.].

        ,  ,             (  )  .

,  1999 . ..  ,     , -,  , . .   . -,    , . .        . -,           (    ,   )     [4 -    .  :  /  . .. . . 2-, . . .: , 1999. .345.].

  ..       : 1)  . 1. 45           ; 2)    . 1. 49                    ,      ; 3)       ,               ; 4) . 4. 49         ; 5)  . 1. 49      ,            ; 6)  . 3. 49                 ; 7)            [5 - .:  ..   / .. . .: -   , 1999. . 6871.].

  , ..      ,       :

1)  . 1. 45          ;

2)    . 1. 49                   ,      

3)       ,              .

4)        ,    ,   ,    .

5)           

6)          .

7)     ,       [6 -  .. ,     ,    :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2002. . 130132.].

..  ,         : 1)          ; 2)          ; 3)        ,   ; 4)        ;

5)     ,      ,  , ,       , ,   , ,   ,   ,     ; 6)     ; 7)     ,      ; 8)               ; 9) ,   ,         ,        [7 -  ..     : -  - :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2005. .62.].

 ..  ,     : 1)  ; 2)           ; 3)    ; 4)      ,   ,       -  [8 - .:  .     / .  //   : 2 .  1:  :  / .   .;  . .. -, .. , .. . 3- ., . . .: , 2010. . 14. .354.].

  .. ,  ,      , : 1)       ; 2)        ; 3)          [9 -  ..        / .. - // -      :   . . 4. : - , 2007. . 33.].

..   ..  ,        , :

1.        .

2.        .

3.           .

4.        .

5.   .

6.             (. 2. 26 ).

7.        , ,    [10 -  ..    : .  / .. , .. . :  - . .. , 2006. . 99100.].

..  ,          : 1)          ; 2)          ; 3)          ; 4)        ; 5)        ; 6)        ; 7)      - ; 8)     ,    ,  , ,       , ,     ,   ,            ,               ; 9)     ; 10)  -            18 ; 11)         ; 12)     ; 13)             ,    ; 14) ,   ,         ,       [11 -  ..      : -  - :  / .. , .. . : -   , 2005. . 7980.].

            ,        ,    . , ,          ,   ,             . , ..         ,                 .       . 49 ,     . 3. 49               .

 ,              ,     .

   .  . 1. 88          ,  .  . 49   ,                   .     ,    ,        - .                   .                .   ,       ,                       .     ,    ,  , ,       , ,     ,   ,            ,               .  . 3. 88               ,    ,   ,           .                  ,             .

  , ,  ,               ,  ,  ,   .  ,      ,   ,       .

, ..  ,                              40  160 .       15     2 . ;  16     3 . ,  16  18     4 . [12 -  ..       / ..  //  .  :  /  . .. . .:  л, 1999. . 21. . 512.].

..   ..  ,   ,   ,     , ,           ,          :   14  15        ;   15  16        ;   16  18         [13 -  ..       / .. , ..  //   . . 11.   .   .  , ., 2008. . II. .110.].

          [14 - .:  ..       / ..  //   :  :  /  . .. , .. , .. . .:   .-. . -,    .-. . -, 2006. . 24. .981;  ..   .  .  3 . . 1.   / .. .-4- ., . . .:  , 2007. .646;  ..  .     / ..  //   :  . . 2.  /  . . .. . : - . -, 1999.  4. . 9. .392;  ..  .     / ..  //    :  5 . / .  . , .,     .. . . 1:   . .:  .    , 2008.  4. . XXV. .1067;  ..     / ..  //  .  :  / . . .. . 4- ., . .-.: , 2008. . 19. .680;  ..    / ..  //   .  2 . . 1:  :  / ..   ;  . .. -, .. , .. . 3- ., . .-.: , 2010. . 19. . 487488;  ..     / ..  //   .  .  2:   :    /  .   ,  .. ,  . ,  .. . .:  , 1999. . IX. .296.].

 ,   ,        ,    ,         .

, ..  ,          ,                           [15 -  ..     / ..  //   .   .  2- . . 1.   / . .   -   . , . ..   . . , . .. . .:   (  --), 2000. . 19. .532.].

  ..              :

)         40  160 , . .        ,  . 49 ;

)        ,    ;

)         14  15     ;     15  16    (. 3. 88 );   16  18       (. 2. 49 ) [16 -  ..       / . .  //   .    :  /  . - . ,  . . . .: , 2008. . 22. .281.].

         ,          .

 ,                  ,       ,     .

  ,   ,    ,        ,               .

             ,            .

, ..  ,    ,    ,   ; :  ,   ,       [17 - .:  ..    .  .   .    / .. . :    , 1894. . 292.].    ..   . ,   ,    .   , . .       .    ,           ,   .   ,     ,             .    ,              .

..             ,   ,  ,     [18 -  ..     :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 1992. . 58;  ..     :   :  / .. . .: -   , 2002. .135.].

      :

     ,      ;

      ;

   ,    ;

         [19 - .:  ..     : -  : .  - . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2001. .51, 53, 56, 6061.].

 ..     ,      .   ,        ( ) ,      , . .  ,    ,         .         ( ) , . .  ,    ,     .

         ()  ,     -  ,        ,        .

                   .        ,      , . . ,    -  ,  , ,    ,     .                 , ,    ,     .

    ,       () ,   .

           , . .   ()   ,        ,          ,       .           , . .   (  () ,   )    (),    () ,        [20 -  ..     / ..  //  -   . 2006.  2. , 2006. . 9093.].

 ,                  .

,   ,   1902 ., .       .  ,            - ,         ,      ,          . ,        ,        ,     [21 - .:  ..    / .. . .:  . .   ʰ, 1902. .36.].    .   ,        ,      [22 - .:  . . 70.].

  , ..      [23 - .:  ..      / .. . .:  , 1904. . 381386.].

 ..     .   ,     ,         ,   .          ,          : ,  , , , ,      ,           . , ,                 ,   ,  ,      ,             ,          .       ,            ;         ,      ,    [24 -  .. .         / . . . : , 1914. . 4647.].

.. ,    ,     , ,       :   .    ,                 [25 - .:  ..      / ..  //    . 1970.  6. ., 1970. . 34.].

     .     -     -   ,    [26 - .:  .          :  - .  /  .- ., 1991. . 31.].

 . .       [27 - .:  .. :  ,   / .. . ., 1983. . 44.],         [28 - .:  . .46.].

  ,      ,   ,          .  ,         (!) [29 - .:    .  6 .  3. . .: , 1970. 350 .;     / . . .. , .. .  2. ., 1970.]          [30 -  ..     / ..  //  -   : - . 2006.  2.-, 2006. . 9093.].

 ,    ,  ,  ,   ,       .

, , .. ,       , ,         .             ,   .      ,       ,     ,       ,     [31 -  ..       / ..  // . 2002.  9. ., 2002. .2.].

..   .. ,       - , ,    -      ,         ,      ,    [32 -  .. - : , , , :  / .. , .. . .: , 2010. . 162.].  ,   ,   - ,      ,     ()    ,          [33 -  . . 182.].

 ,          (.. , .. , .. ),   ,   .      ,  ,          , . .     -,          -             .

 ,  -      : ,  ,             .

     ,          () , . . ,     ,         / ,  ,    [34 -  ..        / ..  //   . 2008.  1. , 2008. . 203.],          () , . . ,     ,          / ,  ,    [35 -  ..        / ..  //   .-2009.  4. .: , 2010. . 306.], , ,   ,   ,         ,     ,          -     .

 ,            .

, ..   ,      .   ,              : 1)   ; 2)     .   : 1)        ; 2)   ,  ; 3)     [36 -  ..       / ..  // . 2002.  9. ., 2002. .3.].

        , , -,        , -,     .

       .

I.    ,          ,     .    . 1. 37    ,         ,   . ,                         ,    ,         ,      ,      [37 - .:    . .: , , 2010. .4.].          .

 . 1. 49       ,    ,        - .      . 1. 25 -  ,       ,    ,        - .

          .  ,     . 47         -     ,       20  2009 . 142,           ,    ,   ,     ,  ,         ,     [38 -               :      20  2009 . 142 //  . 2009.  4975. 14 .]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/e-yahshibekyan/effektivnost-ispolneniya-otbyvaniya-nakazaniya-v-vide-obyazatelnyh-rabot-monografiya/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


   (20072011):  . ., 2012. . 164.




2


.:   . ., 1994. .362.




3


.:  .          :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .- --, 1999.-. 87-107, 130182;  ..       (    ):  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2004.-. 84- 204;  ..         :  . . : 12.00.08. ., 2011. . 16^42.




4


   .  :  /  . .. . . 2-, . . .: , 1999. .345.




5


.:  ..   / .. . .: -   , 1999. . 6871.




6


 .. ,     ,    :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2002. . 130132.




7


 ..     : -  - :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2005. .62.




8


.:  .     / .  //   : 2 .  1:  :  / .   .;  . .. -, .. , .. . 3- ., . . .: , 2010. . 14. .354.




9


 ..        / .. - // -      :   . . 4. : - , 2007. . 33.




10


 ..    : .  / .. , .. . :  - . .. , 2006. . 99100.




11


 ..      : -  - :  / .. , .. . : -   , 2005. . 7980.




12


 ..       / ..  //  .  :  /  . .. . .:  л, 1999. . 21. . 512.




13


 ..       / .. , ..  //   . . 11.   .   .  , ., 2008. . II. .110.




14


.:  ..       / ..  //   :  :  /  . .. , .. , .. . .:   .-. . -,    .-. . -, 2006. . 24. .981;  ..   .  .  3 . . 1.   / .. .-4- ., . . .:  , 2007. .646;  ..  .     / ..  //   :  . . 2.  /  . . .. . : - . -, 1999.  4. . 9. .392;  ..  .     / ..  //    :  5 . / .  . , .,     .. . . 1:   . .:  .    , 2008.  4. . XXV. .1067;  ..     / ..  //  .  :  / . . .. . 4- ., . .-.: , 2008. . 19. .680;  ..    / ..  //   .  2 . . 1:  :  / ..   ;  . .. -, .. , .. . 3- ., . .-.: , 2010. . 19. . 487488;  ..     / ..  //   .  .  2:   :    /  .   ,  .. ,  . ,  .. . .:  , 1999. . IX. .296.




15


 ..     / ..  //   .   .  2- . . 1.   / . .   -   . , . ..   . . , . .. . .:   (  --), 2000. . 19. .532.




16


 ..       / . .  //   .    :  /  . - . ,  . . . .: , 2008. . 22. .281.




17


.:  ..    .  .   .    / .. . :    , 1894. . 292.




18


 ..     :  . . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 1992. . 58;  ..     :   :  / .. . .: -   , 2002. .135.




19


.:  ..     : -  : .  - . : 12.00.08 /  .. , 2001. .51, 53, 56, 6061.




20


 ..     / ..  //  -   . 2006.  2. , 2006. . 9093.




21


.:  ..    / .. . .:  . .   ʰ, 1902. .36.




22


.:  . . 70.




23


.:  ..      / .. . .:  , 1904. . 381386.




24


 .. .         / . . . : , 1914. . 4647.




25


.:  ..      / ..  //    . 1970.  6. ., 1970. . 34.




26


.:  .          :  - .  /  .- ., 1991. . 31.




27


.:  .. :  ,   / .. . ., 1983. . 44.




28


.:  . .46.




29


.:    .  6 .  3. . .: , 1970. 350 .;     / . . .. , .. .  2. ., 1970.




30


 ..     / ..  //  -   : - . 2006.  2.-, 2006. . 9093.




31


 ..       / ..  // . 2002.  9. ., 2002. .2.




32


 .. - : , , , :  / .. , .. . .: , 2010. . 162.




33


 . . 182.




34


 ..        / ..  //   . 2008.  1. , 2008. . 203.




35


 ..        / ..  //   .-2009.  4. .: , 2010. . 306.




36


 ..       / ..  // . 2002.  9. ., 2002. .3.




37


.:    . .: , , 2010. .4.




38


              :      20  2009 . 142 //  . 2009.  4975. 14 .


